Hybrid solid electrolytes (HSEs) leverage the benefits of their organic and inorganic components, yet optimizing ion transport and component compatibility requires a deeper understanding of their intricate ion transport mechanisms. Here, macroscopic charge transport is correlated with local lithium (Li)-ion diffusivity in HSEs, using poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) as matrix and Li6PS5Cl as filler. Solvent- and dry-processing methods were evaluated for their morphological impact on Li-ion transport. Through multiscale solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance analysis, we reveal that the filler enhances local Li-ion diffusivity within the slow polymer segmental dynamics. Phase transitions indicate inhibited crystallization in HSEs, with reduced Li-ion diffusion barriers attributed to enhanced segmental motion and conductive polymer conformations. Relaxometry measurements identify a mobile component unique to the hybrid system at low temperatures, indicating Li-ion transport along polymer-filler interfaces. Comparative analysis shows solvent-processed HSEs exhibit better morphological uniformity and enhanced compatibility with Li-metal anodes via an inorganic-rich solid electrolyte interphase.