Avoiding Digital Disappointment
A Retrospective Study Applying DSM-NPV to a European Shipyard Innovation
Miguel Calvache (TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
Jeroen Pruyn (Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences, TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
Alessia Napoleone (TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
Investments in digital technologies in engineer-to-order shipyards are often justified with optimistic business cases that emphasize direct costs and early benefits, yet value delivery is frequently delayed by integration and adoption work. This paper applies the DSM–NPV evaluation framework in a retrospective case on the introduction of a pipe spool tracking system within the piping department of a shipyard. The system was introduced to replace fragmented manual status reporting. A Design Structure Matrix (DSM) is used to map baseline information flows in the shipyard’s piping division and to identify the system changes required to integrate the new technology. Those cascades are translated into a traceable set of additional activities and benefit timing adjustments that inform a revised Net Present Value (NPV) model under uncertainty, contrasted with the original “as-approved” evaluation approach. Results show that the implementation footprint extends beyond shop-floor reporting into planning, logistics, supervision, and data governance, and that downstream benefits depend on stable adoption, reliable data, and role-specific processing and visualization. The study illustrates how the DSM-NPV approach improves expectation setting through integration of dependency analysis with financial modelling and supports change management planning for shipyard (digital) projects.
Files
File under embargo until 18-03-2027