Allowable Hull Loading due to Fender Contact

Abstract

Marine structures are frequently equipped with rubber fender systems, which absorb the berthing en­ergy in order to protect both the marine structure and the berthing vessel. These fender systems absorb the kinetic berthing energy by elastic deflection and the associated reaction fender force introduces a berthing impact load acting on the vessel’s side hull. In guidelines and rules on ship design, recommendations regarding the structural resistance due to external fenders are not present. On the other hand, special requirements state minimal strengthening for tug resistance, which results in marked areas on a vessel’s side hull at which tug contact is allowed. Also for ships equipped with integrated steel fenders in their side hull, also known as beltings, minimal strengthening is required. Since the use of fender systems in ports is common, and all ships require to berth in a port the maximum hull loading due to fender contact is an important factor to take into account from the vessel’s perspective. PIANC WG33 published design recommendations for the maximum allowable hull pressure in kN/m2 for different types of vessels. The size of the fender contact area is in practice determined by dividing the design reaction force by the maximum allowable hull pressure. However, the hull pres­sures in this recommendation are based on the pressure on the keel of a fully laden vessel. Based on this background information, not all values are reliable, since some pressures correspond to a draft of 70 meters. Besides that, the pressure formulation does not contain information on the specific geom­etry of the contact area, i.e. height and width. This thesis systematically analyses the strength of the vessels’ parallel side hull for different failure modes, e.g. yielding in the stiffeners due to excessive bending­ or shear stresses. The structural ge­ometry of various vessel types is represented by various grillages. Two different pressure distributions were considered: a soft contact area, and a rigid contact area, to cover the most extreme behaviour of a fender panel. The results of this study show that the allowable load is largely influenced by the geometry of the contact area. The fender panels designed using the PIANC WG33 fender design are not always opti­mal. Especially for fender panels having large widths, the current guidelines seem to be too optimistic. Consequently, it is necessary to define a maximum width to what extent the current guidelines are allowable. This study shows that a specific allowable force in kN for a specific geometry is preferred over the current guidelines. In this study, a general formulation for the maximum allowable hull loading is proposed. This for­mulation requires the specific structural lay­out of the vessel that encounters the berthing facility. If the specific ship’s particulars are not known, recommendations are provided for different vessel types. These recommendations consist of a new acceptance criterion for each vessel type, which can be used to optimise the geometry of fender panels. The findings of this study can be used in the design of fender systems and the new design criterion has been submitted to the members of PIANC WG211.