Understanding the potential and constraints of water reclamation is essential for the decision makers to design interventions that improve the process in a safely manner e.g. for Maputo, Mozambique. In this thesis i) the potential and constraints of using (partially) treated wast
...
Understanding the potential and constraints of water reclamation is essential for the decision makers to design interventions that improve the process in a safely manner e.g. for Maputo, Mozambique. In this thesis i) the potential and constraints of using (partially) treated wastewater in irrigated agriculture for sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) was analysed; ii) the concentration of the indicator Escherichia coli (E. coli) in irrigation water, the lettuce (Lactuca sativa) produced in the irrigation fields in Infulene Valley, in Maputo, Mozambique, and the lettuce subsequently sold at local markets in Maputo was assessed; iii) and the potential contribution of wastewater-based nutrients to the supply of nitrogen (N), phosphorous (P), and potassium (K) for lettuce production in the Infulene Valley, in Maputo, Mozambique, was studied.
An extensive literature review was performed for existing examples of water reclamation in sub-Saharan Africa, followed by laboratorial analyses of water, soil and lettuce samples collected in the Infulene valley in Maputo. We analysed the faecal coliform contamination considering the E. coli as its indicator, the content of nutrients (Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Potassium), and the potential toxic elements (PTE) present in the samples.
Water reclamation is informally practiced in many SSA countries, with wide use of untreated reclaimed wastewater in agriculture. Wastewater quality in most of SSA countries is regulated by the 1989 WHO guidelines, instead of its more recent 2006 guidelines. The 1989 WHO guidelines are based on restrictive effluent criteria, which are more practical to use, compared to the 2006 WHO guidelines. However, the 1989 WHO guidelines are not effective for risk reduction of the farmers’ practices, based on the installed wastewater treatment capacity and the vulnerability of contamination along the supply chain. The 2006 WHO guidelines are more complex to implement for most of the SSA countries. The multiple barrier approach has been proposed for safe water reclamation combining the treatment and the critical points for quality control in the value chain to reduce the health risks. This requires the development of a water reclamation approach, which matches the required water quality at the point of use and the design of an affordable wastewater treatment, which reduces risks on the long term. Overall, it was concluded that there is a potential in SSA countries for water reclamation, although it requires the development of the relatively poor water and sanitation infrastructure to support its implementation.
We found that irrigation water is not the only potential source of faecal contamination in the value chain of lettuce produced at farms and sold at local markets of Maputo. The lettuce produced in the Infulene valley was also contaminated along the value chain, regardless of the irrigation source. The process of washing lettuce in the market presents a potential for re-contamination and it contributes little in risk reduction. Some measures for reducing the risk of contamination such as delaying harvest at the farm, and hygienic practices at the marketplace will impact the contamination levels of the lettuce, irrespective of the use of reclaimed wastewater or other water sources for irrigation in the Infulene Valley in Maputo.
Our analysis revealed further that wastewater is a viable alternative for nutrient supply in the Infulene Valley. It contains higher amounts of essential nutrients (N, P, and K) compared to groundwater. This highlights the potential of wastewater as an effective source to (1) re-plenish nutrients in agricultural systems to meet crop nutrient demands and (2) to reduce reliance on traditional fertilizers. However, careful nutrient management is crucial to avoid excessive nutrient dosing, which can lead to health and environmental hazards such as groundwater pollution, pollution of water ways, and soil degradation. Implementing strategies such as combined source control, frequent water monitoring, and appropriate treatment options can help for ferti-irrigation in peri-urban areas like the Infulene Valley.
Finally, our data showed that PTE were present at low concentrations in the irrigation water and soil. In plants, the concentration of chromium, aluminium, iron and sodium exceeded the recommended levels, suggesting sources unrelated to irrigation water. The high concentration of certain PTE when using river water and wastewater revealed the need for monitoring and understanding the elemental composition of crops, especially when different irrigation sources are used. Additionally, elevated sodium adsorption ratios and electrical conductivity levels across irrigation sources emphasize the need for cautious use of wastewater for irrigation. Monitoring activities are recommended for the Infulene valley, in order to prevent accumulation of Mn, Al, Fe, Cr and Na, which potentially have negative impacts on the crop production, environment, and food security.
Overall, it can be concluded that the promotion of safe water reclamation in SSA countries should be implemented applying a holistic approach, including water treatment and the entire agricultural value chain that includes crop producers (farms), crop handlers, market vendors, and end consumers. Planners should consider the ‘farm-to-market-consumer’ chain to implement local safety measures that mitigate risks. Change in social behaviour towards reclaimed wastewater also represents an important aspect for inclusion in activities towards the implementation of safe water reclamation. At policy level, persistent behaviours should also be changed to facilitate revisiting infrastructures and policies for reclaiming wastewater. In addition, initiatives for water reclamation should consider all potential end users, such as agricultural and industrial users, while embedding opportunities for a circular economy for a positive impact on farmers, society, and the environment.