MB
M. Bonenkamp
info
Please Note
<p>This page displays the records of the person named above and is not linked to a unique person identifier. This record may need to be merged to a profile.</p>
2 records found
1
Long-term morphological modelling of tidal inlet systems
Implementing salt marshes in ASMITA
Master thesis
(2023)
-
M. Bonenkamp, Z.B. Wang, Y. Huismans, P.M.J. Herman, Jasper Dijkstra, Q.J. Lodder
A rise in the global mean temperature induced by climate change is expected to have a large impact on ecosystems in all regions of the world. One of the threats is accelerated sea level rise (SLR). This may induce the loss of intertidal areas in tidal inlet systems. The long-term morphological response of tidal inlet systems can be modelled using reduced complexity model ASMITA (Aggregated Scale Morphological Interaction between Tidal inlets and the Adjacent coast). The ASMITA model simulates morphological development on an aggregated spatial and temporal scale by imposing a morphological equilibrium condition. As such the model is fast, allowing for multiple long-term simulations. The model is physics-based and the parameters can be related to field values.
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
...
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
...
A rise in the global mean temperature induced by climate change is expected to have a large impact on ecosystems in all regions of the world. One of the threats is accelerated sea level rise (SLR). This may induce the loss of intertidal areas in tidal inlet systems. The long-term morphological response of tidal inlet systems can be modelled using reduced complexity model ASMITA (Aggregated Scale Morphological Interaction between Tidal inlets and the Adjacent coast). The ASMITA model simulates morphological development on an aggregated spatial and temporal scale by imposing a morphological equilibrium condition. As such the model is fast, allowing for multiple long-term simulations. The model is physics-based and the parameters can be related to field values.
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
Student report
(2022)
-
Jaïr van Woudenberg, Serban Alexandru, Marloes Bonenkamp, Lotte de Boer, Margot Ridderikhoff, M.Z. Voorendt, R.E.M. Riva
In the southeast of Spain heavy storms can occur in the late summer and early autumn, during which great amounts of rain pours down. During a storm that took place in September 2019, over 300 mil- limetres of rain fell in just five hours. Throughout the 2019 flooding event, the Rambla de la Carrasquilla has overflowed its banks and the adjacent agricultural lands flooded and large amounts of water ac- cumulated in the streets of Los Nietos. Since the 2019 flood, improvements to the river system of the Rambla de la Carrasquilla have been made. For instance: a relatively small culvert was replaced with a bigger one in 2021, to increase the discharge capacity. Due to global warming, the probability of occurrence of the heavy storms will increase and thus the probability of flooding. However, the lack of historical data makes it hard to assess the influence of different storms and the replacement of the cul- vert on future floods. Numerical models can be used to make predictions of floodings and gain insight in storm impacts. The aim of this report is summarized by the question: How can the flood areas and peak water levels of the Rambla de la Carrasquilla and its catchment be obtained by simulating three different scenarios based on peak discharges using HEC-RAS models?. At first a spatial analysis of the river system was done using QGIS. Hereafter a 1D and 2D model were constructed with the help of a Digital Terrain Model (DTM). QGIS and RiverGIS were used to define the geometry of the system for the 1D model, where the 2D model geometry was constructed in HEC-RAS itself. The dimensions of the structures in the river were measured using photogrammetry, due to which dimensions could be obtained with an absolute error of around 2 cm. Fieldwork was carried out to estimate the surface roughness of the main channel and parts of the flood plains.
The results consist of different floodmaps that were made using 1D and 2D HEC-RAS models with different settings and boundary conditions. For the 1D model, one run was done using a single reach for the whole river and another including a bifurcation for the downstream part of the river. It can be concluded that the 1D model approach is not very suitable for our research as it is unable to accurately construct the flooded areas. The 2D model performed better and thus was used to further investigate the influence of different model parameters and inputs. Important take-away points are that the time step is of large influence for finding a stable solution, which is found around Δ𝑡 = 1 [second] in this report. The influence of the surface roughness of the river bed and floodplains was investigated by using Manning’s n. These results showed clearly that a higher value for Manning’s n leads to a larger flooded area. When investigating the influence of structures (two bridges, a pipeline and a culvert) on the flooded area, it is found that the structures do not have a great influence. The reason for this is that at critical points, the river already overflows its banks when the flow is not hindered by these structures. Adding the structures makes this only slightly worse. Furthermore, the 2021 culvert only showed a slight improvement in flooded area with respect to the 2019 culvert.
In order to further calibrate the HEC-RAS models, a comparison was made with floodmaps that were constructed by the Spanish government. Both studies show similar results, although the government used a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution, which can have a large impact on the outcome. However, this government study cannot be used for validation of the models in this research, as the results are based on hypothetical situations instead of empirical data as well.
For further research it is recommended to investigate more accurate hydrological boundary conditions, based on empirical rainfall data. For both boundary conditions a constant value was taken, but the behaviour over time could change the output of the results. Besides that, it could be interesting to study the exact effect of using a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution for the Rambla de la Carrasquilla. As this can have a direct influence on the size of the flooded area. Furthermore, the approaches used in this research can be used for investigating different flood mitigation solutions. These solutions, for example heightening of the river banks or widening of the bed, can be implemented in the 2D model before applying them in real life. ...
The results consist of different floodmaps that were made using 1D and 2D HEC-RAS models with different settings and boundary conditions. For the 1D model, one run was done using a single reach for the whole river and another including a bifurcation for the downstream part of the river. It can be concluded that the 1D model approach is not very suitable for our research as it is unable to accurately construct the flooded areas. The 2D model performed better and thus was used to further investigate the influence of different model parameters and inputs. Important take-away points are that the time step is of large influence for finding a stable solution, which is found around Δ𝑡 = 1 [second] in this report. The influence of the surface roughness of the river bed and floodplains was investigated by using Manning’s n. These results showed clearly that a higher value for Manning’s n leads to a larger flooded area. When investigating the influence of structures (two bridges, a pipeline and a culvert) on the flooded area, it is found that the structures do not have a great influence. The reason for this is that at critical points, the river already overflows its banks when the flow is not hindered by these structures. Adding the structures makes this only slightly worse. Furthermore, the 2021 culvert only showed a slight improvement in flooded area with respect to the 2019 culvert.
In order to further calibrate the HEC-RAS models, a comparison was made with floodmaps that were constructed by the Spanish government. Both studies show similar results, although the government used a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution, which can have a large impact on the outcome. However, this government study cannot be used for validation of the models in this research, as the results are based on hypothetical situations instead of empirical data as well.
For further research it is recommended to investigate more accurate hydrological boundary conditions, based on empirical rainfall data. For both boundary conditions a constant value was taken, but the behaviour over time could change the output of the results. Besides that, it could be interesting to study the exact effect of using a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution for the Rambla de la Carrasquilla. As this can have a direct influence on the size of the flooded area. Furthermore, the approaches used in this research can be used for investigating different flood mitigation solutions. These solutions, for example heightening of the river banks or widening of the bed, can be implemented in the 2D model before applying them in real life. ...
In the southeast of Spain heavy storms can occur in the late summer and early autumn, during which great amounts of rain pours down. During a storm that took place in September 2019, over 300 mil- limetres of rain fell in just five hours. Throughout the 2019 flooding event, the Rambla de la Carrasquilla has overflowed its banks and the adjacent agricultural lands flooded and large amounts of water ac- cumulated in the streets of Los Nietos. Since the 2019 flood, improvements to the river system of the Rambla de la Carrasquilla have been made. For instance: a relatively small culvert was replaced with a bigger one in 2021, to increase the discharge capacity. Due to global warming, the probability of occurrence of the heavy storms will increase and thus the probability of flooding. However, the lack of historical data makes it hard to assess the influence of different storms and the replacement of the cul- vert on future floods. Numerical models can be used to make predictions of floodings and gain insight in storm impacts. The aim of this report is summarized by the question: How can the flood areas and peak water levels of the Rambla de la Carrasquilla and its catchment be obtained by simulating three different scenarios based on peak discharges using HEC-RAS models?. At first a spatial analysis of the river system was done using QGIS. Hereafter a 1D and 2D model were constructed with the help of a Digital Terrain Model (DTM). QGIS and RiverGIS were used to define the geometry of the system for the 1D model, where the 2D model geometry was constructed in HEC-RAS itself. The dimensions of the structures in the river were measured using photogrammetry, due to which dimensions could be obtained with an absolute error of around 2 cm. Fieldwork was carried out to estimate the surface roughness of the main channel and parts of the flood plains.
The results consist of different floodmaps that were made using 1D and 2D HEC-RAS models with different settings and boundary conditions. For the 1D model, one run was done using a single reach for the whole river and another including a bifurcation for the downstream part of the river. It can be concluded that the 1D model approach is not very suitable for our research as it is unable to accurately construct the flooded areas. The 2D model performed better and thus was used to further investigate the influence of different model parameters and inputs. Important take-away points are that the time step is of large influence for finding a stable solution, which is found around Δ𝑡 = 1 [second] in this report. The influence of the surface roughness of the river bed and floodplains was investigated by using Manning’s n. These results showed clearly that a higher value for Manning’s n leads to a larger flooded area. When investigating the influence of structures (two bridges, a pipeline and a culvert) on the flooded area, it is found that the structures do not have a great influence. The reason for this is that at critical points, the river already overflows its banks when the flow is not hindered by these structures. Adding the structures makes this only slightly worse. Furthermore, the 2021 culvert only showed a slight improvement in flooded area with respect to the 2019 culvert.
In order to further calibrate the HEC-RAS models, a comparison was made with floodmaps that were constructed by the Spanish government. Both studies show similar results, although the government used a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution, which can have a large impact on the outcome. However, this government study cannot be used for validation of the models in this research, as the results are based on hypothetical situations instead of empirical data as well.
For further research it is recommended to investigate more accurate hydrological boundary conditions, based on empirical rainfall data. For both boundary conditions a constant value was taken, but the behaviour over time could change the output of the results. Besides that, it could be interesting to study the exact effect of using a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution for the Rambla de la Carrasquilla. As this can have a direct influence on the size of the flooded area. Furthermore, the approaches used in this research can be used for investigating different flood mitigation solutions. These solutions, for example heightening of the river banks or widening of the bed, can be implemented in the 2D model before applying them in real life.
The results consist of different floodmaps that were made using 1D and 2D HEC-RAS models with different settings and boundary conditions. For the 1D model, one run was done using a single reach for the whole river and another including a bifurcation for the downstream part of the river. It can be concluded that the 1D model approach is not very suitable for our research as it is unable to accurately construct the flooded areas. The 2D model performed better and thus was used to further investigate the influence of different model parameters and inputs. Important take-away points are that the time step is of large influence for finding a stable solution, which is found around Δ𝑡 = 1 [second] in this report. The influence of the surface roughness of the river bed and floodplains was investigated by using Manning’s n. These results showed clearly that a higher value for Manning’s n leads to a larger flooded area. When investigating the influence of structures (two bridges, a pipeline and a culvert) on the flooded area, it is found that the structures do not have a great influence. The reason for this is that at critical points, the river already overflows its banks when the flow is not hindered by these structures. Adding the structures makes this only slightly worse. Furthermore, the 2021 culvert only showed a slight improvement in flooded area with respect to the 2019 culvert.
In order to further calibrate the HEC-RAS models, a comparison was made with floodmaps that were constructed by the Spanish government. Both studies show similar results, although the government used a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution, which can have a large impact on the outcome. However, this government study cannot be used for validation of the models in this research, as the results are based on hypothetical situations instead of empirical data as well.
For further research it is recommended to investigate more accurate hydrological boundary conditions, based on empirical rainfall data. For both boundary conditions a constant value was taken, but the behaviour over time could change the output of the results. Besides that, it could be interesting to study the exact effect of using a Digital Terrain Model with a higher resolution for the Rambla de la Carrasquilla. As this can have a direct influence on the size of the flooded area. Furthermore, the approaches used in this research can be used for investigating different flood mitigation solutions. These solutions, for example heightening of the river banks or widening of the bed, can be implemented in the 2D model before applying them in real life.