Neighbourhood effects research at a crossroads: Ten challenges for future research

Neighbourhood effects research at a crossroads: Ten challenges for future research

Van Ham, M.
Manley, D.

OTB Research Institute for the Built Environment

2012-12-31

Neighbourhood effects research is at a crossroads since current theoretical and em-pirical approaches do not seem to be moving the debate forward. In this paper, we present a set of ten challenges as a basis for a new research agenda which will give new direction to the neighbourhood effects debate. The ten challenges are: 1) Future work should concentrate on explaining what is in the “black-box” of the ‘neigh-bourhood effect’ by deriving and testing clear hypotheses on causal neighbourhood effect mechanisms; 2) Studies should explicitly investigate the relationship between neighbourhood context and individual outcomes; 3) Alternative outcome variables such as subjective well-being should be considered; 4) We should move away from point-in-time measures of neighbourhood characteristics and take into account peo-ple’s neighbourhood histories; 5) More attention is needed for the intergenerational transmission of neighbourhood effects; 6) We need to understand neighbourhood se-lection and to incorporate neighbourhood selection explicitly in models of neighbour-hood effects; 7) We need a better operationalization of neighbourhood; 8) Neigh-bourhood effects researchers need to broaden their horizon to include other spatial contexts which might matter, in addition, or in place of the residential neighbour-hood; 9) We need bespoke data to investigate neighbourhood effects; 10) The tenth and final challenge is to combine qualitative and quantitative methods into one re-search design.

neighbourhood effects
challenges
causality
theory
bespoke data

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:df265c68-c9fc-42d0-807d-d25d55e82e40

Delft University of Technology, OTB Research Institute for the Built Environment

Working paper 2012-03

Institutional Repository

report

(c) 2013 Van Ham, M.
Manley, D.