DD

David Dubbeldam

info

Please Note

24 records found

Journal article (2026) - Eric Johnsson, Shrinjay Sharma, Arvind Gangoli Rao, David Dubbeldam, Sofia Calero, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Hydroisomerization of alkane isomers is an important step in the manufacture of current kerosene and sustainable aviation fuels. Zeolites are used as acid catalysts in this process. It is therefore important to have predictions of the adsorption capacity or maximum loading of hydrocarbons in zeolites. Here, a cascade model using machine learning models is used to predict the maximum loading of alkane isomers in zeolites. The cascade is composed of a gradient-boosted tree classifier stage that predicts whether adsorption occurs and a regressor predicting the value of the maximum loading. The final data set consists of 45 different adsorbates (both linear and branched alkanes up to C16) and 97 different zeolite structures, resulting in 4365 data points. Descriptors include information on the geometry and topology of zeolite channels as well as the shape and size of the adsorbates. Extra composite descriptors are also present to provide the physical basis for predictions. Multiple regressors of different natures are considered: support vector regressors, gradient-boosted trees, extreme gradient-boosted trees, and the TabPFN pretrained model. TabPFN yields the highest generalization performance and the lowest error. An interpretability analysis using SHAP reveals that the most influential descriptors are physically meaningful, highlighting steric and volumetric constraints as the primary factors controlling the prediction of qmax. It is shown that despite both the classifier and the regressor being insensitive to random splits in data, the regressor is prone to overfitting at low fractions of data withheld for testing. The cascade model is compared to an Artificial Neural Network for training and resource efficiency. Despite training being longer for the neural network, the final model is lighter in both memory and storage. This work is built on our previous research in predicting the Henry coefficients of long-chain alkanes in zeolites. Using this previous model and the findings of this work, one could construct the adsorption isotherm for any alkane, thus enabling the analysis of adsorption behavior of alkane mixtures using IAST. ...
Journal article (2025) - David Dubbeldam, Sofia Calero, Randall Q. Snurr, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
In the days prior to the Thermodynamics2024 conference in Delft (The Netherlands), the annual RASPA workshop/school took place at Delft University of Technology with 55 participants (both industry and academics) from all over the world. RASPA is a popular open-source molecular simulation software package for studying adsorption and diffusion in fluids and nanoporous materials, and it is especially popular in the metal-organic frameworks and zeolite communities. The main contributors to RASPA (and organisers of the RASPA workshop/school in Delft) are David Dubbeldam, Sofia Calero, Randall Q. Snurr, and Thijs J.H. Vlugt. In this short paper, we briefly explain the history of RASPA and the RASPA workshops, as well as our strategy to teach the workshop participants how to use RASPA for their specific research projects. ...
Journal article (2025) - Youri A. Ran, Joseph Tapia, Shrinjay Sharma, Peng Bai, Sofia Calero, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, David Dubbeldam
Adsorption simulations often assume a rigid framework, which can be exploited by replacing the expensive framework-adsorbate energy/force evaluation by interpolation of a precomputed energy grid. We present the implementation in RASPA3 of a triquintic interpolation algorithm by Boateng and Bradach and compare it to the tricubic algorithm of Lekien and Marsden. We extended the scheme to interpolation in fractional space to facilitate interpolation of non-rectangular frameworks and evaluated the accuracy. We find that the use of grids is advantageous for larger systems and/or large cutoffs, but generally the efficiency gains are modest (a factor of 2–5). ...
Journal article (2025) - S. Sharma, Ping Yang, David Dubbeldam, T.J.H. Vlugt, Yachan Liu, K.R. Rossi, Peng Bai, Marcello Rigutto, Erik Zuidema, Umang Agarwal, Richard Baur, Sofía Calero
Shape-selective adsorption in zeolites plays a pivotal role in catalytic hydroisomerization of long-chain alkanes, a key process in producing sustainable aviation fuels from Fischer–Tropsch products. Accurately predicting adsorption behavior for the large number of alkane isomers in different zeolite frameworks is computationally intensive. To address this, we have developed a machine learning framework that rapidly and accurately predicts Henry coefficients of linear (C1–C30) and branched (C4–C20) alkanes in one-dimensional zeolites. Using descriptors based on chain length, branching patterns, and molecular graphs, we evaluate multiple ML models, including Random Forest, XGBoost, CatBoost, TabPFN, and D-MPNN in MTT-, MTW-, MRE-, and AFI-type zeolites. TabPFN and D-MPNN offer the highest predictive accuracy. Active learning further boosts model performance by efficiently selecting diverse and structurally informative isomers. We also uncover activity cliffs, where small changes in molecular structure lead to sharp variations in adsorption, and demonstrate that targeted oversampling of these cases improves model robustness. Finally, we combine the ML-predicted Henry coefficients with gas-phase thermodynamics to compute reaction equilibrium distributions for C16 hydroisomerization. This integrated, data-driven approach enables efficient screening and design of shape-selective zeolite catalysts, thereby reducing the need for costly simulations ...
Journal article (2025) - Ziyan Li, Leonidas Constantinou, Richard Baur, David Dubbeldam, Sofia Calero, Shrinjay Sharma, Marcello Rigutto, Poulumi Dey, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Accurate prediction of thermodynamic properties of hydrocarbons is essential for chemical process modelling. Conventional group contribution methods often are used to predict these properties. However, these methods often require extensive parameter sets to handle structural complexities. A refined group contribution method for predicting thermodynamic properties of hydrocarbon isomers with reduced complexity and improved accuracy is presented and discussed. By combining the structural framework of Constantinou and Gani (CG94) with a sensitivity-based selection of second-order groups, a reduced yet highly effective set of twelve second-order groups is identified. This reduced set retains the predictive power comparable to more complex models while significantly reducing the number of parameters. Linear regression is applied to model enthalpies and Gibbs free energies of formation for a wide temperature range. To test broader applicability, the model is further extended to properties that require nonlinear regression, including critical temperatures, critical pressures, acentric factors, and liquid densities. For all cases, the proposed model achieves high predictive accuracy, demonstrating its robustness and generalizability. This methodology balances interpretability, efficiency, and performance, making it suitable for both research and industrial thermodynamic modelling. ...
Journal article (2025) - Ziyan Li, Leonidas Constantinou, Richard Baur, David Dubbeldam, Sofia Calero, Shrinjay Sharma, Marcello Rigutto, Poulumi Dey, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Group contribution methods (GCMs) provide a practical and computationally efficient approach for predicting thermodynamic properties of hydrocarbons, especially when experimental data are scarce. This review evaluates the evolution of GCMs from classical first-order schemes (e.g. Lydersen method, Joback method) to more advanced second-order frameworks (e.g. CG94, Sharma method), hybrid extensions, and emerging machine learning integrations. While first-order models are simple and widely used, these models struggle with branched and long-chain molecules. Second-order approaches significantly improve structural sensitivity and predictive accuracy, achieving deviations below 2–3% for critical properties and within 1 kcal/mol for formation enthalpies of branched alkanes. Nevertheless, challenges remain in extrapolating to highly complex molecules, underrepresented functional groups, and extreme conditions. Promising directions include reinforcement of second-order GCMs with molecular theory, systematic expansion of experimental and quantum-based datasets, and hybrid GCM–machine learning models that retain interpretability while improving generalisability. We recommend prioritising models that balance accuracy, robustness, simplicity, and transferability to accelerate sustainable process and product designs, particularly in applications such as fuel upgrading including hydroisomerisation, separation processes, and green chemical development. ...
Journal article (2024) - S. Sharma, Richard Baur, Marcello Rigutto, Erik Zuidema, Umang Agarwal, Sofía Calero, David Dubbeldam, T.J.H. Vlugt
Entropies for alkane isomers longer than C10 are computed using our recently developed linear regression model for thermochemical properties which is based on second-order group contributions. The computed entropies show excellent agreement with experimental data and data from Scott’s tables which are obtained from a statistical mechanics-based correlation. Entropy production and heat input are calculated for the hydroisomerization of C7 isomers in various zeolites (FAU-, ITQ-29-, BEA-, MEL-, MFI-, MTW-, and MRE-types) at 500 K at chemical equilibrium. Small variations in these properties are observed because of the differences in reaction equilibrium distributions for these zeolites. The effect of chain length on heat input and entropy production is also studied for the hydroisomerization of C7, C8, C10, and C14 isomers in MTW-type zeolite at 500 K. For longer chains, both heat input and entropy production increase. Enthalpies and absolute entropies of C7 hydroisomerization reaction products in MTW-type zeolite increase with higher temperatures. These findings highlight the accuracy of our linear regression model in computing entropies for alkanes and provide insight for designing and optimizing zeolite-catalyzed hydroisomerization processes. ...
Journal article (2024) - Dominika O. Wasik, José Manuel Vicent-Luna, Azahara Luna-Triguero, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, Sofía Calero
The series of metal–organic frameworks M-MOF-74 gained popularity in the field of capture and separation of CO2 due to the presence of numerous, highly reactive open-metal sites. The description of effective interactions between guest molecules and open-metal sites without accounting for polarization effects is challenging but it can significantly reduce the computational cost of simulations. In this study, we propose a non-polarizable force field for CO2, and H2 adsorption in M-MOF-74 (M = Ni, Cu, Co, Fe, Mn, Zn) by scaling the Coulombic interactions of M-MOF-74 atoms, and Lennard-Jones interaction potentials between the center of mass of H2 and the open-metal centers. The presented force field is based on UFF and DREIDING parameters, characterized by high transferability and efficiency. The quantum behavior of H2 at cryogenic temperatures is considered by incorporating Feynman–Hibbs quantum corrections. To validate the force field, the experimental isotherms of CO2 at 298 K and 10−1 – 102kPa, the isotherms of H2 at 77 K and 10−5 – 102kPa, the corresponding enthalpy of adsorption, and the binding geometries in the M-MOF-74 series were reproduced using Monte Carlo simulations in the grand-canonical ensemble. The computed loadings, heats of CO2 and H2 adsorption, and binding geometries in M-MOF-74 are in very good agreement with the experimental values. The temperature transferability of the force field from 77 K to 87 K, and 298 K was shown for adsorption of H2. The validated force field was used to study the adsorption and separation of CO2/H2 mixtures at 298 K. The adsorption of H2 practically does not occur when CO2 is present in the mixture. As indicated from simulated breakthrough curves, the breakthrough time of CO2 in M-MOF-74 follows the same order as the uptake and the heat of CO2 adsorption: Ni ¿ Co ¿ Fe ¿ Mn ¿ Zn ¿ Cu. Increasing the feed mole fraction of CO2 in the breakthrough simulations from 0.1 to 0.9 speeds up the saturation of the adsorbent, leading to a faster exit of CO2 with the column effluent. The application of the non-polarizable force field allows full investigation of the capture and separation of CO2 in M-MOF-74, and can be expanded to study multi-component mixtures or industrial reactions in future research. ...
Journal article (2024) - Shrinjay Sharma, Marcello S. Rigutto, Erik Zuidema, Umang Agarwal, Richard Baur, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
We study important aspects of shape selectivity effects of zeolites for hydroisomerization of linear alkanes, which produces a myriad of isomers, particularly for long chain hydrocarbons. To investigate the conditions for achieving an optimal yield of branched hydrocarbons, it is important to understand the role of chemical equilibrium in these reversible reactions. We conduct an extensive analysis of shape selectivity effects of different zeolites for the hydroisomerization of C7 and C8 isomers at chemical reaction equilibrium conditions. The reaction ensemble Monte Carlo method, coupled with grand-canonical Monte Carlo simulations, is commonly used for computing reaction equilibrium of heterogeneous reactions. The computational demands become prohibitive for a large number of reactions. We used a faster alternative in which reaction equilibrium is obtained by imposing chemical equilibrium in the gas phase and phase equilibrium between the gas phase components and the adsorbed phase counterparts. This effectively mimics the chemical equilibrium distribution in the adsorbed phase. Using Henry’s law at infinite dilution and mixture adsorption isotherm models at elevated pressures, we calculate the adsorbed loadings in the zeolites. This study shows that zeolites with cage or channel-like structures exhibit significant differences in selectivity for alkane isomers. We also observe a minimal impact of pressure on the gas-phase equilibrium of these reactions at typical experimental reaction temperatures 400 − 700 K . This study marks initial strides in understanding the reaction product distribution for long-chain alkanes. ...
Journal article (2023) - Shrinjay Sharma, Marcello S. Rigutto, Richard Baur, Umang Agarwal, Erik Zuidema, Salvador R.G. Balestra, Sofia Calero, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory (IAST) is a common method for modelling mixture adsorption isotherms based on pure component isotherms. When the adsorbent has distinct adsorption sites, the segregated version of IAST (SIAST) provides improved adsorbed loadings compared to IAST. We have adopted the concept of SIAST and applied it to an explicit isotherm model which takes into account the different sizes of the adsorbates: the so called Segregated Explicit Isotherm (SEI). The purpose of SEI is to have an explicit adsorption model that can consider both size-effects of the co-adsorbed molecules and surface heterogeneities. In sharp contrast to IAST and SIAST, no iterative scheme is required in case of SEI, which leads to much faster simulations. A comparative study has been performed to analyse the adsorption isotherms calculated using these three methods. The adsorbed loadings predicted by SEI and SIAST are in excellent agreement with the Grand-Canonical Monte Carlo (GCMC) simulation data. The loadings estimated by IAST show considerable deviations from the GCMC data at high pressures. Breakthrough curve modelling is used to compare the effects of these three models at dynamic conditions. The explicit model (SEI) leads to the fastest simulation run time, followed by SIAST. ...

Simulation code for breakthrough, ideal adsorption solution theory computations, and fitting of isotherm models

Journal article (2023) - Shrinjay Sharma, Salvador R.G. Balestra, Richard Baur, Umang Agarwal, Erik Zuidema, Marcello S. Rigutto, Sofia Calero, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, David Dubbeldam
We present the RUPTURA code (https://github.com/iraspa/ruptura) as a free and open-source software package (MIT license) for (1) the simulation of gas adsorption breakthrough curves, (2) mixture prediction using methods like the Ideal Adsorption Solution Theory (IAST), segregated-IAST and explicit isotherm models, and (3) fitting of isotherm models on computed or measured adsorption isotherm data. The combination with the RASPA software enables computation of breakthrough curves directly from adsorption simulations in the grand-canonical ensemble. RUPTURA and RASPA have similar input styles. IAST is implemented near machine precision but we also provide several explicit mixture prediction methods that are non-iterative and potentially faster than IAST. The code supports a wide variety of isotherm models like Langmuir, Anti-Langmuir, BET, Henry, Freundlich, Sips, Langmuir-Freundlich, Redlich-Peterson, Toth, Unilan, O'Brian & Myers, Asymptotic Temkin, and Bingel & Walton. The isotherm model parameters can easily be obtained by the fitting module. Breakthrough plots and animations of the column properties are automatically generated. In addition to highlighting the code, we also review all the developed techniques from literature for mixture prediction, breakthrough simulations, and isotherm model fitting, and provide a tutorial discussing the workflows. ...
Journal article (2023) - Dominika O. Wasik, Ana Martín-Calvo, Juan José Gutiérrez-Sevillano, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, Sofía Calero
Formic acid production from CO2 allows the reduction of carbon dioxide emissions while synthesizing a product with a wide range of applications. CO2 hydrogenation is challenging due to the cost of transition metal catalysts and the toxicity of the transition elements. In this work, the thermodynamic confinement effects of the metal–organic framework UiO-66 on the CO2 hydrogenation to formic acid were studied by force field-based molecular simulations. The confinement effects of UiO-66 and the metal–organic frameworks Cu-BTC, and IRMOF-1 were compared, to assess the impact of different pore size and metal centers on the production of HCOOH. Monte Carlo simulations in the grand-canonical ensemble were performed in the frameworks, using gas phase mole fractions of CO2, H2, and HCOOH at chemical equilibrium, obtained from Continuous Fractional Component Monte Carlo simulations in the Reaction Ensemble. The adsorption isobars of the components in metal–organic frameworks were computed at 298.15 – 800 K, 1 – 60 bar. The enhancement of HCOOH production due to preferential adsorption of HCOOH in metal–organic frameworks was calculated for all studied conditions. UiO-66, Cu-BTC, and IRMOF-1 affect CO2 hydrogenation reaction, shifting the thermodynamical equilibrium toward HCOOH formation. The prevailing factor is the type of metal center in the metal–organic framework. The confinement effect of Cu-BTC turns out to exceed the enhancement caused by UiO-66, and IRMOF-1. The resulting mole fraction of HCOOH increased by ca. 2000 times compared to the gas phase at 298.15 K, 60 bar. Cu-BTC can be considered as an alternative to improve the production of HCOOH due to elimination of the high-cost temperature elevation, cost reduction of downstream processing methods, and comparable final concentration of HCOOH to the reported concentrations of formate obtained using transition metal catalysts. ...
Journal article (2022) - Umang Agarwal, Marcello S. Rigutto, Erik Zuidema, A. P.J. Jansen, Ali Poursaeidesfahani, Shrinjay Sharma, David Dubbeldam, T.J.H. Vlugt
A reactor model that deconvolutes thermodynamics of adsorption of hydrocarbon in the pores of zeolite Beta, obtained by Configurational-bias Monte Carlo simulations, from intrinsic, intraporous kinetics of hydroisomerization and hydrocracking reactions, provides a good quantitative description of all significant reactions in the kinetic network for interconversion and cracking of different heptane isomers. Activation enthalpies obtained for intraporous reactions follow the expected order according to the carbenium ion formalism: methyl shift< ethyl shift < isom(B) ∼ crack(B2) < crack(B1) < crack(C) ∼ crack(D) < crack(E) and apparently within each isomerization class, in terms of carbenium ions formally involved: sec → tert < sec → sec ∼ tert → tert < tert → sec. except for the ethyl shift reaction forming 3-ethylpentane. Cracking happens primarily through 2,4-dimethylpentane (type B2), regardless of the initial reactant. The model can be subsequently used to separate the effect of pore structure on selective adsorption and on intraporous reaction kinetics. Zeolite Beta will serve as a base case for a comparison of different zeolite structures. ...
Journal article (2022) - Andrzej Sławek, Gabriela Jajko, Karolina Ogorzały, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, Wacław Makowski
In this work, adsorption properties of the UiO-66 metal–organic framework were investigated, with particular emphasis on the influence of structural defects. A series of UiO-66 samples were synthesized and characterized using a wide range of experimental techniques. Type I adsorption isotherms for low-temperature adsorption of N2 and Ar showed that micropore volume and specific surface area significantly increase with the number of defects. Adsorption of hexane isomers in UiO-66 was studied by means of quasi-equilibrated temperature-programmed desorption and adsorption (QE-TPDA) experimental and Monte Carlo simulation techniques. QE-TPDA profiles revealed that only defect-free UiO-66 exhibits distinct two adsorption states. This technique also yielded high-quality adsorption isobars that were successfully recreated using Grand-Canonical Monte Carlo molecular simulations, which, however, required refinement of the existing force fields. The calculations demonstrated the detailed mechanism of adsorption and separation of hexane isomers in the UiO-66 structure. The preferred tetrahedral cages provide suitable voids for bulky molecules, which is the reason for unusual “reverse” selectivity of UiO-66 towards di-branched alkanes. Interconnection of the tetrahedral cavities due to missing organic linkers greatly reduces the selectivity of the defected material. ...
Journal article (2022) - Ahmadreza Rahbari, Remco Hartkamp, Othonas A. Moultos, Albert Bos, Leo J.P. Van Den Broeke, Mahinder Ramdin, David Dubbeldam, Alexey V. Lyulin, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
One of the important parameters in water management of proton exchange membranes is the electro-osmotic drag (EOD) coefficient of water. The value of the EOD coefficient is difficult to justify, and available literature data on this for Nafion membranes show scattering from in experiments and simulations. Here, we use a classical all-atom model to compute the EOD coefficient and thermodynamic properties of water from molecular dynamics simulations for temperatures between 330 and 420 K, and for different water contents between λ = 5 and λ = 20. λ is the ratio between the moles of water molecules to the moles of sulfonic acid sites. This classical model does not capture the Grotthuss mechanism; however, it is shown that it can predict the EOD coefficient within the range of experimental values for λ = 5 where the vehicular mechanism dominates proton transfer. For λ > 5, the Grotthuss mechanism becomes dominant. To obtain the EOD coefficient, average velocities of water and ions are computed by imposing different electric fields to the system. Our results show that the velocities of water and hydronium scale linearly with the electric field, resulting in a constant ratio of ca. 0.4 within the error bars. We find that the EOD coefficient of water linearly increases from 2 at λ = 5 to 8 at λ = 20 and the results are not sensitive to temperature. The EOD coefficient at λ = 5 is within the range of experimental values, confirming that the model can capture the vehicular transport of protons well. At λ = 20, due to the absence of proton hopping in the model, the EOD coefficient is overestimated by a factor of 3 compared to experimental values. To analyze the interactions between water and Nafion, the partial molar enthalpies and partial molar volumes of water are computed from molecular dynamics simulations. At different water uptakes, multiple linear regression is used on raw simulation data within a narrow composition range of water inside the Nafion membrane. The partial molar volumes and partial molar excess enthalpies of water asymptotically approach the molar volumes and molar excess enthalpies of pure water for water uptakes above 5. This confirms the model can capture the bulklike behavior of water in the Nafion at high water uptakes. ...

Thermodynamic Integration and Hybrid Trial Moves

Journal article (2021) - H. Mert Polat, Hirad S. Salehi, Othonas A. Moultos, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, Remco Hens, Dominika O. Wasik, Ahmadreza Rahbari, Frédérick De Meyer, Céline Houriez, Christophe Coquelet, Sofia Calero, David Dubbeldam
We present several new major features added to the Monte Carlo (MC) simulation code Brick-CFCMC for phase- and reaction equilibria calculations (https://gitlab.com/ETh_TU_Delft/Brick-CFCMC). The first one is thermodynamic integration for the computation of excess chemical potentials (μex). For this purpose, we implemented the computation of the ensemble average of the derivative of the potential energy with respect to the scaling factor for intermolecular interactions (⟨∂U∂λ⟩). Efficient bookkeeping is implemented so that the quantity ∂U∂λ is updated after every MC trial move with negligible computational cost. We demonstrate the accuracy and reliability of the calculation of μex for sodium chloride in water. Second, we implemented hybrid MC/MD translation and rotation trial moves to increase the efficiency of sampling of the configuration space. In these trial moves, short Molecular Dynamics (MD) trajectories are performed to collectively displace or rotate all molecules in the system. These trajectories are accepted or rejected based on the total energy drift. The efficiency of these trial moves can be tuned by changing the time step and the trajectory length. The new trial moves are demonstrated using MC simulations of a viscous fluid (deep eutectic solvent). ...
Journal article (2021) - Ahmadreza Rahbari, Julio C. Garcia-Navarro, Mahinder Ramdin, Leo J.P. Van Den Broeke, Othonas A. Moultos, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Force field-based molecular simulations were used to calculate thermal expansivities, heat capacities, and Joule-Thomson coefficients of binary (standard) hydrogen-water mixtures for temperatures between 366.15 and 423.15 K and pressures between 50 and 1000 bar. The mole fraction of water in saturated hydrogen-water mixtures in the gas phase ranges from 0.004 to 0.138. The same properties were calculated for pure hydrogen at 323.15 K and pressures between 100 and 1000 bar. Simulations were performed using the TIP3P and a modified TIP4P force field for water and the Marx, Vrabec, Cracknell, Buch, and Hirschfelder force fields for hydrogen. The vapor-liquid equilibria of hydrogen-water mixtures were calculated along the melting line of ice Ih, corresponding to temperatures between 264.21 and 272.4 K, using the TIP3P force field for water and the Marx force field for hydrogen. In this temperature range, the solubilities and the chemical potentials of hydrogen and water were obtained. Based on the computed solubility data of hydrogen in water, the freezing-point depression of water was computed ranging from 264.21 to 272.4 K. The modified TIP4P and Marx force fields were used to improve the solubility calculations of hydrogen-water mixtures reported in our previous study [ Rahbari, A.;et al. J. Chem. Eng. Data 2019, 64, 4103-4115 ] for temperatures between 323 and 423 K and pressures ranging from 100 to 1000 bar. The chemical potentials of ice Ih were calculated as a function of pressure between 100 and 1000 bar, along the melting line for temperatures between 264.21 and 272.4 K, using the IAPWS equation of state for ice Ih. We show that at low pressures, the presence of water has a large effect on the thermodynamic properties of compressed hydrogen. Our conclusions may have consequences for the energetics of a hydrogen refueling station using electrochemical hydrogen compressors. ...

Force field performance, and Wolf vs. Ewald for electrostatic Interactions” (Fluid Phase Equilibria (2019) 485 (239–247), (S037838121830503X), (10.1016/j.fluid.2018.12.006))

Journal article (2020) - Sebastián Caro-Ortiz, Remco Hens, Erik Zuidema, Marcello Rigutto, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
Vapor-liquid equilibria of xylenes were computed using Monte Carlo simulations in the Gibbs ensemble. For binary mixtures, the predicted composition of the liquid phase is in agreement with experiments. The computed vapor phase densities of each isomer showed an effect on the predicted composition of the vapor phase of the mixture. Unfortunately, the Monte Carlo code used to calculate the vapor-liquid equilibrium contained an error in the acceptance rule for molecule transfer in multi-component mixtures. The Continuous Fractional Component (CFCMC) [1–3] algorithm in the Gibbs ensemble adds an extra molecule -the fractional molecule-per molecule type. In the CFCMC algorithm, trial moves are attempted to transform a fractional molecule of type a in box i to a whole molecule and, simultaneously, transform a molecule of type a in box j [Formula presented] i to a fractional molecule. These trial moves should be accepted according to Ref. [1]: [Formula presented] where [Formula presented] is the number of molecules of type a in box j, [Formula presented] is the number of molecules of type a in box i, and [Formula presented] is the energy difference between the old and the new configuration. Unfortunately, what was implemented (incorrectly) in the computer code is: [Formula presented] where [Formula presented] and [Formula presented] are the total number of molecules of all types in box i and j, respectively, and not only of type a. For the simulation of a single component, [Formula presented] and [Formula presented]. Therefore, the mistake in the acceptance rule only affects the simulations that include more than one component. As such, Figs. 1, Fig. 2, Fig. 3, Fig. 4, and Table 1 of the article are not affected by this error. This error was hard to detect for xylene isomers, as the boiling point of these isomers are close, and therefore [Formula presented] is close to [Formula presented]. The corrected code has been tested to yield the same results as the RASPA software [4,5] for various multi-component systems. The phase composition diagram using the correct code is shown in Fig. 5. The observations based on the incorrect results remain. The composition of the liquid phase is not affected by the choice of force field or method for electrostatic interactions. For all the force fields, the correct vapor phase composition calculated with the Ewald and the Wolf methods are closer than in the incorrect simulations. In the incorrect results, the largest difference between vapor phase composition calculated with the Wolf and the Ewald method was 0.089 [mol/mol]. In the correct results, this difference is reduced to 0.067 [mol/mol]. [Figure presented] The predicted composition of the liquid phase is in excellent agreement with the experimental data. The correct simulations of the vapor phase compositions are closer to the experimental data than the incorrect simulations. The simulations with the incorrect acceptance rules showed an azeotrope behaviour that is not present in the correct simulations of the phase compositions. [Figure presented] The phase composition of the binary mixture and the excess chemical potential are not related. This is consistent with the observations from the incorrect simulations. [Formula presented] The predicted composition of the liquid phase is in excellent agreement with the experimental data. The correct simulations of the vapor phase compositions are closer to the experimental data than the incorrect simulations. The simulations with the incorrect acceptance rules showed an azeotrope behaviour that is not present in the correct simulations. [Figure presented] ...
Review (2019) - David Dubbeldam, Krista S. Walton, Thijs J.H. Vlugt, Sofia Calero
Molecular simulations are an excellent tool to study adsorption and diffusion in nanoporous materials. Examples of nanoporous materials are zeolites, carbon nanotubes, clays, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), covalent organic frameworks (COFs) and zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs). The molecular confinement these materials offer has been exploited in adsorption and catalysis for almost 50 years. Molecular simulations have provided understanding of the underlying shape selectivity, and adsorption and diffusion effects. Much of the reliability of the modeling predictions depends on the accuracy and transferability of the force field. However, flexibility and the chemical and structural diversity of MOFs add significant challenges for engineering force fields that are able to reproduce experimentally observed structural and dynamic properties. Recent developments in design, parameterization, and implementation of force fields for MOFs and zeolites are reviewed. ...

Force field performance, and Wolf vs. Ewald for electrostatic interactions

Journal article (2019) - Sebastián Caro-Ortiz, Remco Hens, Erik Zuidema, Marcello Rigutto, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt
This article explores how well vapor-liquid equilibria of pure components and binary mixtures of xylenes can be predicted using different force fields in molecular simulations. The accuracy of the Wolf method and the Ewald summation is evaluated. Monte Carlo simulations in the Gibbs ensemble are performed at conditions comparable to experimental data, using four different force fields. Similar results using the Wolf and the Ewald methods can be obtained for the prediction of densities and the phase compositions of binary mixtures. With the Wolf method, up to 50% less CPU time is used compared to the Ewald method, at the cost of accuracy and additional parameter calibration. The densities of p-xylene and m-xylene can be well estimated using the TraPPE-UA and AUA force fields. The largest differences of VLE with experiments are observed for o-xylene. The p-xylene/o-xylene binary mixtures at 6.66 and 81.3 kPa are simulated, leading to an excellent agreement in the predictions of the composition of the liquid phase compared to experiments. The composition of the vapor phase is dominated by the properties of the component with the largest mole fraction in the liquid phase. The accuracy of the predictions of the phase composition are related to the quality of the density predictions of the pure component systems. The phase composition of the binary system of xylenes is very sensitive to slight differences in vapor phase density of each xylene isomer, and how well the differences are captured by the force fields. ...