D.C. Slobbe
Please Note
53 records found
1
Modeling the SAR altimetry noise
From high posting rates to precision gains
Measurements of tides are relatively sparse in the Arctic. This paper studies GNSS buoy tracks to complement existing data. Existing methods to perform tidal harmonic analysis of the buoy data are inadequate in the Arctic region because these methods for tidal analysis combine data from multiple buoy tracks, which is often infeasible in the Arctic. Moreover, we find that there are significant spatial and temporal variations in amplitudes and phases in baroclinic zones. To address these complexities, we introduce a new approach–Model-derived Fitting Method–to estimate the tidal current constituents (TCC) from a single buoy trajectory. Our study assesses the proposed method by analyzing GNSS buoy data from three Arctic regions characterized by barotropic or baroclinic tidal currents. Through detailed case studies in the Barents Sea, Chukchi Sea, and Baffin Bay, our approach demonstrates accuracy, robustness, and operational capabilities. In the Barents Sea, TCC estimates from two buoys were compared at a common location within their trajectories and compared against model estimates. In the Chukchi Sea's barotropic dominant zone, our method's estimates were evaluated against nearby ADCP mooring data. In Baffin Bay, known for baroclinic currents, a synthetic evaluation confirmed the method's effectiveness. Our study also highlights that phase variations along buoy trajectories can lead to frequency shifts in the spectrum, similar to the Doppler shift effect, particularly notable in regions with baroclinic tides.
Arctic sea ice leads to a significant dissipation of tidal energy, necessitating its inclusion in global tidal models. However, most global tidal models either neglect or only partially incorporate the impact of sea ice on tides. This study proposes a method to model the dissipative forces exerted by sea ice on tides without directly coupling to a sea ice model, yet utilizing sea ice parameters such as thickness and concentration. Our approach involves (re)-categorizing the sea ice cover into regions dominated either by the velocity difference between sea ice and tides (Vertical Shear (VS)) or by the shear from drifting sea ice on tides (Horizontal Shear (HS)), which primarily govern the energy dissipation between tides and sea ice. The subdivision and resulting areas of these HS and VS regions are based on a nondimensional number referred to as the Friction number, which is the ratio of the internal stress of the sea ice field to the ice–water frictional stress, and directly depends on the thickness and concentration of the sea ice. The new parameterization is validated through a performance assessment comparing it to a commonly used approach of assuming all the sea ice to be stationary (landfast). The seasonal modulation of the M2 tidal component, quantified as the March–September difference, serves as the performance metric, demonstrating that the new parameterization has better agreement with observations from altimeter- and tide gauge-derived seasonal modulation. The results indicate that the physics of ice–tide interaction is better represented with the new parameterization of sea ice-induced dissipation, making it suitable for investigating the effects of declining sea ice thickness on tides.
Multi-mission satellite altimetry data have been used to study the spatial and temporal variability in global storm surge water levels. This was done by means of a time-dependent extreme value analysis applied to the monthly maximum detided water levels. To account for the limited temporal resolution of the satellite data, the data were first stacked on a 5∘× 5∘ grid. Moreover, additional scaling was applied to the extreme value analysis for which the scaling factors were determined by means of a resampling method using reanalysis data. In addition to the conventional analysis using data from tide gauges, this study provides an insight in the ocean-wide storm surge properties. Nonetheless, where possible, results were compared to similar information derived from tide gauge data. Except for secular changes, the satellite-derived results are comparable to the information derived from tide gauges (correlation > 0.5), although the tide gauges show more local variability. Where limited correlation was observed for the secular change, it was suggested that the satellites may not be able to fully capture the temporal variability in the short-lived, tropical storms, as opposed to extra-tropical storms.
Polygon-Informed Cross-Track Altimetry (PICTA)
Estimating river water level profiles with the Sentinel-6 altimeter
Polygon-Informed Cross-Track Altimetry (PICTA)
Estimating river water level profiles with the Sentinel-6 altimeter
Traditionally, nadir-looking satellite radar altimeters provide water levels of rivers only at intersections with the satellite's ground track, called virtual stations. These observations have limited spatial coverage because such cross-overs are sparse, depending on the altimeter's orbit. In this work, we introduce the novel concept of Polygon-Informed Cross-Track Altimetry (PICTA), enabling accurate estimation of water levels at cross-track distances — for as long as the target's signal is recorded in the altimeter's range window. Using fully-focused SAR data from the Sentinel-6 altimetry mission, we demonstrate how the new approach can provide detailed river water level profiles over a ground swath of about 14 km cross-track width and with an along-track resolution as fine as 10 m. On the one hand, this marks a drastic improvement in the number of available measurements when compared to the virtual station approach, on the other hand, for the first time, water surface slopes and level variations along the river, caused by rapids, dams, and sluices, can be directly observed using a nadir radar altimeter. The validation over two river segments in France reveals biases as low as ±4 cm and random errors on the order of 3–8 cm at 30 m along-track resolution. The new PICTA concept can potentially be generalized to other targets, such as lakes or even coastlines.
All realizations of the European Vertical Reference System (EVRS) computed so far are solely based on geopotential differences obtained by spirit leveling/gravimetry. As such, there are no direct connections between height benchmarks separated by large water bodies. In this study, such connections are added by means of model-based hydrodynamic leveling resulting in a new, yet unofficial realization of the EVRS. The model-derived mean water levels used in computing the hydrodynamic leveling connections were obtained from the Nemo-Nordic (Baltic Sea) and 3D DCSM-FM (northwest European continental shelf) hydrodynamic models. The impact of model-based hydrodynamic leveling on the European Vertical Reference Frame is significant, especially for France and Great Britain. Compared to a solution which only uses spirit leveling/gravimetry, the differences in these countries reach tens to hundreds of kgalmm . We also observed an improved agreement with normal heights obtained by differencing GNSS and the European gravimetric quasi-geoid 2015 (EGG2015) heights. In Great Britain, the south-north slope of 48 mm deg - 1 present in the solution which uses only spirit leveling/gravimetry data reduced to 2.2 mm deg - 1 . In France, the improvement is confined to the southwest. The choice of the period over which water levels are averaged has an impact on the results as it determines, among others, the set of tide gauges available to establish the hydrodynamic leveling connections. When using an averaging period that can be considered as the least preferred choice based on three established criteria, the positive impact for France has gone. For Great Britain, the estimated south-north slope became 12.6 mm deg - 1 . This is larger than the slope obtained using the most preferred averaging period but still substantially lower compared to the slope associated with a solution that uses only spirit leveling/gravimetry.
This paper investigates the full variance–covariance (VC) matrix of two high-resolution regional quasi-geoid models, utilizing a spherical radial basis function parameterization. Model parameters were estimated using weighted least-squares techniques and variance component estimation (VCE) for data weighting. The first model, known as the “RCR model,” is computed through the remove–compute–restore method, incorporating various local gravity and radar altimeter datasets. The second model, the “combined model,” includes the GOCO05s satellite-only global geopotential model as an additional dataset with a full-noise VC matrix. Validation of the noise VC matrix scaling for each quasi-geoid model is achieved by comparing observed and formal noise standard deviations of differences between geometric and gravimetric height anomalies at GPS height markers in the Netherlands. Analysis of the noise VC matrix of height anomalies at grid nodes reveals significantly smaller formal noise standard deviations for the RCR model compared to the combined model. This difference is attributed to VCE assigning larger weights to the GOCO05s dataset, which exhibits greater noise standard deviations for the specific spatial scales used. Additionally, the formal noise standard deviations of height anomaly differences, relevant for GNSS-heighting, favor the RCR model. However, the disparity between the two models is smaller than implied by the height anomaly noise standard deviations. This is due to the combined model’s noise autocorrelation function displaying a longer correlation length (67 km) in contrast to the RCR model’s (17 km). Consequently, the combined model exhibits a greater reduction in noise variance for height anomaly differences relative to white noise compared to the RCR model.
We present exact, closed-form expressions for the complete RTM correction and the harmonic correction to disturbing potential, gravity disturbance, gravity anomaly, and height anomaly. They need to be applied in quasi-geoid modelling whenever data points are buried inside the masses after residual terrain model (RTM) reduction and analytically downward-continued functionals of the disturbing potential at the original locations of the data points are required. Compared to recent work of the authors published in this journal, no Taylor series enter the expressions and numerical instabilities of the harmonic downward continuation from the RTM surface to the Earth’s surface are avoided as are inaccuracies in the free-air upward continuation from the Earth’s surface to the RTM surface caused by a lack of precise information about higher-order derivatives of the disturbing potential. The new expressions can easily be implemented in any existing RTM software package and do not require additional computational resources. For two test areas located in western Norway and the Auvergne in France, we compute the complete RTM correction and the harmonic correction to the afore-mentioned functionals of the disturbing potential. Overall, all harmonic corrections are non-negative with maximum values of 1.54 m 2/ s 2, 263.0 μ Gal, 263.9 μ Gal, and 15.7 m (Norway) and 1.55 m 2/ s 2, 263.3 μ Gal, 263.3 μ Gal, and 15.8 cm (Auvergne) for disturbing potential, gravity disturbance, gravity anomaly, and height anomaly, respectively. The medians are 0.02 m 2/ s 2, 33.6 μ Gal, 33.7 μ Gal, and 0.3 cm (Norway) and 0.01 m 2/ s 2, 19.2 μ Gal, 19.2 μ Gal, and 0.1 cm (Auvergne). We also show that the nth Taylor polynomials used in the recent work of the authors published in this journal may have large remainders depending on the topography in the vicinity of the evaluation point no matter how n is chosen. Finally, we show that the commonly used expression for the harmonic correction to gravity anomaly introduced in 1981 is almost exact, though it was derived along a completely different line of reasoning. The errors do not exceed 49 μ Gal in both test areas. Moreover, the errors have a negligible impact on the computed height anomalies in one-centimetre quasi-geoid modelling, as the mean error does not exceed a few μ Gal in both test areas.
The main objective of this study is to develop and analyze an empirical noise model for model-derived coastal summer mean water levels (SMWLs) and use that to obtain a more realistic quality impact of combining hydrodynamic leveling and Unified European Leveling Network (UELN) data in realizing the European Vertical Reference System (EVRS). We considered three state-of-the-art hydrodynamic models for the Northeast Atlantic Ocean, including the North Sea and Wadden Sea; AMM7, DCSMv6-ZUNOv4, and 3D DCSM-FM. Moreover, we assess the spatiotemporal performance of these three models in representing coastal SMWLs. The empirical noise models are determined from the differences between observation- and model-derived SMWLs at coastal tide gauges. All three noise models show that the model noise is indeed correlated over sea distances up to hundreds of kilometers. At the same time, they all show a relatively large discontinuity at the origin (i.e., nugget effect); between 12.1 cm2 (3D DCSM-FM) and 16.3 cm2 (DCSMv6-ZUNOv4). The variance (i.e., covariance at zero sea distance) for these two models is 15.3 cm2 and 21.7 cm2, respectively. Averaging the water levels over three summers, lowered the variance and nugget effect for 3D DCSM-FM to 12.7 cm2 and 10.0 cm2, respectively. Our analysis also showed that between 30 and 50% of the variance has to be attributed to errors in the vertical referencing of the tide gauges. We lacked the information to assess what proportion of the observed noise covariances should be attributed to these errors. The performance assessments revealed significant variations over both space and time as well as among the three hydrodynamic models. The results suggest that there is still room for model improvement. In the final experiments, we used the noise model of the best overall performing model (i.e., 3D DCSM-FM) to reassess the quality impact of combining hydrodynamic leveling and UELN data in realizing the EVRS. The results suggest that not including the noise covariances leads to an overestimation of the total quality impact by 7 % and 8 % , when we average the water levels over one and three summer periods, respectively.
Earlier work has empirically demonstrated some advantages of an increased posting rate of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) altimeters beyond the expected ground resolution of about 320 m in Delay-Doppler (unfocused SAR, UFSAR) processing, corresponding to ∼20 Hz sampling. Higher posting rates of 40–80 Hz were shown to prevent spectral aliasing of the signal, enable to measure swell wave related signal distortions and may lead to a reduced root mean square error of 1 Hz estimates of Sea Surface Heights (SSH), radar cross section (sigma0) and Significant Wave Heights (SWH) from current SAR altimeters. These improvements were explained by the narrow noise autocovariance function of the waveform signal's power speckle noise in along-track direction on one hand, and frequency doubling by power detection (squaring of the signal) on the other. It has not been explained, however, why the power speckle noise decorrelates faster than anticipated by the predicted Doppler resolution, and whether this decorrelation depends on the altimeter and processing configuration. Also, it has not been shown explicitly that the estimates of SSH, SWH and sigma0 decorrelate in the same way. Describing the noise autocovariance function – or equivalently the noise power spectral density via the Wiener-Kintchin theorem – is necessary on two counts: Knowing the noise autocovariance allows to apply optimal filtering strategies that maximize precision on one hand, while the noise power spectral density predicts the frequencies contained in the noise (and signals), which in turn determines the required sampling frequency according to the Nyquist theorem. Using a newly derived analytic noise autocovariance model for UFSAR-processed altimeter data, we show that the swift signal decorrelation is mainly due to the observation geometry. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that the noise autocovariance functions of power speckle, SSH, SWH and sigma0 estimates in along-track direction are different and depend on the sea state. On top of that, the noise autocovariance functions are strongly dependent on the number of Doppler beams used for multilooking, the used retracker, and the processing choices such as antenna gain pattern compensation and windowing within the UFSAR processing (Level-1b). We validated our noise autocovariance model with segments of 42 Sentinel-3B overpasses. Our findings are in accordance to all earlier work, but indicate that the reported precision improvements with respect to 20 Hz may have been too optimistic and that the SSH, SWH and sigma0 generally decorrelate slower than the power speckle noise. We found that the required posting rate is always higher or equal to 40 Hz. Our results will potentially enable improved spectral analysis and optimal filtering of any UFSAR altimetry data. More importantly, our results can be used to trade off different aspects for determining an optimal posting rate in UFSAR altimeter processing in different sea states and with changing processing parameters, which is necessary in view of strict precision requirements of existing and future SAR altimetry missions.
We demonstrate in this work how we can take advantage of known unfocused SAR (UF-SAR) retracking methods (e.g. the physical SAMOSA model) for retracking of fully-focused SAR (FF-SAR) waveforms. Our insights are an important step towards consistent observations of sea surface height, significant wave height and backscatter coefficient (wind speed) with both UF-SAR and FF-SAR. This is of particular interest for SAR altimetry in the coastal zone, since coastal clutter may be filtered out more efficiently in the high-resolution FF-SAR waveform data, which has the potential to improve data quality. We implemented a multi-mission FF-SAR altimetry processor for Sentinel-3 (S3) and Sentinel-6 Michael Freilich (S6), using a back-projection algorithm, and analysed ocean waveform statistics compared to multilooked UF-SAR. We find for Sentinel-3 that the averaged power waveforms of UF-SAR and FF-SAR over ocean are virtually identical, while for Sentinel-6 the FF-SAR power waveforms better resemble the UF-SAR zero-Doppler beam. We can explain and model the similarities and differences in the data via theoretical considerations of the waveform integrals. These findings suggest to use the existing UF-SAR SAMOSA model for retracking S3 FF-SAR waveforms but the SAMOSA zero-Doppler beam model for S6 FF-SAR waveforms, instead. Testing the outlined approach over short track segments, we obtain range biases between UF-SAR and FF-SAR lower than 2 mm and significant wave height biases lower than 5 cm.
Both empirical and assimilative global ocean tidal models are significantly more accurate in the deep ocean than in shelf and coastal waters. In this study, we answered whether this is due to the quality of the models used to reduce tide and surge or the general approach to treat tide and surge as two separate components of the water level obtained from stand-alone models, which ignores the nonlinear tide–surge interaction. In doing so, we used tide gauge observations as partially synthetic altimeter time series, tide–surge water-level time series obtained with the 2D Dutch Continental Shelf Model–Flexible Mesh (DCSM), and tide and surge water-level time series obtained using the DCSM, FES2014 (FES) and the Dynamic Atmospheric Correction (DAC) product. Expressed in the root-sum-square (RSS) of the eight main tidal constituents, we obtained a reduction (Formula presented.) % when removing the DCSM tide–surge water levels compared to when we removed the sum of the DCSM tide and DCSM surge water levels. The RSS obtained in the latter case was only 3.3% lower than with FES and DAC. We conclude that the lower tidal estimates accuracy in shelf-coastal waters derives from the missing nonlinear tide–surge interactions.
Our awareness of ice caps' and mountain glaciers' sensitivity to climate change has driven major advances in the application of remote sensing techniques during the past decade. Regarding ESA's SARIn altimeter CryoSat-2, processing the full waveform to generate swaths of elevation estimates has become standard practice in regions of complex topographies. This technique provides information on areas where we would be blind otherwise. In this article, we discuss systematic errors and analyze their impact on surface elevation measurements and change rates of two test areas. In particular, we focus on periodically occurring errors in elevation swaths, caused by the superposition of coherent signals from range-ambiguous surfaces. They can lead to measurement errors in excess of 10 m, affect most measurements in mountainous regions, are difficult to exclude with established post-processing techniques, and occur repeatedly for satellite revisits introducing a 369-day periodicity-difficult to distinguish from the annual cycle. We show a correlation between derived elevation swaths and the sensor view angle and explore the influence of common data exclusion choices on higher level products. Our results indicate that these systematic errors hold a substantial share of the error budget and that the choice of thresholds impacts higher level products. We conclude that error correlations need to be considered to characterize the data accuracy. With the established data editing strategies, systematic errors prevent resolving seasonal mass changes of single mountain glacier basins and impact aggregates over larger areas or longer periods.
Benefits of fully focused SAR altimetry to coastal wave height estimates
A case study in the North Sea
Estimating the three geophysical variables significant wave height (SWH), sea surface height, and wind speed from satellite altimetry continues to be challenging in the coastal zone because the received radar echoes exhibit significant interference from strongly reflective targets such as sandbanks, sheltered bays, ships etc. Fully focused SAR (FF-SAR) processing exhibits a theoretical along-track resolution of up to less than half a metre. This suggests that the application of FF-SAR altimetry might give potential gains over unfocused SAR (UF-SAR) altimetry to resolve and mitigate small-scale interferers in the along-track direction to improve the accuracy and precision of the geophysical estimates. The objective of this study is to assess the applicability of FF-SAR-processed Sentinel-6 Michael Freilich (S6-MF) coastal altimetry data to obtain SWH estimates as close as possible to the coast. We have developed a multi-mission FF-SAR processor and applied the coastal retracking algorithm CORALv2 to estimate SWH. We assess different FF-SAR and UF-SAR processing configurations, as well as the baseline Level-2 product from EUMETSAT, by comparison with the coastal, high-resolution SWAN-Kuststrook wave model from the Deltares RWsOS North Sea operational forecasting system. This includes the evaluation of the correlation, the median offset, and the percentage of cycles with high correlation as a function of distance to the nearest coastline. Moreover, we analyse the number of valid records and the L2 noise of the records. The case study comprises five coastal crossings of S6-MF that are located along the Dutch coast and the German coast along the East Frisian Islands in the North Sea. We observe that accurate and precise SWH records can be estimated in the nearshore zone within 1–3 km from the coast using satellite SAR altimetry. We find that the FF-SAR-processed dataset with a Level-1b posting rate of 140 Hz shows the greatest similarity with the wave model. We achieve a correlation of ∼0.8 at 80% of valid records and a gain in precision of up to 29% of FF-SAR vs UF-SAR for 1–3 km from the coast. FF-SAR shows, for all cycles, a high correlation of greater than or equal to 0.8 for 1–3 km from the coast. We estimate the decay of SWH from offshore at 30 km to up to 1 km from the coast to amount to 26.4% ± 3.1%.