Print Email Facebook Twitter Peer grading the peer reviews Title Peer grading the peer reviews: A dual-role approach for lightening the scholarly paper review process Author Arous, Ines (University of Fribourg) Yang, J. (TU Delft Web Information Systems) Khayati, Mourad (University of Fribourg) Cudre-Mauroux, Philippe (University of Fribourg) Date 2021 Abstract Scientific peer review is pivotal to maintain quality standards for academic publication. The effectiveness of the reviewing process is currently being challenged by the rapid increase of paper submissions in various conferences. Those venues need to recruit a large number of reviewers of different levels of expertise and background. The submitted reviews often do not meet the conformity standards of the conferences. Such a situation poses an ever-bigger burden on the meta-reviewers when trying to reach a final decision. In this work, we propose a human-AI approach that estimates the conformity of reviews to the conference standards. Specifically, we ask peers to grade each other's reviews anonymously with respect to important criteria of review conformity such as sufficient justification and objectivity. We introduce a Bayesian framework that learns the conformity of reviews from both the peer grading process, historical reviews and decisions of a conference, while taking into account grading reliability. Our approach helps meta-reviewers easily identify reviews that require clarification and detect submissions requiring discussions while not inducing additional overhead from reviewers. Through a large-scale crowdsourced study where crowd workers are recruited as graders, we show that the proposed approach outperforms machine learning or review grades alone and that it can be easily integrated into existing peer review systems. Subject CrowdsourcingHuman-AI collaborationPeer gradingPeer review To reference this document use: http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:efd06fd5-b732-4de2-8bc5-af985d5c5236 DOI https://doi.org/10.1145/3442381.3450088 Publisher Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) ISBN 978-1-4503-8312-7 Source The Web Conference 2021 - Proceedings of the World Wide Web Conference, WWW 2021 Event 2021 World Wide Web Conference, WWW 2021, 2021-04-19 → 2021-04-23, Ljubljana, Slovenia Series The Web Conference 2021 - Proceedings of the World Wide Web Conference, WWW 2021 Part of collection Institutional Repository Document type conference paper Rights © 2021 Ines Arous, J. Yang, Mourad Khayati, Philippe Cudre-Mauroux Files PDF 3442381.3450088.pdf 1.49 MB Close viewer /islandora/object/uuid:efd06fd5-b732-4de2-8bc5-af985d5c5236/datastream/OBJ/view