Repository hosted by TU Delft Library

Home · Contact · About · Disclaimer ·

Strategic design issues of IMS versus end-to-end architectures

Publication files not online:

Author: Braet, O. · Ballon, P.
Institution: TNO Informatie- en communicatietechnologie
Source:Info, 5, 9, 44-56
Identifier: 240148
Keywords: Informatics · Business management · Competitive strategy · Mobile communication systems · Business · Design · Information and communication technology · Internet · Management practice · Trade-off


Purpose - The paper aims to discuss the business issues surrounding the choice between the end-to-end internet architecture, in particular peer-to-peer networks, versus managed telecommunications architectures, in particular IMS, for the migration towards a next-generation mobile system. Design/methodology/approach - The paper organises the arguments available in the literature and technical field along four critical business design dimensions, providing a balanced overview of both sides of the argument. Findings - The paper discriminates between weak and strong arguments on both sides, and introduces a number of recommendations towards actors that will implement IMS. Research limitations/implications - The arguments collected from the literature and industry are not exhaustive but selected on their relevancy for business repercussions. Originality/value - While most position papers on IMS or P2P are written from an opinionated perspective, this paper offers a trade-off view of both side's advantages and disadvantages. It reframes the dispute as a number of design trade-offs to be made on various levels.