Circular Image

A.R. Balkenende

info

Please Note

136 records found

Journal article (2026) - J. Bolanos Arriola, M.M. Weber, Nina van Dulmen, Jeroen Guinée, Martina Vijver, R. Balkenende
Current Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) frameworks, such as those proposed by the Joint Research Centre, support the development of safer, more sustainable substances, materials, and manufacturing processes. However, these were not designed for product developers or designers and therefore do not align with the iterative and creative nature of product development, nor with its specific needs and constraints. Broad adoption of SSbD requires tiered, resource-efficient assessments tailored to the specific needs of different professionals. The product developer’s perspective is essential for creating safer, more sustainable products, enabling context-specific evaluation of chemical applications, substances of concern (SoC), and product life cycles. In a circular economy, where products, parts, and materials circulate, holistic views become critical, as emissions and exposures may increase and accumulate. Therefore, we developed the Mapping Assessment for Product Substance Safety and Sustainability (MAPSSS) tool, which integrates principles of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Risk Assessment (RA) into a product development context. Through iterative development based on real-life cases of products containing SoC, we combined essential elements of RA and LCA into a product development workflow. Expert input on environmental assessment and ecotoxicology informed each iteration of the process. MAPSSS supports product developers in identifying and assessing SoC risks, trade-offs, uncertainty levels, and environmental impacts across the product life cycle. It enables the identification of risk hotspots in reference products, supporting mitigation strategies and comparison with new solutions. This represents an initial step toward a product-specific SSbD assessment tool for early design stages. ...

Guidance for circular product development

Journal article (2026) - Puck Bos, Sonja Van Dam, Ruud Balkenende, Conny Bakker
The transition to a circular economy calls for reduced reliance on fossil resources. Bio-based plastics offer potential environmental benefits, but their effective use in durable products is complex and under-researched. This study explores key considerations product developers face when using bio-based plastics in circular product development, with a focus on durable applications. Semi-structured interviews with product developers and a scoping literature review were conducted to identify and examine these considerations across the product life cycle. Eight key considerations were derived, highlighting dilemmas related to feedstock selection, regulations, material properties, the mass balance approach, costs, consumer perception, recovery strategies, and biodegradability. The study presents guidance to support product developers in navigating these considerations and making informed decisions. Results highlight the importance of early-stage life cycle thinking and interdisciplinary collaboration. Despite challenges, bio-based plastics can contribute to circular product development when supported by dedicated investments in knowledge and time to, for example, source bio-based plastics with low environmental impact and explore new design opportunities with novel bio-based plastics. The findings offer both theoretical insight and guidance for product developers aiming to incorporate bio-based plastics in their products. ...

How smart TV design affects recyclability in practice

Understanding how product design shapes recycling outcomes is becoming increasingly important as the demand for recyclable electronics grows. This study investigates how design choices influence recyclability through an analysis of four commercially available smart TVs from major brands. We conducted manual disassembly and controlled shredding tests to explore how materials and connections behave under realistic recycling conditions.Our findings show that recyclability is mainly limited by plastics that are seldom recovered in practice, even when recyclable in principle. Most connections broke down effectively during shredding, with limited material losses. Some design features, however, still hindered recovery, such as ductile materials that trap others. Based on these findings, we propose design guidelines and compare them with existing literature. Our work contributes to the growing body of research linking product design with current recycling processes and can inform design practice and future regulations that support a more circular electronics industry. ...

Criteria for High-Quality Design for Recycling Methods †

Electronics recycling aims at the recovery of materials from obsolete electronic products, containing valuable, harmful, and polluting materials. While product design can improve recyclability, a gap remains between design and recycling practices. This study assessed the quality of published Design for Recycling (DfR) methods for electronics to develop criteria for high-quality methods. A systematic review of 30 years of the literature identified 16 distinct methods, which were evaluated for completeness, practical applicability, and alignment with recycling practices. The review shows major gaps in method development and validation, with few methods being tested in design practice or validated by recycling experiments. Based on these findings, we propose criteria emphasizing aspects such as design practitioner involvement, integration with recycling practice, adaptability, and clear documentation. This study shows the need for practical and accessible methods that bridge the gap between design and recycling. ...
Conference paper (2026) - D.C. van Dolderen, C.A. Bakker, A. R. Balkenende
Electronic waste is one of the fastest-growing waste streams, yet only a small fraction is properly recycled. Many challenges in recycling originate in product design; for example the choice of materials and joining methods. This paper presents the first version of the Design for Recycling of Electronics Guide, developed to bridge
the gap between design and recycling practice. Based on case studies, shredding experiments, and method reviews,it provides practical guidance to help designers anticipate and improve recyclability during product development. ...
In contrast to most plastics, ambiently biodegradable (AB) plastics fully break down under natural conditions, avoiding microplastic pollution. This study takes a research-through-design approach to explore how we might use AB plastics in durable products that wear down, and how this affects their design. Through speculative design explorations of diverse cases, we developed a preliminary design framework that introduces a novel approach to integrating AB plastics into sustainable product design. Our study addresses the tension between the durability of products and the temporality of biodegradable plastics, which must break down under ambient conditions to prevent microplastic pollution. We explored the current limitations of AB plastics, including their mechanical properties and the challenges they pose when used in real-world conditions. While the analysis is explorative and not exhaustive, our findings indicate that AB plastics have the potential to serve as a viable solution for reducing microplastic pollution in applications where microplastic release is unavoidable. We also stress the importance of designing with circular design principles to ensure high-value recovery pathways are prioritized over biodegradation whenever possible. The study concludes by emphasizing the need for continued collaboration among product designers, material scientists, and biodegradation experts to further optimize the properties and applications of AB plastics, suggesting that practical testing and case studies will be key to advancing their use in sustainable product design. ...
Journal article (2026) - Julieta Bolaños Arriola, Emilia Ingemarsdotter, Conny Bakker, Ruud Balkenende
Non-professional repairs could contribute to an increase in repairs, supporting circular economy goals, yet they raise safety concerns. While recent regulatory actions promote repair, they focus mainly on advancing access to professional repair, rather than enabling repairs by non-professionals, such as consumers and volunteers. This study investigates how product design can mitigate repair safety risks and contribute to safe non-professional repairs. In this exploratory research, a washing machine and a washer-dryer combo were analyzed through repeated disassembly and reassembly to identify mechanical, electrical, thermal, and chemical risks occurring during and after repair, as well as risk-inducing and risk-preventing design features and product architecture. Identified risk-inducing features include exposed components, vulnerable electrical and water connections, lack of reassembly guidance, and differences between disassembly and reassembly sequences. Based on the analysis insights, we developed a first version of a method for identifying, assessing, and mitigating repair safety risks. The method provides elements to visualize repair safety risks as an additional layer on disassembly maps and preliminary design recommendations to mitigate risk. The repair-risk mapping method aims to support designers in analyzing and anticipating repair safety risks and identifying relevant risk-inducing design features. Our findings show that relatively small design interventions, such as visual guidance, reusable connectors, robust connections, and enforced disassembly and reassembly sequences, can reduce risks and make repairs more accessible to non-professionals. Our research suggests that product design plays a crucial role in expanding repair opportunities to a broader range of users while maintaining safety. ...
Existing material selection methods seem to offer limited support for addressing substance safety in practice, as the focus remains on intrinsic material properties and less on exposure risk. This hinders Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) efforts that can prevent use and accumulation of substances of concern (SoCs) across product lifecycles in a circular economy. This study reviews 29 sustainable material selection methods to evaluate how they do support substance safety. Results show that substance safety is generally embedded within the broader sustainability realm without explicit risk or lifecycle-based assessment. Of the four steps that can be distinguished in material selection, most methods support the steps ‘Establishing a set of candidates’ and ‘Comparing candidates’ but the steps ‘Formulating selection criteria’ and ‘Choosing suitable candidates’ are often unsupported, leaving critical substance safety trade-offs unaddressed. The importance of mindsets such as systemic thinking and iterative reflection is recognized but underrepresented. The findings highlight the need to adapt existing methods with better guidance and risk integration to advance SSbD in material selection. ...
Repair plays a pivotal role in the circular economy, but evaluating repairability factors such as disassembly times can be complex and time consuming. Existing tools listing proxy times to avoid such measurements had limited libraries of activities, only relevant to ICT product fasteners, and reassembly times were neglected or assumed to be equal to disassembly times, which is not always true. This study introduces the Disassembly and Reassembly Time (DaRT) model: a simplified, time-based tool developed from over 10,000 data points on many connection types from several household products, generating proxy times for many more activities applicable to many more product types. It also compared median times for disassembly and reassembly, showing which tasks are similar enough to use the same proxy time, while highlighting occasional differences, such as part-handling steps. Validated through comparisons with independent disassembly data for vacuum cleaners, washing machines, and smart TVs, DaRT demonstrates strong correlation and minimal bias. Balancing ease of use with reliability, it outperforms simpler step-count methods and offers greater practicality than the complex eDiM. Overall, DaRT enhances repair scoring systems, guides design for repair, and fosters a more circular electronics industry, ultimately fueling more sustainable innovation. ...
Journal article (2026) - Niklas Engberg, Carlos Felipe Blanco, Valerio Barbarossa, Conny Bakker, Ruud Balkenende, Justin Z. Lian, Benjamin Sprecher
Recent research has emphasized the need to adapt life cycle inventories and life cycle impact assessments to account for changes in future scenarios. This is mostly achieved by using Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs), which combine environmental and economic data to develop prospective life cycle inventories (LCIs). However, running complex IAMs to simulate scenarios is computationally expensive, and the resulting data is not always aligned with the geographical scope of background inventories. This study explores the potential of machine learning (ML) to create prospective water-scarcity characterisation factors by forecasting the AWARE factor for ~ 9700 watersheds globally. Historical time series of water-scarcity characterisation factors are generated using the global freshwater model WaterGAP v2.2d and the AWARE method. Several ML models are trained on these historical datasets and benchmarked using symmetric mean absolute percentage error (sMAPE). The best-performing model, N-Beats, is then used to forecast AWARE values through 2032. The results demonstrate that ML can produce spatially and temporally explicit forecasts with reasonable accuracy (median sMAPE ~ 28%). However, the models primarily capture seasonal patterns rather than long-term structural trends and the results are sensitive to the quality and representativeness of the training data. This study highlights both the potential and the limitations of time series forecasting for developing prospective characterisation factors in life cycle assessment. ...

Plastics

Book chapter (2025) - Ruud Balkenende, Jeremy Faludi, Conny Bakker
Review (2025) - Benedetta Rotondo, Conny Bakker, Ruud Balkenende, Venanzio Arquilla
Nowadays, the circular economy represents a promising strategy for achieving sustainable development through optimising resource efficiency, extending product lifespans, and reducing environmental impacts. Despite the growing interest in circular design practices, companies often face difficulties integrating these principles into their established New Product Development (NPD) processes. This is mainly due to the overwhelming number of available design tools and methods, which are fragmented, challenging to navigate, overlap in functionality, and lack standardisation. This study provides a comprehensive mapping, classification, and analysis of 77 existing circular design tools identified through a systematic literature review and supplementary online searches. The tools were systematically categorised according to format, data type, industry sector, circular strategies, innovation focus, aims, and applicability across the NPD stages. The results indicate a predominance of physical, qualitative, and sector-agnostic tools, emphasising circularity integration within the Discover, Define, and Develop phases of the design process. This structured classification facilitates stakeholder navigation of existing resources, highlighting opportunities for more targeted, industry-specific tool development, consumer-oriented approaches, and the importance of considering Industry 4.0 technologies in circular design practice. Future research could address these gaps by developing customised frameworks, validating tool effectiveness through real industrial applications, and promoting deeper integration of circular design tools within NPD practices and business objectives. ...

Design for Recycling

Book chapter (2025) - Ruud Balkenende, Jeremy Faludi

How to balance Repair and Recycling

The short lifespans and rapid innovation cycles of electronic products result in the loss of valuable and critical resources (Bakker, Wang, Huisman, & den Hollander, 2014; Baldé et al., 2024). Strategies aimed at extending product lifetimes, such as design for repair, focus on improving the ease of manual disassembly (De Fazio, Bakker, Flipsen, & Balkenende, 2021). However, connections optimized for repairability can hinder the mechanical separation of materials during recycling. This highlights a critical trade-off: improving repairability can often conflict with recyclability, emphasizing the need for balanced design approaches that address both recovery goals. Navigating these trade-offs requires a deeper understanding of how materials and connection types in electronics affect circular strategies. This research aims to investigate tensions between repairability and recyclability by analyzing a diverse set of electronic products and relating the findings to their design architecture. This study seeks to inform design strategies that optimize for both repairability and recyclability, thus prolonging product lifetime while minimizing resource losses at end-of-life. ...

Introduction

Book chapter (2025) - Jeremy Faludi, Ruud Balkenende, Conny Bakker
The increasing digitisation that we have witnessed in the past few years has resulted in increased information and communications technology (ICT) hardware manufacturing, which is not sustainable due to the growing demand for critical materials and the greenhouse emissions associated with it. A solution is transitioning to a circular economy (CE). To facilitate this, boost the data economy and digital innovation, the European Union has introduced digital product passports (DPPs), which should provide information about a product’s lifetime to bring more transparency into supply chains. However, several challenges, namely the lack of findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable ICT and materials data and tools to support its interpretation for decision-making, are present. Utilising ontologies and knowledge graphs is a possible solution. Although the ontology work in the ICT and materials domains has been on the rise, there is a lack of a unified semantic model that can capture the complex, heterogeneous cross-domain data needed for building DPPs of ICT devices such as laptops and data servers. Motivated by this, we present the RePlanIT ontology for ICT DPPs, which captures knowledge on several levels – ICT device, hardware components, materials and the CE itself. RePlanIT’s specification is based on a literature survey, interviews and inputs from domain experts from both industry and academia. The ontology, its utilisation for building a knowledge graph of DPPs of laptops and data servers and its application have been successfully validated in a real-world case focusing on supporting more sustainable ICT procurement in government. ...