Methane removal is an essential step in drinking water production from methane-rich groundwaters. Conventional aeration-based stripping results in significant direct methane emissions, contributing up to one-third of a treatment plant's total carbon footprint. To address this, a full-scale trickling filter was operated for biological methane oxidation upstream of a submerged sand filter, and its performance was compared to a conventional aeration–submerged sand filtration set-up. Full-scale data were combined with ex-situ batch assays and metagenome-resolved metaproteomics to quantify the individual contribution of the main (a)biotic processes and characterize the enriched microbial communities. Both treatment setups fully removed methane, iron, ammonium, and manganese, yet the underlying mechanisms differed significantly. Methane was completely removed from the effluent after trickling filtration, with stripping and biological oxidation each accounting for half of the removal, thereby halving overall methane emissions. Methane-oxidizing bacteria not only outcompeted nitrifiers in the trickling filter, but also likely contributed directly to ammonia oxidation. In contrast to the submerged filter preceded by methane stripping, signatures of biological iron oxidation were almost completely absent in the trickling filter, suggesting that the presence of methane directly or indirectly promotes chemical iron oxidation. All systems had similar ex-situ manganese oxidation capacities, yet removal occurred only in the submerged filters but not the trickling filter. Ultimately, our results demonstrate that trickling filtration is effective in promoting biological methane oxidation at comparable produced drinking water quality, highlighting its potential for advancing sustainable drinking water production.