Finite element (FE) simulations of structures and materials are becoming increasingly accurate, but also more computationally expensive as a collateral result. This development occurs in parallel with a growing demand for data-driven design. To reconcile the two, a robust and data-efficient optimization method called Bayesian optimization (BO) has been previously established as a technique to optimize expensive objective functions. The mesh width of an FE model can be exploited to evaluate an objective at a lower or higher fidelity (cost & accuracy) level, which is the domain of multi-fidelity BO (MFBO) applications. However, BO and MFBO are usually not directly compared in the literature. Moreover, sampling quality and assessing design parameter sensitivity are often underrepresented parts of data-driven design. This paper combines global sensitivity analysis and (MF) BO into a novel, efficient Bayesian data-driven framework. We compare the performance of BO with that of MFBO by maximizing the energy absorption (EA) problem of spinodoid cellular structures. The findings show that similar or better designs are suggested by MFBO with 16% fewer expensive objective evaluations compared to BO when maximizing the EA. The results, which are made open-source, serve to support the utility of multi-fidelity techniques across expensive data-driven design problems.

In the pursuit of designing safer and more efficient energy-absorbing structures, engineers must tackle the challenge of improving crush performance while balancing multiple conflicting objectives, such as maximising energy absorption and minimising peak impact forces. Accurately simulating real-world conditions necessitates the use of complex material models to replicate the non-linear behaviour of materials under impact, which comes at a significant computational cost. This study addresses these challenges by introducing a multi-objective Bayesian optimisation framework specifically developed to optimise spinodoid structures for crush energy absorption. Spinodoid structures, characterised by their scalable, non-periodic topologies and efficient stress distribution, offer a promising direction for advanced structural design. However, optimising design parameters to enhance crush performance is far from straightforward, particularly under realistic conditions. Conventional optimisation methods, although effective, often require a large number of costly simulations to identify suitable solutions, making the process both time-consuming and resource intensive. In this context, multi-objective Bayesian optimisation provides a clear advantage by intelligently navigating the design space, learning from each evaluation to reduce the number of simulations required, and efficiently addressing the complexities of non-linear material behaviour. By integrating finite element analysis with Bayesian optimisation, the framework developed in this study tackles the dual challenge of improving energy absorption and reducing peak force, particularly in scenarios where plastic deformation plays a critical role. Leveraging scalarisation and hypervolume-based techniques, the framework effectively identifies Pareto-optimal solutions that balance these conflicting objectives while accounting for the complexities of plastic material behaviour. Importantly, the approach also prevents problematic densification, ensuring structural integrity during impact. The results not only demonstrate the framework's ability to outperform the NSGA-II algorithm but also highlight its potential for wider applications in structural and material optimisation. The framework's adaptability to various design requirements underscores its capability to address complex, multi-objective optimisation challenges associated with real-world conditions.