Beyond material flows

Bridging bottom-up and top-down approaches for modelling the circular economy

Master Thesis (2026)
Author(s)

S.E. Rasing (TU Delft - Technology, Policy and Management)

Contributor(s)

Arnold Tukker – Mentor (Universiteit Leiden)

D.P. Peck – Mentor (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)

Faculty
Technology, Policy and Management
More Info
expand_more
Publication Year
2026
Language
English
Graduation Date
17-08-2026
Awarding Institution
Delft University of Technology
Programme
Industrial Ecology
Sponsors
Universiteit Leiden
Faculty
Technology, Policy and Management
Page Views
31
Reuse Rights

Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.

Abstract

The global use of natural resources continues to increase, contributing to the transgression of planetary boundaries. The circular economy (CE) is seen as a way to address this by reducing, reusing, recycling, and recovering materials within the economy. However, these CE strategies affect prices, demand, and other economic dimensions beyond material flows, creating economy-wide effects that remain poorly understood. To capture these dynamic impacts, Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) models are increasingly used, as they incorporate price and substitution effects to model the economy-wide dynamics of CE strategies. However, CGE models are highly aggregated and use monetary units, meaning they are not good at capturing flows to waste and recycling, due to their low and often highly fluctuating value, and thus, cannot model physical material flows at the level of detail required for CE modelling. Material Flow Analysis (MFA) is better suited to capturing these material flows, but cannot capture the economy-wide dynamics of a CE strategy. The limitations of both models demonstrate the need for a linked MFA-CGE approach capable of modelling CE strategies with enough product-level detail, while also capturing the generated economy-wide effects.

A literature review shows that previous MFA-CGE linkages have provided valuable insights but are not suited to assessing CE strategies at the product level, since they focus on single materials rather than products, neglect the stock-flow dynamics that determine future material availability, or remain theoretical without empirical validation. To address this gap, this thesis explores the possibilities of linking a product-oriented dynamic MFA (dMFA) with a CGE model to assess the economy-wide impacts of product-specific CE strategies. This is done by developing a proof of concept for a soft-linking approach between a product-level dMFA and a CGE model, demonstrated through a case study on the lifetime extension of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) through repair in the European Union (EU).

Based on inflow data for 54 EEE categories covering 1980–2022, a dual-stock dMFA model is developed, in which the stocks of new and repaired products are separated to account for the shorter lifetime of repaired products. The model is run under two scenarios: a baseline without additional repair and a repair scenario, driven by household preference change in which a product-specific repair rate is applied to each EEE category. The resulting flows for 2017 are then soft-linked to a CGE model (GREEN-R), aggregated into two regions: the EU and the rest of the world. The soft-linking approach allocates the changes in material inflows derived from the dMFA to a shift in household final demand, away from new EEE and towards repair services. The physical inflows of the dMFA are translated into monetary flows at basic prices, using price data obtained from production and trade statistics. The linkage is then implemented by applying a relative reduction to the household’s consumption of EEE in the CGE model, with all expenditure no longer spent on new EEE redirected towards EEE repair services.

The results of the repair scenario are as follows. First, the dMFA provides the material foundation for the CE scenario, showing how an increase in repair reduces both the inflow of new EEE and generated waste by 10.1% and 10.9%, respectively. It also reveals that the volume of repaired products exceeds the inflow of new EEE it replaces, due to the shorter lifetimes of repaired products. Translated into monetary terms, the 10.1% reduction in inflow corresponds to a 14.1% reduction in household consumption of EEE. Second, by applying this monetary inflow reduction to the CGE model, the economy-wide dynamics of the increase in repair are identified. Wages rise by 0.08% as labour demand increases, but since labour is an important factor of production, this also drives inflation. Real household income therefore falls by 0.01%, while less labour-intensive sectors become relatively cheaper, shifting the composition of household consumption through substitution and income effects. The CGE model also reports GHG emissions, showing that repair delivers a climate benefit, with global emissions falling by 2.76 Mt.

Together, these results demonstrate that soft-linking a product-level dMFA to a CGE model provides insights that neither model could generate in itself. By doing so, this thesis demonstrates the value of soft-linking and provides directions for future research, since the method rests on simplifications and leaves certain dynamics outside its scope that would need to be addressed.

Files

Thesis_V_Final.pdf
(pdf | 1.86 Mb)
License info not available
S4._CGE_methodologies.pdf
(pdf | 0.409 Mb)
License info not available