Evaluation of the Morphological and Ecological Response to a Conceptual Artificial Bypass System at IJmuiden Port

Abstract

This thesis explores the potential of a fixed artificial bypass system for a sustainable and eco-friendly approach to coastal management in IJmuiden. The presence of the IJmuiden Port disrupts the natural processes, causing significant morphological changes to the coastal area. Current management practices require frequent dredging and nourishment to mitigate the erosion of the downdrift coast and maintain the depth necessary for navigation in the channel and port. These activities result in significant emissions and adverse ecological impacts. Particularly affecting benthic life, organisms living in or on the seabed.


Implementing a fixed artificial bypass system, already proven successful in similar projects globally, emerges as a potential solution to reduce dredging and nourishment activities. This system aims to restore the natural sediment transport by pumping sediment from the updrift to the downdrift side. In addition, its more continuous discharge of sediment is anticipated to be less disruptive for benthic life compared to traditional nourishment methods.

The best-case scenario calculation performed in this thesis presents that an artificial bypass system at IJmuiden could potentially reduce dredging activity by 3.5% and nourishment activity by 37%. To assess whether these reductions can be achieved, this thesis introduces a newly developed framework for assessing the effectiveness of sediment bypass concepts based on four performance indicators: (1) Dredging Activity of Channel and Port, (2) Sediment Demand of Downdrift Coast, (3) Impact on Benthic Community and (4) Feasibility.



This method includes simulating the response of the coastal system after implementing varying bypass concepts using a Delft3D model. The Delft3D model’s applicability and predictive skill are assessed via hydrodynamic and morphodynamic validation. Concluding that the model can reproduce the general trends but introduces numerical errors in the exact quantification of the morphological development. Despite this limitation, the output from these Delft3D simulations was used to evaluate the response of different artificial bypass concepts based on the four performance indicators. The first two indicators are based on the simulated sediment transport values and assessments of the development of the bed. The evaluation of the third indicator is based on a calculation performed using the developed benthic evaluation tool, named the 'Benthimeter'. This newly developed tool provides a method that intends to visualize and quantify the impact on the benthic community induced by nourishment activity. Although the Benthimeter requires further calibration and validation, it marks a good first step towards integrating ecology into coastal management.


The results of this thesis demonstrate that the coastal system of IJmuiden allows for sediment withdrawal, where allready 10% of the required annual sediment trap was observed within one simulated month. Also northward sediment dispersal towards the downdrift coast was observed at simulations, indicating that such a system could reduce the sediment demand. These findings provide confidence that the principles of bypassing sediment around the port of IJmuiden hold. Consequently, it is anticipated that an artificial bypass system would, to some amount, reduce the need for dredging and nourishment activity. Also, the calculated impact on the benthic community confirms the hypothesis that a more continuous nourishment approach reduces the impact on the benthos. While the findings of this study provide an initial indication of the potential effectiveness of an artificial bypass system at IJmuiden, they do not provide long-term effect estimates. Further research is suggested to examine the primary drivers of dredging and nourishment activity, along with efforts to simulate the equilibrium state to evaluate the long-term effects.


The most important contribution of this thesis is the introduction of innovative tools, guidelines, and effective methods. This framework can be used in future research to improve our knowledge of sustainability and ecology in coastal practices.