A. Jarquin Laguna
Please Note
39 records found
1
After a Life at Sea
Environmental life cycle assessment of end-of-life strategies for offshore solar
Using a prospective cradle-to-grave Life Cycle Assessment, three degradation scenarios, low, medium, and high, were developed based on observed degradation mechanisms from offshore structures and terrestrial PV systems. Each scenario is linked to a distinct end-of-life strategy. Results show that environmental impacts are significantly influenced by material recovery rates rather than performance losses, with the reuse of PV modules in the low degradation scenario yielding the lowest environmental footprint. A backcasting analysis positions this low degradation scenario as a desirable future vision, emphasizing design for longevity, reuse, and circularity.
Key strategies identified include the use of advanced encapsulants, durable backsheets, anti-corrosion coatings, and marine-adapted cleaning technologies. This research underscores the importance of early-stage assessments to embed circular economy principles in offshore solar design, highlighting material innovation and sustainable end-of-life planning as critical to the long-term success of this emerging renewable technology. ...
Using a prospective cradle-to-grave Life Cycle Assessment, three degradation scenarios, low, medium, and high, were developed based on observed degradation mechanisms from offshore structures and terrestrial PV systems. Each scenario is linked to a distinct end-of-life strategy. Results show that environmental impacts are significantly influenced by material recovery rates rather than performance losses, with the reuse of PV modules in the low degradation scenario yielding the lowest environmental footprint. A backcasting analysis positions this low degradation scenario as a desirable future vision, emphasizing design for longevity, reuse, and circularity.
Key strategies identified include the use of advanced encapsulants, durable backsheets, anti-corrosion coatings, and marine-adapted cleaning technologies. This research underscores the importance of early-stage assessments to embed circular economy principles in offshore solar design, highlighting material innovation and sustainable end-of-life planning as critical to the long-term success of this emerging renewable technology.
Wave Energy for Seawater Desalination
Hydraulic Coupling of Heaving and Surge Wave Energy Converters to Reverse Osmosis: A Numerical Study Across Sea States
An open source MATLAB based solver was used to integrate hydrodynamic data from frequency-domain Boundary Element Method (BEM) solver into time-domain simulations. Both devices harnessed mechanical energy, which was then sent to the reverse osmosis unit via a hydraulic piston configuration. Power matrices displaying SEC, water production and permeate concentration were used to present the results, offering a direct comparison.
Results showed that the two devices differed significantly. Only in high-energy wave circumstances did the heaving device operate effectively, exhibiting low SEC of 2-4 kWh/m³ and significant freshwater output in certain sea states. However, in moderate or lower-energy seas, its efficiency significantly decreased. With SEC normally ranging from 2 to 4.5 kWh/m³ and consistently higher freshwater output, even in milder sea conditions, the oscillating surge device, on the other hand, showed more stable performance. According to the study, the oscillating surge device can provide desalinated water with salt concentrations below the threshold of 600 ppm suggested by the World Health Organization in the majority of sea states, whereas the heaving device often crosses this limit, with the exception of energetic wave conditions. These findings are in good alignment with previous studies on wave-powered desalination.
Limitations include the exclusion of operational issues such as membrane fouling or long-term system degradation, the assumption of linear interpolation for calculating intermediate sea states, and possible errors resulting from simplified models.
The use of complex interpolation techniques to improve accuracy, more simulations over multiple sea states, and experimental validation of results are some suggestions for future research. Additionally, combining environmental and economic evaluations will help in determining if larger-scale deployment of these wave-powered desalination systems is feasible. This study highlights oscillating surge devices as a strong option for sustainable freshwater generation and offers insightful information for enhancing wave energy desalination.
...
An open source MATLAB based solver was used to integrate hydrodynamic data from frequency-domain Boundary Element Method (BEM) solver into time-domain simulations. Both devices harnessed mechanical energy, which was then sent to the reverse osmosis unit via a hydraulic piston configuration. Power matrices displaying SEC, water production and permeate concentration were used to present the results, offering a direct comparison.
Results showed that the two devices differed significantly. Only in high-energy wave circumstances did the heaving device operate effectively, exhibiting low SEC of 2-4 kWh/m³ and significant freshwater output in certain sea states. However, in moderate or lower-energy seas, its efficiency significantly decreased. With SEC normally ranging from 2 to 4.5 kWh/m³ and consistently higher freshwater output, even in milder sea conditions, the oscillating surge device, on the other hand, showed more stable performance. According to the study, the oscillating surge device can provide desalinated water with salt concentrations below the threshold of 600 ppm suggested by the World Health Organization in the majority of sea states, whereas the heaving device often crosses this limit, with the exception of energetic wave conditions. These findings are in good alignment with previous studies on wave-powered desalination.
Limitations include the exclusion of operational issues such as membrane fouling or long-term system degradation, the assumption of linear interpolation for calculating intermediate sea states, and possible errors resulting from simplified models.
The use of complex interpolation techniques to improve accuracy, more simulations over multiple sea states, and experimental validation of results are some suggestions for future research. Additionally, combining environmental and economic evaluations will help in determining if larger-scale deployment of these wave-powered desalination systems is feasible. This study highlights oscillating surge devices as a strong option for sustainable freshwater generation and offers insightful information for enhancing wave energy desalination.
Offshore Charging
Technical Feasibility of an Offshore Charging Station in Shallow Water
In this report, it is studied how the water depth affects the technical feasibility of the KONGSBERG OCS in shallow water. To do so, the KONGSBERG OCS is modeled in OrcaFlex for water depths ranging from 60 to 30 meters, analyzing key system components such as the buoy, the mooring system and the dynamic power cable (DPC). A surface-based charging concept was found to be unfeasible due to excessive pitch motion, leading to a focus on submerged designs. The analysis shows that the OCS is technically feasible at 40 m and 60 m depths, fulfilling both ultimate and fatigue limit state requirements. At 30 m depth, the system remains technically possible, but it exhibits several limitations, including a significantly reduced cable fatigue life of about 7.5 years, occasional buoy emergence above the sea surface, and increased interference with the seabed and mooring lines. The dominant driver of fatigue was identified as cable motion and the most critical load cases were those with aligned wave and current directions. Polyester was confirmed to be the most suitable mooring material, maintaining acceptable cable curvature in all feasible configurations.
To further improve the system and expand its applicability, several areas of future research are proposed. These include: evaluating the system’s behavior during charging mode with vessel interaction; developing a plug retrieval mechanism for emergency release scenarios; conducting fatigue enhancement studies for operation in shallower depths; incorporating rotational flow and vortex shedding effects using CFD to improve added mass and damping accuracy; and performing an economic assessment comparing the submerged system to a monopile-mounted alternative in very shallow waters. These directions aim to refine the design and expand its deployment potential within the growing offshore wind and electrification landscape.
...
In this report, it is studied how the water depth affects the technical feasibility of the KONGSBERG OCS in shallow water. To do so, the KONGSBERG OCS is modeled in OrcaFlex for water depths ranging from 60 to 30 meters, analyzing key system components such as the buoy, the mooring system and the dynamic power cable (DPC). A surface-based charging concept was found to be unfeasible due to excessive pitch motion, leading to a focus on submerged designs. The analysis shows that the OCS is technically feasible at 40 m and 60 m depths, fulfilling both ultimate and fatigue limit state requirements. At 30 m depth, the system remains technically possible, but it exhibits several limitations, including a significantly reduced cable fatigue life of about 7.5 years, occasional buoy emergence above the sea surface, and increased interference with the seabed and mooring lines. The dominant driver of fatigue was identified as cable motion and the most critical load cases were those with aligned wave and current directions. Polyester was confirmed to be the most suitable mooring material, maintaining acceptable cable curvature in all feasible configurations.
To further improve the system and expand its applicability, several areas of future research are proposed. These include: evaluating the system’s behavior during charging mode with vessel interaction; developing a plug retrieval mechanism for emergency release scenarios; conducting fatigue enhancement studies for operation in shallower depths; incorporating rotational flow and vortex shedding effects using CFD to improve added mass and damping accuracy; and performing an economic assessment comparing the submerged system to a monopile-mounted alternative in very shallow waters. These directions aim to refine the design and expand its deployment potential within the growing offshore wind and electrification landscape.
Wave energy potential in Chile
Identification of a preferred site & device combination with an integration proposition
In this study, time-domain finite-element simulations in OrcaFlex are used under Ultimate Limit State (ULS) conditions. Two configurations, catenary and lazy-wave, are compared. A parametric study varies hang-off point (HOP) angle, bend-stiffener dimensions, and buoyancy-section characteristics. Decoupled and coupled analyses then assess three integration points within the FPV system: the floater, a corner buoy, and the transverse line. Performance is measured by peak curvature, tension, and seabed clearance.
Curvature is the governing design constraint; tensions remain well below strength limits across cases. Standard bend stiffeners reduce end-region curvature but are not sufficient alone. Combined HOP-angle adjustments and stiffer or longer bend stiffeners are most effective in 20 m water depth. At 35 m, curvature hotspots move away from the ends, and benefits from local end-point adjustments decrease. Lazy-wave configurations increasingly help at 35 m by lowering curvature, distributing it along the cable’s length, and stabilising tensions. At 20 m, however, they provide limited seabed clearance (often <2 m), which is operationally risky without accurate buoyancy calibration and regular inspection.
System integration strongly influences performance. Among the tested connection points, the corner buoy offers the best balance of mechanical response and practicality, acting as an accessible hub that reduces motions at the HOP and eases installation and maintenance. For 20 m depth, a catenary cable connected at the corner buoy is the most reliable and feasible option. At 35 m, the lazy-wave configuration becomes more attractive due to improved curvature and tension margins, though with higher installation complexity.
Overall, reliable DPC design for offshore FPV requires an integrated approach that couples lay-out configuration, connection strategy, installation, and operations from the outset. This initial analysis indicates that a catenary DPC configuration is feasible for lightweight FPV systems in the North Sea, but an increase in cable bending stiffness is preferred to improve curvature control and design margins.
...
In this study, time-domain finite-element simulations in OrcaFlex are used under Ultimate Limit State (ULS) conditions. Two configurations, catenary and lazy-wave, are compared. A parametric study varies hang-off point (HOP) angle, bend-stiffener dimensions, and buoyancy-section characteristics. Decoupled and coupled analyses then assess three integration points within the FPV system: the floater, a corner buoy, and the transverse line. Performance is measured by peak curvature, tension, and seabed clearance.
Curvature is the governing design constraint; tensions remain well below strength limits across cases. Standard bend stiffeners reduce end-region curvature but are not sufficient alone. Combined HOP-angle adjustments and stiffer or longer bend stiffeners are most effective in 20 m water depth. At 35 m, curvature hotspots move away from the ends, and benefits from local end-point adjustments decrease. Lazy-wave configurations increasingly help at 35 m by lowering curvature, distributing it along the cable’s length, and stabilising tensions. At 20 m, however, they provide limited seabed clearance (often <2 m), which is operationally risky without accurate buoyancy calibration and regular inspection.
System integration strongly influences performance. Among the tested connection points, the corner buoy offers the best balance of mechanical response and practicality, acting as an accessible hub that reduces motions at the HOP and eases installation and maintenance. For 20 m depth, a catenary cable connected at the corner buoy is the most reliable and feasible option. At 35 m, the lazy-wave configuration becomes more attractive due to improved curvature and tension margins, though with higher installation complexity.
Overall, reliable DPC design for offshore FPV requires an integrated approach that couples lay-out configuration, connection strategy, installation, and operations from the outset. This initial analysis indicates that a catenary DPC configuration is feasible for lightweight FPV systems in the North Sea, but an increase in cable bending stiffness is preferred to improve curvature control and design margins.
This thesis systematically defined its fundamental objectives, beginning with the development of a 1D unsteady model for compressible flow in pipeline systems. This model, which served as the basis for subsequent studies, was verified against the existing literature, revealing a 2-4% difference in flow rates and pressure responses. Subsequently, the scope was broadened to include nozzle configurations, which were gradually included in the pipeline model. The model evolved through configurations with one, three, and five nozzles, where larger diameters increased dampening on transient pressure fluctuations. As the research progressed, the final model, incorporating five nozzles, was used as the basis for the scaled Bubble Curtain Technology (BCT) model.
A sensitivity analysis for this study was carried out utilizing parameters from existing research. The sensitivity study specifically emphasized the influence of geometric (hose and nozzle diameters, hose length, nozzle spacing) and operational factors (discharge coefficient, water depth, air flow rate) on the flow dynamic of Bubble Curtain Technology (BCT). The main findings from this research included reducing backflow with smaller diameters and lowering reverse flow with greater discharge coefficients and airflow rates. Changing the hose length and nozzle spacing proved effective for adjusting the required flow rates. The investigation also found that nozzle diameter and discharge coefficient had a considerable impact on nozzle flow rates, with a 2-3% increase over reference values at the maximum value range. Other geometric and operational parameters in the tested ranges had a relatively lower influence on the nozzle flow rates or generated pressure variations.
The scaled BCT unsteady compressible flow dynamics model presented in this thesis is still in its early stages of development, but it can serve as a basis for the development of full-scale pneumatic models that can enhance BCT and lessen the environmental impact of offshore wind farm operations.
...
This thesis systematically defined its fundamental objectives, beginning with the development of a 1D unsteady model for compressible flow in pipeline systems. This model, which served as the basis for subsequent studies, was verified against the existing literature, revealing a 2-4% difference in flow rates and pressure responses. Subsequently, the scope was broadened to include nozzle configurations, which were gradually included in the pipeline model. The model evolved through configurations with one, three, and five nozzles, where larger diameters increased dampening on transient pressure fluctuations. As the research progressed, the final model, incorporating five nozzles, was used as the basis for the scaled Bubble Curtain Technology (BCT) model.
A sensitivity analysis for this study was carried out utilizing parameters from existing research. The sensitivity study specifically emphasized the influence of geometric (hose and nozzle diameters, hose length, nozzle spacing) and operational factors (discharge coefficient, water depth, air flow rate) on the flow dynamic of Bubble Curtain Technology (BCT). The main findings from this research included reducing backflow with smaller diameters and lowering reverse flow with greater discharge coefficients and airflow rates. Changing the hose length and nozzle spacing proved effective for adjusting the required flow rates. The investigation also found that nozzle diameter and discharge coefficient had a considerable impact on nozzle flow rates, with a 2-3% increase over reference values at the maximum value range. Other geometric and operational parameters in the tested ranges had a relatively lower influence on the nozzle flow rates or generated pressure variations.
The scaled BCT unsteady compressible flow dynamics model presented in this thesis is still in its early stages of development, but it can serve as a basis for the development of full-scale pneumatic models that can enhance BCT and lessen the environmental impact of offshore wind farm operations.
For this study a physical medium scale pneumatic model of the air-bubble curtain system was designed based on data available from the offshore industry. Tests were performed both in dry and wet conditions which approximate those that are seen in the industrial practice. The role of several geometrical and operational parameters of the pneumatic system, like the inlet pressure, inlet flow rate, internal hose diameter, nozzle diameter, nozzle spacing, static water pressure, on the operational conditions along the hose-nozzle is explored. The influence of the volumetric flow rate along the hose-nozzle on the pressure development along the hose-nozzle is examined. The examined correlation between air flow temperature and air flow rate at the inlet of the compressed air supply and the pressure development over the hose-nozzle forms valuable input for a future numerical model that includes the temperature of the inlet flow rate. The test setup with configurations of reduced lengths in dry conditions is used to experimentally determine the discharge coefficients of a range of different nozzles. Here, the limitations of the test setup are carefully considered and a comparison with numerical results provided by compressible flow theory is followed.
...
For this study a physical medium scale pneumatic model of the air-bubble curtain system was designed based on data available from the offshore industry. Tests were performed both in dry and wet conditions which approximate those that are seen in the industrial practice. The role of several geometrical and operational parameters of the pneumatic system, like the inlet pressure, inlet flow rate, internal hose diameter, nozzle diameter, nozzle spacing, static water pressure, on the operational conditions along the hose-nozzle is explored. The influence of the volumetric flow rate along the hose-nozzle on the pressure development along the hose-nozzle is examined. The examined correlation between air flow temperature and air flow rate at the inlet of the compressed air supply and the pressure development over the hose-nozzle forms valuable input for a future numerical model that includes the temperature of the inlet flow rate. The test setup with configurations of reduced lengths in dry conditions is used to experimentally determine the discharge coefficients of a range of different nozzles. Here, the limitations of the test setup are carefully considered and a comparison with numerical results provided by compressible flow theory is followed.
Transportation of Hydrogen in Flexible Pipes From a Floating Wind Turbine
A Numerical Parametric Study
This research evaluates the impact of various parameters in lazy wave configurations on the tension and curvature behavior of flexible pipes used for hydrogen transport in offshore wind-to-hydrogen systems, utilizing simulations performed in OrcaFlex (OF). The research shows that failure modes, tension, overbending, and compression, are only exceeded in non-optimal wave configurations, with the Minimum Bend Radius (MBR) being a more critical constraint than the Minimum Breaking Load (MBL). However, both limits are breached when compression, looping at the Touch Down Point (TDP), or collapse has already occurred, suggesting that the pipe may be overdesigned or that the lazy wave configuration represents a conservative design approach. Furthermore, research also finds that environmental factors have minimal impact on tension and curvature, with static effects contributing for 86\% of total tension and 78\% of total curvature. This indicates that static analysis can provide an initial configuration without the need for computationally demanding dynamic simulations, as the design limits of MBL and MBR are exceeded in similar static and dynamic scenarios. Lastly, the design of a lazy wave configuration can be simplified to three configurational parameters: a buoyant section parameter (the outer diameter of the Buoyancy Modules (BM), pitch between BMs, or the buoyant section length), the first section catenary length, and a total configuration parameter (total length or horizontal distance between the HOP and TP), since the parameters within each group exhibit similar behavior in terms of tension and curvature responses when varied individually.
...
This research evaluates the impact of various parameters in lazy wave configurations on the tension and curvature behavior of flexible pipes used for hydrogen transport in offshore wind-to-hydrogen systems, utilizing simulations performed in OrcaFlex (OF). The research shows that failure modes, tension, overbending, and compression, are only exceeded in non-optimal wave configurations, with the Minimum Bend Radius (MBR) being a more critical constraint than the Minimum Breaking Load (MBL). However, both limits are breached when compression, looping at the Touch Down Point (TDP), or collapse has already occurred, suggesting that the pipe may be overdesigned or that the lazy wave configuration represents a conservative design approach. Furthermore, research also finds that environmental factors have minimal impact on tension and curvature, with static effects contributing for 86\% of total tension and 78\% of total curvature. This indicates that static analysis can provide an initial configuration without the need for computationally demanding dynamic simulations, as the design limits of MBL and MBR are exceeded in similar static and dynamic scenarios. Lastly, the design of a lazy wave configuration can be simplified to three configurational parameters: a buoyant section parameter (the outer diameter of the Buoyancy Modules (BM), pitch between BMs, or the buoyant section length), the first section catenary length, and a total configuration parameter (total length or horizontal distance between the HOP and TP), since the parameters within each group exhibit similar behavior in terms of tension and curvature responses when varied individually.
Information from the Alpheus project about the engineering requirements for an offshore LH PHS plant is used, following ISO 14044 Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology. In this study, the construction, maintenance and operation of an offshore LH PHS plant are assessed, focusing on Global Warming Potential (GWP), Water Use Depletion Potential (WUDP) and Abiotic Depletion Potential for Elements (ADP-E). This is studied with and without the input of electricity, sourcing it from wind or from the Dutch grid mix. Moreover, these results are compared with Lithium iron phosphate (LFP) Batteries and for Wind-Green Hydrogen.
For the construction, operation and maintenance of the LH PHS plant, it is estimated that the emissions would reach 2.8Mt of CO2-eq, 601 million m3 of water and 140.2t of Sb-eq. These emissions are mainly shared between civil and electromechanical infrastructure, the former has more relevance for GWP with almost 56% of the emissions whereas the latter reaches 69% for WUDP and 98% for ADP-E. When electricity is incorporated into the equation and these emissions are translated per kWh, emissions from the generation of electricity exceed 2.4, 5.6 and 1.8 times those emissions from the infrastructure for GWP, WUDP and ADP-E. When comparing LH PHS with other technologies using wind as the only source of electricity production, LFP Batteries outperform LH PHS most of the time for GWP and WUDP, whereas LFP are consistently the worst performer for ADP-E. LH PHS always performs better than Green Hydrogen in all three impact categories.
If emissions reductions are to be achieved in the LH PHS case, the focus should be put on the electricity side: improving the efficiency of the plant, storing only clean energy and improving the performance of renewables. Finally, there are other considerations to LH PHS implementation that should be taken into account that are not assessed in this report. The use of materials and their circularity must be considered, as well as the social ramifications of projects like PHS and mining materials for Li-ion Batteries. Furthermore, impacts on biodiversity must be addressed and its damages should not only be minimized but restored or even improved. ...
Information from the Alpheus project about the engineering requirements for an offshore LH PHS plant is used, following ISO 14044 Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology. In this study, the construction, maintenance and operation of an offshore LH PHS plant are assessed, focusing on Global Warming Potential (GWP), Water Use Depletion Potential (WUDP) and Abiotic Depletion Potential for Elements (ADP-E). This is studied with and without the input of electricity, sourcing it from wind or from the Dutch grid mix. Moreover, these results are compared with Lithium iron phosphate (LFP) Batteries and for Wind-Green Hydrogen.
For the construction, operation and maintenance of the LH PHS plant, it is estimated that the emissions would reach 2.8Mt of CO2-eq, 601 million m3 of water and 140.2t of Sb-eq. These emissions are mainly shared between civil and electromechanical infrastructure, the former has more relevance for GWP with almost 56% of the emissions whereas the latter reaches 69% for WUDP and 98% for ADP-E. When electricity is incorporated into the equation and these emissions are translated per kWh, emissions from the generation of electricity exceed 2.4, 5.6 and 1.8 times those emissions from the infrastructure for GWP, WUDP and ADP-E. When comparing LH PHS with other technologies using wind as the only source of electricity production, LFP Batteries outperform LH PHS most of the time for GWP and WUDP, whereas LFP are consistently the worst performer for ADP-E. LH PHS always performs better than Green Hydrogen in all three impact categories.
If emissions reductions are to be achieved in the LH PHS case, the focus should be put on the electricity side: improving the efficiency of the plant, storing only clean energy and improving the performance of renewables. Finally, there are other considerations to LH PHS implementation that should be taken into account that are not assessed in this report. The use of materials and their circularity must be considered, as well as the social ramifications of projects like PHS and mining materials for Li-ion Batteries. Furthermore, impacts on biodiversity must be addressed and its damages should not only be minimized but restored or even improved.
All conventional wind systems convert mechanical energy into electricity, which is used to power the desalination units. Delft Offshore Turbine (DOT) aims to replace the conventional drivetrain with a hydraulic transmission system that uses seawater as a hydraulic transfer medium. The examined DOT500 PRO system consists of a wind turbine connected to a hydraulic positive displacement pump, which induces seawater flow under high pressure. A reverse osmosis unit can be used to desalinate saltwater using this high-pressure flow and a Pelton turbine generator can be used to produce electricity. The long-term objective of the DOT project is to lower complexity, mass, maintenance, and capital expense to make offshore wind a competitive source of electricity. To further reinforce the concept's techno-economic components, the future strategy calls for the centralized production of electricity.
This study aims to develop an operating strategy for the DOT500 PRO system for freshwater production at an offshore location. The viability of using such a system in a place with offshore wind conditions and predetermined freshwater demand was investigated using a constant operating scheme of a single spear valve. A numerical model is developed in Python to deliver the appropriate desalination unit size under offshore wind conditions in order to cover the water requirements of a given location. The model is applied to a case study of Agios Efstratios in Greece and can be used as a tool to investigate possible applications using the associated datasets. This research has yielded the following results:
1. A simple and robust system operating strategy for maximum water production that will ensure stable turbine function, while active control is used to maintain the system at constant operation when its limits are reached.
2. The direct influence of the spear valve position and reverse osmosis unit size on the system’s rated conditions and a reduced rated wind speed by 21.3% from the one utilized conventionally on the reference wind turbine.
3. The minimum required number of RO pressure vessels and membranes according to site-specific offshore wind profile and freshwater demand, as well as options for reducing the RO unit size.
...
All conventional wind systems convert mechanical energy into electricity, which is used to power the desalination units. Delft Offshore Turbine (DOT) aims to replace the conventional drivetrain with a hydraulic transmission system that uses seawater as a hydraulic transfer medium. The examined DOT500 PRO system consists of a wind turbine connected to a hydraulic positive displacement pump, which induces seawater flow under high pressure. A reverse osmosis unit can be used to desalinate saltwater using this high-pressure flow and a Pelton turbine generator can be used to produce electricity. The long-term objective of the DOT project is to lower complexity, mass, maintenance, and capital expense to make offshore wind a competitive source of electricity. To further reinforce the concept's techno-economic components, the future strategy calls for the centralized production of electricity.
This study aims to develop an operating strategy for the DOT500 PRO system for freshwater production at an offshore location. The viability of using such a system in a place with offshore wind conditions and predetermined freshwater demand was investigated using a constant operating scheme of a single spear valve. A numerical model is developed in Python to deliver the appropriate desalination unit size under offshore wind conditions in order to cover the water requirements of a given location. The model is applied to a case study of Agios Efstratios in Greece and can be used as a tool to investigate possible applications using the associated datasets. This research has yielded the following results:
1. A simple and robust system operating strategy for maximum water production that will ensure stable turbine function, while active control is used to maintain the system at constant operation when its limits are reached.
2. The direct influence of the spear valve position and reverse osmosis unit size on the system’s rated conditions and a reduced rated wind speed by 21.3% from the one utilized conventionally on the reference wind turbine.
3. The minimum required number of RO pressure vessels and membranes according to site-specific offshore wind profile and freshwater demand, as well as options for reducing the RO unit size.
are already some prototype WECs tested around the world but there is no leading design that proves to be a cost-effective way to convert this energy to electricity.
A company from the Netherlands, Dutch Wave Power, also tries to build a cost-effective device to harvest the ocean’s energy. Their design consists of a floating tube or cylinder that converts the heave and sway motion into a pitch motion. This pitch motion drives a generator which generates electrical power. The generator is connected to the outer wall of the float and rotates as the float pitches. Inside the generator is a shaft that is kept in place by an inside pendulum. Dutch Wave Power validated their concept with experimental tests in a wave flume. The next step in the development is a numerical model. This model
gives insight into the effects that influence the dynamics and power production of the WEC. Secondly, a numerical model eliminates the need for new experimental tests each time a design parameter is changed.
The numerical model estimates the dynamics of the WEC. The BEM software NEMOH is used to estimate the diffraction and radiation forces coefficients. A state-space approximation of the Cummins equation is used to capture the memory effect of the radiation forces. The Froude-Krylov forces are fully non-linear and are evaluated for each time step. Lastly, some friction and drag forces are included. The PTO system is described as a linear damper. The numerical model is validated with experimental tests executed by Dutch Wave Power.
Next, the numerical model is adapted to also estimate the hydrodynamics in irregular waves. The irregular waves used in this thesis are based on a JONSWAP spectrum. Using the parameters of the JONSWAP spectrum, a sea-state with the desired significant wave height and peak period can be generated. The
Froude-Krylov and the diffraction forces are estimated based on the principle of superposition. With this irregular wave model, a power matrix is constructed for a WEC with twice the size that was used in the experimental tests. This power matrix gives an indication of the ideal operational wave conditions, where the efficiency of the WEC is the highest, and it makes it enables the possibility to compare the performance of the WEC at different sea-states. ...
are already some prototype WECs tested around the world but there is no leading design that proves to be a cost-effective way to convert this energy to electricity.
A company from the Netherlands, Dutch Wave Power, also tries to build a cost-effective device to harvest the ocean’s energy. Their design consists of a floating tube or cylinder that converts the heave and sway motion into a pitch motion. This pitch motion drives a generator which generates electrical power. The generator is connected to the outer wall of the float and rotates as the float pitches. Inside the generator is a shaft that is kept in place by an inside pendulum. Dutch Wave Power validated their concept with experimental tests in a wave flume. The next step in the development is a numerical model. This model
gives insight into the effects that influence the dynamics and power production of the WEC. Secondly, a numerical model eliminates the need for new experimental tests each time a design parameter is changed.
The numerical model estimates the dynamics of the WEC. The BEM software NEMOH is used to estimate the diffraction and radiation forces coefficients. A state-space approximation of the Cummins equation is used to capture the memory effect of the radiation forces. The Froude-Krylov forces are fully non-linear and are evaluated for each time step. Lastly, some friction and drag forces are included. The PTO system is described as a linear damper. The numerical model is validated with experimental tests executed by Dutch Wave Power.
Next, the numerical model is adapted to also estimate the hydrodynamics in irregular waves. The irregular waves used in this thesis are based on a JONSWAP spectrum. Using the parameters of the JONSWAP spectrum, a sea-state with the desired significant wave height and peak period can be generated. The
Froude-Krylov and the diffraction forces are estimated based on the principle of superposition. With this irregular wave model, a power matrix is constructed for a WEC with twice the size that was used in the experimental tests. This power matrix gives an indication of the ideal operational wave conditions, where the efficiency of the WEC is the highest, and it makes it enables the possibility to compare the performance of the WEC at different sea-states.
One of the main challenges is to quantify the effect of the different design choices regarding size and connection compliance on the forces within the connections between the floaters. The aim of this research is to give insight into the interaction between connection forces and different concept choices regarding the size of the floaters and the compliance of the connections between the floaters.
A numerical model of two floaters which are connected with two connections at each end of the structure is developed. The forces and motions of the floating structure are computed using numerical tools in the frequency domain. The hydrodynamic coefficients and wave excitation forces are obtained using the boundary element method software NEMOH. The connections between the floaters are modelled as a set of linear translational and rotational springs in each degree of freedom. The results are validated using earlier studies.
The influence of the design choices is investigated for application at the North sea for different wave directions. First, four different dimensions are varied, the length, the width and the draft of the floaters and the size of the gap between the floaters. The results are then analyzed and compared for each dimension. The comparison of the results shows the influence of each dimension on the force in the connections. Secondly, the connection stiffness is varied in four different directions, the axial, shear, bending and torsional stiffness. The comparison of the results show the interaction between connection stiffness and resulting forces in the connections.
The developed numerical frequency domain model shows the interaction between forces and moments in the connections and different design choices. The results can be used to give an insight into the occurring forces within the connections between two floater for application in the North sea. ...
One of the main challenges is to quantify the effect of the different design choices regarding size and connection compliance on the forces within the connections between the floaters. The aim of this research is to give insight into the interaction between connection forces and different concept choices regarding the size of the floaters and the compliance of the connections between the floaters.
A numerical model of two floaters which are connected with two connections at each end of the structure is developed. The forces and motions of the floating structure are computed using numerical tools in the frequency domain. The hydrodynamic coefficients and wave excitation forces are obtained using the boundary element method software NEMOH. The connections between the floaters are modelled as a set of linear translational and rotational springs in each degree of freedom. The results are validated using earlier studies.
The influence of the design choices is investigated for application at the North sea for different wave directions. First, four different dimensions are varied, the length, the width and the draft of the floaters and the size of the gap between the floaters. The results are then analyzed and compared for each dimension. The comparison of the results shows the influence of each dimension on the force in the connections. Secondly, the connection stiffness is varied in four different directions, the axial, shear, bending and torsional stiffness. The comparison of the results show the interaction between connection stiffness and resulting forces in the connections.
The developed numerical frequency domain model shows the interaction between forces and moments in the connections and different design choices. The results can be used to give an insight into the occurring forces within the connections between two floater for application in the North sea.
The installation of monopiles using the MUST comprises three phases: the barge mooring / lift-off, upending / slewing and lowering / driving phase. Based on the results from a qualitative critical event analysis, the lift-off phase is expected to be limiting. Hence, a hydrodynamic model is developed to quantitatively analyse this phase. Experimental simulations, which are performed in parallel with the model development, result in the preliminary conclusions that multiple pendulum effects influence the results to a limited extent, while viscous roll damping and hydrodynamic interaction effects can be strong determinants of the resulting responses.
The relative z-motion between the lifted monopile and the barge and the barge roll response are identified as governing parameters. To reduce the first limiting factor, a system that allows for instantaneously increasing the vertical clearance between the monopile and the barge is proposed. The effectiveness of this system is tested for two barge loadcases. For the first case, the average workability increase for the optimal heading at a typical location is calculated as 8.3%. For the second, the increase is marginal, as the barge responses are more limiting. Furthermore, is it found that a Passive Motion Compensator (PMC) can reduce the probability of the introduction of snap loads in the winch cable, and therefore allows for system optimisations. A PMC with 10% of critical damping can reduce the required winch capacity with a factor of 2.3 w.r.t. the uncompensated case.
It is recommended to perform follow-up studies into the system performance during upending / slewing and lowering / driving. Also, it is advised to evaluate the effect of a larger barge and a PMC on the workability. To balance the associated investments and workability increases, the logistical models developed in a parallel study can be used. Finally, for iterative calculations, it was found to be beneficial to make an estimate based on a fast simplified model and to subsequently feed the results back into a more detailed, but slower model.
...
The installation of monopiles using the MUST comprises three phases: the barge mooring / lift-off, upending / slewing and lowering / driving phase. Based on the results from a qualitative critical event analysis, the lift-off phase is expected to be limiting. Hence, a hydrodynamic model is developed to quantitatively analyse this phase. Experimental simulations, which are performed in parallel with the model development, result in the preliminary conclusions that multiple pendulum effects influence the results to a limited extent, while viscous roll damping and hydrodynamic interaction effects can be strong determinants of the resulting responses.
The relative z-motion between the lifted monopile and the barge and the barge roll response are identified as governing parameters. To reduce the first limiting factor, a system that allows for instantaneously increasing the vertical clearance between the monopile and the barge is proposed. The effectiveness of this system is tested for two barge loadcases. For the first case, the average workability increase for the optimal heading at a typical location is calculated as 8.3%. For the second, the increase is marginal, as the barge responses are more limiting. Furthermore, is it found that a Passive Motion Compensator (PMC) can reduce the probability of the introduction of snap loads in the winch cable, and therefore allows for system optimisations. A PMC with 10% of critical damping can reduce the required winch capacity with a factor of 2.3 w.r.t. the uncompensated case.
It is recommended to perform follow-up studies into the system performance during upending / slewing and lowering / driving. Also, it is advised to evaluate the effect of a larger barge and a PMC on the workability. To balance the associated investments and workability increases, the logistical models developed in a parallel study can be used. Finally, for iterative calculations, it was found to be beneficial to make an estimate based on a fast simplified model and to subsequently feed the results back into a more detailed, but slower model.
To quantitatively compare the strategies, and to consider stochastic processes (e.g., weather conditions), a discrete-event simulation modelling approach is adopted. To arrive at substantiated conclusions, a framework is followed, which provides a roadmap and rigour criteria for the design, implementation and evaluation phases. First, a conceptual model is developed and face validated. Next, a numerical “base model” is constructed, which describes the most basic strategy. This model is face validated by industry experts and evaluated by parameter variability, convergence and historical data validation tests. It is concluded that the base model is structured according to shared practical experiences, responds satisfactory to parameter changes, requires 35 simulation runs to converge, and has good predictive capabilities. Hence, it is deemed suitable to function as a “template” for the modelling of the other strategies.
The simulation results are evaluated for each of the considered substructures separately. (i) MP – TP installation. In general, assembly-line installation strategies, in which two Heavy Lift Vessels (HLVs) are deployed, are associated with the shortest installation time. The shuttling – assembly-line and the shuttling–alternating (in which MPs and TPs are installed alternatingly) strategies are associated with the lowest costs. Both involve a shuttling transportation strategy, in which the HLV(s) ensure(s) both the transportation and installation of the components. The mooring of barges alongside an HLV in feeder strategies (feeder vessels supply components to an HLV, which stays at the wind farm under development) and the installation of TPs by a relatively small HLV in assembly-line strategies are identified as the main bottlenecks. Reducing these by relatively simple solutions can result in significant performance increases. Lastly, the project start date is found to be a strong determinant of strategy performance. (ii) Jacket – foundation pile installation. The assembly-line strategies are found to result in the shortest jacket installation times as well. However, only the shuttling – assembly-line strategy is additionally associated with the lowest costs. Furthermore, it is found that a separate pile-dredging vessel can help to reduce the time and costs associated with separate phases installation strategies, in which jackets and their foundation piles are installed in different phases. Also for jackets, the barge mooring alongside the HLV is identified to be the largest bottleneck. Reducing this bottleneck can result in significant performance benefits. Lastly, a relationship is found between the performance of jacket installation strategies and the project start date, although weaker than for MP installation.
The developed decision support tool can provide a platform for further research into the logistics of offshore wind and other industries, whereas the obtained results are only valid within the set boundaries. To widen the applicability, it is recommended to perform follow-up studies in which a stochastic mechanical failure component is included, and the sensitivity to the wind farm size and port-to-farm distance is tested. Furthermore, it is advised to extend this study to investigate the potential of the industry adopting a more holistic process or market point of view. ...
To quantitatively compare the strategies, and to consider stochastic processes (e.g., weather conditions), a discrete-event simulation modelling approach is adopted. To arrive at substantiated conclusions, a framework is followed, which provides a roadmap and rigour criteria for the design, implementation and evaluation phases. First, a conceptual model is developed and face validated. Next, a numerical “base model” is constructed, which describes the most basic strategy. This model is face validated by industry experts and evaluated by parameter variability, convergence and historical data validation tests. It is concluded that the base model is structured according to shared practical experiences, responds satisfactory to parameter changes, requires 35 simulation runs to converge, and has good predictive capabilities. Hence, it is deemed suitable to function as a “template” for the modelling of the other strategies.
The simulation results are evaluated for each of the considered substructures separately. (i) MP – TP installation. In general, assembly-line installation strategies, in which two Heavy Lift Vessels (HLVs) are deployed, are associated with the shortest installation time. The shuttling – assembly-line and the shuttling–alternating (in which MPs and TPs are installed alternatingly) strategies are associated with the lowest costs. Both involve a shuttling transportation strategy, in which the HLV(s) ensure(s) both the transportation and installation of the components. The mooring of barges alongside an HLV in feeder strategies (feeder vessels supply components to an HLV, which stays at the wind farm under development) and the installation of TPs by a relatively small HLV in assembly-line strategies are identified as the main bottlenecks. Reducing these by relatively simple solutions can result in significant performance increases. Lastly, the project start date is found to be a strong determinant of strategy performance. (ii) Jacket – foundation pile installation. The assembly-line strategies are found to result in the shortest jacket installation times as well. However, only the shuttling – assembly-line strategy is additionally associated with the lowest costs. Furthermore, it is found that a separate pile-dredging vessel can help to reduce the time and costs associated with separate phases installation strategies, in which jackets and their foundation piles are installed in different phases. Also for jackets, the barge mooring alongside the HLV is identified to be the largest bottleneck. Reducing this bottleneck can result in significant performance benefits. Lastly, a relationship is found between the performance of jacket installation strategies and the project start date, although weaker than for MP installation.
The developed decision support tool can provide a platform for further research into the logistics of offshore wind and other industries, whereas the obtained results are only valid within the set boundaries. To widen the applicability, it is recommended to perform follow-up studies in which a stochastic mechanical failure component is included, and the sensitivity to the wind farm size and port-to-farm distance is tested. Furthermore, it is advised to extend this study to investigate the potential of the industry adopting a more holistic process or market point of view.
Motion compensated offshore knuckle boom crane
A mechanical feasibility study
This thesis, studies the mechanical feasibility of a motion compensated knuckle boom crane, compensating for the wave-induced vessel motions by controlling the available actuators in such a manner, that the crane tip stays stationary. A typical knuckle boom crane has three actuated degrees of freedom, consisting of the slewing, boom luffing and jib luffing angle. To study such a system, a numerical model is developed that combines the multi body dynamics of the knuckle boom crane with models for the hydraulic actuation of the crane and incorporates the full six degree of freedom vessel motions. The actuated degrees of freedom are controlled using three separate proportional integral controllers. The desired trajectories for the controllers are calculated using the geometric relations of the crane, based on the assumption that the desired crane tip coordinate in the global axis system is known.
Using the numerical model, insight is gained in the natural frequencies, forces/moments on the system, the necessary hydraulic properties and motion compensation performance. From the simulation results, it can be concluded that the cylinder forces and slewing torques increase when the motion compensation is turned on, compared to an uncompensated crane. Comparing the simulation results, to the Barge Master T40 crane, it can be concluded that cylinder forces, cylinder sizes, stroke velocities and power requirements are in line with requirements that can be achieved with existing technology. The main limitation, is expected to be the rated torque of the slewing motor, when the crane is positioned parallel to the vessel. In this position the main contributor to the motion compensation is the slewing motor. Using the proposed concept, motion compensation performance comparable to the existing Barge Master T40 is achieved. From the presented simulation scenarios, results indicate that the operational parameters and motion compensation performance of the system are feasible and competitive compared with existing technology.
...
This thesis, studies the mechanical feasibility of a motion compensated knuckle boom crane, compensating for the wave-induced vessel motions by controlling the available actuators in such a manner, that the crane tip stays stationary. A typical knuckle boom crane has three actuated degrees of freedom, consisting of the slewing, boom luffing and jib luffing angle. To study such a system, a numerical model is developed that combines the multi body dynamics of the knuckle boom crane with models for the hydraulic actuation of the crane and incorporates the full six degree of freedom vessel motions. The actuated degrees of freedom are controlled using three separate proportional integral controllers. The desired trajectories for the controllers are calculated using the geometric relations of the crane, based on the assumption that the desired crane tip coordinate in the global axis system is known.
Using the numerical model, insight is gained in the natural frequencies, forces/moments on the system, the necessary hydraulic properties and motion compensation performance. From the simulation results, it can be concluded that the cylinder forces and slewing torques increase when the motion compensation is turned on, compared to an uncompensated crane. Comparing the simulation results, to the Barge Master T40 crane, it can be concluded that cylinder forces, cylinder sizes, stroke velocities and power requirements are in line with requirements that can be achieved with existing technology. The main limitation, is expected to be the rated torque of the slewing motor, when the crane is positioned parallel to the vessel. In this position the main contributor to the motion compensation is the slewing motor. Using the proposed concept, motion compensation performance comparable to the existing Barge Master T40 is achieved. From the presented simulation scenarios, results indicate that the operational parameters and motion compensation performance of the system are feasible and competitive compared with existing technology.
Improving the Techno-Economic Performance of Wave Energy Converters
From the Perspective of Systematic Sizing
An experimental and numerical investigation of the hydrodynamics of the ducted system of a "Van Rompay Turbine"
With the goal to capture energy from the current of an ocean, river, estuary or similar
A proposed PHS system known as Subsea Pumped Hydro Storage (SPHS) has been assessed from a techno-economic standpoint. As intermittent renewable energy sources become increasingly widespread in the electrical system, the demand for power regulation grows. Implementing energy storage in the system is one approach to balance the demand for power with the supply. This thesis looked at an idea that is a sea-based variant of the existing pumped hydro storage technique. A SPHS unit is made up of a hollow structure on the seabed that may be emptied of water using a pump during periods of low demand and high energy generation in the system, and the unit is charged at that moment. When the system requires more energy, water is permitted to flow into the tank through a turbine, creating power.
In India, a locality study of prospective areas where the PHS may be placed and operated effectively is carried out. Muppandal (Tamil Nadu) is used as a case study. When the PHES is used, a positive influence on the power system's behavior may be seen, with the degree of wind integration being raised and dispatched on demand. The generation of peak demand by inefficient and costly units is reduced, lowering the total generating cost.
The main goal of this work is to determine the Technical feasibility of a proposed SPHSP system and to evaluate Levelised cost of storage. The study will be conducted to reach out to the suitable selection of turbines and pumps and to design the concrete storage tank in such a deep-sea environment. It is observed that the maximum depth upto which the storage tank can be built is 1200m depth for 5m high wall and 1000m depth for 7m high wall. The appropriate turbine is selected based on specific speed and it comes out that Francis turbine is suitable for depth 200m to 1200m. The levelised cost of storage (LCOS) is also calculated, and it works out to be $4.53 per kilowatt hour for 1200m depth. There are different methods suggested to increase the bearing capacity of the soil and compaction grouting seems to be the most appropriate improvement method.
...
A proposed PHS system known as Subsea Pumped Hydro Storage (SPHS) has been assessed from a techno-economic standpoint. As intermittent renewable energy sources become increasingly widespread in the electrical system, the demand for power regulation grows. Implementing energy storage in the system is one approach to balance the demand for power with the supply. This thesis looked at an idea that is a sea-based variant of the existing pumped hydro storage technique. A SPHS unit is made up of a hollow structure on the seabed that may be emptied of water using a pump during periods of low demand and high energy generation in the system, and the unit is charged at that moment. When the system requires more energy, water is permitted to flow into the tank through a turbine, creating power.
In India, a locality study of prospective areas where the PHS may be placed and operated effectively is carried out. Muppandal (Tamil Nadu) is used as a case study. When the PHES is used, a positive influence on the power system's behavior may be seen, with the degree of wind integration being raised and dispatched on demand. The generation of peak demand by inefficient and costly units is reduced, lowering the total generating cost.
The main goal of this work is to determine the Technical feasibility of a proposed SPHSP system and to evaluate Levelised cost of storage. The study will be conducted to reach out to the suitable selection of turbines and pumps and to design the concrete storage tank in such a deep-sea environment. It is observed that the maximum depth upto which the storage tank can be built is 1200m depth for 5m high wall and 1000m depth for 7m high wall. The appropriate turbine is selected based on specific speed and it comes out that Francis turbine is suitable for depth 200m to 1200m. The levelised cost of storage (LCOS) is also calculated, and it works out to be $4.53 per kilowatt hour for 1200m depth. There are different methods suggested to increase the bearing capacity of the soil and compaction grouting seems to be the most appropriate improvement method.
In this project, the TU Delft in-house U2DiVA code is indicated as a conservative and time-effective tool to assess the hydrodynamic response of a vertical-axis tidal turbine under surge, sway and yaw motions compared to the computational fluid dynamics approach commonly used in the scientific literature. The effect of surge motion on the fluid-structure interaction of two existing vertical-axis tidal turbines is investigated using U2DiVA. The analysis focuses on the details of the time evolution of the flow field perceived at the blades and on the modified cyclic loading and power extraction when given surging conditions are imposed. ...
In this project, the TU Delft in-house U2DiVA code is indicated as a conservative and time-effective tool to assess the hydrodynamic response of a vertical-axis tidal turbine under surge, sway and yaw motions compared to the computational fluid dynamics approach commonly used in the scientific literature. The effect of surge motion on the fluid-structure interaction of two existing vertical-axis tidal turbines is investigated using U2DiVA. The analysis focuses on the details of the time evolution of the flow field perceived at the blades and on the modified cyclic loading and power extraction when given surging conditions are imposed.