Socio-economic feasibility study on the implementation of an Electric Road System between the port of Rotterdam and the port of Antwerp

Socio-economic feasibility study on the implementation of an Electric Road System between the port of Rotterdam and the port of Antwerp

Duijn, Kevin (TU Delft Civil Engineering & Geosciences; TU Delft Transport and Planning)

Annema, J.A. (mentor)
van Binsbergen, A.J. (graduation committee)
Tavasszy, Lorant (graduation committee)
Saeednia, M. (graduation committee)
Tuinenburg, Emilio (graduation committee)
Koopman, Erik (graduation committee)

Delft University of Technology

Civil Engineering | Transport and Planning

2023-12-22

In order to fulfill the climate commitments outlined in the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement, there is a pressing need to substantially reduce Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions worldwide. Among these GHG emissions, CO2 contributes for 75% of the total Greenhouse Gas emissions. The transport sector accounts for 22% of these CO2 emissions. Despite the only 2% of the overall vehicle fleet in Europe, trucks and buses contribute a substantial 28% to the annual CO2 emissions on roads. Decarbonizing the transportation sector can be approached with various solution, with electrification emerging as one viable solution. Electrification involves converting diesel trucks with internal combustion engines into battery trucks. Furthermore, extending this shift to heavy duty trucks can be achieved by implementing an Electric Road System (ERS), utilizing either inductive or conductive charging. Completing an European network for ERS would be optimal, considering the daily cross-border transportation undertaken by heavy-duty trucks. Given the challenges in constructing a full European network at once, it is recommended to start an ERS infrastructure between two major freight handling points to guarantee high initial utilization. Numerous studies and pilot projects have investigated ERS technologies, with the Overhead Catenary Line system currently standing out as the most mature technology. However, existing studies primarily focus on the technical aspects or cost-effectiveness of ERS technology, neglecting a crucial aspect—the Social Cost-Benefit Analysis (SCBA) that evaluates the socio-economic impact of implementing an Overhead Catenary Line system. Moreover, these studies mostly looked into the implementation of a larger ERS network. Consequently, the main research question is formulated: What is the socio-economic feasibility of the implementation of an Electric Road System (ERS), the overhead catenary line system, between two freight handling points?
The shift towards electrification has already begun, with the introduction of battery trucks alongside diesel trucks. Hence, a transitional phase involving a mix of diesel and battery trucks is anticipated in the coming years (the zero alternative). The study has focused on testing one policy measure, namely the implementation of an ERS infrastructure between the ports of Rotterdam and Antwerp. The implementation of an ERS network, extend the truck fleet (consisting of diesel trucks and battery trucks), with a new type: the catenary trucks. This is the so called policy scenario (anticipated completion by 2030), which has been compared with the zero alternative. Three distinct route alternatives between the ports were assessed through SCBA, revealing that implementing an ERS infrastructure proves welfare enhancing for all three route alternatives, thus demonstrating the socio-economic feasibility of the policy measure. Furthermore, among the route alternatives (the Western route, the Middle route and the Eastern route), the Eastern route presents the most favorable Net Present Value outcomes for ERS infrastructure. However, conducting further studies encompassing research variables and non-monetized factors arising from ERS infrastructure implementation is necessary. This comprehensive analysis is crucial for informed decision making regarding the successful implementation of an Electric Road System.

Electric Road Systems
Overhead Catenary Line
decarbonization
Heavy duty trucks
Social cost benefit analysis

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:3bf8900e-1d4b-4eb5-8087-842a32b374dd

Student theses

master thesis

© 2023 Kevin Duijn