Title
Analogy versus Metaphor: Aldo van Eyck’s Poetic Images In-Between Fields
Author
Campos Uribe, A. (TU Delft Space & Type)
Lacomba Montes, P. (TU Delft Space & Type)
Contributor
Borree, Sarah (editor)
Knuth, Stephanie (editor)
Röger, Moritz (editor)
Date
2023
Abstract
The Dutch architect Aldo van Eyck wrote the Tree-Leaf Statement in 1961, as a visiting professor at Washington University. Contrary to what it may seem, the words were in fact a declaration against the direct analogy of tree-city, since Van Eyck rejected the use of tree hierarchies within the urbanism of his time. "The tree analogy fails altogether [...] direct analogy leads nowhere, neither to the idea of the tree nor of the city". Instead, Van Eyck proposed a kaleidoscopic poetic image that succeeded in capturing the deep meaning of his own urban thinking, which he called the configurative discipline. However, the tree-leaf metaphor also resulted in a strong dispute within Team 10 that caused an important shift in Van Eyck’s career, who subsequently limited himself to exploring the intrinsic quality of architectural space and abandoned large scale projects. We propose in this article that this event demonstrates the power and danger of metaphors as poetic images that grow in-between fields, and that can yield incredible transformative powers.
To reference this document use:
http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:a72e36ba-e643-41de-a3fb-cbb79fd553f0
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003299219-9
Publisher
Routledge - Taylor & Francis Group, London
Embargo date
2024-06-23
ISBN
9781032289342
Source
Metaphorical Practices in Architecture: Metaphors as Method and Subject in the Production of Architecture
Part of collection
Institutional Repository
Document type
book chapter
Rights
© 2023 A. Campos Uribe, P. Lacomba Montes