The design of machinery for handling granular materials relies mainly on empirical methods and in-house engineering knowledge. This traditional approach provides incremental improvements that are often limited. Advancements in simulation and optimization can offer a promising alternative approach. Most of the research involved in improving or optimizing equipment design does not include the realistic performance of the new prototype and as such it is uncertain that the predicted performance is also guaranteed in practice. In this study, a design framework for a new generation of machinery handling granular materials, grabs, has been established that includes a full-scale validation step. This has been proven to lead to a breakthrough in equipment design. This design framework uses a co-simulation between Discrete Element Method (DEM) and Multi Body Dynamics (MBD), thus, capturing operational conditions in full-scale. The DEM simulation supported design step integrated as the main step to generate new prototypes. The performance of the prototype is evaluated by conducting full-scale experiments, thus validating the adequacy of the new design as well as the accuracy of the co-simulation. Through this a full design cycle has been fulfilled and a validated model has been achieved that is independent of specific design configurations.

Purpose: The development of bulk material handling equipment can be accelerated and made less expensive when testing of virtual prototypes is adopted. However, the modelling of a grab unloader requires a large volume (77 m3) of iron ore pellets, making the computational costs prohibitive. This paper investigates the extent to which the original particles can be substituted by larger, coarser grains. It is crucial that this particle upscaling does not alter the realistic behaviour of the simulated bulk material, nor its interaction with the bulk handling equipment. Approach: First, our coarse graining technique is explained and set out for the particle system at hand. The material behaviour is then characterized using three laboratory experiments (two angle of repose tests and a penetration test). Next, the results of simulations using two contact models with and without coarse graining with different scale factors are compared with the measured material behaviour and material-equipment interaction. This includes a comparison of the macrobehaviour of the bulk material and the tool interaction of coarser grains in a cutting and sliding process. After reaching a satisfactory verified solution on the laboratory scale, the material behaviour and interaction behaviour of a large-scale experiment are modelled. A simulation model of a grab unloader was used for validation of the chosen coarse graining approach. Findings: Using the scaling method presented, the macroscopic tests indicated consistent material behaviour, regardless of the chosen particle scale for two contactmodels. Scaling of the tool interaction process produced mixed results: the sliding process scaled consistently but the penetration process did not, most likely because it is significantly harder for coarser grains to move since they have to move further to the sides before the tool can pass, leading to higher normal forces and frictional forces on the tip. This inconsistency was compensated for by adjusting the wall friction coefficient in the tip of the penetration tool. Once this adapted coarse graining scheme was applied to the industrial-scale simulation of a grab unloader, it produced consistent particle-scale invariant results. Originality/value: This research is the first to show how coarse graining schemes for DEM simulations can be applied to large-scale bulk handling equipment involving dominance of material equipment interaction through penetration of the bulk material.

Purpose: Bulk material-handling equipment development can be accelerated and is less expensive when testing of virtual prototypes can be adopted. However, often the complexity of the interaction between particulate material and handling equipment cannot be handled by a single computational solver. This paper aims to establish a framework for the development, verification and application of a co-simulation of discrete element method (DEM) and multibody dynamics (MBD). Design/methodology/approach: The two methods have been coupled in two directions, which consists of coupling the load data on the geometry from DEM to MBD and the position data from MBD to DEM. The coupling has been validated thoroughly in several scenarios, and the stability and robustness have been investigated. Findings: All tests clearly demonstrated that the co-simulation is successful in predicting particle–equipment interaction. Examples are provided describing the effects of a coupling that is too tight, as well as a coupling that is too loose. A guideline has been developed for achieving stable and efficient co-simulations. Originality/value: This framework shows how to achieve realistic co-simulations of particulate material and equipment interaction of a dynamic nature.