Low-loss Deposited Dielectrics for Superconducting Integrated Circuits

Doctoral Thesis (2025)
Authors

B.T. Buijtendorp (TU Delft - Tera-Hertz Sensing)

Research Group
Tera-Hertz Sensing
More Info
expand_more
Publication Year
2025
Language
English
Research Group
Tera-Hertz Sensing
ISBN (print)
978-94-6384-777-3
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4233/uuid:50173f5f-cf91-4353-b4a7-2c681fc898d8
Reuse Rights

Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.

Abstract

Deposited dielectrics with low loss at millimeter-submillimeter (mm-submm) wavelengths are beneficial for the development of superconducting integrated circuits (ICs) for astronomy, such as filter banks, on-chip Fourier-transform spectrometers, and kinetic inductance parametric amplifiers. Although it is possible to fabricate microstrip lines using crystalline Si extracted from a silicon-on-insulator wafer by a flip-bonding process, deposited dielectrics al- low for simpler and more flexible chip designs and fabrication routes. In the ∼10–100 THz frequency range, dielectric losses are typically dominated by infrared absorption due to vibrational modes, whereas in the microwave fre- quency band (∼1–10 GHz) and at sub-Kelvin temperatures the dielectric loss is typically dominated by absorption due to two-level systems (TLSs). How- ever, the origin of the mm-submm (∼0.1–1 THz) loss in deposited dielectrics was unknown. In this dissertation we show that the mm-submm loss in de- posited dielectrics can be explained by the absorption tail of vibrational modes which are located above 10 THz. Furthermore, we found that hydrogenated amorphous silicon carbide (a-SiC:H) has a very low mm-submm loss tangent of 1.3×10−4 at 350 GHz, which makes it a promising low-loss deposited dielectric for mm-submm superconducting integrated circuits.

Based on a literature study we identified a-SiC:H and hydrogenated amor- phous silicon (a-Si:H) as potentially promising low-loss dielectrics. In order to find the origin of the mm-submm loss, and to define which materials we investi- gated in this PhD project, we characterized the dielectrics’ material properties at room temperature prior to performing the cryogenic loss measurements. We deposited a-SiC:H at a substrate temperature Tsub of 400◦C using plasma- enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD), and we deposited the a-Si:H films at Tsub of 100◦C, 250◦C, and 350◦C. We characterized the films’ material properties using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Raman spec- troscopy and ellipsometry. For the a-Si:H we determined the hydrogen content and the microstructure parameter from the FTIR data, the bond-angle disorder from the Raman data, and the void volume fraction from the ellipsometry data. For both the a-Si:H and the a-SiC:H we determined the band gap and optical refractive index from the ellipsometry data, and the infrared refractive index from the FTIR data. From the Raman spectra we observed that the a-SiC:H and the a-Si:H films were amorphous. Furthermore, we performed electron diffraction spectroscopy to determine the Si to C ratio of the a-SiC:H. For the a-Si:H we found that the all the material properties depend monotonically on Tsub. Additionally, we measured the cryogenic microwave loss of the a-Si:H films, but we found no correlation between the microwave loss and Tsub.

No cryogenic mm-submm and microwave loss data was available for a- SiC:H. We measured the low-power and cryogenic microwave loss of the a- SiC:H and found that the microwave loss tangent (tanδ ∼ 10−5) is compa- rable to the loss of a-Si:H. Furthermore, we measured the mm-submm loss in the range of 270–385 GHz using an on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment. The observed mm-submm losss value of 1.2 × 10−4 at 350 GHz was significantly lower than what was reported for a-Si:H, which previously exhibited the low- est reported microwave and mm-subm wave loss values among the deposited dielectrics which are commonly used in superconducting ICs. Furthermore, we found that the mm-submm loss of the a-SiC:H increases monotonically with frequency. This was surprising in the framework of TLSs and led us to the hypothesis that another loss mechanism than TLSs might be dominant at mm- submm wavelengths. In addition to the low losses, the a-SiC:H was found to be beneficial thanks to its very low stress, lack of blisters, and the possibility to fabricate a membrane from the a-SiC:H on a c-Si wafer.

To study the origin of the frequency dependent mm-submm loss in the a- SiC:H, we extended the on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment to the 270–600 GHz range by making use of a wideband leaky antenna. Additionally, we measured the complex dielectric constant of the a-SiC:H in the 3–100 THz range using Fourier-transform spectroscopy (FTS). We modeled the FTS data using the Maxwell-Helmholtz-Drude (MHD) dispersion model and obtained the complex dielectric constant in the 3-100 THz range. Finally, we modeled the combined on-chip loss data from the Fabry-Pérot experiments and the FTS data by fitting the MHD dispersion model in the frequency range of 0.27–100 THz. Our model demonstrates that the mm-submm loss in the a-SiC:H above 200 GHz can be explained by the absorption tail of vibrational modes which are located above 10 THz. These results pave the way for a thorough understanding of the mm-submm loss in deposited dielectrics.

The low losses of the a-SiC:H allow for integrated superconducting spec- trometers with a large frequency bandwidth and relatively high resolving pow- ers without sacrificing too much optical efficiency. This has led to the application of the a-SiC:H in the DESHIMA 2.0 filter bank, which has seen first light in 2023 at the ASTE telescope in the Atacama Desert.