Should we care about the level of detail in trees when running urban microscale simulations?

Should we care about the level of detail in trees when running urban microscale simulations?

Fu, Runnan (Student TU Delft)
Pađen, I. (TU Delft Urban Data Science)
Garcia Sanchez, C. (TU Delft Urban Data Science)

2024

Due to lack of information and long geometry generation times, tree geometries are usually oversimplified or even ignored in Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) simulations that predict wind and pollutant dispersion in urban areas. Nevertheless, trees are known to impact local wind patterns and air quality levels. Thus, in this paper we explore the effects that tree models automatically reconstructed at diverse Level of Detail (LoD) (1, 2 and 3) have in numerical wind predictions. We address this by comparing the non-dimensional velocity magnitude differences between simulations with multiple tree LoDs. To further understand these differences in changing environmental contexts we use three morphologies: an isolated tree, an idealized street, canyon, and a real urban geometry from Rotterdam, The Netherlands The numerical results show that the velocity magnitude differences between the cases with LoD1 tree models and those with LoD2 tree models can be over 1.0 m/s while the differences between LoD2 and LoD3 cases are rather limited, usually lower than 0.2 m/s. Consequently, through this study we highlight the importance of using tree models in LoD2 or LoD3 at least for CFD simulations of wind flows in urban areas. To further support this conclusion we also analyze the impact of changing wind directions and tree Leaf Area Density (LAD) values in the impact of tree LoDs on wind. The differences found in this work linked to the level of realism in your tree models can support future studies where researchers want to make an informed choice.

CFD
Level of detail
Tree model
Urban area
Wind flow

http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:c21148a4-4e92-40cf-b9eb-696a657ea4bd

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2023.105143

2210-6707

Sustainable Cities and Society, 101

Institutional Repository

journal article

© 2024 Runnan Fu, I. Pađen, C. Garcia Sanchez