The authors regret that the Fig. 6a of the article was incorrect. [...]

Half-joints in concrete bridges are known to exhibit an increased rate of degradation. Their main vulnerability is situated in the re-entrant corner, buried deep inside the joint. This makes visual inspection nearly impossible. A Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) system offers a promising alternative, but interpretation of the half-joint status from SHM data is not straightforward. The study presented in this paper is a case study of the SHM system on the Naardertrekvaart bridge in the Netherlands. Analysis of SHM data revealed a dependence of the movement of the bridge on a seasonal temperature cycle, presumably caused by hindered thermal contraction of the half-joints. This phenomenon offered no reliable estimation of the half-joint status. In addition, from the movement of the lower half-joint nibs under traffic loads, a stiffness parameter was devised, used as an estimation of the half-joint status. The study indicated that a high-frequency approach can increase effectiveness of the SHM system.

The next generation of acoustic emission (AE) applications in concrete structural health monitoring (SHM) relies upon a reliable and quantitative relationship between AE measurements and corresponding AE sources. To achieve this, it is a prerequisite to accurately model the whole AE process that is a multiscale coupling process between local material fracturing and induced elastic wave propagation at structural level. Such a complex process, however, cannot be well addressed in currently available modelling methods. To fill this research gap, this study proposes a lattice modelling approach that achieves for the first time the explicit simulation of complete waveforms of transient AE signals induced by concrete fracture. The proposed approach incorporates an explicit time integration technique with a novel proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control algorithm for reducing spurious oscillations and a Rayleigh damping-based calculation and calibration method for the attenuation of AE waves. In this paper, the proposed lattice modelling approach is implemented to simulate the concrete Mode-I fracturing process in a three-point bending test. Besides the mechanical behaviors and AE hit number, a comparison was conducted between numerically and experimentally obtained AE waveforms. The AE waveforms and their attenuation characteristics simulated by the proposed lattice modelling method turn out to be comparable to experimental results. The proposed approach is of significance for a deep understanding of AE-related fracture mechanisms and a more reliable application of AE technique.

During a proof load test on a bridge, high magnitude loads are applied. To avoid causing irreversible damage, thresholds to the structural responses, the so-called stop criteria, need to be defined. This paper proposes to categorize stop criteria into three levels: green light (related to the serviceability limit state), yellow light (related to potential irreversible damage) and red light (related to potential local collapse). For the Ultimate Limit State, stop criteria for shear and flexure are defined. Shear stop criteria are derived from mechanical models, using traditional strain measurements and acoustic emission measurements. These stop criteria are validated with experiments on reinforced concrete slab strips, straight slabs, and skewed slabs. The resulting traffic light system gives the bridge engineer a tool to make decisions during a proof load test. This approach is a step forward in the interpretation of structural responses during proof load testing.

Safe proof loading of concrete bridges requires reliable stop criteria. Such criteria must ensure sufficient margin to the ultimate resistance and may be based on observations from advanced testing. In particular, the identification of thresholds related to pre-stressed and non-shearreinforced slab structures is currently ongoing with an addition of specific focus on potentially brittle failure modes of such structures. This paper presents representative examples of identifying stop criteria and target load thresholds using a combination of laboratory- and in-situ testing. Responses from recently tested structures and structural elements will be presented to enable discussion and perspectivation. The presented test results show measurable warning with sufficient margin from crack initiation to stop criterion. It was additionally seen that the target load often may be the governing threshold when proof load testing.

Aggregate interlock is considered one of the most important shear transfer mechanisms in concrete members. In the well-established Two-Phase model proposed by Walraven in the 1980s, the shear stress transferred by aggregate interlock is estimated by calculating the projected contact areas of two crack surfaces. As one of the main assumptions in the model, the crack surface is idealized by a plain surface crossing randomly distributed, idealized spherical aggregates. This was a necessary simplification of an actual crack surface in the 1980s because of the lack of measurement equipment as well as computational capacity. With the development of high-accuracy 3D scanning techniques, new possibilities for modelling aggregate interlock have become available. This paper proposes a generalised method to determine the aggregate interlock stresses using the crack surface directly from 3D scanning. The proposed method is cross-verified with the Two-Phase model using the same simplified crack surface. A case study using the scanned crack surfaces of concrete cubes is conducted to investigate the influence of surface roughness. The proposed method provides a new possibility for conducting a refined investigation of the aggregate interlock for new concrete types, especially under the scope of the next-generation Eurocode shear provision.

The concrete slab bridge on Balladelaan in the Netherlands was built in 1946. It is a cast-in-place concrete bridge with five spans that together form a statically indeterminate deck system. For this type of concrete bridge, shear failure often appears to be the critical failure mechanism, raising concerns about the structural capacity and remaining service life of the bridge. Additionally, the bridge has undergone several undocumented modifications over its lifetime, making it difficult to accurately assess its safety. To monitor this bridge and predict its structural capacity, 22 ultrasonic sensors, known as Smart Aggregates (SAs), and 16 temperature sensors were embedded in the bridge by drilling holes to track changes such as crack development, stress variations, and temperature fluctuations. This paper presents the initial phase measurements from the SAs and temperature sensors in the monitoring project. The main goals of this phase are (1) to ensure that the installed sensors function properly and (2) to establish a preliminary correlation between the measurements from the SAs and the temperature sensors.

Reinforced concrete solid slab bridges are often skewed to cross underlying objects, which increases the shear stress concentration at the obtuse corner. Limited experimental evidence on skewed slabs is available, so that both the shear capacity and failure mode in skewed slab bridges are subject to discussion. Therefore, an experimental program at Delft University of Technology investigated the capacity and failure modes in skewed slabs under concentrated loads near the edge. Results from 15 tests on five 1:2-scale slab members result in shear failures and show a decreasing capacity with increasing skew angles. The obtuse corner is found to be critical; the reinforcement layout did not influence the capacity significantly. Comparisons with calculation methods showed reasonable accuracy. A proposed method using a larger integration length around the peak shear stress obtained from linear finite element modeling may be recommended for assessment.

The field of proof-loading has expanded over the last decade with excellent examples of successful collaborations and multidisciplinary approaches. Advanced testing has, as one of the essential subjects in an interdisciplinary assessment, brought significant value to further understanding of structural responses and failure mechanisms related to concrete bridges. This paper presents laboratory and field collapse testing examples in the Netherlands and Denmark, and related investigations of the response of non-shear reinforced slabs until failure. A special focus is dedicated to load application, examples of test approaches, some practical insights and test result comparison. Considerations of the laboratory and field test planning in synergy will be discussed based on the results and experiences obtained. A substantial margin to ultimate failure was found from crack identification or other measurable warnings in all tests. These observations suggests that it is possible to get sufficient warning even for non-shear reinforced concrete slabs structures.

Many existing concrete structures require effective assessment of the bearing capacity. A critical failure mode is shear, especially for concrete structures without or with limited shear reinforcement. The shear failure is brittle and often leads to loss of property and lives. Therefore the shear failure should be indicated before it occurs. A potential solution is to use acoustic emission (AE) monitoring, which is sensitive to minor changes in concrete, even micro-cracking, both on the surface and inside the structure. By combining the knowledge of shear failure processes and AE techniques, this paper presents an AE-based shear failure indication system. The system automatically identifies three levels of structural damage levels up to shear failure, which are categorized from minor to severe levels as green-light, yellow-light, and red-light criteria. The 'traffic light system' is validated using six shear tests on full-scale reinforced concrete beams without shear reinforcement. The robustness of the system is also validated across these tests.

As the existing bridge stock is ageing in various parts of the world, the topic of how to assess, maintain and/or improve, and manage existing bridges becomes increasingly important. Existing bridges may be designed according to outdated codes with requirements that may be considered unsafe nowadays, and for loads that are significantly different than those used nowadays. For those bridges, an accurate assessment leads to more efficient management of the bridge stock. This paper outlines various strategies that lead to an improvement of the assessment, and potentially to the extension of the service life of existing concrete bridges. This paper provides a selected examples that engineers who are faced with the assessment of ageing bridge can use. Ultimately, the presented insights can serve to support countries with a younger bridge stock in the development of an assessment strategy.

As the existing bridge stock is aging, assessment of existing bridges becomes increasingly important. In the Netherlands, the shear capacity of reinforced concrete slab bridges is found to be insufficient. In particular, the shear and punching shear capacity of reinforced concrete slab bridges subjected to concentrated loads from the design tandem or truck is subject to discussion, as the shear behavior is situated in between oneway and two-way shear. Currently, an experimental program is being conducted at Delft University of Technology to determine the shear capacity of straight and skewed reinforced concrete slabs under point loads near to the support. This paper presents the results of the 25 tests conducted on six straight slabs of 5m × 2.5 m × 0.3 m subjected to a proof load testing loading protocol. The failure load and modes of the slabs are described in detail. Reinforced concrete slabs under concentrated loads can fail in shear, punching, and flexure, as well as a combination of these failure modes. The results of the experiments are compared to strength predictions obtained by using current design models and current methods for assessment. These experiments demonstrated that the Dutch guidelines, which are based on previous slab experiments, are an improvement as compared to the Eurocode for the assessment of existing reinforced concrete slab bridges. Ultimately, this work provides recommendations for bridge engineers tasked to assess reinforced concrete skewed slab bridges.

Aging infrastructure globally faces degradation, posing risks and requiring substantial repair investment. Strategic maintenance practices are crucial for evaluating structural conditions and ensuring sustainability. The growing demands on modern materials and structures necessitate enhanced health monitoring approaches. Shifting from reactive to proactive maintenance methodologies is paramount, due to lower investment while keeping the structural performance at acceptable standards. However, quantitative assurance of repair/reinforcement/retrofit programs or self-healing effect in structures is similarly crucial for the operation of the infrastructure. Non-destructive testing (NDT) techniques, such as ultrasound, acoustic emission, and optical methods, play a vital role in assessing structural health. Through real-world case studies, the effectiveness of repair in addition to damage assessment are evaluated, encouraging a more systematic approach to monitoring structural repair efficacy. The paper intends to address the research gap in monitoring the repair effectiveness in civil structures and materials and provides valuable insights to enhance repair strategies in civil engineering.

This paper proposes a new mechanical model to describe the dowel action with the aim of using the model to gain a deeper understanding of the unstable dowel splitting cracking observed in shear experiments of beams without shear reinforcement. The model was developed by combining beam on elastic foundation (BEF) theory and fracture mechanics. The proposed model is able to predict the whole evolution process of dowel action until the propagation of the dowel splitting crack becomes unstable. The model theoretically proves that the development of a dowel splitting crack can become unstable under certain conditions, therefore leading to the unstable shear failure of the whole member. In addition to the derivation of the analytical model, the paper also validates the model using data from the literature. Finally, an analytical solution of the critical shear displacement that triggers the unstable dowel splitting crack is derived. It can be used to improve the failure criterion initially proposed in the Critical Shear Displacement Theory (CSDT).

Dowel action is recognized as one of the major shear resistance mechanisms. Although the dowel action only contributes a relatively small portion of the total shear resistance, the shear failure of reinforced concrete members without shear reinforcement usually occurs accompanied by unstable dowel cracking. This paper presents a new description of the dowel splitting process and a mechanical model based on two theories, namely the Beam on Elastic Foundation (BEF) theory and fracture mechanics. The mechanical model analytically describes the three stages during the dowel splitting of the longitudinal rebar in an RC beam, which are the elastic stage, stable cracking stage and unstable cracking stage. The proposed model can capture the post-peak behaviour of the nature of dowel action. Finally, a simplified equation for engineering practices is proposed. The proposed expression shows promising agreement with the experimental data.

The shear provision for members without shear reinforcement in the second generation of Eurocode has been changed to a new set of formulas based on the critical shear crack theory (CSCT). The formula is based on a shear failure criterion originally developed for reinforced concrete members without shear reinforcement. To allow its application as a design code type for formula, the original CSCT failure criterion undergoes several modifications, such that it can be used to verify the shear resistance of prestressed members as well. Since the new Eurocode shear provision will be applied to design and assess prestressed concrete members in Europe and many other countries in the world, it is important to extensively validate this model. This paper presents a validation study of three different variations of the CSCT strain-based failure criteria, including the one eventually employed in the second generation Eurocode shear provision, using the ACI-DAfStb shear database. The results are also compared with the current Eurocode shear provisions. The second generation Eurocode shear formula appears to be able to determine the shear resistance more accurately than the current one, even for prestressed concrete members without shear reinforcement while it was not actually developed for this. However, Annex I.8 shear formula may lead to an overestimation of the shear resistance for higher values of the effective span to depth ratio (acs/d).

To date, there is no comprehensive approach available that can explicitly model the complete transient waveforms of acoustic emissions (AE) induced by fracture processes in brittle and quasi-brittle materials like concrete. The complexity of AE modelling arises from the intricate coupling between the local discontinuity of material fracturing and the global continuity of elastic wave propagation in solids. Among others, the lattice type models are promising approaches, as they are known to be a matured modelling approach to simulate the fracturing process in concrete-like materials. Nevertheless, like other discrete element methods (DEM), they are currently limited to describing the number and rate of AE events (broken elements) in the fracture process and cannot explicitly model wave generation and propagation. In this study, we propose a lattice modeling framework to simulate the propagation of complete waveforms of fracture-induced AE signals in concrete. A proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control algorithm is incorporated in an explicit time integration procedure to reduce dynamic noise from spurious oscillations. Additionally, a Rayleigh damping-based calculation method and corresponding calibration procedure are proposed to model the attenuation of AE signals due to material damping. Using the developed approach, we systematically investigate the feasibility of lattice models for elastic wave propagation simulation, the dependence of lattice mesh sizes and the choice of numerical damping parameters. These results lead to a systematic framework which can be employed in simulating wave propagation with attenuation using DEM models in general including lattice models.

Proof load testing for assessment can involve a large risk due to the high loads. Stop criteria can reduce this risk. Stop criteria are necessary for shear, which is a brittle failure mode. This paper describes the development of shear stop criteria for slab strips. The shear stop criteria are developed by combining theoretical concepts related to cracking, as well the relationship between bending- and shear-critical regions, along with insights from the Critical Shear Crack Theory and the Critical Shear Displacement Theory. The shear stop criteria are validated with fourteen beam tests. The result is a set of shear stop criteria in a “traffic light system” with a green light level related to serviceability, and yellow and red light related to the ultimate limit state for shear. These stop criteria serve as the basis for a global approach for proof load testing of reinforced concrete bridges.

Aging infrastructure in the Netherlands presents a significant challenge, particularly with precast girder bridges made continuous, which exhibit inadequate shear reinforcement per current design codes. To address shear capacity and accuracy of current assessment practices, a research program including full-scale shear tests is underway at Delft University of Technology. As a part of the research, a blind pre-diction contest with two specimens has been organized. The experiments showed that the loss of composite action at the interface is the primary failure mechanism, and generally an accurate model of the interface behaviour in such composite members is missing. In this paper, a further review of the available interface models and previous tests is conducted. This review leads to the challenges in the accurate evaluation of the interface behaviour, as well as the next steps to address them: a new set of full-scale specimens, and a small-scale test setup reflecting a realistic stress distribution.

Coda wave interferometry (CWI) holds promise as a technique for concrete stress monitoring. This is because the coda, which consists of multiply scattered arrivals, is the result of propagation through the medium over large distances. As such, it is sensitive to both minute structural changes and small velocity changes in that medium. Previous studies focusing on concrete have predominantly utilized the time-domain-based stretching technique to measure travel-time changes. There is, however, a lack of consensus on how to quantify these changes effectively. In this study, we conduct a systematic comparison between two techniques, namely the stretching technique and the wavelet cross-spectrum (WCS) technique, for measuring stress-induced velocity changes in a cylindrical concrete sample. Our comparison focuses on two key aspects: (i) stability against cycle skipping and (ii) consistency in retrieving velocity changes. Experimental results reveal that both the WCS technique and the stretching technique yield consistent velocity changes. In terms of stability, it is challenging to determine which technique performs better, due to differences in the mechanisms triggering cycle skipping. However, when considering waves with frequencies ranging from 50 kHz to 80 kHz, both techniques exhibit comparable performance. Based on our findings, we offer the following recommendations for utilizing these CWI techniques in concrete stress monitoring: For the stretching technique, selecting the time window length based on the wave frequency and the expected magnitude of velocity change. For the WCS technique, operating it in the frequency band where spectral decomposition shows sufficiently high energy in the signal and can accommodate the expected magnitude of velocity change.