De-icing road salts are widely employed for snow and ice mitigation in cold climate regions, with sodium chloride (NaCl) being the most commonly used salt. The extensive application of NaCl has raised significant infrastructure, sustainability, and environmental concerns, and it has led to the emergence of various alternative de-icing salts, including other chloride-based and organic salts and compounds. In this study, the effect of zinc and acetate species on the corrosion behaviour of steels was systematically investigated using a combination of atmospheric corrosion testing, immersion testing, electrochemical measurements, cross-sectional microscopy, Zn K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XANES), and thermodynamic speciation modelling. The effect of eight chloride and non-chloride salts and their mixtures on the corrosion of structurally important galvanized steel, mild steel, and high-strength steel was studied. The chloride-based salts were found to be more detrimental than the organic salts to the corrosion of mild and high-strength steels, but all the salts were similarly corrosive to galvanized steel. It was found that the presence of both zinc and acetate species significantly enhanced corrosion and the Fe dissolution rate in steels. >40 wt.% of the 20 µm-thick galvanized zinc layer was dissolved after one week of immersion in 0.5 M sodium chloride or sodium acetate. After this one-week immersion, or the 10-week atmospheric field exposure, any remaining zinc was entirely in the form of zinc oxide. Our findings call for further investigation before using organic de-icing salts, alone or in mixtures with NaCl, on galvanized steel.