Jv

J.W. van Wingerden

info

Please Note

326 records found

Journal article (2026) - D.C. van der Hoek, T. Dammann, J.W. van Wingerden
Wind farms experience reduced power production and elevated structural loading due to wake interactions. Wake-mixing control techniques, which dynamically excite upstream turbine wakes to accelerate recovery, have demonstrated promising improvements in downstream power production but at the expense of increased fatigue loading. Identifying the optimal control settings and quantifying the resulting load implications remain challenging because these methods require high-fidelity simulations that capture both the dynamic actuation and the resulting turbulence. Moreover, existing load surrogate models do not incorporate wake-mixing control, largely because conventional engineering wake models are unable to reproduce periodic wake excitation. This study presents two complementary advances to improve the design of wake-mixing strategies using a limited number of large eddy simulations (LES) and Gaussian process (GP) regression. First, we develop an efficient simulation-driven framework to identify optimal frequency and amplitude parameters for wake-mixing control, yielding a clear optimal power gain of 7.5 % near a Strouhal number of 0.25 and pitch amplitudes of around 4° for a two-turbine array. Second, we present a surrogate model capable of predicting fatigue loads for wake-mixing control. Using LES-derived rotor-plane inflow fields for aeroelastic simulations, we construct a load database that encompasses various combinations of wake overlap, turbine spacing, and wind farm control settings. The result is a load surrogate model based on GP regression trained on sector-averaged inflow quantities that accurately predicts damage equivalent loads, including the effect of increased excitation in the wake. This model enables the joint evaluation of power gains and load penalties at the wind farm level, supporting a more informed design of wake-mixing control strategies. Applying the load surrogate model to a two-turbine case study demonstrates the trade-off between additional power gain and increased structural loading of both turbines with the helix method. ...
Wakes of upstream turbines impinge on downstream turbines in wind farms, causing power losses and increased fatigue. Wind farm control methods, such as the Helix approach, have been proposed to actively stimulate mixing of the wake with the free stream by pitching the blades dynamically. As a result, a periodic structure is forced in the wake, which increases average downstream wind velocity and thereby improves downstream turbines’ power production. However, downstream turbines could further exploit this periodic wake structure by pitching dynamically as well, but in sync with the phase of the incoming wake structure. Depending on the phase offset between the impinging wake and the downstream pitch, this creates destructive or constructive interference between the two wakes and further improves power production downstream. This work presents and experimentally validates such a control strategy for downstream wind turbines and evaluates it on a three-turbine wind farm in an experimental wind tunnel setting using scaled wind turbines. Results validate the controller's effectiveness and show that the third turbine's performance improvement is strongly influenced by the phase offset between the periodic wake components generated by the second turbine and those present in the upstream wake. ...
An actuatable porous disk (APD) with controllable porosity is presented, with the purpose of enabling future turbine cluster experiments on a small scale with dynamic collective induction control. Here, a proof of concept for the APD model is presented, including analyses of both static and dynamic behavior. To quantify the wake, the APD wake is probed with a static sensor porous disk placed at various positions in the wake. The results show that the APD thrust coefficient is strongly correlated to the porosity, and the unsteady spectrum of the wake contain clear peaks at APD actuation frequencies. This proves the capabilities of the APD model for dynamically controlling its thrust coefficient and altering its wake. ...
Engineering wake models are essential tools in wind farm design and operation. Their computational efficiency enables rapid layout optimization, energy calculation, and turbine control setpoint design. As wind farms grow in scale and density, wake interactions between turbines limit overall energy capture and increase structural loading. Wind Farm Control strategies have become critical for mitigating these effects. While wake steering, the intentional yaw misalignment of upstream turbines, has consistently demonstrated power gains, new dynamic control strategies are emerging. Among these, the Helix approach has shown particular promise in accelerating wake recovery and improving downstream power production. While engineering models for wake steering are well established, dedicated models for the Helix approach remain unavailable. This study presents a novel steady-state engineering model for predicting the velocity deficit and added turbulence of wind turbines operating under Helix actuation. The proposed model extends double-Gaussian velocity deficit and bell-curve– shaped turbulence intensity formulations to account for Helix-specific effects of actuation amplitude and ambient turbulence. Calibration and validation against high-fidelity large-eddy simulations demonstrate strong agreement across a wide range of operating conditions. The model accurately reproduces wake recovery trends, variations in the velocity-deficit profile, turbulence distributions, and the resulting downstream power availability. Finally, a case study on a large offshore wind farm illustrates that, under typical offshore atmospheric conditions, Helix control and wake steering yield individual power gains of up to 2.5% and 6.1%, respectively, while their combined application achieves total power gains of up to 7.1%. ...
Factors like growing data availability and increasing system complexity have sparked interest in data-driven predictive control (DDPC) methods like Data-enabled Predictive Control (DeePC). However, closed-loop identification bias arises in the presence of noise, which reduces the effectiveness of obtained control policies. In this paper we propose Closed-loop Data-enabled Predictive Control (CL-DeePC), a framework that unifies different approaches to address this challenge. To this end, CL-DeePC incorporates instrumental variables (IVs) to synthesize and sequentially apply consistent single or multi-step-ahead predictors. Furthermore, a computationally efficient CL-DeePC implementation is developed that reveals an equivalence with Closed-loop Subspace Predictive Control (CL-SPC). Time marching simulations of DeePC and CL-DeePC are conducted using Hankel matrices of past data that are updated at every time step to induce potentially troublesome closed-loop correlations between inputs and noise. Compared to DeePC, CL-DeePC simulations demonstrate superior reference tracking, with a sensitivity study finding a 48% lower susceptibility to noise-induced reference tracking performance degradation. ...
Journal article (2026) - M. Baricchio, D.C. van der Hoek, T. Dammann, Pieter M.O. Gebraad, J. Iori, J.W. van Wingerden
Wind farm flow control mitigates wake effects by adjusting turbine settings to improve overall farm performance rather than the output of each turbine. Wake steering is an established wind farm flow control approach, while the helix method has recently emerged as a promising solution that enhances wake recovery by increasing mixing with the free-stream flow. This study quantifies the value of a combined strategy, in which each turbine can apply wake steering or the helix method. The analysis is performed considering different levels of uncertainty in wind direction, using engineering wake models that enable the simulation of these techniques on large-scale wind farms. A novel optimization algorithm, called multi-strategy serial-refine (MSR), is developed in this study, extending the state-of-the-art yaw-optimization method to include multiple control strategies and a generalized objective. A scaled version of an offshore wind farm in the Netherlands is selected as the case study, consisting of 69 IEA 22 MW turbines. The proposed combined strategy results in a greater increase in annual energy production than either individual strategy, leveraging the effectiveness of the helix method when multiple misaligned downstream turbines are present. This trend persists even under wind direction uncertainty. Due to the high sensitivity of wake steering to such uncertainty, the combined strategy benefits from the superior robustness of the helix method under these conditions. ...
Journal article (2026) - Taejune Kong, Rogier Dinkla, Jan Willem van Wingerden, Tom Oomen, Sehoon Oh
Subspace predictive control (SPC) is a data-driven control strategy that utilizes input–output measurements to predict future system behavior without requiring explicit model identification. Conventional SPC exhibits vulnerability to an unknown input disturbance, leading to degraded control performance and steady-state errors. To address these limitations, this article proposes a robust SPC method that inherently mitigates the effect of a constant input disturbance by augmenting the state-space representation through the internal model principle (IMP). This augmentation enables the controller to achieve integral action without requiring a separate disturbance observer (DOB) design. The proposed method is implemented in a data-driven framework, where an auxiliary disturbance is introduced into the data-driven algorithm to enhance disturbance rejection. A transfer function analysis verifies that the proposed Robust SPC eliminates a constant disturbance while maintaining the role of a DOB. Experimental validation on a two-inertia system confirms that the proposed method significantly improves reference tracking performance compared to conventional SPC, demonstrating its effectiveness in disturbance rejection without additional modeling complexity. ...
Journal article (2026) - Fritz A. Engeln, Jan Willem van Wingerden, Timm Faulwasser
The behavior of a linear time-invariant system can be characterized entirely by measured input–output data that spans the vector space of all possible trajectories of the system relying on the fundamental lemma by Willems et al. However, useful a priori knowledge of the system is usually neglected. We propose a novel method for incorporating prior knowledge, specifically, known pole and zero locations, into a data-driven representation by constructing filters that pre-process the measured input–output data. To this end, a physics-informed data-driven predictor is introduced, where trajectories are obtained as linear combinations of the columns of a filtered block-Hankel matrix. We explicitly derive the output prediction error and show how leveraging prior knowledge reduces the impact of future noise realizations on output predictions and improves the accuracy of the initial state that is inferred from past data. ...
Journal article (2026) - M. Becker, J.W. van Wingerden
Wind farm flow control strategies aim to manipulate the flow between the turbines to achieve a farm-wide goal. Wake steering is one such strategy, typically employed to increase the yield of a wind farm by redirecting upstream turbines’ wakes away from downstream ones. This control approach is sensitive to the wind direction, and frequently varying wind directions create the need for robust yaw steering control setpoints. In the past, this has been achieved in the steady-state domain, as dynamic simulations are typically deemed too expensive to perform a large grid-search for optimal setpoints. This paper utilizes a computationally cheap dynamic wake model and explores how robust control setpoints can be derived in the time domain. To this end, the paper presents a methodology for generating synthetic wind direction changes with a prescribed variation in wind direction. These wind direction time series are then used to create a database of a two-turbine wind farm, which allows the exploration of different cost functions in time. The database provides both the expected value and the uncertainty of both power and energy. The obtained data is then used to explore four cost functions to derive robust setpoints. Comparing energy and power performance, we define useful quantities of interest to connect the two and to highlight necessary assumptions made when using steady-state setpoints. The paper concludes by applying the resulting look-up table controllers in a ten-turbine wind farm. The performance shows that maximizing for the expected power is the best approach to increase the farm efficiency. The results also show that an alternative cost function, which avoids losses, does lead to similar but smaller gains at a much lower yaw angle investment. ...
The wake interaction between wind turbines causes significant losses in wind farm efficiency that can potentially be alleviated using wake control techniques. We provide detailed experimental evidence on how the coupling between the so-called helix wake control technique and a floating turbine's yaw dynamics can be used to increase wake recovery. Using tomographic particle image velocimetry during wind tunnel experiments, we analysed the wake dynamics and its coupling to a floating wind turbine. The measurements show that ensuring the floating turbine's yaw motion is in phase with the blade pitch dynamics of the helix technique enables an increase of 12 percentage points in available energy in the flow on top of the helix method applied to bottom-fixed turbines. We find that the in-phase scenario results in an earlier interaction between the tip and hub vortices inside the wake, which leads to the desired breakdown of the vortices, thus accelerating the entrainment of energy into the wake. ...
Conference paper (2026) - Manuel Lara, Mario L. Ruz, Francisco Vazquez, Sebastiaan Paul Mulders, Jan Willem Van Wingerden, Juan Garrido
In the nominal operating region of wind turbines, collective pitch control (CPC) regulates power by maintaining rated rotor speed, while individual pitch control (IPC) mitigates cyclic blade loads caused by wind variations like wind shear or turbulence. However, tuning CPC presents a significant trade-off, as improving power regulation often leads to an increase in fatigue blade loads. Additionally, IPC implementation via Multi-Blade Coordinate (MBC) transformation suffers from coupling between IPC loops, reducing controller effectiveness. Prior studies suggest that azimuth offset and static inverted decoupling enhance classical IPC implementations by mitigating this coupling. However, a comparative performance analysis between both implementations remains unexplored. This study addresses this analysis through a multi-objective optimization approach to tune CPC and IPC strategies for a 15 MW reference wind turbine. Four configurations (baseline CPC with conventional IPC, CPC+IPC, CPC+IPC with azimuth offset, and CPC+IPC with static inverted decoupling) are optimized. Results show that a well-tuned CPC improves IPC effectiveness, while the incorporation of azimuth offset or static inverted decoupling in IPC significantly improves both objectives, achieving reductions of approximately 19% in damage equivalent load on the blades and 60% in the integral squared error of power output compared to the baseline CPC with conventional IPC, and around 9% and 30% relative to the CPC with conventional IPC. ...
The helix approach has shown potential in increasing wind farm power production through enhancing wake mixing. By applying periodic blade pitch signals to upstream turbines, a helical wake is generated, which reduces velocity deficits for downstream turbines and mitigates the wake effect. While promising, the closed-loop implementation of the helix approach remains largely unexplored, which could enable handling uncertainties and model errors in wind farm applications. This work presents a framework that integrates lidar-based wake measurements to enable such closed-loop control. First, a downwind-facing continuous-wave lidar is used to extract the hub vortex as the controlled variable. Second, we developed a control algorithm that regulates the hub vortex position in the helix frame, thereby controlling the helical wake. Simulations in QBlade show that the framework enables a real-time, flow-informed closed-loop wake mixing approach. Compared with the open-loop cases, the framework corrects the shear-induced steady-state wake bias and enables measurement-informed, dynamic pitch adjustments under turbulence. In shear, bias correction increases downstream power but raises structural loads on both turbines; under turbulence, dynamic pitch control delivers a modest farm-level power gain with only minor load increases. These outcomes highlight the promise of flow-informed, closed-loop wake-mixing control and motivate further investigation. ...
Wind turbines operating within a wind farm experience significant power losses due to wake interactions. Dynamic induction control has been proposed as a solution to mitigate these losses by enhancing wake mixing with the free stream, thereby increasing the effective wind speed at downstream rotor planes. Such wind farm flow control strategies typically rely on periodic inputs, characterised by a mean value, amplitude, and frequency. The selection and optimisation of these parameters is, however, commonly performed empirically, due to the high computational cost of high-fidelity flow simulations. Model-free controllers may have the potential to identify a periodic control input tailored to the environmental conditions without relying on a costly flow model. This paper proposes an economic data-driven controller with the objective of wind farm power maximisation. Results are illustrated using a setup of two wind turbines interacting through a free-vortex wake engineering model. The proposed method converges to a periodic input that leads to a total power increase of 6.4% compared to a greedy control scenario. These findings conceptually demonstrate the potential of data-driven methods for dynamic wind farm flow control as a viable and computationally efficient alternative to model-based optimisation. ...
Many systems are subject to periodic disturbances and exhibit repetitive behaviour. Model-based repetitive control employs knowledge of such periodicity to attenuate periodic disturbances and has seen a wide range of successful industrial implementations. The aim of this paper is to develop a data-driven repetitive control method. In the developed framework, linear periodically time-varying (LPTV) behaviour is lifted to linear time-invariant (LTI) behaviour. Periodic disturbance mitigation is enabled by developing an extension of Willems’ fundamental lemma for systems with exogenous disturbances. The resulting Data-enabled Predictive Repetitive Control (DeePRC) technique accounts for periodic system behaviour to perform attenuation of a periodic disturbance. Simulations demonstrate the ability of DeePRC to effectively mitigate periodic disturbances in the presence of noise. ...
Book (2025) - Nassir Cassamo, Jan Willem van Wingerden
This book presents data-driven algorithms used in the context of wind farm modelling and exploits their relation with concepts from non-linear dynamical system theory. The algortihms include Input Output Dynamic Mode Decomposition and their combination with the Koopman Operator theory. The latter improves on modelling and analysis of the aerodynamic interaction between wind turbines in wind farms and assists in uncovering insights into the existing dynamics and improves models accuracy. The authors introduce the topic of wind farm flow control, illustrating current strategies devised to overcome power losses in wind plants due to the aerodynamic interaction between turbines. Although controlling wind farms as a whole is becoming increasingly important, the high dimensions and governing non-linear dynamics inherent of wind farm systems make the design of numerical optimal controllers computationally expensive. This book describes a possible pathway to circumvent this challenge through reduced order models that can embed the existing non-linearities. The authors make use of high fidelity open-source simulation datasets and developed algorithms to fully show the potential of this approach using visual results. The reader is motivated to use the datasets and algorithms and exploit the potential of the reduced order models. ...
Denser turbine spacing in wind farms leads to increased wake interactions, causing power losses when each turbine operates under its own greedy control scheme. To mitigate these effects, research is exploring strategies that consider the entire wind farm rather than singular turbines. The so-called helix approach has recently gotten significant attention from the research community. It aims to reduce wake losses through periodic individual pitch control. Wake steering on the other hand uses yaw actuation to laterally deflect the wake away from downstream turbines. In this paper, we adapt and validate a steady-state surrogate model to compute the time-averaged velocity field behind a wind turbine operating with the helix approach. The model is tuned using data from Large Eddy Simulations. We compare the helix model to wake steering and baseline operation in a wind farm case study, demonstrating that the helix approach offers promising benefits under specific wind conditions. ...
Benchmarking numerical models is essential for validating their accuracy and ensuring consistency across simulation platforms. This study presents a comparative benchmark analysis of two widely used Large Eddy Simulation (LES) codes, AMR-WIND and NREL SOWFA-6, focusing on wind turbine rotor performance, wake dynamics, and atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) representation. The evaluation includes an actuator line model (ALM)-based uniform inflow wind turbine simulation and ABL precursors under neutral and unstable conditions. The uniform inflow wake analysis examined differences in wind turbine induction and wake development between the two codes. Additionally, neutral and unstable atmospheric boundary layer precursors were generated for an offshore environment and compared. Results indicate a difference in wake breakdown location between the codes (one contributing factor was the difference in numerical schemes used for the advection terms.) The number of actuator points required for smooth velocity distribution across the rotor was higher for SOWFA-6 than AMR-WIND. In ABL precursors, time-averaged flow fields showed strong agreement, though minor discrepancies in turbulence were observed, particularly in unstable conditions, affecting coherence analysis. The energy distribution across wavenumbers showed a good match between the codes, with slight discrepancies observed in the large and small wavenumber regions. The cutoff wavenumber was found to be similar for both codes. Lateral and vertical coherence at small and large separations were in close agreement for the neutral ABL. However, in the unstable ABL, notable differences in coherence were observed between the codes for separations greater than 40 m. ...
Journal article (2025) - Unai Gutierrez-Santiago, Jonathan Keller, Alfredo Fernández-Sisón, Henk Polinder, Jan Willem van Wingerden
Accurate knowledge of the mechanical loads of wind turbine gearboxes has become essential in modern, highly loaded gearbox designs, as maintaining or even improving gearbox reliability with increasing torque density demands is proving to be challenging. Unfortunately, the traditional method of measuring dynamic mechanical torque using strain gauges placed on the outer surface of a rotating shaft and transmitting the resulting signal is unsuitable for serial deployment due to technical and economic constraints. An alternative method based on fiber-optic strain sensors placed on the stationary outer surface of the gearbox ring gear has been proposed. Like shaft torsion, the radial deformation of the ring gear is proportionate to the rotor torque. Placing the sensors on a stationary component is a cost-effective alternative for serial implementation because the need for complex and expensive data transfer via wireless transmission or a slip ring is eliminated. In this paper, we present the results of an extensive field experiment conducted to evaluate the torque measurement accuracy of this novel sensing solution installed on the gearbox of a Gamesa G97 2-MW wind turbine at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s Flatirons Campus. Torque measurements derived from fiber-optic strain sensors placed on the ring gear of the planetary stage are compared to conventional torque measurements from strain gauges placed on the main shaft. Two different torque estimation data processing methods were evaluated, with the method based on operational deflection shapes providing the most accurate results with an average normalized root mean square error below 0.7% for a load revolution distribution analysis. The effect of operating conditions on the torque estimate was also investigated, and the third planet-passing operational deflection shape was found to be the least sensitive to nontorque load-related effects. The fiber-optic strain sensors’ successful operation during the complete test campaign has demonstrated a robust and accurate solution for fleet-wide enhanced gearbox remaining useful life estimation. ...
Floating offshore wind turbines pave the way to accessing deep-water regions with abundant wind resources. However, they face specific control challenges, such as the negative damping problem and increased model complexity. Since model-based control is becoming increasingly demanding, a model-free, data-driven approach is considered. Additionally, floating wind turbines are susceptible to rough environmental disturbances. Feedforward information, such as wave elevation measurements from wave radars, may be included in the controller to lessen the impact of disturbances. Although waves have been shown to increase rotor speed oscillations and turbine loads, wave-preview-based methods have only recently been explored. To this end, this paper first proposes a modified Data-enabled Predictive Control formulation that includes past and future information about measurable disturbances. The feasibility of this control strategy is then demonstrated for floating wind turbines through mid-fidelity simulations. The model-free, feedforward controller uses a preview of wave forces acting on the floating platform and aims for rotor speed regulation. Simulations indicate that the data-driven approach has potential for floating wind turbine control, and including wave feedforward action reduces the amplitude of rotor speed oscillations. ...
Journal article (2025) - Marcus Becker, Maxime Lejeune, Philippe Chatelain, Dries Allaerts, Rafael Mudafort, Jan Willem Van Wingerden
Wind farm flow control (WFFC) is the discipline of manipulating the flow between wind turbines to achieve a farm-wide goal, like power maximization, power tracking or load mitigation. Specifically, steady-state control approaches have shown promising results in both theory and practice for power maximization. But how are they expected to perform in a dynamically changing environment? This paper presents an open-source wake modeling framework called OFF (abbreviated from the models OnWARDS, FLORIDyn and FLORIS). It allows the approximation of the performance of WFFC strategies in response to environmental changes at a low computational cost. It is rooted in previously published dynamic parametric engineering models and offers a flexible and adaptable platform to explore these models further. The presented study tests the modeling framework by investigating the performance of different wake steering controllers in a 10-turbine wind farm case study based on a subset of the Dutch wind farm Hollandse Kust Noord (HKN). The case study uses a 24 h wind direction time series based on field data and verifies subsets of the time series in a large-eddy simulation (LES). The results highlight how dependent yaw travel is on the controller settings and suggest where users can strike a balance between power gains and actuator usage. They also show the structural differences and similarities between steady-state and dynamic engineering models. The comparison to LES shows what timescales the surrogate models cover and how accurately. While steady-state models capture turbine power signal dynamics up to ≈ 1/570 Hz, the dynamic wake description can predict dynamics up to ≈ 1/360 Hz with a better correlation and normalized root-mean-square error. Further results show that the dynamic wake description is mainly advantageous over steady-state wake models for shorter periods (< 20 min). The paper also opens up discussion about the effectiveness of wind farm flow control in a time-marching manner as opposed to a steady-state viewpoint. ...