Numerical Study of Shear Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beams using Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites

Abstract

Existing reinforced concrete (RC) structures can be strengthened using Strain Hardening Cementitious Composites (SHCC). The ability of SHCC in exhibiting a ductile response under tensile load due to strain­-hardening after crack initiation makes it a viable material to be used in, both, construction and retrofitting of concrete structures. The main objective of this research is to study the shear behaviour of SHCC-strengthened RC beams using NLFEA. The shear behaviour of benchmark RC beams is analysed first. The analysis of the selected RC beams analysed using Damage-based shear retention function results in accurate predictions of peak load if a fine mesh size resulting in 30 or more elements in the height of the beam is used. However, the failure type is predicted inaccurately for both coarse and fine mesh sizes due to lack of consideration for aggregate interlock in Damage-based shear retention function. The analysis of the selected RC beams using Al-Mahaidi shear retention function results in accurate predictions of peak load if a coarse mesh size resulting in 20 elements in the height of the beam is used. The failure type is also predicted accurately using Al-Mahaidi shear retention function with the stated mesh size. The consideration for aggregate interlock implicitly in Al-Mahaidi shear retention function in the form of shear retention factor allows for accurate prediction of both peak load and failure type. After analysing the shear behaviour of RC beams, the shear behaviour of a reinforced SHCC beam is analysed using Al-Mahaidi shear retention function since it can predict both failure load and failure type accurately for RC beams. In comparison with experiment, the peak load for the reinforced SHCC beam is underestimated and the failure type is also incorrectly modelled. Use of embedded reinforcement results in excessive cracking along the reinforcement, causing convergence issues at a load lower than the experimental peak load. Such excessive cracking is not observed in RC beams since cracks more localized in concrete as compared to SHCC, which exhibits multi-cracking behaviour. Therefore, the shear behaviour of selected reinforced SHCC beam using Al-Mahaidi shear retention function is not accurately modelled. After the analysis of shear behaviour of concrete and SHCC separately, their behaviour is studied in the form of SHCC-RC hybrid beams. The solution strategy consisting of Al-Mahaidi shear retention function is used, and different types of hybrid interface are modelled. The results show that peak load and failure type are accurately predicted when a numerically perfect bond is modelled at hybrid interface for hybrid beams exhibiting no debonding during experimentation. This is in case of a mesh size resulting in 20 elements in the height of beam used. The peak load and failure type, however, are inaccurately predicted when delamination is modelled at the hybrid interface for hybrid beams failing due to delamination during experimentation, irrespective of the mesh size considered. This is due to the inability of the Coulomb friction interface model in recognising significant delamination at the hybrid interface as a reason for the failure of the hybrid beam.