A. Crosato
Please Note
75 records found
1
In river systems, transported suspended sediment interacts with in-channel and riparian vegetation. The involved physical processes are complex and still poorly reproduced by numerical models. This study compares the performance of background horizontal eddy viscosity models in reproducing flow fields and suspended sediment transport processes inside partially vegetated flows. Particularly, we selected an experiment with a partly-vegetated flume which we numerically replicated with the Delft 3D-2DH model. We applied three existing horizontal eddy viscosity approaches: constant value, Elder model and hybrid model. Besides, we represented the vegetation by using Baptist formulation. The results show that the Elder viscosity model reproduces the explicit development of vortices along the flume, while all three viscosity models show an underestimate of the sediment deposition in the vegetated area and an overestimation of sediment deposition in the non-vegetated area. Further investigation is needed to reproduce the experimental introduction of the sediment and to link transversal suspended sediment dynamics with the resolved dynamics in numerical models.
Baptist’s method, Drag Force and Single-Stem approaches are the commonly used tools implemented in Delft3D to model water and sediment transport processes in vegetated channels. Despite their wide application, the model reliability has seldom been tested against data of controlled flume experiments with solid suspension. Here, we investigate the ability to reproduce suspended sediment transport through emergent vegetation by comparing the results of 2D simulations to existing experimental data. The results show that in low vegetation density, the Baptist and Drag Force approaches are not sensitive enough to density variations. The Single-Stem approach reproduces detailed flow structure and sediment deposition around stems, but its high computational time is a limitation for long-term simulations or dense vegetation. Furthermore, we observed that the simplification of 2D depth-averaged models and the non-equilibrium of sediment transport in both experiments and numerical simulations may also affect the overall performance of the vegetated modelling approaches.
This work compares different approaches on their ability to reproduce the effects of vegetation on suspended solids concentration in two-dimensional models built in Delft3D. The work focuses on emerging vegetation, represented as rigid cylinders, and sediment deposition. Comparisons are based on the ability to reproduce flume experiments available in the literature by analysing both flow field and sediment deposition results. ...
This work compares different approaches on their ability to reproduce the effects of vegetation on suspended solids concentration in two-dimensional models built in Delft3D. The work focuses on emerging vegetation, represented as rigid cylinders, and sediment deposition. Comparisons are based on the ability to reproduce flume experiments available in the literature by analysing both flow field and sediment deposition results.
Effects of urbanization and deforestation on flooding
Case study of Cap-Haïtien City, Haiti
Cap-Haïtien, the second largest city in Haiti, is highly vulnerable to earthquakes, landslides, and flooding. The rapid pace of urbanization and deforestation has exacerbated the risk of flooding, resulting in disasters in November 2012, 2016, and 2022. This study aims to assess the impact of urbanization and deforestation on river flooding in Cap-Haïtien by applying the hydrological model Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and the hydrodynamic model Sobek-Rural. We examined the current situation and a scenario of future urbanization and deforestation. Urbanization and deforestation are found to play a pivotal role in the production and deposition of sediment along the lower Haut-du-Cap River reaches. The existing hydraulic capacity of the river and its drainage system cannot handle the estimated peak flows. The mountain ravines west of the city are found to be the primary source of sediment-laden flash floods. We recommend retention basins, drainage extensions, and pragmatic public policies to mitigate flood risk. Comprehensive strategies are needed to address the detrimental effects of urbanization and deforestation on flooding in Cap-Haïtien and similar regions where a lack of water governance has worsened the flooding alongside urbanization and deforestation. We generalize our experiences from Cap-Haïtien into a broader framework for data-scarce areas.
Active geomorphological interventions, such as reprofiling of river bars, are often used to increase bar dynamics and prevent vegetation encroachment. River restoration management should be planned based on the knowledge of what processes will follow the intervention and on the anticipation of the consequences. However, in many cases, the associated physical processes are not clearly identified whereas their consequences on bar morphodynamics are still not fully understood. This study aims to bring new insights into the biomorphodynamics evolution of the riverbed after restoration works by using a 2D biomorphodynamic model developed in the TELEMAC-MASCARET system. It seeks to compare and evaluate the performance of five bar reprofiling scenarios in which the bar elevation is lowered to just below the water level at specified design discharges. The study area is located in the channelized and regulated alpine gravel-bed Isère River (France). Bar dynamics and early stages of vegetation establishment are analyzed for the first 2 years after each restoration scenario. The results indicate that plant colonization would occur in all cases. Overall, maximizing the reduction of bar height is the most effective way to improve the bar dynamics and limit future vegetation encroachment.
On the relationship between flow-field and bank erosion in rivers
Insights from large-eddy simulations
Assuming that the equilibrium geometry of river channels does not depend on their initial state but solely on boundary conditions, several formulas have been derived that relate the channel depth and width to the river bankfull discharge and bed material. However, due to the existence of a threshold for sediment motion and the strong non-linearity between sediment transport and flow rate, this assumption might not be generally valid for gravel-bed rivers. This research clarifies the role of the initial conditions, more specifically the initial channel width, on the geometry of gravel-bed rivers considering a variety of boundary conditions. The approach includes laboratory experiments and two-dimensional modeling, reproducing the evolution of alluvial channels with different starting widths, discharge regimes and sediment input rates. The experiments represent the Arc River (France). Thus, the characteristics of this river were used in the numerical model to obtain a realistic virtual case complementing the experiments. Different boundary and starting conditions resulted in either braided or single-thread channels. We found that the initial width strongly influences the evolution process and leaves a footprint on the river braid-belt extension. The active width of braided systems and the width of single-thread channels do not depend on the starting condition. They depend on sediment input rather than on discharge variability. Different initial widths result in different final bed levels. This indicates that the initial channel width may affect the degree of channel incision or aggradation. The results of this study justify the use of equilibrium formulas for single-thread rivers.
Adaptation of river channels to a wetter or drier climate
Insights from the Lower Pilcomayo River, South America
Climate change has a direct influence on both hydrology and floodplain vegetation of water courses, which are key players in river morphodynamics. The river system response to climate change is complex and the effects of non-linear interactions between alterations in water, sediment and vegetation remain incompletely understood. Which of these components becomes dominant in shaping the river channel when climate becomes drier or wetter? To answer this question, we investigate the cross-sectional response of sand-bed rivers to climate change focusing on channel width and depth, which respond directly to changes in boundary stresses. Thanks to the exceptional availability of long time-series of daily discharge and cross-sectional profiles, the Pilcomayo River is an ideal living lab for this investigation. We constructed a two-dimensional model of the river using the open-source state-of-the-art, structured Delft3D code. The highly dynamic behaviour and quick morphological adaptation of the Pilcomayo allowed reducing the period of time covered by the simulations because the river cross-section adapts its morphology to a new value of the water discharge within hours or days, which is crucial for modelling investigations. Calibration and validation were successfully performed by comparison with historical data. We considered several scenarios representing current, dryer and wetter climates. The results show that a dryer climate reduces the river channel depth and enlarges the width. A wetter climate increases the channel depth but produces negligible widening. Vegetation, sparser with a drier climate and denser with a wetter climate, is found to control the channel width. This analysis is unique and shows which alterations can be expected in alluvial sand-bed rivers with natural vegetated banks due to climate change.
Flushing is a common measure to manage and reduce the amount of sediment stored in reservoirs. However, the sudden release of large volumes of sediment abruptly increases the suspended solids concentration and alters the riverbed composition. Similar effects can be produced also by natural flood events. Do flushing operations have more detrimental impacts than natural floods? To answer this question, we investigated the impact of flushing on the survival of the Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the Sandy River (OR, USA), assuming that sediment is flushed from hypothetical bottom gates of the, now decommissioned, Marmot Dam. The effects of several flushing scenarios are analyzed with a 2D morphodynamic model, together with habitat suitability curves and stress indicators. The results show that attention has to be paid to duration: the shorter the flushing operation, the lesser the stresses on fish survival and spawning habitats. Flushing causes high stress to salmon eggs and larvae, due to unbearable levels of suspended sediment concentrations. It also decreases the areas usable for spawning due to fine-sediment deposition, with up to 95% loss at peak flow. Without the dam, the corresponding natural flood event would produce similar effects, with up to 93% loss. The study shows that well-planned flushing operations could mimic a natural impact, but only partly. In the long-term, larger losses of spawning grounds can be expected, since the removal of fine sediment with the release of clear water from the reservoir is a lengthy process that may be undesirable due to water storage reduction.
Effects of Vegetation Patch Patterns on Channel Morphology
A Numerical Study