Il viaggio nello spazio non costituisce una condizione di eccezionalità morale. Ciò che si ottiene nello spazio si ottiene anche sulla Terra!

Il viaggio nello spazio non costituisce una condizione di eccezionalità morale. Ciò che si ottiene nello spazio si ottiene anche sulla Terra!

Balistreri, Maurizio (University of Turin)
Umbrello, S. (TU Delft Ethics & Philosophy of Technology)

2022

There is a growing body of scholarship that is addressing the ethics, in particular, the bioethics of space travel and colonisation. Naturally, a variety of perspectives concerning the ethical issues and moral permissibility of different technological strategies for confronting the rigours of space travel and colonisation have emerged in the debate. Approaches ranging from genetically enhancing human astronauts to modifying the environments of planets to make them hospitable have been proposed as methods. This paper takes a look at a critique of human bioenhancement proposed by Mirko Garasic who argues that the bioenhancement of human astronauts is not only functional but necessary and thus morally permissible. However, he further claims that the bioethical arguments proposed for the context of space do not apply to the context of Earth. This paper forwards three arguments for how Garasic’s views are philosophically dubious: (1) when he examines our responsibility towards future generations he refers to a moral principle (which we will call the principle of mere survival) which, besides being vague, is not morally acceptable; (2) the idea that human bioenhancement is not natural is not only debatable but morally irrelevant; and (3) it is not true that the situations that may arise in space travel cannot occur on Earth. We conclude that not only is the (bio)enhancement of humans on Earth permissible but perhaps even necessary in certain circumstances.

bioenhacement
Earth
Mars

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:530a5230-2fda-4f9e-82ac-544ea51a5cc0

https://doi.org/10.4081/mem.2022.1213

0025-7834

Medicina e Morale, 71 (3), 311-321

Institutional Repository

journal article

© 2022 Maurizio Balistreri, S. Umbrello