J.W. van Wingerden
Please Note
88 records found
1
The resulting framework accounts for both passive and active repositioning within a single optimization loop. One XGBoost surrogate predicts the surge and sway displacement of each platform, and a second predicts the optimal yaw angle directly, which removes the nested control optimization that would otherwise run at every candidate layout. The framework is assessed on the Kriti~3 site off Crete, with 12 IEA 15~MW turbines on the VolturnUS-S semi-submersible and three mooring designs ranging from stiff to highly compliant.
Accounting for passive repositioning inside the layout optimization yields only a small median gain in annual energy production (AEP) over fixed-position optimization, though the gain increases with mooring compliance, and on the most compliant design the displacement-aware approach reaches a distinctly better layout than fixed-position optimization finds. The stronger effect is on the control side. On that same compliant design, yaw setpoints optimized under a fixed-position assumption turn a predicted gain into a net loss once applied to the moving platform, since the yaw-induced drift carries the rotors into wakes the fixed-position optimizer never evaluated. A displacement-aware optimization not only avoids this loss but unlocks further gain, using the same yaw-induced motion to steer the platforms clear of upstream wakes. The displacement response must therefore be accounted for inside the control optimization, and the requirement grows stronger the more compliant the mooring.
The two surrogates keep the layout-control co-design computationally tractable, where a nested formulation running the actual yaw optimizer and platform simulations inside the loop would be prohibitive. At this site and farm size, fixed-position, displacement-aware, and co-design optimization reach nearly the same AEP, with co-design adding little over displacement-aware layout optimization, in line with co-design results reported for bottom-fixed farms. Because many distinct layouts reach a near-equal AEP, the designer keeps the freedom to choose among them on criteria beyond energy capture, such as cabling or structural loads. ...
The resulting framework accounts for both passive and active repositioning within a single optimization loop. One XGBoost surrogate predicts the surge and sway displacement of each platform, and a second predicts the optimal yaw angle directly, which removes the nested control optimization that would otherwise run at every candidate layout. The framework is assessed on the Kriti~3 site off Crete, with 12 IEA 15~MW turbines on the VolturnUS-S semi-submersible and three mooring designs ranging from stiff to highly compliant.
Accounting for passive repositioning inside the layout optimization yields only a small median gain in annual energy production (AEP) over fixed-position optimization, though the gain increases with mooring compliance, and on the most compliant design the displacement-aware approach reaches a distinctly better layout than fixed-position optimization finds. The stronger effect is on the control side. On that same compliant design, yaw setpoints optimized under a fixed-position assumption turn a predicted gain into a net loss once applied to the moving platform, since the yaw-induced drift carries the rotors into wakes the fixed-position optimizer never evaluated. A displacement-aware optimization not only avoids this loss but unlocks further gain, using the same yaw-induced motion to steer the platforms clear of upstream wakes. The displacement response must therefore be accounted for inside the control optimization, and the requirement grows stronger the more compliant the mooring.
The two surrogates keep the layout-control co-design computationally tractable, where a nested formulation running the actual yaw optimizer and platform simulations inside the loop would be prohibitive. At this site and farm size, fixed-position, displacement-aware, and co-design optimization reach nearly the same AEP, with co-design adding little over displacement-aware layout optimization, in line with co-design results reported for bottom-fixed farms. Because many distinct layouts reach a near-equal AEP, the designer keeps the freedom to choose among them on criteria beyond energy capture, such as cabling or structural loads.
Data-Driven Control of Floating Offshore Wind Turbines
Using Multi-Input Multi-Output Closed-Loop Subspace Predictive Control
Most wake-steering studies rely on steady-state models and focus primarily on power maximization. However, reducing the cost of wind energy also requires extending turbine lifetime, since downstream turbines operating in wake-induced flow experience increased fatigue loading. Aeroelastic simulators can capture these load dynamics, but they are too computationally expensive for control-oriented applications. An efficient alternative is to use load surrogate models that predict fatigue loads from simple inflow and operational quantities. At the same time, the transition from steady-state flow models to dynamic flow models enables the representation of time-varying wake evolution and provides a more realistic environment for evaluating control strategies.
In this thesis, the dynamic wind farm model OFF is coupled with a sector-averaged load surrogate model that predicts damage equivalent loads (DELs) from turbine operation conditions and simple inflow quantities sampled across the rotor plane. The implementation process is described in detail, together with the challenges and limitations encountered. This integrated framework is then used to develop a power-load balanced control strategy that incorporates tower base fatigue loads, and is applied in both the steady state model FLORIS and OFF to assess its performance under more realistic conditions.
A case study with three turbines and three time-varying wind direction signals shows that the resulting balanced controller in OFF achieves power gains of up to 12.57% and tower base load reductions of up to 14.40% compared to the baseline. A comparison between FLORIS and OFF reveals that FLORIS provides an upper bound on predicted power gains and load reductions. The structural differences between steady-state and dynamic models explain the observed differences in predicted power and load responses. ...
Most wake-steering studies rely on steady-state models and focus primarily on power maximization. However, reducing the cost of wind energy also requires extending turbine lifetime, since downstream turbines operating in wake-induced flow experience increased fatigue loading. Aeroelastic simulators can capture these load dynamics, but they are too computationally expensive for control-oriented applications. An efficient alternative is to use load surrogate models that predict fatigue loads from simple inflow and operational quantities. At the same time, the transition from steady-state flow models to dynamic flow models enables the representation of time-varying wake evolution and provides a more realistic environment for evaluating control strategies.
In this thesis, the dynamic wind farm model OFF is coupled with a sector-averaged load surrogate model that predicts damage equivalent loads (DELs) from turbine operation conditions and simple inflow quantities sampled across the rotor plane. The implementation process is described in detail, together with the challenges and limitations encountered. This integrated framework is then used to develop a power-load balanced control strategy that incorporates tower base fatigue loads, and is applied in both the steady state model FLORIS and OFF to assess its performance under more realistic conditions.
A case study with three turbines and three time-varying wind direction signals shows that the resulting balanced controller in OFF achieves power gains of up to 12.57% and tower base load reductions of up to 14.40% compared to the baseline. A comparison between FLORIS and OFF reveals that FLORIS provides an upper bound on predicted power gains and load reductions. The structural differences between steady-state and dynamic models explain the observed differences in predicted power and load responses.
In Rhythm with the Wind
Synchronized Wake Mixing in Wind Farms
This dissertation, titled “In Rhythm with the Wind: Synchronized Wake Mixing in Wind Farms”, addresses this challenge by exploring how dynamic, synchronized control strategies can mitigate wake-induced losses and improve overall wind farm performance. This work goes beyond the conventional approach of turbines operating independently and instead investigates how coordinated turbine control can create new opportunities.... ...
This dissertation, titled “In Rhythm with the Wind: Synchronized Wake Mixing in Wind Farms”, addresses this challenge by exploring how dynamic, synchronized control strategies can mitigate wake-induced losses and improve overall wind farm performance. This work goes beyond the conventional approach of turbines operating independently and instead investigates how coordinated turbine control can create new opportunities....
Balancing Power and Durability in Floating Offshore Wind Turbines
A Framework to Extend Blade Fatigue Life and Maximise Annual Energy Production via Pareto-Optimised PI Control
This thesis proposes an adaptive closed-loop Subspace Predictive Control (SPC) framework designed in an attempt to handle the complexity of larger, nonlinear wind turbines. Closed-loop SPC is a direct Data-Driven Predictive Control (DDPC) method that does not rely on explicit state-space modeling, but instead uses measured input-output data to predict future outputs and compute optimal control action. For the optimal control action, it sets up a receding horizon optimization that regulates above-rated rotor speed. This thesis focuses on the above-rated region, where aeroelastic complexity becomes more pronounced due to higher wind speeds and greater wind speed variations, posing significant control challenges.
To capture time-varying and nonlinear behavior more effectively, the closed-loop SPC incorporates Recursive Least Squares (RLS). The controller adapts to time-varying conditions through online parameter estimation using RLS, which updates a locally linear model in real time. Three RLS variants are examined: standard RLS without forgetting, RLS with exponential forgetting, and RLS with directional forgetting. Standard RLS weighs all past data equally, which may be effective when the system dynamics remain stationary but limits adaptability to changing conditions. Exponential forgetting addresses this by placing more weight on recent data, improving adaptiveness, but at the potential cost of losing parameter estimation accuracy in less-excited directions. Directional forgetting refines this further by applying forgetting selectively along the directions of incoming data, preserving excitation in recently unexcited directions and enhancing estimation robustness.
To reduce the phase lag introduced by increased rotor inertia, wind preview information is incorporated into the closed-loop SPC as a feedforward signal. This wind preview is included in the receding horizon optimization problem, enabling the controller to anticipate and proactively respond to upcoming wind changes. Additionally, the wind preview is demonstrated using more realistic measurements obtained through a LIDAR simulator.
The adaptive closed-loop SPC is validated on the DTU 10 MW reference turbine using QBlade, a high-fidelity wind turbine simulator. Various wind scenarios, including gusts, ramps, and turbulent inflow, are evaluated with and without wind preview feedforward. Results demonstrate that the inclusion of wind preview significantly improves rotor speed tracking performance and reduces pitch activity. This improvement is also observed when more realistic LIDAR wind measurements are used in simulations with a turbulent wind field. In the conducted wind cases, among the RLS-based adaptive closed-loop SPC strategies, exponential forgetting combined with wind preview consistently outperformed the other RLS approaches across all scenarios evaluated in this thesis. These findings demonstrate that introducing adaptiveness through forgetting, together with feedforward wind information, can enhance closed-loop SPC performance in rated rotor speed tracking. ...
This thesis proposes an adaptive closed-loop Subspace Predictive Control (SPC) framework designed in an attempt to handle the complexity of larger, nonlinear wind turbines. Closed-loop SPC is a direct Data-Driven Predictive Control (DDPC) method that does not rely on explicit state-space modeling, but instead uses measured input-output data to predict future outputs and compute optimal control action. For the optimal control action, it sets up a receding horizon optimization that regulates above-rated rotor speed. This thesis focuses on the above-rated region, where aeroelastic complexity becomes more pronounced due to higher wind speeds and greater wind speed variations, posing significant control challenges.
To capture time-varying and nonlinear behavior more effectively, the closed-loop SPC incorporates Recursive Least Squares (RLS). The controller adapts to time-varying conditions through online parameter estimation using RLS, which updates a locally linear model in real time. Three RLS variants are examined: standard RLS without forgetting, RLS with exponential forgetting, and RLS with directional forgetting. Standard RLS weighs all past data equally, which may be effective when the system dynamics remain stationary but limits adaptability to changing conditions. Exponential forgetting addresses this by placing more weight on recent data, improving adaptiveness, but at the potential cost of losing parameter estimation accuracy in less-excited directions. Directional forgetting refines this further by applying forgetting selectively along the directions of incoming data, preserving excitation in recently unexcited directions and enhancing estimation robustness.
To reduce the phase lag introduced by increased rotor inertia, wind preview information is incorporated into the closed-loop SPC as a feedforward signal. This wind preview is included in the receding horizon optimization problem, enabling the controller to anticipate and proactively respond to upcoming wind changes. Additionally, the wind preview is demonstrated using more realistic measurements obtained through a LIDAR simulator.
The adaptive closed-loop SPC is validated on the DTU 10 MW reference turbine using QBlade, a high-fidelity wind turbine simulator. Various wind scenarios, including gusts, ramps, and turbulent inflow, are evaluated with and without wind preview feedforward. Results demonstrate that the inclusion of wind preview significantly improves rotor speed tracking performance and reduces pitch activity. This improvement is also observed when more realistic LIDAR wind measurements are used in simulations with a turbulent wind field. In the conducted wind cases, among the RLS-based adaptive closed-loop SPC strategies, exponential forgetting combined with wind preview consistently outperformed the other RLS approaches across all scenarios evaluated in this thesis. These findings demonstrate that introducing adaptiveness through forgetting, together with feedforward wind information, can enhance closed-loop SPC performance in rated rotor speed tracking.
Towards Adaptive Real-Time Constrained Subspace Predictive Control
From simulation to real-life application
A key insight in computational efficiency is the R-CL SPC algorithm, which updates system parameters online using recursive least squares estimation combined with Givens rotations. This reduces computational complexity by avoiding large-scale matrix inversions at each time step. Additionally, the CR-CL SPC variant introduces constraint handling via a Quadratic Programming (QP) solver, enabling input and output constraints.
These algorithms’ performances were evaluated through simulation studies and real-time experiments on a piezo-actuated beam setup, where the control objective was to suppress the first two natural vibration modes. The R-CL SPC algorithm demonstrated a strong balance between computational efficiency and control performance, achieving execution times below 0.2 ms while maintaining effective vibration damping. Meanwhile, though at a higher computational cost, CR-CL SPC validated constraint enforcement capabilities.
This thesis demonstrates that adaptive SPC algorithms can be successfully implemented on real-world hardware. The results contribute to the growing knowledge on direct DDPC strategies and provide a foundation for their broader application in real-time, constrained control systems. ...
A key insight in computational efficiency is the R-CL SPC algorithm, which updates system parameters online using recursive least squares estimation combined with Givens rotations. This reduces computational complexity by avoiding large-scale matrix inversions at each time step. Additionally, the CR-CL SPC variant introduces constraint handling via a Quadratic Programming (QP) solver, enabling input and output constraints.
These algorithms’ performances were evaluated through simulation studies and real-time experiments on a piezo-actuated beam setup, where the control objective was to suppress the first two natural vibration modes. The R-CL SPC algorithm demonstrated a strong balance between computational efficiency and control performance, achieving execution times below 0.2 ms while maintaining effective vibration damping. Meanwhile, though at a higher computational cost, CR-CL SPC validated constraint enforcement capabilities.
This thesis demonstrates that adaptive SPC algorithms can be successfully implemented on real-world hardware. The results contribute to the growing knowledge on direct DDPC strategies and provide a foundation for their broader application in real-time, constrained control systems.
Data-Driven Control
Beyond ARX: Towards ARMAX in Subspace Predictive Control
Among the various data-driven approaches, Subspace Predictive Control (SPC) integrates subspace identification with Model Predictive Control (MPC) into a unified data-driven framework. The classical SPC formulation is based on an AutoRegressive with eXogenous input (ARX) model, which restricts its ability to capture coloured noise and complex stochastic dynamics.
This thesis investigates whether SPC can be extended to AutoRegressive Moving Average with eXogenous input (ARMAX) models to enhance noise modelling and control performance. The research addresses two key questions: from a theoretical perspective, how ARMAX models can be integrated into the SPC framework to achieve improved noise representation; and from a practical perspective, how ARMAX-based SPC can be applied to a real-life system exhibiting an anti-resonance.
The proposed framework reformulates the SPC data and prediction equations to include the ARMAX structure and employs Extended Recursive Least Squares for online identification. Both simulation studies and laboratory experiments on an inertia-spring-damping system were conducted to evaluate reference tracking, computational cost, and numerical robustness.
The results demonstrate that lower-order ARMAX models outperform ARX models, achieving substantially lower Integral Absolute Error (IAE), Integral Squared Error (ISE), and Input Energy (InEn) while producing smoother control actions. For higher-order models, however, both methods show comparable control performance, as the deterministic part of the system dynamics becomes well identified. Importantly, the computational cost of the ARMAX-based SPC remains of the same order as the ARX formulation for an equivalent number of parameters, confirming its feasibility for real-time implementation. These findings provide a foundation for future research on multi-input multi-output (MIMO) systems, hybrid SPC formulations, and stochastic predictive control frameworks.
Keywords – Data-Driven Control, Subspace Predictive Control, Model Predictive Control, System Identification, Recursive Least Squares, ARX, ARMAX, Markov Parameters. ...
Among the various data-driven approaches, Subspace Predictive Control (SPC) integrates subspace identification with Model Predictive Control (MPC) into a unified data-driven framework. The classical SPC formulation is based on an AutoRegressive with eXogenous input (ARX) model, which restricts its ability to capture coloured noise and complex stochastic dynamics.
This thesis investigates whether SPC can be extended to AutoRegressive Moving Average with eXogenous input (ARMAX) models to enhance noise modelling and control performance. The research addresses two key questions: from a theoretical perspective, how ARMAX models can be integrated into the SPC framework to achieve improved noise representation; and from a practical perspective, how ARMAX-based SPC can be applied to a real-life system exhibiting an anti-resonance.
The proposed framework reformulates the SPC data and prediction equations to include the ARMAX structure and employs Extended Recursive Least Squares for online identification. Both simulation studies and laboratory experiments on an inertia-spring-damping system were conducted to evaluate reference tracking, computational cost, and numerical robustness.
The results demonstrate that lower-order ARMAX models outperform ARX models, achieving substantially lower Integral Absolute Error (IAE), Integral Squared Error (ISE), and Input Energy (InEn) while producing smoother control actions. For higher-order models, however, both methods show comparable control performance, as the deterministic part of the system dynamics becomes well identified. Importantly, the computational cost of the ARMAX-based SPC remains of the same order as the ARX formulation for an equivalent number of parameters, confirming its feasibility for real-time implementation. These findings provide a foundation for future research on multi-input multi-output (MIMO) systems, hybrid SPC formulations, and stochastic predictive control frameworks.
Keywords – Data-Driven Control, Subspace Predictive Control, Model Predictive Control, System Identification, Recursive Least Squares, ARX, ARMAX, Markov Parameters.
A major challenge in monopile installation occurs when the tip of the pile contacts the seabed and establishes a connection with the lateral soil. This introduces an abrupt change in the overall system dynamics and increases the risk of DP instability problems of the vessel. These problems are not new to the offshore industry. However, with the introduction of the MCGF, the risk of DP instability increases, as there is now a much stronger dynamic coupling between the vessel, the monopile and the seabed. Therefore, it is important that the MCGF is properly controlled, as this directly influences the reaction forces applied to the vessel. However, properly tuning the MCGF controller is challenging, as it strongly depends on the lateral soil behavior. Currently, these controller gains are tuned using simulations in which the soil behavior is modeled using CPT data. Nevertheless, the estimated behavior based on this data contain large uncertainties and therefore the control settings might become suboptimal during the installation. Furthermore, since soil dynamics also changes during installation, it is beneficial to use a real-time estimation method that takes this into account. Therefore, this thesis investigates different identification methods to obtain real-time estimates of lateral soil behavior during the monopile installation process.
Two main approaches are explored; the augmented EKF approach and the GPLFM approach. The augmented EKF approach shows to be capable of estimating soil behavior by directly identifying the lateral and rotational soil stiffness values, given that the filter is carefully tuned. However, tuning the filter is computationally demanding due to the large number of tunable parameters, which makes this method impractical for site-specific tuning prior to installation using the first measurements obtained. This limitation is critical, as offshore installations face varying conditions at each site, and accurate estimation therefore requires site-specific tuning. To address this tuning challenge, an alternative method is introduced: the GPLFM approach. In this framework, the identification task is reformulated as a GP regression problem. An important advantage of this method is that the process covariance matrix is determined in a data-driven manner, providing a complete covariance structure governed by only a small number of tunable parameters. Consequently, the parameter space is greatly reduced, enabling efficient site-specific tuning. As a result, it is shown that it is possible to obtain accurate estimation results across varying conditions.
Therefore, it is found that the GPLFM method offers a promising solution for real-time estimation of lateral soil behavior during monopile installation. By providing real-time estimates, this study supports the development of more effective MCGF control strategie. This can in the future be used to improve the MCGF controller as it can now be adjusted automatically during the installation process rather than manually. Furthermore, it can help to prevent DP instability problems. ...
A major challenge in monopile installation occurs when the tip of the pile contacts the seabed and establishes a connection with the lateral soil. This introduces an abrupt change in the overall system dynamics and increases the risk of DP instability problems of the vessel. These problems are not new to the offshore industry. However, with the introduction of the MCGF, the risk of DP instability increases, as there is now a much stronger dynamic coupling between the vessel, the monopile and the seabed. Therefore, it is important that the MCGF is properly controlled, as this directly influences the reaction forces applied to the vessel. However, properly tuning the MCGF controller is challenging, as it strongly depends on the lateral soil behavior. Currently, these controller gains are tuned using simulations in which the soil behavior is modeled using CPT data. Nevertheless, the estimated behavior based on this data contain large uncertainties and therefore the control settings might become suboptimal during the installation. Furthermore, since soil dynamics also changes during installation, it is beneficial to use a real-time estimation method that takes this into account. Therefore, this thesis investigates different identification methods to obtain real-time estimates of lateral soil behavior during the monopile installation process.
Two main approaches are explored; the augmented EKF approach and the GPLFM approach. The augmented EKF approach shows to be capable of estimating soil behavior by directly identifying the lateral and rotational soil stiffness values, given that the filter is carefully tuned. However, tuning the filter is computationally demanding due to the large number of tunable parameters, which makes this method impractical for site-specific tuning prior to installation using the first measurements obtained. This limitation is critical, as offshore installations face varying conditions at each site, and accurate estimation therefore requires site-specific tuning. To address this tuning challenge, an alternative method is introduced: the GPLFM approach. In this framework, the identification task is reformulated as a GP regression problem. An important advantage of this method is that the process covariance matrix is determined in a data-driven manner, providing a complete covariance structure governed by only a small number of tunable parameters. Consequently, the parameter space is greatly reduced, enabling efficient site-specific tuning. As a result, it is shown that it is possible to obtain accurate estimation results across varying conditions.
Therefore, it is found that the GPLFM method offers a promising solution for real-time estimation of lateral soil behavior during monopile installation. By providing real-time estimates, this study supports the development of more effective MCGF control strategie. This can in the future be used to improve the MCGF controller as it can now be adjusted automatically during the installation process rather than manually. Furthermore, it can help to prevent DP instability problems.
The total available wind energy capacity increases significantly when deeper waters can also be accessed by wind turbines and wind farms. For these areas, floating wind turbine technology will play an essential role. When they are deployed in similarly sized wind farms as bottom-fixed wind farms they will also encounter challenges currently faced by these bottom-fixed farms. One of these challenges is the wake interaction between turbines, a cause of significant efficiency losses for a wind farm. The field of wind farm flow control aims to develop a control solution that can alleviate the negative effects of the wake interaction between turbines... ...
The total available wind energy capacity increases significantly when deeper waters can also be accessed by wind turbines and wind farms. For these areas, floating wind turbine technology will play an essential role. When they are deployed in similarly sized wind farms as bottom-fixed wind farms they will also encounter challenges currently faced by these bottom-fixed farms. One of these challenges is the wake interaction between turbines, a cause of significant efficiency losses for a wind farm. The field of wind farm flow control aims to develop a control solution that can alleviate the negative effects of the wake interaction between turbines...
This thesis explores the use of frequency domain models, full-scale data and Control Moment Gyroscopes to enhance the floating installation of wind turbine towers. The resulting contributions highlight the challenges and relevance of offshore motion compensation, advancing the state-of-the-art and contributing to the future of the wind sector. ...
This thesis explores the use of frequency domain models, full-scale data and Control Moment Gyroscopes to enhance the floating installation of wind turbine towers. The resulting contributions highlight the challenges and relevance of offshore motion compensation, advancing the state-of-the-art and contributing to the future of the wind sector.
We propose that TNs, with their ability to represent high-dimensional data through low-rank structures, can effectively alleviate the limitations of kernel machines. Our research is structured around three central inquiries: first, we examine how TNs can accelerate kernel machine scalability while accurately approximating kernel functions; second, we elucidate the theoretical links between TN-constrained kernel machines and Gaussian processes, providing insights into convergence and generalization; finally, we introduce a novel optimization framework characterizing a specific TN, the multi-linear singular value decomposition (MLSVD), in terms of primal and dual problems. ...
We propose that TNs, with their ability to represent high-dimensional data through low-rank structures, can effectively alleviate the limitations of kernel machines. Our research is structured around three central inquiries: first, we examine how TNs can accelerate kernel machine scalability while accurately approximating kernel functions; second, we elucidate the theoretical links between TN-constrained kernel machines and Gaussian processes, providing insights into convergence and generalization; finally, we introduce a novel optimization framework characterizing a specific TN, the multi-linear singular value decomposition (MLSVD), in terms of primal and dual problems.
Large-Eddy Simulations of Helix Active Wake Control
Sensitivity, Robustness and Advanced Actuator Line Modelling
Wind turbines clustered in a wind farm operate on average at a lower efficiency than they would achieve in isolation. One major source of this efficiency loss is wake interaction. As wind turbines extract kinetic energy from the wind, they leave behind a region of low wind speed, the so-called wake. When wakes generated by upstream turbines impinge on downstream turbines in the farm, they reduce their power output and thus the overall farm efficiency. In the design phase, the wind farm layout is optimised to minimise wake losses; however, even in an optimal layout wake losses are significant. From the desire to further mitigate the remaining wake losses, the field of wind farm flow control (WFFC) arose, which aims to reduce wake losses by farm-wide coordinated control of the wind turbines.
Wind farm flow control strategies differ based on their working mechanism, e.g. control strategies aim to either reduce the initial wake deficit of upstream turbines by reducing the turbine thrust or redirecting wakes past downstream turbines by intentionally misaligning upstream turbines with the incoming wind direction. A newer category of strategies for WFFC is active wake control (AWC). Compared to the former quasi-steady strategies, AWC strategies are inherently dynamic as their working mechanism relies on unsteady actuation, which aims to trigger underlying instability modes of the wake flow. One of the most recently developed AWC strategies is helix active wake control. It makes use of the individual pitch control capabilities (IPC) of modern wind turbines in order to intentionally force the first instability mode of the wake.
This thesis is concerned with high-fidelity modelling of helix active wake control using large-eddy simulation (LES) of the atmospheric flow, where the effect of IPC is captured by representing the turbine in the LES by means of the actuator line model (ALM). Judging the potential of helix active wake control requires (i) quantifying the arising power-load trade-off, (ii) comparing it to established WFFC strategies like wake steering, and (iii) ultimately testing it in realistic transient atmospheric boundary layers. To this end, the overall objective of this thesis is to
"Assess the performance of helix active wake control in quasi-steady atmospheric boundary layers and develop actuator line model capabilities for its study in coarse grid real weather large-eddy simulations."
In a first step, the sensitivity of helix active wake control to the amplitude of the pitch actuation is quantified for a full wake overlap scenario. It is found that the activation of the control leads to a trade-off between power gain and additional turbine loading in terms of the incurred damage equivalent loads (DEL). While the power gain monotonically increases for pitch amplitudes between one and six degrees, the same trend is observed for the DELs of the actuated turbine. Hence, the value of activating the control and selecting its pitch amplitude setpoint will need to be determined based on a higher-level metric like the current electricity price.
In a second step, the sensitivity of the power gain achieved with helix active wake control to varying degrees of wake overlap and turbine spacing is compared to wake steering. It is found that wake steering outperforms the helix except for dense spacing combined with full wake overlap. However, when considering a varying wind direction around full wake overlap without an immediate control response, the results suggest that the power gain achieved by the helix control setpoint is more robust.
The previous finding suggests that time-varying wind directions are important for selecting the best control strategy. Hence, in a third step, an actuator line model is implemented into an atmospheric LES code, which allows for driving microscale LES with mesoscale forcing derived from numerical weather prediction models in order to include additional time scales in the problem. The correctness of the ALM implementation is verified with reference to results from four other research LES codes. Additionally, the emphasis is on ensuring accurate thrust and power predictions on coarser LES grids. To this end, the filtered lifting line correction is included in the ALM implementation.
Current corrections for coarse grid ALM-LES, e.g. the filtered lifting line correction, do not consider the complete unsteady problem. Thus, as a last step, we take the IPC actuation underlying helix active wake control as an opportunity to formally investigate unsteadiness in the ALM for scenarios corresponding to unsteady attached flow below stall. By deriving a semi-analytical solution for the two-dimensional "ALM'' its connection to Theodorsen theory is established. Further, this solution allows for determining the optimal kernel width for the unsteady ALM, which is approximately 40% of the chord length and determining bounds of its validity. Importantly, we find that even when using the optimal kernel width, the magnitude of the unsteady force cannot be accurately captured anymore by the ALM if the reduced frequency exceeds k>0.2.
In summary, this thesis contributed to the understanding of under which circumstances the application of helix active wake control for the mitigation of wake effects might be a viable option. Given that the benefits and drawbacks of the helix are at least partially complementary with wake steering control, both control strategies could be seen as pieces of a more comprehensive toolbox of wind farm flow control strategies. The activation of a respective control strategy would then happen only during periods corresponding to its identified favourable conditions. Hence, the model development conducted in the second part of this thesis aims towards building a simulation environment - spanning from mesoscale effects down to airfoil aerodynamics - within which such a selection process of WFFC strategies can be studied in realistic weather conditions. ...
Wind turbines clustered in a wind farm operate on average at a lower efficiency than they would achieve in isolation. One major source of this efficiency loss is wake interaction. As wind turbines extract kinetic energy from the wind, they leave behind a region of low wind speed, the so-called wake. When wakes generated by upstream turbines impinge on downstream turbines in the farm, they reduce their power output and thus the overall farm efficiency. In the design phase, the wind farm layout is optimised to minimise wake losses; however, even in an optimal layout wake losses are significant. From the desire to further mitigate the remaining wake losses, the field of wind farm flow control (WFFC) arose, which aims to reduce wake losses by farm-wide coordinated control of the wind turbines.
Wind farm flow control strategies differ based on their working mechanism, e.g. control strategies aim to either reduce the initial wake deficit of upstream turbines by reducing the turbine thrust or redirecting wakes past downstream turbines by intentionally misaligning upstream turbines with the incoming wind direction. A newer category of strategies for WFFC is active wake control (AWC). Compared to the former quasi-steady strategies, AWC strategies are inherently dynamic as their working mechanism relies on unsteady actuation, which aims to trigger underlying instability modes of the wake flow. One of the most recently developed AWC strategies is helix active wake control. It makes use of the individual pitch control capabilities (IPC) of modern wind turbines in order to intentionally force the first instability mode of the wake.
This thesis is concerned with high-fidelity modelling of helix active wake control using large-eddy simulation (LES) of the atmospheric flow, where the effect of IPC is captured by representing the turbine in the LES by means of the actuator line model (ALM). Judging the potential of helix active wake control requires (i) quantifying the arising power-load trade-off, (ii) comparing it to established WFFC strategies like wake steering, and (iii) ultimately testing it in realistic transient atmospheric boundary layers. To this end, the overall objective of this thesis is to
"Assess the performance of helix active wake control in quasi-steady atmospheric boundary layers and develop actuator line model capabilities for its study in coarse grid real weather large-eddy simulations."
In a first step, the sensitivity of helix active wake control to the amplitude of the pitch actuation is quantified for a full wake overlap scenario. It is found that the activation of the control leads to a trade-off between power gain and additional turbine loading in terms of the incurred damage equivalent loads (DEL). While the power gain monotonically increases for pitch amplitudes between one and six degrees, the same trend is observed for the DELs of the actuated turbine. Hence, the value of activating the control and selecting its pitch amplitude setpoint will need to be determined based on a higher-level metric like the current electricity price.
In a second step, the sensitivity of the power gain achieved with helix active wake control to varying degrees of wake overlap and turbine spacing is compared to wake steering. It is found that wake steering outperforms the helix except for dense spacing combined with full wake overlap. However, when considering a varying wind direction around full wake overlap without an immediate control response, the results suggest that the power gain achieved by the helix control setpoint is more robust.
The previous finding suggests that time-varying wind directions are important for selecting the best control strategy. Hence, in a third step, an actuator line model is implemented into an atmospheric LES code, which allows for driving microscale LES with mesoscale forcing derived from numerical weather prediction models in order to include additional time scales in the problem. The correctness of the ALM implementation is verified with reference to results from four other research LES codes. Additionally, the emphasis is on ensuring accurate thrust and power predictions on coarser LES grids. To this end, the filtered lifting line correction is included in the ALM implementation.
Current corrections for coarse grid ALM-LES, e.g. the filtered lifting line correction, do not consider the complete unsteady problem. Thus, as a last step, we take the IPC actuation underlying helix active wake control as an opportunity to formally investigate unsteadiness in the ALM for scenarios corresponding to unsteady attached flow below stall. By deriving a semi-analytical solution for the two-dimensional "ALM'' its connection to Theodorsen theory is established. Further, this solution allows for determining the optimal kernel width for the unsteady ALM, which is approximately 40% of the chord length and determining bounds of its validity. Importantly, we find that even when using the optimal kernel width, the magnitude of the unsteady force cannot be accurately captured anymore by the ALM if the reduced frequency exceeds k>0.2.
In summary, this thesis contributed to the understanding of under which circumstances the application of helix active wake control for the mitigation of wake effects might be a viable option. Given that the benefits and drawbacks of the helix are at least partially complementary with wake steering control, both control strategies could be seen as pieces of a more comprehensive toolbox of wind farm flow control strategies. The activation of a respective control strategy would then happen only during periods corresponding to its identified favourable conditions. Hence, the model development conducted in the second part of this thesis aims towards building a simulation environment - spanning from mesoscale effects down to airfoil aerodynamics - within which such a selection process of WFFC strategies can be studied in realistic weather conditions.
While probabilistic methods have many benefits, such as recursive estimation and uncertainty quantification, they often come with substantial memory and compute requirements.
Computational challenges are particularly pronounced in large-scale settings, where data sets contain a high number of measurements, and for high-dimensional problems, which require exponentially many parameters to describe probability distributions.
These scenarios can suffer from the curse of dimensionality, which requires exponentially growing computing resources, making conventional approaches computationally intractable.
This dissertation addresses computational challenges by leveraging tensor networks (TNs) to develop computationally efficient probabilistic algorithms.
TNs, also known as tensor decompositions, extend matrix decomposition to higher dimensions by representing large multidimensional arrays, i.e., tensors, in a compact, decomposed format, defined by TN components and TN ranks.
Under the assumption of low-rank structure, TNs enable efficient storage and computation, making large-scale and high-dimensional problems more tractable, even on resource-constrained hardware such as conventional laptops.
The focus of this work is on scalable solutions for Bayesian estimation problems involving Gaussian distributions and exact inference, including recursive filtering and Gaussian process (GP) regression. ...
While probabilistic methods have many benefits, such as recursive estimation and uncertainty quantification, they often come with substantial memory and compute requirements.
Computational challenges are particularly pronounced in large-scale settings, where data sets contain a high number of measurements, and for high-dimensional problems, which require exponentially many parameters to describe probability distributions.
These scenarios can suffer from the curse of dimensionality, which requires exponentially growing computing resources, making conventional approaches computationally intractable.
This dissertation addresses computational challenges by leveraging tensor networks (TNs) to develop computationally efficient probabilistic algorithms.
TNs, also known as tensor decompositions, extend matrix decomposition to higher dimensions by representing large multidimensional arrays, i.e., tensors, in a compact, decomposed format, defined by TN components and TN ranks.
Under the assumption of low-rank structure, TNs enable efficient storage and computation, making large-scale and high-dimensional problems more tractable, even on resource-constrained hardware such as conventional laptops.
The focus of this work is on scalable solutions for Bayesian estimation problems involving Gaussian distributions and exact inference, including recursive filtering and Gaussian process (GP) regression.
There are several reasons why a wind turbine may not generate its maximum capacity, one of them being its placement. Turbines are often placed in farms, which allows the collective use of infrastructure and minimizes land usage. The downside is that the turbines influence one another: As a turbine extracts energy from the wind, an area with lowered wind speed develops downstream. This area is called wake, and other turbines affected by it will generate less energy.
The ways to address this problem can be split into pre- and post-construction measures. Pre-construction the wind farm layout can be optimized, and post-construction control strategies are needed to operate the wind farm optimally. These strategies fall under the term wind farm flow control and aim to manipulate the flow between the turbines to optimize the farm performance. A turbine’s wake can be altered by changing the turbine’s resistance to the flow or by misaligning the turbine with the wind direction. The former leads to a faster wake recovery, and the latter results in a redirection of the wake, also called wake-steering.
The current state-of-the-art of wind farm flow control is to utilize wake-steering in an open-loop control configuration. To this end, steady-state engineering models of the wake are used to optimize the farm set points offline. This is done for a selection of atmospheric conditions and the set points are stored in a lookup table (LuT). During operation, the flow conditions are used to look up the precomputed turbine set points. A problem with this approach arises as open-loop control assumes a perfect match between the model and the actual conditions in the field. There are reasons why this might not be the case: (i) There is an inevitable modeling error, which creates a mismatch between the model and the reality; (ii) conditions can arise that are offline not accounted for, e.g., time-varying atmospheric conditions or layout changes due to turbine downtime.
These problems can be addressed by closing the loop. In closed-loop control, measurements are used to continuously correct the model and to adapt it to the current state of the true wind farm. Optimal set points are then found based on the current model state. The control strategy can, therefore, react to new conditions. A challenge is that the optimization needs to happen online and requires a way to incorporate sensor data into the model. Previous work has designed closed-loop approaches using the same computationally cheap steady-state models that were previously used for open-loop control. This was achieved by adapting the parameters of the model based on the mismatch between the observed and predicted measurements, like power generated. A core assumption these models make is that the flow is in a never changing steady state. However, flow conditions do change, and the large spacing between turbines leads to minutes of delay between the control action the upstream turbine takes and the effect that the downstream turbine experiences. The question arises: What could be achieved using dynamic wake models instead of steady-state ones? These can incorporate wake dynamics, which could lead to better decision-making.
This thesis designs a closed-loop model-predictive wind farm flow control strategy based on a dynamic wake model to maximize the energy generated by a wind farm under time-varying conditions. The thesis is comprised of three building blocks: (i) The development of a dynamic wake model, (ii) the derivation of a sensor fusion strategy to identify the state of the flow field, (iii) the composition of a control strategy that uses the model to optimize the control set points. The building blocks are then connected to form the closed-loop control strategy.
The model building is based on the further development of an existing model, which utilizes a steady-state wake model and reintroduces flow dynamics. In the first step, the underlying wake model is substituted by a three-dimensional one, and the formulation is adapted to heterogeneous flow conditions. In the second step, the model is reformulated as a framework that links to an arbitrary wake model. This is done to profit from advancements in the steady-state model development and to significantly decrease the computational cost of the model. In the third step, the dynamic model is compared to a steady-state one in a set of high-fidelity wind farm simulations under time-varying conditions based on field measurements. The results show that the dynamic model does provide a better match with a simulated wind farm.
In the second part of the thesis, a state estimation methodology is introduced. To this end, an ensemble approach is adopted, where the multiple versions of the model are simulated in parallel. The correlation between the ensembles is then used to correct them based on the predicted and measured wind direction and power measurements of the turbines. A byproduct of the ensemble approach is that each estimated state also has an uncertainty based on how much the ensembles agree on its value.
The third part of this thesis investigates the control and optimization problem. This part focuses on the cost function formulation and the behavior it leads to. In a steady-state frame, the delays do not have to be taken into account, but in a dynamic formulation, they become a challenge. We, therefore, propose a cost-function formulation that synchronizes the control actions with their effect at the downstream turbines. This leads to a series of smaller optimization problems instead of one larger one.
The three building blocks of this thesis are then tested in a case study: The closed-loop controller is employed to maximize the energy of a ten-turbine wind farm under time-varying conditions. Both the farm layout and wind direction time series are based on field conditions. The controller generates an overall energy gain of up to 4% over the baseline using noise-free wind direction measurements.
This is on par with the steady-state approach. However, the closed-loop approach is found to be more robust to disturbed wind direction measurements - Where the performance of the steady-state approach decreases to 1.7% due to the sensor noise; the closed-loop approach still achieves a 2.5% gain.
The conclusion of the work presented in this thesis is thereby: Closed-loop wind farm flow control based on a dynamic engineering surrogate model leads to a more accurate and robust state estimation of the wind farm flow field but, given no preview, does not necessarily lead to a higher energy generation than what can be achieved with steady-state models. ...
There are several reasons why a wind turbine may not generate its maximum capacity, one of them being its placement. Turbines are often placed in farms, which allows the collective use of infrastructure and minimizes land usage. The downside is that the turbines influence one another: As a turbine extracts energy from the wind, an area with lowered wind speed develops downstream. This area is called wake, and other turbines affected by it will generate less energy.
The ways to address this problem can be split into pre- and post-construction measures. Pre-construction the wind farm layout can be optimized, and post-construction control strategies are needed to operate the wind farm optimally. These strategies fall under the term wind farm flow control and aim to manipulate the flow between the turbines to optimize the farm performance. A turbine’s wake can be altered by changing the turbine’s resistance to the flow or by misaligning the turbine with the wind direction. The former leads to a faster wake recovery, and the latter results in a redirection of the wake, also called wake-steering.
The current state-of-the-art of wind farm flow control is to utilize wake-steering in an open-loop control configuration. To this end, steady-state engineering models of the wake are used to optimize the farm set points offline. This is done for a selection of atmospheric conditions and the set points are stored in a lookup table (LuT). During operation, the flow conditions are used to look up the precomputed turbine set points. A problem with this approach arises as open-loop control assumes a perfect match between the model and the actual conditions in the field. There are reasons why this might not be the case: (i) There is an inevitable modeling error, which creates a mismatch between the model and the reality; (ii) conditions can arise that are offline not accounted for, e.g., time-varying atmospheric conditions or layout changes due to turbine downtime.
These problems can be addressed by closing the loop. In closed-loop control, measurements are used to continuously correct the model and to adapt it to the current state of the true wind farm. Optimal set points are then found based on the current model state. The control strategy can, therefore, react to new conditions. A challenge is that the optimization needs to happen online and requires a way to incorporate sensor data into the model. Previous work has designed closed-loop approaches using the same computationally cheap steady-state models that were previously used for open-loop control. This was achieved by adapting the parameters of the model based on the mismatch between the observed and predicted measurements, like power generated. A core assumption these models make is that the flow is in a never changing steady state. However, flow conditions do change, and the large spacing between turbines leads to minutes of delay between the control action the upstream turbine takes and the effect that the downstream turbine experiences. The question arises: What could be achieved using dynamic wake models instead of steady-state ones? These can incorporate wake dynamics, which could lead to better decision-making.
This thesis designs a closed-loop model-predictive wind farm flow control strategy based on a dynamic wake model to maximize the energy generated by a wind farm under time-varying conditions. The thesis is comprised of three building blocks: (i) The development of a dynamic wake model, (ii) the derivation of a sensor fusion strategy to identify the state of the flow field, (iii) the composition of a control strategy that uses the model to optimize the control set points. The building blocks are then connected to form the closed-loop control strategy.
The model building is based on the further development of an existing model, which utilizes a steady-state wake model and reintroduces flow dynamics. In the first step, the underlying wake model is substituted by a three-dimensional one, and the formulation is adapted to heterogeneous flow conditions. In the second step, the model is reformulated as a framework that links to an arbitrary wake model. This is done to profit from advancements in the steady-state model development and to significantly decrease the computational cost of the model. In the third step, the dynamic model is compared to a steady-state one in a set of high-fidelity wind farm simulations under time-varying conditions based on field measurements. The results show that the dynamic model does provide a better match with a simulated wind farm.
In the second part of the thesis, a state estimation methodology is introduced. To this end, an ensemble approach is adopted, where the multiple versions of the model are simulated in parallel. The correlation between the ensembles is then used to correct them based on the predicted and measured wind direction and power measurements of the turbines. A byproduct of the ensemble approach is that each estimated state also has an uncertainty based on how much the ensembles agree on its value.
The third part of this thesis investigates the control and optimization problem. This part focuses on the cost function formulation and the behavior it leads to. In a steady-state frame, the delays do not have to be taken into account, but in a dynamic formulation, they become a challenge. We, therefore, propose a cost-function formulation that synchronizes the control actions with their effect at the downstream turbines. This leads to a series of smaller optimization problems instead of one larger one.
The three building blocks of this thesis are then tested in a case study: The closed-loop controller is employed to maximize the energy of a ten-turbine wind farm under time-varying conditions. Both the farm layout and wind direction time series are based on field conditions. The controller generates an overall energy gain of up to 4% over the baseline using noise-free wind direction measurements.
This is on par with the steady-state approach. However, the closed-loop approach is found to be more robust to disturbed wind direction measurements - Where the performance of the steady-state approach decreases to 1.7% due to the sensor noise; the closed-loop approach still achieves a 2.5% gain.
The conclusion of the work presented in this thesis is thereby: Closed-loop wind farm flow control based on a dynamic engineering surrogate model leads to a more accurate and robust state estimation of the wind farm flow field but, given no preview, does not necessarily lead to a higher energy generation than what can be achieved with steady-state models.
Wind farm control strategies can be implemented to mitigate these wake effects and optimize wind farm power generation. In scenarios requiring on-demand response, such as those explored in this thesis, wind turbines are leveraged to provide flexibility, constrained by their maximum power availability. The power delivery of wind power plants upon request is facilitated by a closed-loop wind farm controller, providing active power control at fast timescales. Active power control involves adjusting the resource's active power to assist power grid operators in balancing energy supply and demand, thereby improving energy security.
Our proposed closed-loop control solution provides superior response capabilities by
compensating for reduced power availability, ultimately enhancing the reliability of on-demand power generation.
The wind variability across turbines, intensified by wake effects, contributes not only to attaining fluctuations in power generation but also to fluctuations in structural loads on the turbines. Amplified by wake-induced turbulence, this structural load variability across turbines leads to uneven degradation of turbine components over the long term. In offshore scenarios, where accessibility is limited and maintenance operations must be minimized due to higher costs compared to onshore counterparts, controlling turbines to prolong their lifetime is of significant interest. In this thesis, this aspect is addressed at both the wind farm and wind turbine levels.
At the farm level, we propose that farms fulfilling grid energy demands must also balance the aerodynamic forces of their turbines to evenly distribute structural degradation among them.
This can be achieved without compromising the power generation when the turbines operate below their maximum energy extraction capacity. We have demonstrated that by implementing a real-time feedback loop, it is feasible to balance aerodynamic loads while meeting wind farm energy demands, albeit limited by wind availability. Moreover, we have demonstrated that balancing aerodynamic forces is advantageous for active power control in a wind farm affected by wake effects, compared to simply distributing power requests uniformly.
At the wind turbine level, we introduced two wind turbine controllers designed to individually restrict real-time aerodynamic loads as a surrogate of structural loads in turbine components. These controllers are referred to as load-limiting controllers. The first load-limiting controller employs an optimal control approach. The operator can impose structural load constraints, using a convex model predictive control for power tracking. The second controller, which is more practical, utilizes a switching mechanism with integral control that allows the operator to prioritize a structural load setpoint over a power demand setpoint. This prioritization aims to reinforce structural safety in situations where turbines are compromised from their design conditions. This could be a consequence of numerous factors, such as unpredictable degradation, installation issues, vessel collisions, and others.
As wind turbines prove to be a viable, reliable, and eco-friendly energy source, new wind farm projects are becoming more ambitious, incorporating a larger number of turbines than ever before. Additionally, there is a substantial growth in wind turbine installations within existing wind farms. This growth in the number of turbines poses an implementation challenge for wind farm control systems. Similar challenges have been encountered in controlling other large-scale systems with collective goals, where agents must instead make decisions based on partial information due to communication limitations in processing or transmission.
Anticipating this implementation challenge, we transition from a centralized to a distributed wind farm control solution. Taking advantage of the time scale inherent in typical wind farm controller implementations, we exchange information with neighboring turbines rather than a central workstation. Our aim, in particular, is not to gather partial information but to achieve consensus across the entire farm. However, our control methodology has a negative implication - the addition of delays - which is carefully examined by the derived stability condition for the design and is assessed through simulations. Notwithstanding these delays, the proposed solution is fully distributed and has been demonstrated to be both simple and effective, facilitating the application of our control solutions in large-scale wind farms.
Lastly, we validate our wind farm control solutions through experiments conducted with scaled wind turbines in full-wake conditions. In this way, we verify the benefits of our control solutions not only through high-fidelity simulations but also through real-world experimentation.
The work presented in this thesis emphasizes the importance of wind turbine controllers capable of offering demanded power to the grid while enhancing reliability in power delivery and addressing structural and maintenance concerns. We introduce closed-loop wind farm controllers designed to handle these challenges. Furthermore, we expand the implementation through a distributed approach on one front, while on the other front, we validate the solutions by means of experiments. The findings from this research contribute to the efficient operation of future wind farms by employing feedback control strategies across clusters of wind turbines. ...
Wind farm control strategies can be implemented to mitigate these wake effects and optimize wind farm power generation. In scenarios requiring on-demand response, such as those explored in this thesis, wind turbines are leveraged to provide flexibility, constrained by their maximum power availability. The power delivery of wind power plants upon request is facilitated by a closed-loop wind farm controller, providing active power control at fast timescales. Active power control involves adjusting the resource's active power to assist power grid operators in balancing energy supply and demand, thereby improving energy security.
Our proposed closed-loop control solution provides superior response capabilities by
compensating for reduced power availability, ultimately enhancing the reliability of on-demand power generation.
The wind variability across turbines, intensified by wake effects, contributes not only to attaining fluctuations in power generation but also to fluctuations in structural loads on the turbines. Amplified by wake-induced turbulence, this structural load variability across turbines leads to uneven degradation of turbine components over the long term. In offshore scenarios, where accessibility is limited and maintenance operations must be minimized due to higher costs compared to onshore counterparts, controlling turbines to prolong their lifetime is of significant interest. In this thesis, this aspect is addressed at both the wind farm and wind turbine levels.
At the farm level, we propose that farms fulfilling grid energy demands must also balance the aerodynamic forces of their turbines to evenly distribute structural degradation among them.
This can be achieved without compromising the power generation when the turbines operate below their maximum energy extraction capacity. We have demonstrated that by implementing a real-time feedback loop, it is feasible to balance aerodynamic loads while meeting wind farm energy demands, albeit limited by wind availability. Moreover, we have demonstrated that balancing aerodynamic forces is advantageous for active power control in a wind farm affected by wake effects, compared to simply distributing power requests uniformly.
At the wind turbine level, we introduced two wind turbine controllers designed to individually restrict real-time aerodynamic loads as a surrogate of structural loads in turbine components. These controllers are referred to as load-limiting controllers. The first load-limiting controller employs an optimal control approach. The operator can impose structural load constraints, using a convex model predictive control for power tracking. The second controller, which is more practical, utilizes a switching mechanism with integral control that allows the operator to prioritize a structural load setpoint over a power demand setpoint. This prioritization aims to reinforce structural safety in situations where turbines are compromised from their design conditions. This could be a consequence of numerous factors, such as unpredictable degradation, installation issues, vessel collisions, and others.
As wind turbines prove to be a viable, reliable, and eco-friendly energy source, new wind farm projects are becoming more ambitious, incorporating a larger number of turbines than ever before. Additionally, there is a substantial growth in wind turbine installations within existing wind farms. This growth in the number of turbines poses an implementation challenge for wind farm control systems. Similar challenges have been encountered in controlling other large-scale systems with collective goals, where agents must instead make decisions based on partial information due to communication limitations in processing or transmission.
Anticipating this implementation challenge, we transition from a centralized to a distributed wind farm control solution. Taking advantage of the time scale inherent in typical wind farm controller implementations, we exchange information with neighboring turbines rather than a central workstation. Our aim, in particular, is not to gather partial information but to achieve consensus across the entire farm. However, our control methodology has a negative implication - the addition of delays - which is carefully examined by the derived stability condition for the design and is assessed through simulations. Notwithstanding these delays, the proposed solution is fully distributed and has been demonstrated to be both simple and effective, facilitating the application of our control solutions in large-scale wind farms.
Lastly, we validate our wind farm control solutions through experiments conducted with scaled wind turbines in full-wake conditions. In this way, we verify the benefits of our control solutions not only through high-fidelity simulations but also through real-world experimentation.
The work presented in this thesis emphasizes the importance of wind turbine controllers capable of offering demanded power to the grid while enhancing reliability in power delivery and addressing structural and maintenance concerns. We introduce closed-loop wind farm controllers designed to handle these challenges. Furthermore, we expand the implementation through a distributed approach on one front, while on the other front, we validate the solutions by means of experiments. The findings from this research contribute to the efficient operation of future wind farms by employing feedback control strategies across clusters of wind turbines.