Circular Image

E.C. Slob

info

Please Note

134 records found

Subsurface electrical conductivity models from frequency-domain electromagnetic (FDEM) induction measurements are often derived using computationally efficient one-dimensional piecewise inversion (PWI) approaches. However, PWI does not account for lateral conductivity variations or the measurement overlap between adjacent soundings, which can limit model estimation accuracy. Laterally constrained inversion (LCI) introduces smoothness constraints to reduce lateral variability between neighbouring models, potentially improving continuity. In this study, both PWI and LCI use a 1D forward function, assuming a horizontally layered earth, and a horizontally laying rigid boom instrument, to perform the estimations This study presents a detailed analysis of how various 2.5D and 3D conductivity distributions, including topographic variations and instrument pitch angle, affect FDEM measurements. We examine how these measurement distortions propagate into PWI and LCI inversion results. Under ideal conditions, such as flat terrain, no instrument tilt, and simple two-layer models, both methods recover accurate conductivity structures, with LCI offering little advantage in accuracy. When topography is introduced, however, distortions occur even at slopes as small as 2°, and both methods show degraded performance, particularly in 3D scenarios. In the field example, LCI produces smoother and more stable results than PWI in the presence of noise, but its assumption of lateral smoothness can be restrictive in geologically complex settings. Our findings show that both inversion strategies are sensitive to topographic and 3D effects, and that error propagation significantly influences inversion reliability. These results highlight the need for improved methodologies capable of handling realistic acquisition conditions and measurement uncertainties in FDEM surveys. ...
Journal article (2026) - David Bruhn, Hemmo A. Abels, Patrick Fulton, Virginie Harcouët-Menou Harcouët-Menou, Ernst Huenges, Stefan Jansen, Alexis Koulidis, Susanne Laumann, Haiyan Lei, Joseph Moore, Paula Rulff, Thorben Schöfisch, Auke Barnhoorn, Evert Slob, Philip J. Vardon, Liliana Vargas Meleza, Denis Voskov, Claire Bossennec, Aoife K. Braiden, Maren Brehme, Romain Chassagne, Alexandros Daniilidis, Mathieu Darnet, Guy Drijkoningen
Low-enthalpy geothermal heat production is becoming increasingly common, which leads to the potentially competitive use of the available subsurface space, especially in densely populated urban areas. A specific challenge presented by the high density of different geothermal systems is understanding the details of convective and conductive heat flow processes and detailed monitoring of properties and processes in the subsurface.

On the TU Delft campus, we aim to drill a borehole of around 4.5 km depth to be used for the exploration, observation, and monitoring of subsurface processes that will be part of a larger research infrastructure under development. This so-called urban energy laboratory includes – in addition to the deep multi-use borehole – a well-instrumented geothermal doublet drilled in 2023, reaching to a depth of 2.2 km; a local seismic monitoring system (installed in 2022); an ultra-sensitive portable seismic monitoring array; and a high-temperature aquifer heat storage system (HT-ATES), for which a pilot well was drilled in 2024. With this urban energy laboratory, we want to tackle problems and better understand processes related to multiple and/or competing subsurface uses in urban environments. The deep exploration and monitoring borehole is designed specifically to monitor fluid and/or flux movement in 3D with unprecedented precision, aiming to understand the propagation of the geothermal cold front and reservoir pressures.

During the 3 d International Continental Scientific Drilling Program (ICDP)-sponsored UrbEnLab workshop, 75 scientists from 17 countries met in Delft, the Netherlands, in June 2024 to prioritize the scientific ambitions of the deep exploration and monitoring borehole and to discuss potential techniques that could be applied to tackle them. Assessing the life cycle of a geothermal system situated in a complex heterogeneous sedimentary system was defined as the broad aim, with revealing the detailed flow field established being a key priority. ...

A new approach based on cumulative resistance models

Journal article (2025) - Oscar I. Calderon Hernandez, L. Rondoni, E. C. Slob, L. V. Socco
Magnetotelluric (MT) data inversion seeks to recover resistivity models of the subsurface. Solving the inversion problem is a non-trivial task, as multiple plausible solutions can be recovered due to the nonlinearity of the problem. To reduce this nonlinearity, we propose a data-driven approach where a 1-D cumulative resistance model is estimated from MT data via a direct data transformation. We define the cumulative representation of layered models as the weighted sum of layer thickness divided by resistivity from surface to any depth level, which is the cumulative conductance. Its inverse, cumulative resistance, is directly related to the real part of the impedance computed from MT data. We train a neural network to transform the MT impedance into a resistance model. The corresponding 1-D resistivity model is obtained without a priori information. We validate our approach using synthetic and real data, opening the discussion for future developments of this new perspective. ...
Conference paper (2025) - S. Harajchi, E.C. Slob
Accurate monitoring of railway ballast and embankments is critical for ensuring stability and safety in railway operations. Ground Penetrating Radar has emerged as a powerful non-destructive tool for characterizing ballast and underlying layers, particularly in estimating layer thickness. The ballast layer is modeled as a heterogeneous layer with pieces of rock and as a homogenized layer represented by a single relative permittivity value using the complex refractive index model. Numerical simulations were performed to evaluate the effects of ballast heterogeneity, layer composition, and thickness on expected reflection data. The results indicate that while homogeneous models are computationally efficient, they fail to capture the intrinsic scattering and attenuation effects of realistic ballast geometries, particularly under variable substructure configurations. The results suggest that laboratory measurements can be performed to understand the quality of the current state of the numerical models. ...
Conference paper (2025) - S. Harajchi, E.C. Slob
Railway ballast is essential for maintaining track stability, ensuring proper drainage, and efficiently distributing loads across the track bed. Regular monitoring of ballast conditions is crucial for the safety and durability of railway infrastructure. Ground Penetrating Radar is commonly employed to assess ballast conditions; however, its signals can be significantly affected by structural elements such as sleepers, which may distort signal propagation due to their material properties. Specifically, reinforced concrete sleepers with embedded metal reinforcement contribute to additional attenuation and scattering, complicating signal interpretation. Numerical simulations using the Finite-Difference Time-Domain method were conducted to model wave propagation in three configurations: no sleeper, pure concrete sleeper, and reinforced concrete sleeper. Simulations at 1 GHz and 400 MHz frequencies reveal that reinforced concrete sleepers significantly enhance signal reflections and introduce complex scattering, particularly at higher frequencies. These results exhibit frequency-dependent behavior, where higher frequencies provide better resolution but also more signal distortion caused by the sleeper material. The study offers valuable insights into optimizing GPR signal interpretation in railway ballast inspections and emphasizes the importance of considering sleeper type and frequency selection in data acquisition and processing. ...
Conference paper (2025) - Marios Karaoulis, Nectaria Diamanti, Chris Bremmer, Evert Slob, Dominique Ngan-Tillard, Pantelis Karamitopoulos
Large areas behind the historic quay walls and bridges in Amsterdam city center are prone to soil mobilization and cavity (sinkhole) formation due to intensified infrastructure developments and extreme groundwater level fluctuations caused by climate change. We carried out a geophysical survey to investigate a sinkhole formed under the Muntplein (Amsterdam, The Netherlands). The surface trace (hole) of the sinkhole was triggered by a heavy vehicle passing over the street which lies in the vicinity of a quay wall and behind the abutment of the Muntsluis bridge. The application of ground penetrating radar (GPR) and electric resistivity tomography (ERT) provided continuous data of the shallow subsurface which enabled the detection of the backfilled cavity, its southwest (SW) extension, the bridge abutment-to-soil transition, key utility lines and the presence of two potential targets for further investigation. A follow-up geotechnical assessment supported by hydrographic survey in the canal validated our findings and substantiated our first interpretation (i.e., sinkhole in development). The paper demonstrates the applicability of non-invasive electromagnetic (EM) methods to rapidly detect cavities in critical urban areas, and, thus, to de-risk climate-smart infrastructure developments. ...
Monitoring temperature changes in geothermal applications is crucial to ensure sustainable heat production and storage operations. This work focuses on a geothermal project situated on the campus of Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands. In connection to deep low-enthalpy geothermal reservoir exploration, an aquifer thermal energy storage system for the purpose of seasonal shallow heat storage is planned. To enable monitoring changes in the electrical resistivity distribution due to heat injection and extraction operations in the shallow subsurface, a new 480 m deep borehole will be equipped with an electrode setup. Measuring the vertical component of the electric field in the borehole using a frequency-domain surface-to-borehole controlled-source electromagnetic setup is particular effective for monitoring reservoir changes. Due to corrosion effects, conventional electrodes have rather limited lifespans, which may not be sufficient for the multi-decade operational plan for this geothermal application.
We use a new approach integrating capacitive electrodes in composite borehole casings. Tests in shallow boreholes have shown comparable results to standard electrodes. Integrating the capacitive sensors in the composite borehole casing is rather time- and cost-intense requiring pre-drilling installation and specially designed electronics. Therefore, we want to optimise the electrode placement along the borehole trajectory. We simulate vertical electric fields at closely spaced receivers along the borehole trajectory for different subsurface scenarios originating from resistivity changes introduced by injecting and extracting hot fluids. Applying the Ramer–Douglas–Peucker algorithm, we determine which electrode locations and combinations are optimal to record resulting variations in the vertical electric field component. The proposed methodology for optimal electrode placement is promising to improve monitoring efficiency in geothermal applications, ensuring sustainable and effective operation over extended periods. ...
Electromagnetic induction measurements from multi-coil configuration instruments are used to obtain information about the electrical conductivity distribution in the subsurface. The resulting inverse problem might not have a unique and stable solution. In that case, a local inversion method can be trapped in a local minimum and lead to an incorrect solution. In this study, we evaluate the well-posedness of the inverse problem for two and three-layered electrical conductivity models. We show that for a two-layered model, uniqueness is ensured only when both in-phase and quadrature data are available from the measurements. Results from a Gauss–Newton inversion and a lookup table demonstrate that the solution space is convex. Furthermore, we demonstrate that for even a simple three-layered model, the data contained in such measurements are insufficient to reach a correct or stable solution. For models with more than 2 layers, independent prior information is necessary to solve the inverse problem. The insights from the numerical examples are applied in a field case. ...
In agriculture, there is a demand for new methods to monitor the dynamics of fresh rainwater lenses overlaying on saline seeping groundwater. For this purpose, integrating different geoelectrical measurements is a non-invasive and low-cost approach to obtaining subsurface information. Geoelectric methods such as electromagnetic induction (EMI) and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) have proven effective in characterizing subsoil electrical properties, which can be correlated to petrophysical properties such as fluid salinity. These methods have different sensitivities and can provide complementary information about the electrical conductivity and geometry of the subsurface. This study explores the effectiveness of a methodology that combines EMI measurements with laterally constrained inversion as prior information for ERT inversion. We investigate the usefulness of the method using synthetic data and data from a coastal Dutch polder system. The findings are promising, demonstrating improved delineation of changes in electrical conductivity, potentially linked with salinity fluctuations in the subsoil. This methodology proves effective in mapping in-depth variations in electrical conductivity. It could facilitate the impact assessment of level-controlled drainage systems on augmenting shallow rainwater lenses and mitigating salinization in Dutch polders. ...
The data assimilation process for geothermal reservoirs often relies on well data, which primarily offer insights into the immediate vicinity of the borehole. However, integrating geophysical methods can provide valuable information beyond well proximity, possibly enhancing reservoir predictions. Current methods of monitoring geothermal reservoirs struggle to maintain a good signal-to-noise ratio for deep reservoirs. Diffusive electromagnetic (EM) methods can be sensitive to the decreasing conductivity from heat extraction in geothermal reservoirs and offer promising additional value. To test their potential effectiveness, numerical examples are simulated. A scheme to incorporate diffusive EM observations into a data assimilation process for geothermal reservoirs is presented and implemented in this study. First, an ensemble of prior models representing the reservoir uncertainty is used to determine the moments of the resulting temperature field using a forward geothermal simulation. Subsequently, a conductivity model is calculated from the temperature field using an empirical relationship. The expected electric field response can then be simulated using an EM forward model. EM sources are placed on the surface around the expected cold plume location. The receiver is placed at reservoir depth. To assimilate the data, the ensemble smoother with multiple data assimilation method is used. The findings demonstrate that the incorporation of EM data provides valuable information regarding the temperature field. This improves the accuracy of the temperature forecast of the entire reservoir when combined with the localized data from the production well and, therefore, helps to resolve the complex migration of the cold front. These results highlight the monitoring potential of EM observations for geothermal reservoirs. ...
Journal article (2023) - J. Hunziker, E. C. Slob, J. Irving
Modeling ground penetrating radar (GPR) reflection data on glaciers with methods that require the discretization of the full subsurface domain is extremely computationally expensive because of the combination of a large domain size and the comparatively short wavelength of the signal. To address this issue, we build on and extend a previously proposed approach based on the assumption of a homogeneous background medium (ice) in which various scattering objects (e.g., crevasses, channels, boulders) are embedded far from each other such that multiple scattering can be ignored. The glacier bed, below which no scatterers are assumed to exist, represents the lower limit of the modeling domain. With this method, the two-way propagation of the radar waves through the ice is simulated in a semi-analytical way, whereby scattering surfaces are represented with a set of planar elements of different electric and reflective properties, allowing a wide range of objects to be simulated. As we also take the antenna radiation pattern at the air-ice interface into account, this simple algorithm is able to produce realistic 3D GPR data in a fast and memory efficient way. In this study, we validate the presented algorithm with an analytical solution for a layered model, and we simulate radar data for a model of the Otemma glacier in Switzerland featuring a realistic topography of the glacier bed and a subglacial channel. ...
Conference paper (2023) - K. Wapenaar, J. Brackenhoff, S. De Ridder, E. Slob, R. Snieder
Green’s functions and propagator matrices are both solutions of the wave equation, but whereas Green’s functions obey a causality condition in time (G = 0 for t < 0), propagator matrices obey a boundary condition in space. Marchenko-type focusing functions focus a wave field in space at zero time. We discuss the mutual relations between Green’s functions, propagator matrices and focusing functions, avoiding up-down decomposition and accounting for propagating and evanescent waves. We conclude with discussing a Marchenko-type Green’s function representation, which forms a basis for extending the Marchenko method to improve the imaging of steeply dipping flanks and to account for refracted waves. ...
Journal article (2023) - Jian Huang, Xi Yang, Feng Zhou, Xiaofeng Li, Bin Zhou, Song Lu, Sergey Ivashov, Iraklis Giannakis, Fannian Kong, Evert Slob
It is not practical to obtain a large number of labeled data to train a supervised learning network in tunnel lining nondestructive testing with ground-penetrating radar (GPR). To decrease the dependence of supervised learning on the number of labeled data, an improved self-supervised learning algorithm—self-attention dense contrastive learning (SA-DenseCL)—is proposed and incorporated with a mask region-convolution neural network (Mask R-CNN), which is trained by unlabeled and labeled GPR data. The proposed SA-DenseCL adds a self-attention-based relevant projection head to the DenseCL architecture of self-supervised learning, capturing the spatially continuing information between adjacent GPR traces. In the workflow, some unlabeled GPR images are used to pre-train the SA-DenseCL network for feature extraction and obtaining the backbone weights, which is superior to the conventional pre-training methods of supervised learning pre-trained by ImageNet images. The weights of the pre-trained backbone are then used to initialize the Mask R-CNN through transfer learning. Subsequently, a limited number of labeled GPR images are used to fine-tune the Mask R-CNN for automatically identifying the locations of the reinforcement bars and voids and estimating the secondary lining thickness. The experimental results show that the average precision reaches 96.70%, 81.04%, and 94.67% in identifying reinforcement bar locations, detecting void defects, and estimating secondary lining thickness, respectively, which outperform the conventional methods that use ImageNet-based supervised learning or GPR image-based DenseCL for initializing the Mask R-CNN backbone weights. It is observed that the improved self-supervised learning-based framework can improve the detection and estimation accuracy in GPR tunnel lining inspection. ...
Journal article (2023) - Y. Li, E.C. Slob, D. Werthmüller, Lipeng Wang, Hailong Lu
Natural gas hydrates have been an unconventional source of energy since the beginning of this century. Gas-hydrate-filled reservoirs show higher resistivity values compared with water-filled sediments. Their presence can be detected using marine controlled-source electromagnetic methods. We classify acquisition configurations into stationary and moving receiver configurations, which are described in terms of the design group, the operational details, and where they have been used successfully in the field for natural gas hydrate exploration. All configurations showed good numerical results for the detection of a 700 m long gas hydrate reservoir buried 200 m below the seafloor, but only the stationary configurations provided data that can be used to estimate the horizontal boundaries of the resistive part of the reservoir when the burial depth is known from seismic data. We discuss the operational steps of the configurations and provide the steps on how to choose a suitable configuration. Different CSEM configurations were used together with seismic data to estimate the edge of the gas hydrate reservoir and the total volume of the gas hydrates, to optimize the drilling location, to increase production safety, and to improve geological interpretations. It seems that CSEM has become a reliable method to aid in the decision-making process for gas hydrate reservoir appraisal and development. ...
Conference paper (2023) - Kate Brooks, Deyan Draganov, Dominique Ngan-Tillard, Mark Lüschen, Coen Nienaber, Evert Slob
We conducted ground penetrating radar (GPR) surveys to detect the presence of simulated clandestine burials at the Amsterdam Research Initiative for Subsurface Taphonomy and Anthropology (ARISTA) test facility. Our aim is to determine the characteristic responses of the simulated clandestine burials in this man-made sandy environment (reclaimed land) and use them to provide recommendations for forensic investigations. We performed GPR surveys over three simulated clandestine burials at ARISTA during four non-consecutive days. The acquired data represent common-offset data to investigate changes to burial detectability depending on central antenna frequency (250 MHz and 500 MHz), different GPR instruments (NOGGIN or pulseEKKO), changes to survey grid orientation relative to burials, and increased soil moisture content in the survey area. In common-offset radargrams the burial anomalies take on many forms, appearing as disruptions to existing features (direct-wave arrivals and soil horizons) and as isolated reflection events (hyperbolic events and burial-length horizontal anomalies). In time slices, the burials are characterized by high- or low-amplitude rectangular anomalies. When used in conjunction, the radargrams and time slices produce characteristic responses consistent with the locations of the burials, regardless of the survey grid orientation. Increased soil moisture at the site improves the detectability of the burials. ...
Conference paper (2023) - M. Carrizo Mascarell, D. Werthmüller, E. Slob
Rigid boom electromagnetic surveys that use coil-coil configurations are often used to obtain information about the subsurface conductivity. Semi-analytic solutions help to simulate electromagnetic induction measurements for a large number of horizontally layered models, which can then be stored and used as a lookup table. This procedure is performed once and then used to find the corresponding model that produces the best data fit, eliminating the need for running numerous simulations in every minimization step of an inversion scheme for large field datasets. We apply this methodology to a numerical example and field data acquired in The Netherlands. Our results from both cases using the global search demonstrate its ability to estimate electrical conductivity distributions in two-layered models in a fast and accurate manner. Furthermore, we apply the workflow using a lookup table based on low induction number approximation-derived measurements. The outcome of implementing this methodology using the low induction number lookup table shows poor accuracy in the electrical conductivity estimations for both the numerical example and the field data in comparison to the semi-analytical approach. ...
Journal article (2023) - Feng Zhou, Iraklis Giannakis, Antonios Giannopoulos, Klaus Holliger, Evert Slob
In hydrocarbon drilling, mud filtrate penetrates permeable formations and alters the pore fluid characteristics in the immediate vicinity of the borehole. Typically, the prevailing in situ pore fluids are displaced by the invading mud filtrate, which leads to gradually changing distributions of the fluid and electrical properties. Understanding this invasion process is crucial for the interpretation of logging data and associated reservoir evaluations. Conventional logging methods tend to be inadequate for this purpose as their resolution is too low. We find that invasion depth can be determined from borehole radar data using an optimized antenna configuration and time-lapse measurements. A series of parametric sensitivity analyses provide information about the effects of variations of the rock and fluid properties on the identification and extraction of borehole radar signals reflected from the invasion front. Our results suggest that by embedding the radar antennas in cavities filled with an absorbing dielectric material, it is possible to minimize the interference arising from the metal components of the logging tool. In the simulated reservoir scenario, a time-lapse measurement mode with a time interval of at least 6 h can reliably extract the radar signals reflected from the invasion front, and the proposed borehole radar has a lateral detection range from 0.15 to 1 m. A comprehensive range of parametric sensitivity analyses indicates that the signals reflected from the invasion front are principally influenced by oil viscosity, porosity, and mud and formation water salinity, as well as by molecular diffusion coefficient and cementation exponent. These properties and parameters should be carefully explored and assessed when applying borehole radar to evaluate mud invasion information in a reservoir environment. ...
Tracking temperature changes by measuring the resulting resistivity changes inside low-enthalpy reservoirs is crucial to avoid early thermal breakthroughs and maintain sustainable energy production. The controlled-source electromagnetic method (CSEM) allows for the estimation of sub-surface resistivity. However, it has not yet been proven that the CSEM can monitor the subtle resistivity changes typical of low-enthalpy reservoirs. In this paper, we present a feasibility study considering the CSEM monitoring of 4–8 Ω·m resistivity changes in a deep low-enthalpy reservoir model, as part of the Delft University of Technology (TU Delft) campus geothermal project. We consider the use of a surface-to-borehole CSEM for the detection of resistivity changes in a simplified model of the TU Delft campus reservoir. We investigate the sensitivity of CSEM data to disk-shaped resistivity changes with a radius of 300, 600, 900, or 1200 m at return temperatures equal to 25, 30, …, 50 °C. We test the robustness of CSEM monitoring against various undesired effects, such as random noise, survey repeatability errors, and steel-cased wells. The modelled differences in the electric field suggest that they are sufficient for the successful CSEM detection of resistivity changes in the low-enthalpy reservoir. The difference in monitoring data increases when increasing the resistivity change radius from 300 to 1200 m or from 4 to 8 Ω·m. Furthermore, all considered changes lead to differences that would be detectable in CSEM data impacted by undesired effects. The obtained results indicate that the CSEM could be a promising geophysical tool for the monitoring of small resistivity changes in low-enthalpy reservoirs, which would be beneficial for geothermal energy production. ...
Journal article (2023) - Leon Diekmann, Ivan Vasconcelos, Kees Wapenaar, Evert Slob, Roel Snieder
Marchenko-type integrals typically relate so-called focusing functions and Green's functions via the reflection response measured on the open surface of a volume of interest. Originating from one dimensional inverse scattering theory, the extension to two and three dimensions set in motion various new developments regarding imaging in complex materials. This extension, however, is based on wavefield decomposition inside the volume and a truncated medium state, i.e. a version of the medium that is reflection-free underneath the focusing location, suggesting that evanescent, refracted and diving waves cannot be included in the representation. We elaborate on a new derivation for Marchenko-like integrals that (i) extends the concept of wavefield focusing by using a generalised homogeneous Green's function, (ii) is based on partial differential equations and thereby allows for additional insights and a new physical intuition for Marchenko equations, (iii) unifies wavefield focusing for open and closed boundary systems, (iv) does not require wavefield decomposition or a truncated medium state, thus including the full wavefield Green's function, (v) enables using forward modelling to obtain, e.g., Marchenko-type, time-compact focusing functions. We place a particular focus on the latter point, illustrating and investigating how to solve the underlying partial differential equations for various types of focusing functions. This paves the way for a deeper understanding of focusing functions as well as advanced full wavefield Marchenko schemes. While the derivations are generally presented for the 3D case, we show numerical examples in 1D. ...
Conference paper (2023) - O.I. Calderon Hernandez, L.V. Socco, E. Slob
This study presents a novel methodology to transform 1D resistivity data into layered resistivity models without prior information by using the concept of cumulative reference models. The proposed methodology involves deriving an error function that transforms apparent resistance measurements into a cumulative resistance, which is then transformed into a layered resistivity model. We applied the methodology to simulated data from various 1D models with different physical parameters, and the results demonstrate that our method can be used to directly transform the data into a layered resistivity model without requiring prior information. This methodology provides a valuable alternative to inversion methods when one local model is available and multiple measurements are available over an area with similar physical parameters. Furthermore, the retrieved rescaled model can be used as a reference model for the inversion process, reducing computational and economic costs. This study highlights the potential of cumulative reference models for subsurface characterization, providing a new paradigm to study the subsurface with increased efficiency. ...