T.J. Konijn
info
Please Note
<p>This page displays the records of the person named above and is not linked to a unique person identifier. This record may need to be merged to a profile.</p>
2 records found
1
A multi-fluid approach for polydisperse pebble accretion
From particles to fluids, establishing the multi-fluid framework
Context. Pebble accretion offers an efficient pathway to form planets, driven by a constant supply of inward drifting mass and an accretion efficiency enhanced by gas drag. While most studies assume a single pebble size (monodisperse), real discs contain a range of sizes (polydisperse) that drift, interact, and accrete at different rates.
Aims. We aim to model polydisperse pebble accretion with a fluid approach, validating the method and exploring how gas disc evolution, solid-to-gas back-reaction, and a polydisperse size distribution affect growth.
Methods. We used FARGO3D, modified to allow pebble accretion, to run 2D hydrodynamic simulations in a global disc with multiple pebble species representing an underlying continuous pebble size distribution.
Results. With our multi-fluid approach, we find values for pebble accretion efficiency consistent with earlier studies for a static gas disc. This confirms that our approach gives an accurate representation of pebble accretion. Evolving the gas disc, we find lower efficiencies compared to an unperturbed gas disc for high Stokes numbers (≳0.3) and higher efficiencies for smaller Stokes numbers (≲0.3). This effect increases for higher planet masses. The accretion rate is mostly dominated by the highest Stokes numbers in our parameter study (St ∈ [10−2,100]). The ratio we find between the polydisperse and monodisperse pebble accretion rates is higher than previous estimations.
Conclusions. We constructed a multi-fluid model framework capable of accurately simulating polydisperse pebble accretion consistent with previous studies. This framework offers advantages for simulating higher planet masses and for modelling multiple pebble species coupled to the gas. We find that the protoplanet’s perturbation of the gas-disc lowers the accretion rate when assuming an MRN-distribution of solids. ...
Aims. We aim to model polydisperse pebble accretion with a fluid approach, validating the method and exploring how gas disc evolution, solid-to-gas back-reaction, and a polydisperse size distribution affect growth.
Methods. We used FARGO3D, modified to allow pebble accretion, to run 2D hydrodynamic simulations in a global disc with multiple pebble species representing an underlying continuous pebble size distribution.
Results. With our multi-fluid approach, we find values for pebble accretion efficiency consistent with earlier studies for a static gas disc. This confirms that our approach gives an accurate representation of pebble accretion. Evolving the gas disc, we find lower efficiencies compared to an unperturbed gas disc for high Stokes numbers (≳0.3) and higher efficiencies for smaller Stokes numbers (≲0.3). This effect increases for higher planet masses. The accretion rate is mostly dominated by the highest Stokes numbers in our parameter study (St ∈ [10−2,100]). The ratio we find between the polydisperse and monodisperse pebble accretion rates is higher than previous estimations.
Conclusions. We constructed a multi-fluid model framework capable of accurately simulating polydisperse pebble accretion consistent with previous studies. This framework offers advantages for simulating higher planet masses and for modelling multiple pebble species coupled to the gas. We find that the protoplanet’s perturbation of the gas-disc lowers the accretion rate when assuming an MRN-distribution of solids. ...
Context. Pebble accretion offers an efficient pathway to form planets, driven by a constant supply of inward drifting mass and an accretion efficiency enhanced by gas drag. While most studies assume a single pebble size (monodisperse), real discs contain a range of sizes (polydisperse) that drift, interact, and accrete at different rates.
Aims. We aim to model polydisperse pebble accretion with a fluid approach, validating the method and exploring how gas disc evolution, solid-to-gas back-reaction, and a polydisperse size distribution affect growth.
Methods. We used FARGO3D, modified to allow pebble accretion, to run 2D hydrodynamic simulations in a global disc with multiple pebble species representing an underlying continuous pebble size distribution.
Results. With our multi-fluid approach, we find values for pebble accretion efficiency consistent with earlier studies for a static gas disc. This confirms that our approach gives an accurate representation of pebble accretion. Evolving the gas disc, we find lower efficiencies compared to an unperturbed gas disc for high Stokes numbers (≳0.3) and higher efficiencies for smaller Stokes numbers (≲0.3). This effect increases for higher planet masses. The accretion rate is mostly dominated by the highest Stokes numbers in our parameter study (St ∈ [10−2,100]). The ratio we find between the polydisperse and monodisperse pebble accretion rates is higher than previous estimations.
Conclusions. We constructed a multi-fluid model framework capable of accurately simulating polydisperse pebble accretion consistent with previous studies. This framework offers advantages for simulating higher planet masses and for modelling multiple pebble species coupled to the gas. We find that the protoplanet’s perturbation of the gas-disc lowers the accretion rate when assuming an MRN-distribution of solids.
Aims. We aim to model polydisperse pebble accretion with a fluid approach, validating the method and exploring how gas disc evolution, solid-to-gas back-reaction, and a polydisperse size distribution affect growth.
Methods. We used FARGO3D, modified to allow pebble accretion, to run 2D hydrodynamic simulations in a global disc with multiple pebble species representing an underlying continuous pebble size distribution.
Results. With our multi-fluid approach, we find values for pebble accretion efficiency consistent with earlier studies for a static gas disc. This confirms that our approach gives an accurate representation of pebble accretion. Evolving the gas disc, we find lower efficiencies compared to an unperturbed gas disc for high Stokes numbers (≳0.3) and higher efficiencies for smaller Stokes numbers (≲0.3). This effect increases for higher planet masses. The accretion rate is mostly dominated by the highest Stokes numbers in our parameter study (St ∈ [10−2,100]). The ratio we find between the polydisperse and monodisperse pebble accretion rates is higher than previous estimations.
Conclusions. We constructed a multi-fluid model framework capable of accurately simulating polydisperse pebble accretion consistent with previous studies. This framework offers advantages for simulating higher planet masses and for modelling multiple pebble species coupled to the gas. We find that the protoplanet’s perturbation of the gas-disc lowers the accretion rate when assuming an MRN-distribution of solids.
Journal article
(2023)
-
T.J. Konijn, R.G. Visser, C. Dominik, C.W. Ormel
Context. Binary Solar System objects are common, ranging from satellite systems with very large mass ratios, M1/M2, to those with mass ratios approaching unity. One well-known example of a binary is the Pluto-Charon system. With Charon being 'only' eight times less massive than Pluto, the question arises (as in the case of many other systems) as to why the mass ratio is still close to unity. There is much evidence that (binary) planet(esimal) formation happened early, when the protoplanetary gas disk was still present. It is likely that (at least some of) these binaries evolved together, as a result of pebble accretion. Pebble accretion is a new key paradigm in planetary formation and it is believed to play a major role in many aspects of the formation of planetary systems, from the radial transport of material to the rapid growth of planetary embryos throughout the system.
Aims. Here, we focus on the question of how the mass arriving in the gravitational influence zone of the binary during pebble accretion is distributed over the binary components for a given initial mass ratio. We also consider whether accretion over time leads to equal-mass binaries (converging mass ratio) or to a dominant primary mass with a small moon (diverging mass ratio).
Methods. We numerically integrated two-dimensional (2D) pebble trajectories in the same typical fashion as for a single mass that is subject to pebble accretion. We tracked the efficiency of accretion for the two separate binary components, compared to a single body with the same mass. These numerical simulations were done for a range of binary mass ratios, mutual separations, Stokes numbers, and two orbital distances, 2.5 and 39 au.
Results. We find that in the limit where pebbles start to spiral around the primary (this holds for relatively large pebbles), the pebble preferentially collides with the secondary, causing the mass ratio to converge towards unity. In our tested case, where the total binary mass is equal to that of the Pluto-Charon system, this takes place on ~Myr timescales. In this regime the total sweep-up efficiency can lower to half that of a pebble-accreting single body because pebbles that are thrown out of the system, after close encounters with the system. These timescales and sweep-up efficiency are calculated under the assumption our 2D simulations compare with the 3D reality. The results show that systems such as Pluto-Charon and other larger equal mass binaries may well have co-accreted by means of pebble accretion in the disk phase without producing binaries, with highly diverging mass ratios. ...
Aims. Here, we focus on the question of how the mass arriving in the gravitational influence zone of the binary during pebble accretion is distributed over the binary components for a given initial mass ratio. We also consider whether accretion over time leads to equal-mass binaries (converging mass ratio) or to a dominant primary mass with a small moon (diverging mass ratio).
Methods. We numerically integrated two-dimensional (2D) pebble trajectories in the same typical fashion as for a single mass that is subject to pebble accretion. We tracked the efficiency of accretion for the two separate binary components, compared to a single body with the same mass. These numerical simulations were done for a range of binary mass ratios, mutual separations, Stokes numbers, and two orbital distances, 2.5 and 39 au.
Results. We find that in the limit where pebbles start to spiral around the primary (this holds for relatively large pebbles), the pebble preferentially collides with the secondary, causing the mass ratio to converge towards unity. In our tested case, where the total binary mass is equal to that of the Pluto-Charon system, this takes place on ~Myr timescales. In this regime the total sweep-up efficiency can lower to half that of a pebble-accreting single body because pebbles that are thrown out of the system, after close encounters with the system. These timescales and sweep-up efficiency are calculated under the assumption our 2D simulations compare with the 3D reality. The results show that systems such as Pluto-Charon and other larger equal mass binaries may well have co-accreted by means of pebble accretion in the disk phase without producing binaries, with highly diverging mass ratios. ...
Context. Binary Solar System objects are common, ranging from satellite systems with very large mass ratios, M1/M2, to those with mass ratios approaching unity. One well-known example of a binary is the Pluto-Charon system. With Charon being 'only' eight times less massive than Pluto, the question arises (as in the case of many other systems) as to why the mass ratio is still close to unity. There is much evidence that (binary) planet(esimal) formation happened early, when the protoplanetary gas disk was still present. It is likely that (at least some of) these binaries evolved together, as a result of pebble accretion. Pebble accretion is a new key paradigm in planetary formation and it is believed to play a major role in many aspects of the formation of planetary systems, from the radial transport of material to the rapid growth of planetary embryos throughout the system.
Aims. Here, we focus on the question of how the mass arriving in the gravitational influence zone of the binary during pebble accretion is distributed over the binary components for a given initial mass ratio. We also consider whether accretion over time leads to equal-mass binaries (converging mass ratio) or to a dominant primary mass with a small moon (diverging mass ratio).
Methods. We numerically integrated two-dimensional (2D) pebble trajectories in the same typical fashion as for a single mass that is subject to pebble accretion. We tracked the efficiency of accretion for the two separate binary components, compared to a single body with the same mass. These numerical simulations were done for a range of binary mass ratios, mutual separations, Stokes numbers, and two orbital distances, 2.5 and 39 au.
Results. We find that in the limit where pebbles start to spiral around the primary (this holds for relatively large pebbles), the pebble preferentially collides with the secondary, causing the mass ratio to converge towards unity. In our tested case, where the total binary mass is equal to that of the Pluto-Charon system, this takes place on ~Myr timescales. In this regime the total sweep-up efficiency can lower to half that of a pebble-accreting single body because pebbles that are thrown out of the system, after close encounters with the system. These timescales and sweep-up efficiency are calculated under the assumption our 2D simulations compare with the 3D reality. The results show that systems such as Pluto-Charon and other larger equal mass binaries may well have co-accreted by means of pebble accretion in the disk phase without producing binaries, with highly diverging mass ratios.
Aims. Here, we focus on the question of how the mass arriving in the gravitational influence zone of the binary during pebble accretion is distributed over the binary components for a given initial mass ratio. We also consider whether accretion over time leads to equal-mass binaries (converging mass ratio) or to a dominant primary mass with a small moon (diverging mass ratio).
Methods. We numerically integrated two-dimensional (2D) pebble trajectories in the same typical fashion as for a single mass that is subject to pebble accretion. We tracked the efficiency of accretion for the two separate binary components, compared to a single body with the same mass. These numerical simulations were done for a range of binary mass ratios, mutual separations, Stokes numbers, and two orbital distances, 2.5 and 39 au.
Results. We find that in the limit where pebbles start to spiral around the primary (this holds for relatively large pebbles), the pebble preferentially collides with the secondary, causing the mass ratio to converge towards unity. In our tested case, where the total binary mass is equal to that of the Pluto-Charon system, this takes place on ~Myr timescales. In this regime the total sweep-up efficiency can lower to half that of a pebble-accreting single body because pebbles that are thrown out of the system, after close encounters with the system. These timescales and sweep-up efficiency are calculated under the assumption our 2D simulations compare with the 3D reality. The results show that systems such as Pluto-Charon and other larger equal mass binaries may well have co-accreted by means of pebble accretion in the disk phase without producing binaries, with highly diverging mass ratios.