Circular Image

F. Beltrame

info

Please Note

7 records found

From Ram Air Cooling Ducts to Energy Harvesting Systems

Doctoral thesis (2026) - F. Beltrame, C.M. de Servi, P. Colonna di Paliano
The improvement of the efficiency of aircraft propulsion systems and the reduction of fuel consumption are key objectives in the development of next-generation propulsion systems. The feasibility and performance of promising concepts such as combined-cycle engines, hybrid-electric propulsion, and hydrogen-fueled systems often depend on complex thermal management or cooling systems, where compact heat exchangers (HXs) are critical components. More in detail, the integration of HXs in airborne systems is limited by strict space and volume constraints as well as by the impact of pressure losses and mass on the performance of the propulsion system. Therefore, sub-optimal HX designs can offset or even negate potential performance gains.
This dissertation documents research work performed as part of the ARENA project, which aims to develop methodologies for assessing the fuel-saving potential of airborne organic Rankine cycle thermal energy harvesting systems serving as bottoming units to gas turbine engines, leveraging unconventional propulsion system configurations. The first objective of the present research is to advance the state-of-the-art regarding methodologies for the optimal design and integration of aerospace-grade compact HXs into novel propulsion systems. The second objective is to investigate the potential of the Meredith effect, whereby the drag introduced by an air-cooled HX is offset by the acceleration of the heated airflow through a nozzle, for airborne ORC units, and to develop methods for the optimal design of the ramair cooling system.
To this end, an HX model for single- and multi-pass configurations, applicable for sizing and rating problems of components operating with sub- and supercritical working fluids, was implemented in the in-house software HeXacode and validated with experimental data. Preliminary design tools based on this HX model have been embedded within the system design framework for integrated system-and-component optimization of aero engines featuring an ORC bottoming unit. The system design framework was used to optimize the design of combined-cycle auxiliary power unit (CC-APU), turboshaft (CC-TS), and turbofan (CC-TF) configurations. The results demonstrate that achieving optimal performance requires balancing HX thermal effectiveness, pressure loss, and mass. However, this integrated optimization approach is computationally time-consuming. Therefore, a data-driven surrogate modeling methodology has been developed to predict the performance of optimized HXs under variable operating conditions and design specifications. This method reduces the computational cost associated with system optimization studies by more than half.
Results of optimal combined cycle engine configurations demonstrated that the thermal energy rejected by the condenser to the ramair stream can increase propulsive efficiency and specific thrust. This thrust gain is primarily influenced by the total pressure losses in the duct, ram-air temperature increase, and total to static nozzle pressure ratio. Therefore, the thrust that can be generated by the ram air cooling duct is much larger in the case of the CC-TF, whereby the condenser is positioned aft of the fan and outlet guide vane within the bypass duct, compared to the CC-TS configuration.
Due to the significant influence of the ram air cooling duct on the aerodynamic performance of the propulsion system, an accurate duct model is required for preliminary design studies. Therefore, a CFD model of the ram air duct has been developed, whereby the HX is modeled as a porous zone while a steady state RANS solver is used for the airflow within the duct. The CFD model has been used to develop a lumped parameter model of the ram air duct. The accuracy of the developed lumped parameter model is comparable to that of the CFD model, and enables fast evaluation of the duct performance at both design and off-design conditions. The lumped parameter model is also used to quantify the influence of HX and duct geometric design, heat rejection, and total pressure losses on drag recovery through the Meredith effect, providing new guidelines for ram air cooling systems for airborne applications.
The methodologies developed in this research work are directly applicable to waste heat recovery systems, fuel-cell-based electric propulsion or turbo-electric propulsion systems, and support early-stage preliminary design assessments. These results contribute to reducing the uncertainty in adopting combined-cycle and other novel propulsion systems, and to guiding future development of lightweight, high-performance HXs for low-emission aviation. ...
Thermal energy recovery is being investigated by leading aerospace companies as a means to improve the efficiency of next-generation propulsion systems. The organic Rankine cycle (ORC) system, due to the flexibility of the concept, is arguably the best technology for waste heat recovery and, thus, a promising solution to develop recuperated engines. In such systems, heat exchangers are arguably the most critical components, as their design must balance thermal performance with constraints on weight and volume. Consequently, integrating the optimization of heat exchangers into the overall system design may lead to substantial performance enhancement compared to more traditional iterative design methods. The objective of this study was the development of a systematic methodology for optimizing airborne thermal systems, with a focus on addressing the computational challenges of integrated design. Three design strategies are compared: (i) optimization of the sole cycle parameters while performing heat exchanger sizing for values of the geometrical characteristics defined a priori based on a preliminary investigation of the design space of these components, (ii) concurrent optimization of both the thermodynamic cycle and of the most critical heat exchanger, e.g., the condenser, and, (iii) use of a data-driven surrogate model of the condenser to predict the optimal heat exchanger geometry as a function of any feasible thermodynamic conditions to reduce the number of optimization variables of the integrated design problem. The surrogate model is constructed based on datasets of Pareto-optimal HX designs in the objective space defined by heat exchanger weight and pressure drops. The three design strategies are applied to two case studies featuring supercritical ORC systems utilizing cyclopentane as the working fluid: a combined cycle auxiliary power unit (CC-APU) and a combined cycle turboshaft (CC-TS) engine. Findings indicate that integrated optimization yields performance gains that vary depending on the heat exchanger topology, application, and thermodynamic cycle. For instance, CC-APU designs obtained with the integrated design optimization method are up to 15% lighter than designs obtained with the optimization of the thermodynamic cycle parameters alone, for the same net power output. Microchannel condenser designs with offset strip fins allow for obtaining a better performance than louvered fin-based designs if a low-pressure drop is targeted, whereas louvered fins are advantageous if a higher pressure drop is allowed. The design strategy employing the surrogate model considerably reduces the computational cost, without significantly affecting accuracy: the relative deviation between the Pareto front obtained with the surrogate model and that obtained with the integrated optimization strategy ranges between 1% and 2.9%. These values are comparable to the uncertainty of the predictions of the heat exchanger model. The reduction in computational time required to generate the Pareto fronts associated with the two case studies is up to 200%. ...
This paper presents a preliminary study about a combined-cycle engine based on a turboshaft engine and an organic-Rankine-cycle (ORC) bottoming unit to be used onboard an aircraft with a turboelectric propulsion system. The aim is to analyse whether benefits with respect to mission fuel consumption can be derived by employing such a combined-cycle
engine when compared to a simple-cycle turboshaft engine. For this purpose, a multidisciplinary optimization framework is developed, incorporating models for the engine, ORC system, ORC turbine, heat exchangers, and mission analysis. This framework is coupled with an optimizer to identify the optimal combined-cycle engine design for minimum mission fuel consumption. The results suggest that fuel savings of around 1.5% are possible with the optimized system if compared to the aircraft employing turboshaft engines. Heat exchanger volume is identified as the most constraining parameter when it comes to combined-cycle performance. The analysis of the results suggests as aspects which might lead to further improvements the evaluation of other ORC architectures, working fluids and heat exchanger topologies. ...
Conference paper (2024) - F. Beltrame, D. Krempus, Piero Colonna, C.M. de Servi
Waste heat recovery (WHR) from aeroengines via compact organic Rankine cycle (ORC) units may increase the fuel efficiency of air transportation. Heat exchangers are arguably the key components of ORC systems for aeronautical applications and their design must be optimized to guarantee the best trade-off between fluid pressure drop, weight and induced aircraft drag. At present, no heat exchangers design guidelines are available for waste heat recovery systems aboard aircraft. This study, thus, contributes to defining a proper design methodology for ORC systems of such applications. The chosen test case is a supercritical ORC system with cyclopentane as the working fluid, which recovers waste heat from the auxiliary power unit of an aircraft. The exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate of the power unit are known and kept constant in the analysis, and so are the ambient conditions, which define the cold sink of the ORC turbogenerator. Three design strategies targeting minimum mass and maximum net power output of the ORC unit have been assessed. In the first one, the multi-objective optimization is performed by prescribing a priori the geometry and frontal area of the heat exchangers. Thus, only the cycle parameters are optimized. The second method tackles, instead, the simultaneous optimization of the geometric parameters of the condenser and the cycle parameters. It was found that the integrated design allows for system mass reduction by 10 - 12% for a given ORC power output, highlighting the importance of performing the simultaneous optimization of the thermodynamic process and the heat exchanger geometry. Finally, the third method addresses the same optimal design problem by leveraging a reduced-order model of the condenser to predict the optimal design space of this component. The generated Pareto front obtained with this method is very similar to that found by optimizing simultaneously the complete condenser geometry and the cycle parameters. The mean deviation is about 2%. With just one heat exchanger surrogate model, the Pareto front was generated in one fourth of the computational time. This is due to the lower number of optimization variables and the faster objective function evaluation. ...
Conference paper (2023) - D. Krempus, F. Beltrame, M. Majer, C.M. de Servi, Roelof Vos
This paper presents a preliminary study about a combined-cycle engine based on a turboshaft engine and an organic-Rankine-cycle (ORC) bottoming unit to be used onboard an aircraft with a turboelectric propulsion system. The aim is to analyse whether benefits with respect to mission fuel consumption can be derived by employing such a combined-cycle engine when compared to a simple-cycle turboshaft engine. For this purpose, a multidisciplinary optimization framework is developed, incorporating models for the engine, ORC system, ORC turbine, heat exchangers, and mission analysis. This framework is coupled with an optimizer to identify the optimal combined-cycle engine design for minimum mission fuel consumption. The results suggest that fuel savings of around 4% are possible with the optimized system if compared to the aircraft employing turboshaft engines. Heat exchanger volume is identified as the most constraining parameter when it comes to combined-cycle performance. The analysis of the results suggests as aspects which might lead to further improvements the evaluation of other ORC architectures, working fluids and heat exchanger topologies. ...
This paper describes an experiment conducted within the nozzle test section of the Organic Rankine Cycle Hybrid Integrated Device (ORCHID) aimed at providing accurate data for the validation of NICFD flow solvers [5]. A supersonic flow of the dense vapor siloxane MM established in the nozzle of the setup was characterized by means of the schlieren technique and by pressure taps along the nozzle profile. The nozzle inlet conditions corresponded to a stagnation temperature and pressure of T0=253∘C and P0=18.36bara. At these inlet conditions, the compressibility factor of the fluid is Z0= 0.58. The nozzle backpressure was equal to Pb=2.2bara. The experimental data-set includes: 1) the average mid-plane local Mach number, which was derived from the schlieren images by estimating the angle of the Mach waves originating from the roughness of the upper and lower nozzle surfaces, 2) the angle of a shock wave generated by a 5∘ wedge placed at the nozzle exit, also detectable in the schlieren images, and 3) the static pressure distribution along the flow expansion acquired with a Scanivalve DSA3218 pressure scanner device. The Mach number at the nozzle exit estimated based on the schlieren images is M= 1.95 ± 0.05, very close to the expected value of M= 2 according to the design conditions of the experiment. The static pressure measurements have a maximum absolute uncertainty amounting to ± 1.80 kPa in the initial stages of the expansion. This information was used to assess the capability of the open-source SU2 flow solver in evaluating the NICFD effects in a supersonic flow of MM when the fluid thermodynamic properties are modeled with a cubic equation of state. For this purpose, two-dimensional Euler simulations were carried out with SU2 for the operating conditions achieved in the experiment. The numerical results are in good agreement with the experimental data. The largest deviation between the simulation and experiment is observed in the nozzle uniform region, where two dips in the Mach number occur due to a slight local decrease in flow velocity owing to two weak shock waves. The shock wave generated by the wedge located at the nozzle outlet propagates with two different angles, namely, βabove= 37. 6∘± 0.86, and βbelow= 31. 6∘± 0.64, due to the axial misalignment of the wedge with respect to the flow. ...
This paper reports one of the initial NICFD experiments in the nozzle test section of the ORCHID aimed at providing accurate data for the validation of flow solvers, albeit, at this stage of the research, the focus is limited to inviscid phenomena. Notably, a series of schlieren photographs displaying Mach waves in the supersonic flow of the dense vapor of siloxane MM were obtained and are documented here for the commissioning experiment, namely, for inlet conditions corresponding to a stagnation temperature and pressure of T0=252∘C and P0=18.4bara. At these inlet conditions the compressibility factor of the fluid is Z0= 0.58. The digital processing of the schlieren images allowed to estimate multiple angles formed by the Mach waves stemming from the upper and lower nozzle surfaces because of the infinitesimal density perturbations generated by the, albeit small, roughness of the metal surfaces. These values are related to the local Mach number by a simple geometric relation. Moreover, the total expanded uncertainty in the Mach number was computed. This information together with the estimate of the average Mach number was used for a first assessment of the capability of evaluating NICFD effects occurring in a dense organic vapor flow of MM by comparison with the results of CFD simulations. The outcome of the comparison was satisfactory. It can thus be inferred that the nozzle test section has been commissioned and it is ready for experimental campaigns in which its full potential in terms of measurements accuracy, repeatability, and operational flexibility will be exploited. ...