Investigation of the influence of open straight-legged stirrups on the shear resistance of concrete beams

Abstract

Nowadays, Rijkswaterstaat reassesses many older concrete bridges to guarantee their structural safety under the influence of increased traffic loads and stricter standards. Many of these concrete bridges contain open straight-legged stirrups, which are not allowed to take into account for the calculations of the shear resistance according to current standards. This often results in theoretical insufficient shear capacity and critical damage to structures, but this is not observed in reality. This indicates that the open straight-legged stirrups probably do contribute to the shear resistance, where an accurate assessment of this contribution could prevent unnecessary and costly structural safety measures. However, very few shear tests with relevant cross-sectional dimensions are performed and documented in literature, especially tests containing open straight-legged stirrups.

The application of Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis (NLFEA) is a useful tool to evaluate and understand the behaviour of structures, but provisions for the implementation of open straight-legged stirrups in concrete structures are lacking. Thus, the goal of this research is to provide a finite element modelling strategy that is able to accurately describe the behaviour of concrete beams with open straight-legged stirrups subjected to shear. The research focusses on describing the behaviour of rectangular concrete beams with open and closed straight-legged stirrups with finite element models using DIANA 10.5 [1].

Schramm [2] has performed multiple shear tests on prestressed concrete beams with several no longer permitted stirrups, including open straight-legged stirrups. He found that open straight-legged stirrups can significantly contribute to the transfer of shear forces [2]. The relevance of the rectangular test beams for comparison with box-girders is validated in this thesis, where the stress distributions in a linear elastic rectangular and box-girder cross-section due to axial forces, bending moments, shear forces and torsion are compared.

In the interest of providing a suitable solution strategy, Schramm’s test beams with closed and open straight-legged stirrups are reproduced with 3-dimensional nonlinear finite element models based on the recommendations of the RTD1016-1 [3], where the influence of various modelling considerations is investigated. The concrete is modelled with a smeared total strain-based crack model with the Hordijk tensioning and parabolic compression relations, including confinement and lateral cracking effects. Reinforcements are modelled as embedded truss elements with the Von-Mises plasticity model. To describe the accurate anchorage behaviour of the open straight-legged stirrups, the interaction between the surrounding concrete and the stirrups is described with the Shima bond-slip relation. The finite element model is first calibrated with a beam with closed stirrups, where modelling clamped restraints with supports on both sides of the beam result in a too-stiff response. By allowing a little rotational freedom in the form of boundary springs, the stiffness of the beam is manipulated without changing the overall load-bearing behaviour...