Electrolytic bicarbonate conversion holds the promise to integrate carbon capture directly with electrochemical conversion. Most research has focused on improving the faradaic efficiencies of the system, however, the stability of the system has not been thoroughly addressed. Here, we find that the bulk electrolyte pH has a large effect on the selectivity, where a higher pH results in a lower selectivity. However, the bulk electrolyte pH has no effect on the stability of the system. A decrease in CO selectivity of 30 % was observed within the first three hours of operation in an optimized system with 3 M KHCO₃ and gap between the membrane and electrode. Single-pass electrolyte experiments at various constant pH values (8.5, 9.0, 9.5, and 10.0), show that only at a pH of 10 the CO selectivity was stable during three hours, reaching a faradaic efficiency toward CO of only 18 % as compared to an initial 55 % at pH 8.5. Trace metal impurities present in the electrolyte were found to be the cause of the decrease in stability as these deposit on the electrode surface. By complexing the trace metal ions with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), the metal deposition was avoided and a stable CO selectivity was obtained.