The concept of wake steering on wind farms for power maximization has gained significant popularity over the last decade. Recent field trials described in the literature not only demonstrate the real potential of wake steering on commercial wind farms but also show that wake steering does not yet consistently lead to an increase in energy production for all inflow conditions. Moreover, a recent survey among experts shows that validation of the concept currently remains the largest barrier to adoption. In response, this article presents the results of a field experiment investigating wake steering in three-turbine arrays at an onshore wind farm in Italy. This experiment was performed as part of the European CL-Windcon project. While important, this experiment excludes an analysis of the structural loads and focuses solely on the effects of wake steering on power production. The measurements show increases in power production of up to 35 % for two-turbine interactions and up to 16 % for three-turbine interactions. However, losses in power production are seen for various regions of wind directions too. In addition to the gains achieved through wake steering at downstream turbines, more interesting to note is that a significant share in gains is from the upstream turbines, showing an increased power production of the yawed turbine itself compared to baseline operation for some wind directions. Furthermore, the surrogate model, while capturing the general trends of wake interaction, lacks the details necessary to accurately represent the measurements. This article supports the notion that further research is necessary, notably on the topics of wind farm modeling and experiment design, before wake steering will lead to consistent energy gains on commercial wind farms.

@en

Active power control regulates the total power generated by wind farms with the power consumed on the electricity grid. Due to wake effects, the available power is reduced and turbulence is increased at downstream wind turbines. Such effects lead to a design challenge for wind farm control, where the delicate balance between supply and demand should be maintained, while considering the load balancing in the wind turbine structures. We propose a control architecture based on simple feedback controllers that adjusts the demanded power set points of individual wind turbines to compensate for turbine saturations and to balance thrust forces. For compensation purposes, the dynamics of power tracking in the wind turbines is approximated as a pure time-delay process, and the thrust force balance design is based on an identified linear model of the turbines. In this paper, we show that the proposed control architecture allows the generated power to track its reference even when turbines saturate, while the thrust forces are balanced. In addition, the result shows that the proposed power dispatch strategy, which considers thrust force balance, also avoids turbine saturation, being thus beneficial for energy production. The effectiveness of the proposed feedback controller is demonstrated using high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics simulations of a small wind farm.@en

This article investigates the optimization of yaw control inputs of a nine-turbine wind farm. The wind farm is simulated using the high-fidelity simulator SOWFA. The optimization is performed with a modifier adaptation scheme based on Gaussian processes. Modifier adaptation corrects for the mismatch between plant and model and helps to converge to the actual plan optimum. In the case study the modifier adaptation approach is compared with the Bayesian optimization approach. Moreover, the use of two different covariance functions in the Gaussian process regression is discussed. Practical recommendations concerning the data preparation and application of the approach are given. It is shown that both the modifier adaptation and the Bayesian optimization approach can improve the power production with overall smaller yaw misalignments in comparison to the Gaussian wake model.

@en

Wind farm control is an active and growing field of research in which the control actions of individual turbines in a farm are coordinated, accounting for inter-turbine aerodynamic interaction, to improve the overall performance of the wind farm and to reduce costs. The primary objectives of wind farm control include increasing power production, reducing turbine loads, and providing electricity grid support services. Additional objectives include improving reliability or reducing external impacts to the environment and communities. In 2019, a European research project (FarmConners) was started with the main goal of providing an overview of the state-of-the-art in wind farm control, identifying consensus of research findings, data sets, and best practices, providing a summary of the main research challenges, and establishing a roadmap on how to address these challenges. Complementary to the FarmConners project, an IEA Wind Topical Expert Meeting (TEM) and two rounds of surveys among experts were performed. From these events we can clearly identify an interest in more public validation campaigns. Additionally, a deeper understanding of the mechanical loads and the uncertainties concerning the effectiveness of wind farm control are considered two major research gaps.

@en

Open-loop wake steering inconsistently improves the energy yield of wind farms in field experiments in the literature. This thesis matures wind farm control technologies for power maximization in a model-based closed-loop framework towards real-world practical applicability. Firstly, open-loop wake steering is evaluated on a commercial onshore wind farm in this thesis. While a net increase in energy yield is measured, the experiment highlights the inaccuracy of the simplified wind farm model, leading to situational losses in energy yield. Secondly, this thesis demonstrates that wind turbine power and wind vane measurements can be used to calibrate the simplified model online to maintain a high model accuracy. This closed-loop concept is tested in high-fidelity simulation, showing a consistent energy yield increase of 1.4%. Finally, this thesis explores the usage of dynamic wind farm models for control, which would further push the accuracy of simplified models yet is held back by the large computational costs. The contributions in this dissertation greatly advance the status quo of wind farm control solutions and their applicability in commercial wind farms.@en

Dynamic wind farm control is a new strategy that aims to apply time-varying, often periodic, control signals on upstream wind turbines to increase the wake mixing behind the turbine. As a result, wake recovery is accelerated, leading to a higher power production of downstream turbines. As the amount of interest in dynamic control strategies for wind turbines in a wind farm is increasing, different approaches are being proposed. One such novel approach is called Dynamic Individual Pitch Control (DIPC). In DIPC, each blade pitch angle of a turbine is controlled independently to dynamically manipulate the direction of the thrust force vector exerted on the wind. Hence, the direction of the wake is varied, inducing wake mixing without significant thrust force magnitude variations on the rotor. In this paper, the effectiveness of different variations in the thrust direction are evaluated and compared using Large Eddy Simulation (LES) experiments.

@en

For the study of wind farm and wake effect, the steady-state wake models like FLORIS were proposed and used during wind farm operations to achieve higher wind power utilization and conversion. However, the dynamic performance of the wake should also be involved in favor of better optimizations. In this paper, a data-driven analysis and modeling method, dynamic mode decomposition (DMD), is used to construct dynamic flow model with high-fidelity flow data. Two DMD-derived models are constructed based on flow data in three-dimensional and two-dimensional spaces, respectively. The obtained models and respective flows are compared in the time and frequency domain. Results show that both models have apparent differences in the frequency domain, but the dominant wake characteristics' consistency is maintained.

@en

Wind farm control using dynamic concepts is a research topic that is receiving an increasing amount of interest. The main concept of this approach is that dynamic variations of the wind turbine control settings lead to higher wake turbulence, and subsequently faster wake recovery due to increased mixing. As a result, downstream turbines experience higher wind speeds, thus increasing their energy capture. In dynamic induction control (DIC), the magnitude of the thrust force of an upstream turbine is varied. Although very effective, this approach also leads to increased power and thrust variations, negatively impacting energy quality and fatigue loading. In this paper, a novel approach for the dynamic control of wind turbines in a wind farm is proposed: using individual pitch control, the fixed-frame tilt and yaw moments on the turbine are varied, thus dynamically manipulating the wake. This strategy is named the helix approach because the resulting wake has a helical shape. Large eddy simulations of a two-turbine wind farm show that this approach leads to enhanced wake mixing with minimal power and thrust variations.

@en

Wind farm (WF) controllers adjust the control settings of individual turbines to enhance the total performance of a wind farm. Most WF controllers proposed in the literature assume a time-invariant inflow, whereas important quantities such as the wind direction and speed continuously change over time in reality. Furthermore, properties of the inflow are often assumed known, which is a fundamentally compromising assumption to make. This paper presents a novel, closed-loop WF controller that continuously estimates the inflow and maximizes the energy yield of the farm through yaw-based wake steering. The controller is tested in a high-fidelity simulation of a 6-turbine wind farm. The WF controller is stress-tested by subjecting it to strongly-time-varying inflow conditions over 5000 s of simulation. A time-averaged improvement in energy yield of 1.4% is achieved compared to a baseline, greedy controller. Moreover, the instantaneous energy gain is up to 11% for wake-loss-heavy situations. Note that this is the first closed-loop and model-based WF controller tested for time-varying inflow conditions (i.e., where the mean wind direction and wind speed change over time) at such fidelity. This solidifies the WF controller as the first realistic closed-loop control solution for yaw-based wake steering.

@en

Wind farm control (WFC) algorithms rely on an estimate of the ambient wind speed, wind direction, and turbulence intensity in the determination of the optimal control setpoints. However, the measurements available in a commercial wind farm do not always carry sufficient information to estimate these atmospheric quantities. In this paper, a novel measure (“observability”) is introduced that quantifies how well the ambient conditions can be estimated with the measurements at hand through a model inversion approach. The usefulness of this measure is shown through several case studies. While the turbine power signals and the inter-turbine wake interactions provide information on the wind direction, the case studies presented in this article show that there is a strong need for wind direction measurements for WFC to sufficiently cover observability for any ambient condition. Further, generally, more wake interaction leads to a higher observability. Also, the mathematical framework presented in this article supports the straightforward notion that turbine power measurements provide no additional information compared with local wind speed measurements, implying that power measurements are superfluous. Irregular farm layouts result in a higher observability due to the increase in unique wake interaction. The findings in this paper may be used in WFC to predict which ambient quantities can (theoretically) be estimated. The authors envision that this will assist in the estimation of the ambient conditions in WFC algorithms and can lead to an improvement in the performance of WFC algorithms over the complete envelope of wind farm operation.

@en

In recent years, wake steering has been established as a promising method to increase the energy yield of a wind farm. Current practice in estimating the benefit of wake steering on the annual energy production (AEP) consists of evaluating the wind farm with simplified surrogate models, casting a large uncertainty on the estimated benefit. This paper presents a framework for determining the benefit of wake steering on the AEP, incorporating simulation results from a surrogate model and large eddy simulations in order to reduce the uncertainty. Furthermore, a time-varying wind direction is considered for a better representation of the ambient conditions at the real wind farm site. Gaussian process regression is used to combine the two data sets into a single improved model of the energy gain. This model estimates a 0.60% gain in AEP for the considered wind farm, which is a 76% increase compared to the estimate of the surrogate model.

@en

The non-dispatchable variability of wind power production presents a substantial challenge to electric system operators who are assigned the task of balancing the demand and generation at each moment at the lowest possible cost while maintaining ultra-high system reliability. The economic factor is the key component of this problem since one can always adequately manage variability and maintain reliability if cost is not considered. There are four key components to a forecasting solution that should each be optimized in order to provide maximum value to the end user: (1) high-quality and representative measurement data for input into the forecasting procedure, (2) skillful forecasting models, (3) effective communication of the critical forecast information to automated or manual decision-makers and (4) meaningful assessment of forecast performance to provide users with confidence in using the forecast information for decision-making.

@en

Active power control for wind farms is needed to provide ancillary services. One of these services is to track a power reference signal with a wind farm by dynamically de- and uprating the turbines. Due to the stochastic nature of the wind, it is necessary to take this stochastic behavior into account when evaluating control signals. In this paper we present a closed-loop stochastic wind farm controller that evaluates thrust coefficients providing power tracking under uncertain wind speed measurements. The controller is evaluated in a high-fidelity wind farm model simulating a 9-turbine wind farm to demonstrate the stochastic controller under different uncertainty levels on the wind speed measurement and different controller settings. Results illustrate that a stochastic controller provides better tracking performance with respect to its deterministic variant.

@en

Wake redirection is an active wake control (AWC) concept that is known to have a high potential for increasing the overall power production of wind farms. Being based on operating the turbines with intentional yaw misalignment to steer wakes away from downstream turbines, this control strategy requires careful attention to the load implications. However, the computational effort required to perform an exhaustive analysis of the site-specific loads on each turbine in a wind farm is unacceptably high due to the huge number of aeroelastic simulations required to cover all possible inflow and yaw conditions. To reduce this complexity, a practical load modeling approach is based on "gridding", i.e., performing simulations only for a subset of the range of environmental and operational conditions that can occur. Based on these simulations, a multi-dimensional lookup table (LUT) can be constructed containing the fatigue and extreme loads on all components of interest. Using interpolation, the loads on each turbine in the farm can the be predicted for the whole range of expected conditions. Recent studies using this approach indicate that wake redirection can increase the overall power production of the wind farm and at the same time decrease the lifetime fatigue loads on the main components of the individual turbines. As the present level of risk perception related to operation with large yaw misalignment is still substantial, it is essential to increase the confidence level in this LUT-based load modeling approach to further derisk the wake redirection strategy. To this end, this paper presents the results of a series of studies focused on the validation of different aspects of the LUT load modeling approach. These studies are based on detailed aeroelastic simulations, two wind tunnel tests, and a full-scale field test. The results indicate that the LUT approach is a computationally efficient methodology for assessing the farm loads under AWC, which achieves generally good prediction of the load trends.

@en

The cubature Kalman filter (CKF) is well-known for a decade as a derivative-free nonlinear Kalman filter that is well-suited for high-dimensional nonlinear estimation problems. This paper further develops this classical CKF in order to cope with time-varying noise statistics as well as inequality constraints on the estimated states. The resulting adaptive filter is suggested to provide more accurate state estimates and to be more robust against filter divergence. Moreover, this contribution proposes an automated filter design based on numerical optimization which uses the normalized estimation error squared (NEES) and the normalized innovation squared (NIS) as part of the objective function. The novel adaptive CKF is applied to wind turbines in order to assess the potential improvement for state and parameter estimation. The simulation results for an illustrative acid test scenario with time-varying measurement noise show the superiority of the novel adaptive CKF since it compensates the noise robustly and thereby outperforms the classical filter.

@en

In wind farms, wake interaction leads to losses in power capture and accelerated structural degradation when compared to freestanding turbines. One method to reduce wake losses is by misaligning the rotor with the incoming flow using its yaw actuator, thereby laterally deflecting the wake away from downstream turbines. However, this demands an accurate and computationally tractable model of the wind farm dynamics. This problem calls for a closed-loop solution. This tutorial paper fills the scientific gap by demonstrating the full closed-loop controller synthesis cycle using a steady-state surrogate model. Furthermore, a novel, computationally efficient and modular communication interface is presented that enables researchers to straight-forwardly test their control algorithms in large-eddy simulations. High-fidelity simulations of a 9-turbine farm show a power production increase of up to 11% using the proposed closed-loop controller compared to traditional, greedy wind farm operation.

@en

Active power control for wind farms is needed to provide ancillary services. One of these services is to track a power reference signal with a wind farm by dynamically de- and uprating the turbines. In this paper we present a closed-loop wind farm controller that evaluates 1) thrust coefficients on a seconds-scale that provide power tracking and minimize dynamical loading on a farm level and 2) yaw settings on a minutes-scale that maximize the possible power that can be harvested by the farm. The controller is evaluated in a high-fidelity wind farm model. A six-turbine simulation case study is used to demonstrate the time-efficient controller for different controller settings. The results indicate that, with a power reference signal below the maximal possible power that can be harvested by the farm with non-yawed turbines, both tracking and reduction in dynamical loading can be ensured. In a second case study we illustrate that, when a wind farm power reference signal exceeds the maximal possible power that can be harvested with non-yawed turbines for a time period, it can not be tracked sufficiently. However, when solving for and applying optimized yaw settings, tracking can be ensured for the complete simulation horizon.

@en

Modern wind farm control (WFC) methods in the literature typically rely on a surrogate model of the farm dynamics that is computationally inexpensive to enable real-time computations. As it is very difficult to model all the relevant wind farm dynamics accurately, a closed-loop approach is a prerequisite for reliable WFC. As one of the few in its field, this paper showcases a closed-loop wind farm control solution, which leverages a steady-state surrogate model and Bayesian optimization to maximize the wind-farm-wide power production. The estimated quantities are the time-averaged ambient wind direction, wind speed and turbulence intensity. This solution is evaluated for a wind farm with nine 10 MW wind turbines in large-eddy simulation, showing a time-averaged power gain of 4.4%. This is the first WFC algorithm that is tested for wind turbines of such scale in high fidelity.

@en

Wind farm control research typically relies on computationally inexpensive, surrogate models for real-time optimization. However, due to the large time delays involved, changing atmospheric conditions and tough-to-model flow and turbine dynamics, these surrogate models need constant calibration. In this paper, a novel real-time (joint state-parameter) estimation solution for a medium-fidelity dynamical wind farm model is presented. In this work, we demonstrate the estimation of the freestream wind speed, local turbulence, and local wind field in a two-turbine wind farm using exclusively turbine power measurements. The estimator employs an Ensemble Kalman filter with a low computational cost of approximately 1.0 s per timestep on a dual-core notebook CPU. This work presents an essential building block for real-time wind farm control using computationally efficient dynamical wind farm models.

@en

The objective of active power control in wind farms is to provide ancillary grid services. Improving this is vital for a smooth wind energy penetration in the energy market. One of these services is to track a power reference signal with a wind farm by dynamically de- and uprating the turbines. In this paper we present a computationally efficient model predictive controller (MPC) for computing optimal control signals for each time step. It is applied in the PArallelized Large-eddy simulation Model (PALM), which is considered as the real wind farm in this paper. By taking measurements from the PALM, we show that the closed-loop controller can provide power reference tracking while minimizing variations in the axial forces by solving a constrained optimization problem at each time step. A six turbine simulation case study is presented in which the controller operates with optimised turbine yaw settings. We show that with these optimized yaw settings, it is possible to track a power signal that temporarily exceeds the power harvested when operating under averaged greedy control turbine settings. Additionally, variations in the turbine's force signals are studied under different controller settings.

@en