While recycling technologies offer solution to the challenges associated with end-of-life tires (ELT), the reliance of the industry on nonrenewable sources raises concerns. The objective of this cradle-to-gate lifecycle assessment study was to quantify the potential environmental impacts due to recycling of ELT into multiple outputs: crumb rubber (CR), micronized rubber powder (MRP), and reclaimed rubber (RR). Thirty-six scenarios were analyzed including three products and two ELT sources using six electricity mix scenarios transitioning the nonrenewable to renewable sources. The global warming potential due to the production of CR, MRP, and RR from domestic ELT were 1.13 × 10⁴, 3 × 10⁴, and 3.63 × 10⁴ kg CO₂ eq., respectively, while 50 % transition to renewables reduced them by 10–15 %. Further, MRP showed the highest land occupation and water consumption potential. Overall, this research provided a holistic overview of current and future impacts of tire recycling industry supporting sustainable practices.