The expected growth of civil air traffic and the inclusion of advanced systems in the Royal Netherlands Air Force result in more demanding airspace requirements across all users, making this a scarce resource. To optimise its usage, military airspaces in Amsterdam Flight Information Region are used as Flexible Use of Airspace (FUA), which no longer considers airspace as entirely ‘civil’ or ‘military’, but as a continuum to be allocated temporarily according to user requirements. Given its importance for civil-military cooperation, FUA is at the core of the Dutch Airspace Redesign Programme, considering both a reorganisation of FUA structures and the plannability policies they are reserved with. In order to inform these decisions, this study analyses the effect of FUA availability and plannability on the fuel efficiency of civil commercial traffic. Historical traffic data from the Eurocontrol R&D data archive is sampled for the month of March 2019 and used in three experiments. On the one hand, Experiment 1 investigates FUA availability by considering flights losing route efficiency due to FUA sectors and comparing them with Great Circle Route alternatives and similar flights historically transiting them. On the other hand, Experiment 2 considers flights making use of FUA sectors during times when these have been delegated to civil use to assess the effects of carrying a surplus fuel due to an insufficient airspace plannability. By proposing new plannability policies, the hypothetical reduction in fuel consumption as a result of not taking the surplus fuel is assessed. Lastly, Experiment 3 combines the benefits found in Experiment 1 with the plannability policies of Experiment 2 to determine the fuel benefits resulting from a tactical rerouting enabled by the new plannability concepts. A total of 1,548 simulations have been performed in the open source air traffic simulator BlueSky to compute the fuel efficiency metrics. The results suggest that making both the Alpha and Delta sectors completely available would result in a yearly reduction in fuel consumption of 70,198 and 100,022 tonnes, respectively; 8,908 and 13,301 of which would be saved solely by adopting a new plannability policy (corresponding to 28,060 and 41,898 tonnes of CO2). Finally, not carrying a surplus fuel due to this concept would contribute to an extra 270 and 394 tonnes of fuel consumption being reduced in 2019 (851 and 1,241 tonnes of CO2).