Critical factors for effective resident participation in neighborhood rehabilitation in Wuhan, China

Critical factors for effective resident participation in neighborhood rehabilitation in Wuhan, China: From the perspectives of diverse stakeholders

Li, Y. (TU Delft Design & Construction Management)
Tao, Y. (University of Cambridge)
Qian, QK (TU Delft Design & Construction Management)
Mlecnik, E. (TU Delft Real Estate Management)
Visscher, H.J. (TU Delft Design & Construction Management)

2024

Resident participation is essential for neighborhood rehabilitation. It requires the active involvement of residents and efficient management by organizers. To improve the effectiveness of resident participation, it is necessary to understand the critical success factors (CSFs) underlying it. However, previous research has examined the critical factors from a single-stakeholder perspective, overlooking potential differences in perceptions among stakeholders with diverse roles and rehabilitation experiences. Based on 30 interviews and 255 questionnaires from six stakeholder groups in Wuhan, China, this study explores how the perception of critical factors for effective resident participation varies among local government, community-based organization, designer, contractor, consulting party, and resident. Thirty-seven factors were identified and compared among the stakeholders. Financial Incentive (for participation organizers) was identified as the most critical factor for effective resident participation, followed by Information Disclosure and Transparency, and Trust. Results from the analysis of variance (ANOVA) show that the six groups differed significantly in the importance of most factors (25/37), especially in Participant Education and Prejudice against the Working Group. Interview results indicate that the COVID-19 pandemic and rehabilitation experience changed stakeholders’ perceived importance of some factors. Specifically, in future RP initiatives, extra emphasis could be placed on Trait and Capacity (of the working group) and Participation-assistance Technologies. Stakeholders regarded these two factors as more critical as their rehabilitation experience accumulated. By understanding stakeholders' conflicting and changing perceptions of effective resident participation, suggestions were proposed to each stakeholder group to fulfill their distinct participation objectives and improve the overall effectiveness of participation practices.

resident participation
neighborhood rehabilitation
Critical success factor (CSF)
stakeholder perception
COVID-19 pandemic
China

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:ebd6177f-bfff-4b3e-b34b-d494e5586a5b

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2023.105000

0169-2046

Landscape and Urban Planning, 244

Institutional Repository

journal article

© 2024 Y. Li, Y. Tao, QK Qian, E. Mlecnik, H.J. Visscher