A critique of The Vastness of Natural Languages by Langendoen and Postal

Title

A critique of The Vastness of Natural Languages by Langendoen and Postal

 Author

Hart, K.P. (TU Delft Analysis) ORCID 0000-0002-4330-2450

 Date

2021

 Abstract

This paper looks at an argument in 'On the vastness of Natural Languages' by D. T. Langendoen and P. M. Postal.

The conclusion is that it does not pass mathematical muster.

The salient points are

saying "language rules impose no size limits" does not mean that one can say "there are arbitrarily large entities"; it simply means that one does not avail oneself of the former assumption, the latter assumption is just that: an assumption (or better axiom), not a consequence of not using the former

the existence proof for co-ordinate projections is mathematically unsound; it establishes that "Tom and Jerry" is a sentence built from the set {Laurel, Hardy}

the proof of the main result uses the assumption "there are projections of any given cardinality"; this assumption is equivalent to the conclusion of the theorem and this reduces the main theorem to a trivial tautology

 To reference this document use:

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:df73f637-882b-4927-9bc2-b73fed59b337

 Part of collection

Institutional Repository

 Document type

working paper

 Rights

© 2021 K.P. Hart
Files
PDF hart_21_A_critique_of_On_.pdf 387.65 KB
Close viewer