<p>There are several efforts to explore employing drones to replace ground transportation in cities. However, this would mean that the expected traffic densities would be significantly higher than existing air traffic management. A decentralised system for traffic management may be necessary in this future because (1) not all airspace actors will want to freely share data, (2) the uncertainty of missions due to wind or other factors could make a previous plan inoperable, and (3) the ad hoc nature of urban missions makes them difficult to plan in advance. This work focuses on the challenges of drone operations within constrained urban airspace. We define constrained airspace as a virtual network overlaid on the physical environment, where tall buildings and urban infrastructure dictate the allowed routes. Drones are restricted to flying within this virtual network, either above the existing street network or along other predetermined segments. A dynamic and decentralised traffic management method is presented. The method uses current aggregate flow data to identify and alter the cost of travelling through high-density clusters. The goal is to reduce local traffic density and complexity by encouraging alternate routes. Three different clustering strategies are presented that look at the current position of aircraft and recent safety events. The dynamic traffic management method is first illustrated with two simple example scenarios. Then an experiment is conducted with different traffic demand levels within the city of Rotterdam. It was observed that when using traffic complexity indicators, the method is able to reduce safety events by 30 percent while only increasing the distance travelled by 6 percent.</p><p> </p>@en

As urban ground transportation congestion increases, there is growing interest in urban air transportation, such as delivery drones and air taxis. However, managing air traffic in densely populated urban areas poses significant challenges, which require effective flight planning, separation management, and airspace design. This paper investigates dynamic capacity balancing methods to manage air traffic in constrained urban airspace, where drones must fly above the existing road network. Specifically, it compares the effectiveness of labelling high-complexity zones using historical data versus real-time aggregate flow data. The results indicate that while both approaches reduce airspace intrusions and improve safety, the best approach depends on traffic demand levels. At lower demand levels, using historical data yields better safety outcomes, whereas using real-time data is more effective at higher demand levels due to its flexibility. At their best, both methods increase the travel distance by less than 6% while reducing airspace intrusions by 30% compared to a case without dynamic capacity balancing.

@en

Urban air mobility can be a potential solution for urban congestion, and high-level concepts of operations (e.g., UTM, U-space) have been developed with the help of large-scale simulations of multi-agent systems. However, one aspect that should be researched more is the effect of wind on the safety and efficiency of missions in an urban environment. While studies that analyse the potential effect of wind on U-space operations exist, they mostly use constant wind fields, or highly simplified wind models. The study at hand investigates whether medium-fidelity CFD models can be used to predict and match recorded wind data in the city centre of The Hague. Six locations with distinct urban features were chosen, and wind measurements were recorded on two separate days. Using the rooftop wind properties obtained during the measurement sessions, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations were performed within a large urban model of the city. Results indicate that there are large discrepancies between the simulated and measured values. Some wind phenomena observed within the measured wind data were also replicated by the CFD model. Thus, based on the results presented in this work, future research should focus on improving computer city models and wind measurement methods to ensure the development of concepts of operations that maximise the safety and efficiency of future U-space operations. @en

Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) Traffic Management (UTM) is an active research subject as its proposed applications are increasing. UTM aims to enable a variety of UAS operations, including package delivery, infrastructure inspection, and emergency missions. That creates the need for extensive research on how to incorporate such traffic, as conventional methods and operations used in Air Traffic Management (ATM) are not suitable for constrained urban airspace. This paper proposes and compares several traffic capacity balancing methods developed for a UTM system designed to be used in highly dense, very low-level urban airspace. Three types of location-based dynamic traffic capacity management techniques are tested: street-based, grid-based, and cluster-based. The proposed systems are tested by simulating traffic within mixed (constrained and open) urban airspace based on the city of Vienna at five different traffic densities. Results show that using local, area-based clustering for capacity balancing within a UTM system improves safety, efficiency, and capacity metrics, especially when simulated or historical traffic data are used.

@en

The use of small aircraft for a wide range of missions in urban airspace is expected to increase in the future. In Europe, efforts have been invested into developing a unified system, called U-space, to manage aircraft in dense very-low-level urban airspace. The Metropolis II project aimed to research what degree of centralisation an air traffic management system should use in such airspace. The paper at hand is a follow-up, and investigates improvements that can be brought to the tactical conflict prevention, detection, and resolution module of such a system in order to harmonise these components with an organic high-density U-space environment. The proposed improvements are: the prioritisation of vertical conflict prevention in intersections, the use of intent in detecting and resolving conflicts, and the use of heading-based manoeuvres in open airspace. Results show that the use of intent information in the conflict detection process, as well as the implementation of suitable tactical prevention procedures, can greatly increase airspace safety. Furthermore, the experiments revealed that the effectiveness of conflict resolution algorithms is highly dependent on the airspace rules and structure. This reiterates the potential for increasing the safety and efficiency of operations within constrained airspace if the tactical separation modules are unified with the other components of air traffic management systems for U-space. @en

The interest in urban air mobility as a potential solution for urban congestion is steadily growing. Air operations in urban areas can present added complexity as compared with traditional air traffic management. As a result, it is necessary to test and develop novel airspace designs and rules. As airspace in urban areas is a scarce resource, creating structures and rules that effectively utilise the airspace is an important challenge. This work specifically focuses on layered airspace design in urban operations constrained to fly between the existing buildings. Two design parameters of airspace design are investigated with two sub-experiments. Sub-experiment 1 investigates layer function assignment by comparing concepts from previous research with different layer assignment distributions. Sub-experiment 2 investigates the flight rules of vertical distribution of traffic within the airspace, to determine whether this is best achieved in a static (pre-allocated) or dynamic manner. Both sub-experiments analyse the overall system safety, route duration, and route distance under increasing traffic demand. Results reveal that the importance of cruising airspace is apparent at high densities. Results also shows that the safest layer allocation flight rule depends on the traffic density. At lower densities dynamic rules help to spread traffic locally. However, when the airspace is saturated it is safer to pre-allocate flight heights if achieved uniformly.@en

The rate of urbanization is expected to continue increasing. This has led to an interest in using drones and air taxis for urban transportation in place of the current methods, which often lead to road congestion. In most places urban air operations will happen above buildings. However, in many cities with large skyscrapers it may not be efficient to fly above buildings as it would add travel distance. For these cases, aircraft will have to operate in constrained airspace (above roads and between buildings). There is still a knowledge gap for operating in constrained very low-level urban airspace. Most studies attempt to improve the safety in constrained airspace with strategic or tactical conflict resolution. But this may not be enough to ensure safety in highly-dense urban environments. The restriction of heading manoeuvres by buildings substantially limits the solution space for conflict resolution. Therefore, conflict prevention with airspace design can be an important tool for improving airspace safety. In a layered airspace, turn layers can be used so that turning aircraft do not create bottlenecks for cruising aircraft that may be behind it. However, merging conflicts can occur when these turning aircraft attempt to re-enter cruising layers. These are typical in both orthogonal (New York) and non-orthogonal (Paris) street networks. Non-orthogonal street networks can also create merging conflicts because it is not always possible to segment cruising aircraft at intersections. This work will propose two conflict prevention doctoral research experiments that aim to reduce merging conflicts. The first will use three different layering techniques to reduce merging conflicts created by turn layers. The second will focus on merging conflicts that are typical of non-orthogonal networks. @en

In order to enable the safe and efficient integration of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles into very low level airspace, current day research focuses on the development of new traffic services and procedures. One of these is the geovectoring protocol, which aims to reduce traffic complexity by setting limits on the allowed ground speed, course, and vertical speed. A geovector can be used to increase the capacity of an airspace by lowering the conflict rate. However, problems emerge when performing avoidance maneuvers in geovectored airspace, as the limits are ignored in this process. A powerful conflict resolution algorithm is the Modified Voltage Potential (MVP). This paper proposes an extension to the MVP algorithm, based on Velocity Obstacle theory. Making use of an alternative horizontal conflict resolution maneuver which respects the geovector, five resolution strategies are defined with different priority settings for the separate limits. The performance of these strategies is compared to pure MVP on geovector, safety, and stability measures, making use of fast-time simulations in a corridor airspace. All geovector resolution strategies show improvements on the ability to perform conflict resolution maneuvers within the geovector limits, while having marginal effects on the overall airspace safety level. It is recommended to further investigate the performance of the geovector resolution strategies for other types of airspace, to verify whether the observed reduction in conflict rate from the geovectors can be reinforced by the resolution strategies.@en

The Metropolis II project aimed to study the impact of centralised separation management for urban aerial mobility. Three concepts were developed in this study: a fully centralised, strategically separated concept, a hybrid concept featuring cen- tralised strategic separation and distributed tactical separation, and a fully distributed tactical concept. A comparative simu- lation study was performed, using traffic scenarios based on predicted demand in an urban airspace in the city of Vienna. Simulations were performed with varying traffic densities and situations. Results show that the purely strategic and purely tactical strategies perform comparably in terms of safety, and that further improvements can be achieved with a combination of those strategies.@en

Air traffic demand has increased at an unprecedented rate in the last decade (albeit interrupted by the COVID pandemic), but capacity has not increased at the same rate. Higher levels of automation and the implementation of decision-support tools for air traffic controllers could help increase capacity and catch up with demand. The air traffic control problem can be effectively modelled as a Markov game, where a team of aircraft (the agents) interact in the airspace (the environment) and cooperatively take resolution actions to achieve a common goal: safe separation in the most efficient way. As in any Markov game, the optimal policy for the team could be learnt through trial and error in a simulated environment using reinforcement learning algorithms. In this paper, we use the soft actor-critic algorithm to unravel the optimal air traffic control policy. Unlike some previous works, we propose a global (i.e., shared) reward that encourages cooperative behaviour. Furthermore, we propose a versatile policy model capable of performing heading, speed, and/or altitude resolution actions. We also demonstrate that the policy is robust and can maintain safe separation even in the presence of uncertainty regarding aircraft position, delays in implementing resolution actions, and wind. The findings of this paper also suggest that there is still significant room for improvement when controlling three degrees of freedom at the same time.@en

Metropolis II aims to provide insights in what is needed to enable high-density urban air operations. It does this by investigating the foundation for U-space U3/U4 services. The final goal is to provide a unified approach for strategic deconfliction, tactical deconfliction, and dynamic capacity management. Highly-dense operations in constrained urban airspace will likely require a degree of complexity that does not exist in modern-day air traffic management. The expected high traffic demand will require a shared use of the airspace instead of assigning exclusive use of blocks of the airspace to some flights. A unified approach for traffic management is needed because at high-densities, airspace design, flight planning, and separation management become increasingly interdependent. Metropolis II builds upon the results of the first Metropolis project. Three concepts with a varying degree of centralisation will be compared using simulations. (1) The centralised concept will take a global approach for separation management. (2) The decentralised concept aims to give the individual agents separation responsibility. (3) The hybrid concept tries to combine a centralised strategic planning agent with a robust tactical separation strategy.

@en

Road traffic delay and urban overcrowding are increasing rapidly all over the world. As a result, several companies have proposed the use of small unmanned aerial vehicles (sUAVs) as an alternative to road-based transportation. These small autonomous drones are expected to operate within a thin airspace band (Very Low Level) in high traffic densities in constrained urban environments. This presents a challenge for ensuring the safe separation and efficient routing of drone flights. Current research has made modest progress towards finding solutions for conflict detection and prevention in highly dense and constrained environments (e.g., in-between buildings). In this paper, the state of the art of urban airspace design and conflict prevention and resolution research are discussed, and their applications to constrained environments. Additionally, fasttime high-fidelity simulations of high-density traffic scenarios are used along a non-orthogonal city layout to identify bottlenecks in the performance of speed-based conflict resolution in a multilayered airspace structure. Results show that the current airspace structure and conflict detection and resolution concepts need to be refined to further reduce conflicts and intrusions that occur in constrained environments. First, additional measures must be adapted to further prevent conflicts during turning and merging. Second, conflict resolution manoeuvres must account for speed limits resulting in turn radii which do not cross physical boundaries. Finally, conflict detection needs to consider the topology of the streets to prevent false-positive conflicts and to prepare in advance for conflicts resulting from heading changes in non-linear streets. @en