Jv

J.E.I. van Raamsdonk

info

Please Note

1 records found

A quantitative socio-spatial analysis of protein ratios across different socio-economic groups and Amsterdam neighborhoods

Master thesis (2026) - J.E.I. van Raamsdonk, J.E. Goncalves, M.C. Onwezen, F. Kremer
The protein transition is commonly monitored through averages, yet these averages do not show whether differences in the plant-to-animal protein balance are shared across socio-economic groups and urban contexts. This thesis examines how the plant-to-animal (PtA) protein ratio differs across socioeconomic groups and neighborhood types in Amsterdam, and what these differences imply for an equitable protein transition.

A quantitative, cross-sectional, and descriptive research design was used in three connected parts. First, national Protein Monitor survey data (n = 3,006) were used to compare the frequency-based PtA protein ratio across education and income groups. Analyses of types of protein and exploratory COM-B interaction models were used to further interpret these differences, while the PtA protein ratio based on grams of protein intake from Traqq dietary records (n = 570) provided a complementary
comparison. Second, k-means clustering of socio-economic, demographic, housing, and food outlet indicators identified five neighborhood types across 72 Amsterdam PC4 areas. Third, 97 Amsterdam respondents were linked to these neighborhood types for an exploratory socio-spatial comparison.

The clearest difference was found between education groups. Lower-educated respondents reported the lowest frequency-based PtA protein ratio, middle-educated respondents fell in between, and higher educated respondents reported the highest ratio. Higher-educated respondents reported more frequent consumption of legumes, nuts and seeds, and meat substitutes, while lower-educated respondents reported more frequent processed meat consumption. The PtA protein ratio based on grams of
protein intake did not differ significantly by education or income. Income was also not associated with the frequency-based PtA protein ratio nationally, although a descriptive income difference appeared in the smaller Amsterdam sample. The neighborhood typology showed that socio-economic position and food outlet density do not form a single urban gradient. Among the three main linked neighborhood
types, Advantaged Urban Residential Areas had the highest mean ratio, while the High-Access Urban Core had the lowest, despite its high food outlet density. These neighborhood differences remain exploratory and cannot be interpreted as causal effects.

The findings differed across socio-economic groups and between the two PtA protein measures. The linked Amsterdam sample also showed descriptive differences between neighborhood types, although these cannot be attributed to neighborhood context itself. An overall ratio can hide these differences. For an equitable protein transition, monitoring should make clear which groups are represented, which types of protein differ between them, and whether the reported ratio varies across neighborhood types. ...