MK

M.D. Klapwijk

info

Please Note

10 records found

Journal article (2022) - Maarten Klapwijk, Thomas Lloyd, Guilherme Vaz
A new partially averaged Navier-Stokes (PANS) closure is derived based on the k-kL (KSKL) model. The aim of this new model is to incorporate the desirable features of the KSKL model, compared to the k-ω shear stress transport model, into the PANS framework. These features include reduced eddy-viscosity levels, a lower dependency on the cell height at the wall, well-defined boundary conditions, and improved iterative convergence. As well as the new model derivation, the paper demonstrates that these desirable features are indeed maintained, for a range of modeled-to-total turbulence kinetic energy ratios (fk), and even for multiphase flow. ...
Doctoral thesis (2021) - M.D. Klapwijk, T.J.C. van Terwisga, J. Westerweel
There is increasing attention for the effects of anthropogenic underwater radiated noise (URN) on marine fauna. This is expected to lead to regulations with respect to the maximum permitted sound emissions of ships. It is known that cavitating tip vortices, generated by ship propellers, are some of the key contributors to URN. Consequently, there is a need to evaluate propeller designs with respect to noise generation in a design stage. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has the potential to offer detailed insights into cavitating vortex dynamics and noise sources, at a reasonable cost. URN can be efficiently estimated using CFD in combination with an acoustic analogy. In order to use such predictions in a design process, it is essential to understand and quantify the errors associated with the numerical predictions of noise sources. This thesis investigates the reliability of such evaluations and aims to reduce occurring modelling errors.

To compute noise sources, it is necessary to simulate cavitation dynamics using scale-resolving simulations (SRS). Here, part of the turbulence kinetic energy spectrum is resolved in space and time, as opposed to being modelled using Reynolds averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS). The SRS method of choice in this work is the partially averaged Navier-Stokes (PANS) method. Bridging models, such as PANS, exhibit a smooth transition and absence of commutation errors between RANS and large eddy simulation (LES) zones, in contrast to hybrid models such as detached eddy simulation (DES). The formulation allows for a theoretical decoupling of the discretisation and modelling errors, thereby enabling verification and validation processes.

PANS allows the user to select the ratios of resolved-to-total turbulence kinetic energy and dissipation (rate). Appropriate settings and methods to estimate these settings a priori are investigated. Furthermore, a new PANS closure is developed, which offers improved convergence behaviour compared to more commonly used models, and is better suited to application for multiphase flows. It has been shown repeatedly in literature that SRS should be accompanied by physical inflow boundary conditions, where time-varying fluctuations, resembling turbulence, should be inserted upstream of the object of interest, to prevent laminar solutions. However, from literature it is clear that for maritime applications this is often neglected. To the knowledge of the author, there is no previous application of such an inflow in combination with cavitation. In this PhD thesis, a synthetic inflow turbulence generator (ITG) is implemented, and tested for several test cases in wetted and cavitating conditions. For these cases, the numerical errors, consisting of discretisation, iterative and statistical errors are evaluated.

Firstly, the results when using the ITG are compared against recycling flow results for a turbulent channel flow, using different SRS methods. It was shown that the ITG can deliver a resolved turbulent inflow at lower computational cost. Secondly, the effect of neglecting such an inflow was tested for the Delft Twist 11 hydrofoil, where it was shown that simulating such a flow with a low ratio of resolved-to-total turbulence kinetic energy can lead to flow separation at the wing leading edge. This is in contrast to experimentally observed behaviour. The inclusion of the ITG can reduce this modelling error, although the sheet cavity dynamics remain largely unaffected. Finally, an elliptical wing with a cavitating tip vortex is simulated. The observed vortex dynamics are compared against a semi-analytical model from literature. To obtain vortex dynamics, the ITG was shown to be necessary. The far-field noise generated by the vortex is quantified and related to the cavity dynamics.

Some of the main contributions of this research are improved insight in the use of SRS in cavitating conditions, in simulating cavity dynamics and in using an ITG to obtain flow fields representative of experimental conditions. In this way it has enhanced our understanding of the ability and limitations in the prediction of acoustic sources due to cavitation. To improve predictions of cavitation dynamics it is recommended to address the cavitation model and the method which describes the cavity interface, to reduce the discrepancy in average cavity size between simulations and experimental observations. ...
Journal article (2021) - Artur K. Lidtke, Maarten Klapwijk, Thomas Lloyd
Inflow turbulence is relevant for many engineering applications relating to noise generation, including aircraft wings, landing gears, and non-cavitating marine propellers. While modelling of this phenomenon is well-established for higher Mach number aerospace problems, lower Mach number applications, which include marine propellers, still lack validated numerical tools. For this purpose, simplified cases for which extensive measurement data are available can be used. This paper investigates the effect of inflow turbulence on a circular cylinder at a Reynolds number of 14,700, a Mach number of 0.029, and with inflow turbulence intensities ranging between 0% and 22%. In the present work focus is put on the hydrodynamics aspect, with the aim of addressing radiated noise in a later study. The flow is simulated using the partially averaged Navier Stokes equations, with turbulence inserted using a synthetic inflow turbulence generator. Results show that the proposed method can successfully replicate nearfield pressure variations and relevant flow features in the wake of the body. In agreement with the literature, increasing inflow turbulence intensity adds broadband frequency content to all the presented fluctuating flow quantities. In addition, the applied variations in inflow turbulence intensity result in a major shift in flow dynamics around a turbulence intensity of 15%, when the dominant effect of von Kármán vortices on the dominant flow dynamics becomes superseded by freestream turbulence. ...
Journal article (2021) - M.D. Klapwijk, Sébastien Lemaire
Increased graphical capabilities of contemporary computer hardware make ray tracing possible for a much wider range of applications. In science, and numerical fluid mechanics in particular, visual inspections still play a key role in both understanding flows, predicted by computational fluid dynamics, exhibiting features observable in real-life, such as interfaces or smoke, and when comparing such flows against experimental observations. Usually, little attention is paid to the visualisation itself, unless when the render is used solely for its eye-catching appearance. In this work, we argue that the use of ray tracing software can help make comparisons between computational and experimental fluid dynamics more robust and meaningful, and that, in some cases, it is even a necessity. Several visualisation problems which can be overcome through application of this methodology are discussed, and the use of ray tracing is exemplified for several common test cases in the maritime field. Using these examples the benefits of ray tracing are shown, and it is concluded that ray tracing can improve the reliability of scientific visual comparisons ...
Journal article (2021) - Rens Liebrand, Maarten Klapwijk, Thomas Lloyd, Guilherme Vaz
This study evaluates the influence of transition and turbulence modeling on the prediction of wetted and cavitating tip vortices for an elliptical wing, while investigating the numerical errors. Transition modeling increases the quality of numerical predictions since the assumption of a fully turbulent boundary layer, commonly found in literature, contributes to underprediction of the tip vortex cavity size. By applying the local correlation-based transition model (LCTM) and controlling the boundary layer thickness using different turbulent inflow conditions, the pressure in the vortex was found to reduce by 20% for an Angle of Attack (AoA) of 5 deg. The consequent increase in cavity size was found to be of a similar order of magnitude. At 9 deg AoA, transition always occurs just downstream of the leading edge, making this AoA more suitable to investigate the effect of different turbulence modeling approaches. Azimuthal and axial velocity fields are validated against stereographic-particle image velocimetry (S-PIV) measurements. The time-averaged velocity profiles predicted by delayed detached-eddy simulation (DDES) and improved delayed detached-eddy simulation (IDDES) are close to the experiments; however, no velocity fluctuations and vortex dynamics are observed around the vortex. A comparison of wetted and cavitating simulations shows that the cavity leads to a change in the balance between production and destruction of turbulence kinetic energy, which reduces the turbulent diffusion in and around the cavity compared to wetted flow conditions. Consequently, the vapor flow exhibits the characteristics of a potential flow. Whether this is physically plausible remains to be investigated. ...
Journal article (2021) - M. Klapwijk, T. Lloyd, G. Vaz, T. van Terwisga
The Delft Twist 11 Hydrofoil is a common test case for investigating the interaction between turbulence and cavitation modelling in computational fluid dynamics. Despite repeated investigations, results reported for the lift and drag coefficient are accompanied by significant uncertainties, both in experimental and numerical studies. When using scale-resolving approaches, it is known that turbulent fluctuations must be inserted into the domain in order to prevent the flow from remaining laminar around the body of interest, although this has been overlooked until now for the present test case. This work investigates the errors occurring when a laminar inflow is applied for mildly separated or attached flows, by employing the partially averaged Navier–Stokes equations with varying values for the ratio of modelled-to-total turbulence kinetic energy, and with varying grid densities. It is shown that depending on the grid resolution laminar leading edge separation can occur. When turbulent fluctuations are added to the inflow, the leading edge separation is suppressed completely, and the turbulent separation zone near the trailing edge reduces in size. The inflow turbulence has a large effect on the skin friction, which increases with increasing turbulence intensity to a limit determined by the grid resolution. In cavitating conditions the integral quantities are dominated by the shedding sheet cavity. The turbulence intensity has little effect on the pressure distribution, leading to a largely unaffected sheet cavitation, although the shedding behaviour is affected. It is shown that, especially in wetted flow conditions, with scale-resolving methods inflow turbulence is necessary to match the experimental flow field. ...
Journal article (2020) - M. Klapwijk, T. Lloyd, G. Vaz, T. van Terwisga
Different variable resolution turbulence modelling approaches (Hybrid, Bridging models and LES) are evaluated for turbulent channel flow at Reτ=395, for cases using either streamwise periodic boundary conditions or a synthetic turbulence generator. The effect of iterative, statistical and discretisation errors is investigated. For LES, little difference between the different sub-filter modelling approaches is found on the finer grids, while on coarser grids ILES deviates from explicit LES approaches. The results for Hybrid models are strongly dependent on their formulation, and the corresponding blending between the RANS and LES regions. The application of PANS with different ratios of modelled-to-total kinetic energy, fk, shows that there is no smooth transition in the results between RANS and DNS. Instead a case-dependent threshold which separates two solution regimes is observed: fk values below 0.2 yield a proper turbulent solution, similar to LES results; higher fk values lead to a laminar flow due to filtering of the smallest scales in the inverse energy cascade. The application of a synthetic turbulence generator is observed to yield similar performance for all models. The reduced computational cost and increased flexibility makes it a suitable approach to enable the usage of SRS for industrial flow cases which depend on the development of a turbulent boundary layer. It ensures that sufficient large-scale structures develop over the full boundary layer height, thereby negating the problem of relying on the inverse energy cascade for the development of turbulence. Both LES and PANS with turbulence generator yield a better match with the reference data than Hybrid models; of these methods PANS is preferable due to the separation of modelling and discretisation errors. ...

Low versus high Reynolds number approach

Conference paper (2019) - Maarten Klapwijk, Thomas Lloyd, Guilherme Vaz, T.J.C. van Terwisga
...
Conference paper (2019) - Rens Liebrand, Maarten Klapwijk, Thomas Lloyd, Guilherme Vaz, Rui Lopes
A sensitivity analysis of the transitional flow over a NACA662 - 415 foil and the elliptical Arndt wing is carried out. The SST turbulence model is complemented with the ? - Re ~?t transition model to determine the effect of varying turbulence intensity and eddy-viscosity ratio on the integral quantities and transition locations. Local grid refinement at the transition location is used to improve convergence. The skin friction drag coefficient is found to be more sensitive to the inflow conditions for 5? angle of attack compared to 9?. The movement of the transition location on the suction side is found to be responsible for this. The transition model captures a laminar separation bubble at the pressure side for both angles of attack, causing the lift coefficient to drop slightly. 3D calculations for the Arndt wing with the same foil section show that applying a transition model can decrease the boundary layer thickness by a factor of three, which is expected to influence the viscous core radius and consequently the minimum pressure in the tip vortex. ...
Journal article (2019) - Maarten Klapwijk, T. Lloyd, G. Vaz
Partially Averaged Navier–Stokes computations can employ three different approaches for specifying the ratio of modelled-to-total turbulence kinetic energy fk. Use can be made of either a constant, a spatially- or a spatially- and temporally-varying value. This work compares different estimates for fk found in literature and evaluates them for two test-cases: a circular cylinder at Re=3900 and a turbulent channel flow at Reτ=395. Additionally, the estimates are compared to the a posteriori computed ratio of modelled-to-total turbulence kinetic energy()hfk˜ obtained from the PANS flow solution. The trends observed for the estimates are similar, although the magnitude varies significantly. All spatially varying fk approaches reduce the PANS model to a DES-like model, thereby entangling modelling and discretisation errors. At the same time, fk˜ shows that the behaviour of these estimates is incorrect: fk becomes too large near the wall of the object and in the far field. It is observed that fk˜ is always lower than the set value, when using fk fixed in space and time. Finally, it is clear that the estimates, applied to internal, boundary layer, flows yield too high values for fk. In order to minimise errors and increase the reliability of industrial CFD results, the approach with a constant fk is still preferable, assuming suitably fine grids are used. ...