In order to establish the variation between results in mass fractions due to software implementation, as measured by the k0-method for INAA, the IAEA has organized a software intercomparison. A complete set of test spectra and associated information was assembled. Efficiency curves, neutron spectrum parameters, correction factors and mass fractions were calculated with the participating programs (k0-IPEN, k0-INRIM, k0-DALAT, k0-IAEA and KayWin) using identical peak areas. In this paper, we report on the observed discrepancies, causes, remedies and future software developments. The test data, as well as intermediate results and observed mass fractions of the certified reference material BCR-320R “channel sediment” are available through the IAEA on request. The variations in concentrations attributed to differences between the programs were initially found to be 5.6 and 7.9%, for certified and uncertified concentrations, respectively. After the certified concentrations had been made available to the participants and they had been allowed to improve their programs, the variations found were 2.7 and 3.4%, respectively. The main identified remaining causes of variation are differences in the procedures used for detector efficiency characterisation and neutron spectrum parameter determination.@en

The k0-method (De Corte in The k0-standardization method: move to the optimization of neutron activation analysis. Habil. Thesis, Ghent University, Belgium, 1987) was developed solely for the use of (n, γ) nuclear reactions in neutron activation analysis. For this, a definition of only the thermal and epi-thermal flux was needed. The fast flux of the fission neutrons was not taken into account although it was considered for primary interferences by De Corte0. The energy distribution of the fission neutrons can be rather well described by a Watt distribution but is reactor dependent. To complicate things, the activation cross-section behaviour is nuclide dependent. In order to incorporate threshold reactions in the k0-method we propose to use predefined kf-factors, measuring the fast flux using a Ni-58 monitor, and to introduce an h-factor that accounts for all deviations for a specific reaction and irradiation facility. It is shown, based on data from Verheijke, that there are useful correlations for Ni-58, Ti-47 and Ti-48. Activation cross section functions indicate that there are possible more relations that might allow h-factors to be predicted.@en