Pumped Hydro Energy Storage (PHS) provides over 90% of the global long-duration energy storage capacity, yet many regions lack the steep terrain required for conventional high-head PHS. Low-head pumped hydro energy storage (LH PHS) systems address this gap in flat topographic regions but requires efficient pump-turbine technology for operation at variable low heads. This study investigates the use of a variable-speed contra-rotating pump-turbine (CR RPT) for LH PHS applications, presenting experimental results from a model-scale test rig stablished at Technische Universität Braunschweig. This test rig uses two open water surface tanks to provide head, unlike conventional hydraulic test rigs that use pumps. The CR RPT achieved hydraulic efficiencies over 80% for a wide range of operating conditions, peaking at 86.1% and 88.4% for pump and turbine modes, respectively. Additionally, dimensionless analysis revealed that the CR-RPT occupies a unique place in the market and that it achieves the largest power density among comparable hydraulic machines, facilitating greater power output and thus streamlining mechanical and civil engineering requirements for LH PHS.

With the rising need for flexible energy storage, recent research shows the potential of contra-rotating reversible pump–turbines (CR RPT) to enable low-head pumped hydropower storage. This study presents a dual variable-speed control architecture for CR RPTs, aimed at providing grid frequency control. The proposed control maximizes the efficiency and shapes the power response to minimize the rise time while averting excessive fluctuations. The control architecture is experimentally validated on a 45 kW reduced-scale CR RPT. The results show that for full reserve activation in frequency containment reserve (FCR), the rise times are <3.92s in turbine mode and <0.23s in pump mode. When scaled to a 10 MW system, with a factor of 1.53 to 2.46, the rise times remain well below the regulatory limit of 30 s. Furthermore, the power response stays within the allowed limits, with root mean square deviations of <58% in turbine mode and <39% in pump mode, relative to the allowed limits. Additionally, the system effectively tracks the varying power setpoints in an actual FCR use case. These findings demonstrate that the proposed control methodology can successfully provide frequency control by dynamically varying the power within imposed power constraints.

Low-head pumped hydro storage technology has been identified as a promising contributor to grid-scale energy storage and the provision of ancillary services. Low-head systems have differing characteristics compared to conventional high-head systems, including larger relative head ranges and increased inertias of both, the water column and the pump–turbines. These differences require new designs as well as a detailed evaluation of their steady-state performance and transient behaviour. For this purpose, an experimental 50kW setup incorporating a 1:22 scale version of a novel reversible pump–turbine, with two contra-rotating runners and independent drivetrains, is designed and constructed. Steady-state performance tests are conducted in turbine and pump modes for several speed ratios between runners. Using head and torque coefficients, the results are compared to a numerical pump–turbine model based on a range of computational fluid dynamics simulations. Additionally, the transient response for a change of operating points is tested and used to benchmark a 1-D numerical model covering dynamic effects including coupling between the conduit and drivetrains. The developed numerical model is then used to simulate the transient behaviour during a shutdown sequence in turbine mode. During the steady-state tests a maximum efficiency of 89% was measured in turbine mode and 92% in pump mode. The test results show that the steady-state RPT characterisation accurately predicts the RPT performance, particularly in turbine mode, with correlation coefficient values between 0.9–0.97. The comparison of the pump mode results shows a minor offset and difference in the correlation between experimental and numerical results. Similarly, the comparison of the transient test case shows a good agreement between the experimental and the simulated dynamic response of the flow rate and rotational speeds. The results have shown the capability of the numerical modelling approach to provide accurate results for steady-state and dynamic performance evaluations. Finally, the simulation of the shutdown sequence indicates that there is no risk of dangerous pressure transients during the desired deceleration of the runners and concurrent closure of the valve.

Large-scale energy storage solutions are crucial to ensure grid stability and reliability in the ongoing energy transition towards a low-carbon, renewable energy based electricity supply. This article presents the evaluation of a novel low-head pumped hydro storage system designed for coastal environments and shallow seas. The proposed system addresses some of the challenges of low-head pumped hydro storage including the need for larger flow rates and reservoirs as well as the requirement of machinery with high efficiencies across a wide operating range to accommodate larger changes in gross head during storage cycles. It includes several units of contra-rotating reversible pump-turbines connected to axial-flux motor generators within a ring dike, as well as dedicated machine- and grid-side control. The technology allows for independent control of each runner, making it possible to adapt to the specific operating conditions of low-head systems. In this work, a numerical approach is used to simulate the system's performance and dynamic behaviour under various operational conditions, including energy generation, storage, and grid support of a 1 GW system with 4 GWh of storage capacity. The potential system performance for energy balancing cycles is evaluated, and a sensitivity analysis is conducted to assess the influence of scaling the motor-generators on performance and footprint of the plant. Additionally, the capability and limitations of the system to respond to grid demand fluctuations and provide frequency regulation services are assessed. The results demonstrate that the low-head pumped hydro storage system is a viable large-scale energy storage solution, capable of round-trip efficiencies above 70% across a wide operating range. By increasing the maximum power of the electric machines, the maximum head range of the whole system is increased which correlates with a threefold increase in energy density per unit area. The dynamic simulations further show that the system can rapidly change its power output allowing it to provide frequency regulation services. Allocating 20% of its nominal power as a reserve, the new power setpoints can be reached within a maximum of 5 s independent of its initial state of charge.

Recently, contra-rotating reversible pump-turbines (CR RPTs) have been proposed to increase the efficiency of low-head pumped hydropower storage applications, which are promising to provide energy storage for non-mountainous regions. To study the control architectures for these systems, a dual-rotor hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) emulator test-setup is developed. The HIL test-setup employs two induction machines controlled by separate regenerative variable frequency drives to emulate the torques on the two runners. A quasi-steady-state RPT model is developed based on 380 steady-state computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations and compared to three transient CFD simulations to analyse the dynamics. Furthermore, the runner torques are adapted to account for the lower friction and higher inertia of the HIL test-setup compared to the prototype CR RPT, ensuring accurate emulation. Finally, it is shown how precise calibration of the drive torque response averts torque errors related to the machine model estimator used in direct torque control. The developed emulator setup offers a cost-effective and controlled environment to optimise and validate control architectures for the novel CR RPT, providing a higher fidelity than theoretical simulation by including the physical effects of the drivetrain, electrical machines and converters that are not entirely captured in mathematical models.

In an effort to make pumped hydropower storage (PHS) technology feasible for regions with a flat topography, recent research shows promising results using a contra-rotating reversible pump-turbine at low-head. In this study, the impact of dual variable speed and inlet valve control is analyzed to evaluate the effect of these three degrees of freedom (DOFs) on the system efficiency and operating range. To this end, analytical models are described to assess pump-turbine performance, conduit losses and electromechanical losses. Methodologically, optimal efficiency maps are computed for every combination of the three DOFs to evaluate individual and combined effects on the overall efficiency. Furthermore, three energy storage cycles are analyzed to further study the performance in realistic use-cases. Key conclusions include an increase in round-trip efficiency by combining variable speed ratio and inlet valve control of 5.6% and 2.0% compared with only variable speed ratio control and variable inlet valve control, respectively. Furthermore, it is shown that using only 1 DOF significantly limits the operating range, with the addition of a variable inlet valve granting a higher impact than a variable speed ratio. Combining inlet valve and speed ratio control leads not only to the highest efficiency, but also the largest operating range, with a maximum round-trip efficiency of 67.5% and an energy storage capacity of 58.6 Wh/m ². The results confirm that exploiting both dual variable speed operation and inlet valve control yields the maximum efficiency and operating range, and is thus the preferred topology for contra-rotating reversible pump-turbines in low-head operation.

Subsea buoyancy gravity energy storage systems (SBGESS) could take advantage of large water depth to store energy in the form of potential energy. In the proposed system, drum hoists mounted on a semisubmerged support structure simultaneously lift concrete cylinders with hundreds of tonnes and lower floaters with equivalent buoyancy force, which can be released with high round trip efficiencies by inverting the motor operation. The present study addresses the potential effect of the vortex-induced vibration (VIV) produced by current velocities on the behaviour of the energy storage modules. In order to analyse the system response, a state-of-the-art VIV model was integrated with a spherical pendulum and tuned with experimental results from the literature. The numerical model allows estimating amplitudes and frequencies of oscillation for a single module in both in-line and cross-flow directions. Results are used to assess the risk between modules of collisions on a previously designed SBGESS.

To provide large-scale energy balancing and ancillary services to grids experiencing rapidly increasing shares of inverter coupled renewable generators, the ALPHEUS project proposes a novel low-head pumped storage system. Aimed at regions where traditional high-head pumped storage systems are not feasible due to topographic constraints, the system consists of a newly designed reversible pump-turbine (RPT), axial-flux motor-generators and a dedicated control and grid coupling. The main aims of ALPHEUS include increased round-trip efficiencies, reduced switching times between pump and turbine mode as well as faster power ramp rates. These directly aid its capability to contribute to grid stability. Aiming to validate simulation results investigating the hydrodynamic performance of the two novel contra-rotating runners making up the RPT as well as the axial-flux motor-generators, an experimental series is planned as part of ALPHEUS. For this, a scaled down version of the RPTs and motor-generators are assembled and connected to two open tanks serving as the upper and lower reservoir. Before the experiments are conducted, preparatory tests are performed to characterise Coulomb and viscous friction in the drivetrain, hydraulic losses in the conduit and other system components. This paper introduces the proposed low-head pumped storage system before presenting the developed experimental setup, approach and the aforementioned characterisation tests.

The increasing development of floating wind turbines has paved the way for exploiting offshore wind resources at locations with greater depth and energy potential. The study presents a novel Subsea Buoyancy Gravity Energy Storage System (SBGESS) that combines buoyancy energy storage and gravity energy storage technologies to overcome the intermittent nature of wind energy. The proposed system is assessed for time-shifting power delivery applications in two Brazilian offshore wind farm sites with varying wind conditions and water depths. The performance of the SBGESS is evaluated by considering different numbers of units, water depths, and control strategies. The results demonstrate that the SBGESS can effectively enhance offshore wind farms’ capacity factor and power output during peak times, particularly in regions with lower wind potential and higher profundity.

The integration of seawater desalination and wind energy technologies has allowed for the development of a directly wind-driven desalination system, with the potential to address freshwater scarcity issues without contributing to CO2 emissions. The system described in this manuscript consists of a wind turbine rotor, which employs a hydraulic transmission to directly pressurise seawater into a reverse osmosis desalination plant and a Pelton turbine generator. After building and commissioning of a 44 m hydraulic wind turbine prototype in the port of Rotterdam in the Netherlands, an experimental campaign was conducted to evaluate the operational range and performance of the hydraulic system. A combination of hardware-in-the-loop tests where used to get insight into the behaviour of the integrated system. The control philosophies used for automatic operation and safety of the system are compared and discussed, as well as the system's behaviour in response to different wind conditions using dummy elements to replace the desalination module. Technical challenges and achievements of commissioning and testing the system are also described, along with lessons learned.

To tackle the growing demand for grid-scale energy storage, the ALPHEUS project proposes a novel low-head pumped hydro storage system aimed for coastal application in countries where the topography does not allow for traditional high-head storage. This system consists of a reversible pump-turbine technology with two contra-rotating runners coupled to their respective axial-flux motor-generators as well as a dedicated control, optimising for energy balancing and the provision of ancillary services. To better understand the integration and dynamic interaction of the individual components of the plant and to allow for the simulation of a wide variety of operating conditions and scenarios, this research aims at developing a system model coupling the hydraulic, mechanical and electrical components. Numerical results are compared and verified based on CFD simulations. While some inaccuracies have to be expected, the comparison shows an overall good match with only minor deviations in dynamic behaviour and steady state results.

Wave-to-Wire models play an important role in the development of wave energy converters. They could provide insight into the complete operating process of wave energy converters, from the power absorption stage to the power conversion stage. In order to cover a set of relevant nonlinear effects, wave-to-wire models are predominately established in the time domain. However, the low computational efficiency of time-domain modeling is hindering the extensive application of wave-to-wire models, especially in early-stage design and optimization where a large number of iterations are required. To address this issue, a spectral-domain wave-to-wire model is proposed, and the nonlinear effects are incorporated by stochastic linearization. This model can significantly reduce the computational load and maintain good accuracy. The reference concept studied in this paper is defined as a heaving point absorber coupled with a linear permanent-magnet generator. Four representative nonlinear effects involved in both the hydrodynamic stage and the electrical stage of the concept are considered. The proposed model is verified against a corresponding nonlinear time-domain wave-to-wire model, and a good agreement is observed. The relative error of the proposed spectral-domain wave-to-wire model is around 2 % in typical operational regions and is still within 7 % for wave states with large significant wave heights, regarding the estimate of the power conversion efficiency. Meanwhile, the computational load of the spectral-domain wave-to-wire model is reduced by 2 to 3 orders of magnitudes compared with the conventional time-domain approach. Finally, a case study of tuning the PTO damping to maximize power production is conducted to demonstrate the performance of the proposed spectral-domain wave-to-wire model.

An adjustable draft point absorber was recently proposed as a novel approach to improve power absorption with constrained power take-off (PTO) capacities. The key feature of the novel wave energy converter (WEC) concept is to adjust the buoy draft by regulating the ballast water inside the buoy, which aims to enable variation of the natural frequency of the WEC. Although previous research has shown benefits for the energy absorption stage, the impact of the draft adjustment on the power conversion efficiency and overall performance has not been examined yet. Therefore, a wave-to-wire model is established to provide an in-depth insight into the systematic performance of the adjustable draft point absorber integrated with a linear permanent magnet generator. Both a nonlinear hydrodynamic model and an analytical generator model are derived, thus the complete process from the wave power input through the whole WEC system to the usable electricity is covered. Based on the established model, wave-to-wire responses of the novel concept are obtained and analyzed. The negative effects of the draft adjustment on the stroke and overlap between the stator and translator are demonstrated. Moreover, a comparison is made between this novel WEC and conventional fixed draft WEC, and both regular and irregular wave states are considered. The results show that the adjustable draft system could increase not only the absorbed power but also the generator conversion efficiency. In specific conditions, the delivered electrical power of the adjustable draft WEC was over 20 % and 10 % higher than a traditional fixed draft system for regular and irregular waves respectively.

Underwater noise from offshore pile driving has raised significant concerns over its ecological impact on marine life. To protect the marine environment and maintain the sustainable development of wind energy, strict governmental regulations are imposed. Assessment and mitigation of underwater noise are usually required to ensure that sound levels stay within the noise thresholds. The air-bubble curtain system is one of the most widely applied noise mitigation techniques. This paper presents a multi-physics approach for modeling an air-bubble curtain system in application to offshore pile driving. The complete model consists of four modules: (i) a compressible flow model to account for the transport of compressed air from the offshore vessel to the perforated hose located in the seabed; (ii) a hydrodynamic model for capturing the characteristics of bubble clouds in varying development phases through depth; (iii) an acoustic model for predicting the sound insertion loss of the air-bubble curtain; and (iv) a vibroacoustic model for the prediction of underwater noise from pile driving which is coupled to the acoustic model in (iii) through a boundary integral formulation. The waterborne and soilborne noise transmission paths are examined separately, allowing us to explore the amount of energy channeled through the seabed and through the bubble curtain in the water column. A parametric study is performed to examine the optimal configuration of the double bubble curtain system for various soil conditions and pile configurations. Model predictions are compared with measured data. The model allows for a large number of simulations to examine different configurations of a single bubble curtain and a double big bubble curtain

To counteract a potential reduction in grid stability caused by a rapidly growing share of intermittent renewable energy sources within our electrical grids, large scale deployment of energy storage will become indispensable. Pumped hydro storage is widely regarded as the most cost-effective option for this. However, its application is traditionally limited to certain topographic features. Expanding its operating range to low-head scenarios could unlock the potential of widespread deployment in regions where so far it has not yet been feasible. This review aims at giving a multi-disciplinary insight on technologies that are applicable for low-head (2-30 m) pumped hydro storage, in terms of design, grid integration, control, and modelling. A general overview and the historical development of pumped hydro storage are presented and trends for further innovation and a shift towards application in low-head scenarios are identified. Key drivers for future deployment and the technological and economic challenges to do so are discussed. Based on these challenges, technologies in the field of pumped hydro storage are reviewed and specifically analysed regarding their fitness for low-head application. This is done for pump and turbine design and configuration, electric machines and control, as well as modelling. Further aspects regarding grid integration are discussed. Among conventional machines, it is found that, for high-flow low-head application, axial flow pump-turbines with variable speed drives are the most suitable. Machines such as Archimedes screws, counter-rotating and rotary positive displacement reversible pump-turbines have potential to emerge as innovative solutions. Coupled axial flux permanent magnet synchronous motor-generators are the most promising electric machines. To ensure grid stability, grid-forming control alongside bulk energy storage with capabilities of providing synthetic inertia next to other ancillary services are required.

Under real sea conditions, floating vertical-Axis tidal current turbines experience motions in six degrees of freedom which impact the hydrodynamic performance. In this paper, a 2D freewake vortex panel method (U2DiVA) is adopted as a time effective tool to assess the hydrodynamic response of an existing floating vertical-Axis tidal turbine under platform s surge motion in uniform tidal current. The results of the numerical simulations show that the surge motion modifies the flow field perceived at the blades, affecting the instantaneous value of the tip speed ratio and the time evolution of the induction field. Consequently, surge motion impacts on the structural strength of the turbine by introducing multiple frequencies of oscillation of the hydrodynamic coefficients and increasing the peak loading on the rotor. Surge motion is found to be beneficial to the average power extraction while only marginally affecting the mean loading. The preliminary findings of this research provide insights about critical aspects for the design and evaluation of floating vertical-Axis tidal turbine systems.

A spectral domain model is established to analyze the performance of a recently proposed wave energy concept, namely the adjustable draft point absorber. The non-linear hydrostatic force is incorporated in the spectral domain model. To improve the accuracy of the proposed model, the incident wave elevation is considered in the statistic linearization of the non-linear term. The proposed model is verified by the results obtained by the non-linear time domain simulations. The results suggest that the proposed spectral domain model could include the non-linear hydrostatic force while maintaining a higher computational efficiency than the non-linear time domain model. Based on the proposed model, the power performance of the adjustable draft WEC is identified. Furthermore, a techno-economic analysis is performed to reveal the benefits of the adjustable draft WEC for a given European sea site. The results show that the adjustable draft WEC is associated with higher power absorption in powerful sea states compared with the conventional fixed draft WEC. In addition, the adjustable draft system could contribute to the improvement of the annual energy production as well as the reduction of the levelized cost of energy of WECs.

A crucial part of wave energy converters (WECs) is the power take-off (PTO) mechanism, and PTO sizing has been shown to have a considerable impact on the levelized cost of energy (LCOE). However, as a dominating type of PTO system in WECs, previous research pertinent to PTO sizing did not take modeling and optimization of the linear permanent magnet (PM) generator into consideration. To fill this gap, this paper provides an insight into how PTO sizing affects the performance of linear permanent magnet (PM) generators, and further the techno-economic performance of WECs. To thoroughly reveal the power production of the WEC, both hydrodynamic modeling and generator modeling are incorporated. In addition, three different methods for sizing the linear generator are applied and compared. The effect of the selection of the sizing method on the techno-economic performance of the WEC is identified. Furthermore, to realistically reflect the relevance of PTO sizing, wave resources from three European sea sites are considered in the techno-economic analysis. The dependence of PTO sizing on wave resources is demonstrated.

Mexico is an attractive candidate for offshore wind energy development due to its geographical location with extensive coasts in the Pacific Ocean and Mexico's Gulf. Although potential offshore wind areas have been geographically assessed, an evaluation of the seasonal variations of the capacity factors has not been considered for the feasibility of the locations. This research identifies potential zones for offshore wind development in the Gulf of Mexico, implementing geographical restrictions such as the Economic Exclusive Zone, distance from the coast, protected areas, bathymetry, and capacity factor seasonality. Wind speeds were obtained from 39 years of reanalyses historical data and two reference wind turbines of 5 and 10 MW were included in the analysis. Three potential areas were identified from the results: the northeast Tamaulipas, the western Campeche, and the northern Yucatan. Monthly mean capacity factors above 45% were estimated from October to June, with the maximum values near 60% between March and April. Conversely, minimum values were observed from July to September but consistently higher than 30%. The analyzed zones show suitable technical conditions for offshore wind development. Further analysis is needed to validate the wind speed conditions, in addition to the evaluation of economic factors, the study of extreme weather conditions like tropical cyclones as well as characteristics in the intertropical region.

The pan-European power grid is experiencing an increasing penetration of Variable Renewable Energy (VRE). The fluctuating and non-dispatchable nature of VRE hinders them in providing the Ancillary Service (AS) needed for the reliability and stability of the grid. Therefore, Energy Storage Systems (ESS) are needed along the VRE. Among the different ESS, a particularly viable and reliable option is Pumped Hydro Storage (PHS), given its cost-effective implementation and considerable lifespan, in comparison to other technologies. Traditional PHS plants with Francis turbines operate at a high head difference. However, not all regions have the necessary topology to make these plants cost-effective and efficient. Therefore, the ALPHEUS project will introduce low-head PHS for regions with a relatively flat topography. In this paper, a grid-forming controlled converter coupled with low-head PHS that can contribute to the grid stability is introduced, emphasising its ability to provide different AS, especially frequency control, through the provision of fast Frequency Containment Reserve (fFCR) as well as synthetic system inertia. This paper is an extended version of the paper “The Contribution of Low-head Pumped Hydro Storage to a successful Energy Transition”, which was presented at the 19^th Wind Integration Workshop 2020.