EM
E.M. Martuganova
info
Please Note
<p>This page displays the records of the person named above and is not linked to a unique person identifier. This record may need to be merged to a profile.</p>
15 records found
1
Relocating seismic events in the North Sea
Challenges and insights for earthquake analysis
Journal article
(2025)
-
Annie Elisabeth Jerkins, Johannes Schweitzer, Tom Kettlety, Evgeniia Martuganova, Daniela Kühn, Volker Oye
In this paper, we present a catalogue of relocated seismic events in the North Sea spanning 1961 to 2022. Data from all relevant agencies were combined, incorporating all available seismic phase readings, thereby enhancing station coverage. As a result, our updated locations reveal a more clustered and aligned seismicity pattern compared with the original catalogue. Even with our combined data set, only 157 of the 7089 relocated events have azimuthal gaps of less than 90 deg. Additionally, the distances between onshore stations and offshore events are considerable. Both of these factors lead to relatively poorly constrained hypocentres for most events. We therefore evaluate the performance of 1-D velocity models routinely used by different North Sea adjacent monitoring agencies for earthquake location estimations in the North Sea. The variations in assessments due to the seismic velocity model used are significantly larger than the uncertainty ellipses calculated in the relocation, demonstrating that arithmetic uncertainties systematically underestimate location uncertainties in this setting. Obtaining a realistic estimate of location uncertainty is however crucial, particularly for distinguishing between natural and induced seismicity. This is fundamental to safe monitoring of the North Sea offshore industries, including geological CO2 storage. To overcome these discrepancies between the uncertainty ellipses and our multiple relocations, we introduce an alternative method that accounts for variability in the 1-D velocity models. This approach enhances the reliability of the earthquake catalogue, and provides a more robust assessment of seismic activity in the North Sea.
...
In this paper, we present a catalogue of relocated seismic events in the North Sea spanning 1961 to 2022. Data from all relevant agencies were combined, incorporating all available seismic phase readings, thereby enhancing station coverage. As a result, our updated locations reveal a more clustered and aligned seismicity pattern compared with the original catalogue. Even with our combined data set, only 157 of the 7089 relocated events have azimuthal gaps of less than 90 deg. Additionally, the distances between onshore stations and offshore events are considerable. Both of these factors lead to relatively poorly constrained hypocentres for most events. We therefore evaluate the performance of 1-D velocity models routinely used by different North Sea adjacent monitoring agencies for earthquake location estimations in the North Sea. The variations in assessments due to the seismic velocity model used are significantly larger than the uncertainty ellipses calculated in the relocation, demonstrating that arithmetic uncertainties systematically underestimate location uncertainties in this setting. Obtaining a realistic estimate of location uncertainty is however crucial, particularly for distinguishing between natural and induced seismicity. This is fundamental to safe monitoring of the North Sea offshore industries, including geological CO2 storage. To overcome these discrepancies between the uncertainty ellipses and our multiple relocations, we introduce an alternative method that accounts for variability in the 1-D velocity models. This approach enhances the reliability of the earthquake catalogue, and provides a more robust assessment of seismic activity in the North Sea.
Ensuring safe North Sea CO2 storage
The design of robust seismic networks to enable focal mechanism analyses for stress field orientation
Seismic monitoring plays a critical role in ensuring the safety and effectiveness of carbon capture and storage (CCS) operations, as it offers essential insights into fault stability and potential risks to storage integrity. Focal mechanism analysis provides knowledge on stress field orientation, fault slip directions, and seismic source characteristics, aiding the understanding of subsurface fault dynamics and stress changes within the reservoir. Analysing focal mechanisms of small, local earthquakes before, during and after CO₂ injection is crucial for understanding seismic response and, as a result, assessing the risk of significant future events.
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea. ...
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea. ...
Seismic monitoring plays a critical role in ensuring the safety and effectiveness of carbon capture and storage (CCS) operations, as it offers essential insights into fault stability and potential risks to storage integrity. Focal mechanism analysis provides knowledge on stress field orientation, fault slip directions, and seismic source characteristics, aiding the understanding of subsurface fault dynamics and stress changes within the reservoir. Analysing focal mechanisms of small, local earthquakes before, during and after CO₂ injection is crucial for understanding seismic response and, as a result, assessing the risk of significant future events.
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea.
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea.
Successful across-scale reservoir characterization is a prerequisite for sustainable utilization of the subsurface. Here, we discuss aspects of distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) vertical seismic profiling (VSP) acquisition in Germany and provide an example of data integration for reservoir characterization at the geothermal research platform Groß Schönebeck, aiming to utilize Permian and Permo-Carboniferous reservoir sections at depths below 4 km. At this site, DAS VSP wireline data obtained in two boreholes were processed successfully for 3D interpretation. The data and their interpretation serve as input for a fundamental update of the structural and property characterization of the reservoir zones, relying on the integration of conventional surface 3D seismics and joint core-log analysis. The new model provides a much more detailed characterization of the target reservoirs, allowing for the first time a geological-based (facies-driven) parameterization of the subsurface, considering hydraulic and thermal properties of the reservoir-forming rocks.
...
Successful across-scale reservoir characterization is a prerequisite for sustainable utilization of the subsurface. Here, we discuss aspects of distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) vertical seismic profiling (VSP) acquisition in Germany and provide an example of data integration for reservoir characterization at the geothermal research platform Groß Schönebeck, aiming to utilize Permian and Permo-Carboniferous reservoir sections at depths below 4 km. At this site, DAS VSP wireline data obtained in two boreholes were processed successfully for 3D interpretation. The data and their interpretation serve as input for a fundamental update of the structural and property characterization of the reservoir zones, relying on the integration of conventional surface 3D seismics and joint core-log analysis. The new model provides a much more detailed characterization of the target reservoirs, allowing for the first time a geological-based (facies-driven) parameterization of the subsurface, considering hydraulic and thermal properties of the reservoir-forming rocks.
Journal article
(2024)
-
Tom Kettlety, Evgeniia Martuganova, Elin Skurtveit, Daniela Kühn, Johannes Schweitzer, Cornelis Weemstra, Brian Baptie, Trine Dahl-Jensen, Annie Jerkins, Peter H. Voss, J. Michael Kendall
Carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology is essential to European decarbonisation efforts, and several offshore CO2 storage projects are being developed in the North Sea. Understanding the geomechanical response to CO2 injection is key to both the pre-characterisation and operation of a storage reservoir. A thorough assessment of seismicity gives critical insights into the stress field and faulting around reservoirs, both key controls on the geomechanical response to injection. Seismicity also illuminates potential hydraulic pathways for leakage, be it directly by revealing the extent of faults, or indirectly through fractures imaged by measurements of seismic anisotropy. High quality seismicity data is critical to underpin all of these methods of analysis. This paper presents the most complete catalogue of seismicity in the North Sea to date. The combined data are enabling revised assessments of seismic hazard and leakage risk in the North Sea, as well as a better understanding of faulting and stress. This study shows the value of unifying disparate seismicity data, allowing for more accurate seismological analyses. These lay the foundation for better management of risks for not only geologic CO2 storage, but other offshore industries and infrastructure.
...
Carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology is essential to European decarbonisation efforts, and several offshore CO2 storage projects are being developed in the North Sea. Understanding the geomechanical response to CO2 injection is key to both the pre-characterisation and operation of a storage reservoir. A thorough assessment of seismicity gives critical insights into the stress field and faulting around reservoirs, both key controls on the geomechanical response to injection. Seismicity also illuminates potential hydraulic pathways for leakage, be it directly by revealing the extent of faults, or indirectly through fractures imaged by measurements of seismic anisotropy. High quality seismicity data is critical to underpin all of these methods of analysis. This paper presents the most complete catalogue of seismicity in the North Sea to date. The combined data are enabling revised assessments of seismic hazard and leakage risk in the North Sea, as well as a better understanding of faulting and stress. This study shows the value of unifying disparate seismicity data, allowing for more accurate seismological analyses. These lay the foundation for better management of risks for not only geologic CO2 storage, but other offshore industries and infrastructure.
Abstract
(2024)
-
Tom Kettlety, Peter Voss, Daniela Kühn, Evgeniia Martuganova, Johannes Schweitzer, Trine Dahl-Jensen, Annie Jerkins, Elin Skurtveit
To effectively design and operate the many CO2 storage projects that are being developed in the North Sea, seismicity needs to be accurately characterised. Measuring seismicity can provide insights into the stress state in the region, fault density and faulting style, as well as fracturing in the overburden. Understanding background seismicity rates is also key to discriminating, determining the risk of, and mitigation against induced seismicity that could result from injection. Communicating earthquake risk is a key challenge in this field, and central to that is the reporting of earthquake sizes or magnitudes. These magnitudes are reported to the public, and thus their integrity needs to be ensured and their uncertainties thoroughly characterised. Magnitudes also are key input into seismic hazard analysis, a necessary step in the site characterisation of CO2 storage projects and other offshore infrastructure. This study compares and re-evaluates the magnitude estimates from a large database of North Sea seismicity compiled by the ACT3 project SHARP Storage. Magnitudes and their associated uncertainties are computed in a consistent manner and compared to the recordings reported by the regional agencies. Systematic differences are explored, and key sensitives are identified. These results will aid in the monitoring of seismicity in the North Sea, risk assessment for CO2 storage and other infrastructure, and the communication of seismic hazard.
...
To effectively design and operate the many CO2 storage projects that are being developed in the North Sea, seismicity needs to be accurately characterised. Measuring seismicity can provide insights into the stress state in the region, fault density and faulting style, as well as fracturing in the overburden. Understanding background seismicity rates is also key to discriminating, determining the risk of, and mitigation against induced seismicity that could result from injection. Communicating earthquake risk is a key challenge in this field, and central to that is the reporting of earthquake sizes or magnitudes. These magnitudes are reported to the public, and thus their integrity needs to be ensured and their uncertainties thoroughly characterised. Magnitudes also are key input into seismic hazard analysis, a necessary step in the site characterisation of CO2 storage projects and other offshore infrastructure. This study compares and re-evaluates the magnitude estimates from a large database of North Sea seismicity compiled by the ACT3 project SHARP Storage. Magnitudes and their associated uncertainties are computed in a consistent manner and compared to the recordings reported by the regional agencies. Systematic differences are explored, and key sensitives are identified. These results will aid in the monitoring of seismicity in the North Sea, risk assessment for CO2 storage and other infrastructure, and the communication of seismic hazard.
Decarbonisation of the European economy represents one of the current challenges to both society and the energy sector. The advancement and further application of carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) technologies are crucial components of the EU’s effort to become climate-neutral by 2050. The success of CCS depends heavily on understanding the present-day stress field to anticipate reservoir and cap rock response to fluid injection. Despite its importance, many proposed carbon storage sites in the North Sea are located in areas with little to no borehole stress data available, presenting a significant challenge.
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies. ...
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies. ...
Decarbonisation of the European economy represents one of the current challenges to both society and the energy sector. The advancement and further application of carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) technologies are crucial components of the EU’s effort to become climate-neutral by 2050. The success of CCS depends heavily on understanding the present-day stress field to anticipate reservoir and cap rock response to fluid injection. Despite its importance, many proposed carbon storage sites in the North Sea are located in areas with little to no borehole stress data available, presenting a significant challenge.
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies.
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies.
North Sea subsurface structures provide prolific opportunities to reduce Europe’s carbon footprint through permanently storing emitted CO2. In this paper we present a methodology to estimate resilience of manmade facilities and environment to potential induced seismicity during injection operations, based on historically observed regionally seismicity. This enables a robust design of a well informed risk management system that provides confidence to stakeholders while properly recognizing and establishing the right level of resilience to seismic events.
The method is demonstrated by applying the assessment for offshore structures on the Norwegian shelf to address resilience to potential seismicity around the NorthernLights prospect. It appears that is likely an event with Moment Magnitude equal to 3.7 can be managed adequately. The method can be extension to other areas in the North Sea, such as the Dutch and UK sectors, and can also address for instance resilience of onshore domestic areas to offshore induced events. ...
The method is demonstrated by applying the assessment for offshore structures on the Norwegian shelf to address resilience to potential seismicity around the NorthernLights prospect. It appears that is likely an event with Moment Magnitude equal to 3.7 can be managed adequately. The method can be extension to other areas in the North Sea, such as the Dutch and UK sectors, and can also address for instance resilience of onshore domestic areas to offshore induced events. ...
North Sea subsurface structures provide prolific opportunities to reduce Europe’s carbon footprint through permanently storing emitted CO2. In this paper we present a methodology to estimate resilience of manmade facilities and environment to potential induced seismicity during injection operations, based on historically observed regionally seismicity. This enables a robust design of a well informed risk management system that provides confidence to stakeholders while properly recognizing and establishing the right level of resilience to seismic events.
The method is demonstrated by applying the assessment for offshore structures on the Norwegian shelf to address resilience to potential seismicity around the NorthernLights prospect. It appears that is likely an event with Moment Magnitude equal to 3.7 can be managed adequately. The method can be extension to other areas in the North Sea, such as the Dutch and UK sectors, and can also address for instance resilience of onshore domestic areas to offshore induced events.
The method is demonstrated by applying the assessment for offshore structures on the Norwegian shelf to address resilience to potential seismicity around the NorthernLights prospect. It appears that is likely an event with Moment Magnitude equal to 3.7 can be managed adequately. The method can be extension to other areas in the North Sea, such as the Dutch and UK sectors, and can also address for instance resilience of onshore domestic areas to offshore induced events.
Abstract
(2024)
-
Peter Voss, Tom Kettlety, Evgeniia Martuganova, Daniela Kühn, Susann Wienecke, Johannes Schweitzer, Cornelis Weemstra, Brian Baptie, Trine Dahl-Jensen, More Authors...
This presentation gives an overview of the ACT3 SHARP Storage project (Stress history and reservoir pressure for improved quantification of CO2 storage containment risks), introducing its ongoing seismological activities. This includes building a new earthquake catalogue for the North Sea area and designing improved seismic monitoring schemes for CO2 storage sites using seismic networks, seismic arrays, and distributed acoustic sensing on fibre-optic cables. The SHARP Storage project was launched in late 2021 with the overall aim to increase accuracy of subsurface CO2 storage containment risk management through the improvement and integration of subsurface stress models, rock mechanical failure and seismicity observations. SHARP is collaboration between 16 research institutions and companies and is supported under the ACT3 call. ACT is an ERA NET Cofund, which is a tool established by the European Commission under the Horizon 2020 programme for research and innovation. More information on the SHARP Storage project is found at https://sharp-storage-act.eu/.
...
This presentation gives an overview of the ACT3 SHARP Storage project (Stress history and reservoir pressure for improved quantification of CO2 storage containment risks), introducing its ongoing seismological activities. This includes building a new earthquake catalogue for the North Sea area and designing improved seismic monitoring schemes for CO2 storage sites using seismic networks, seismic arrays, and distributed acoustic sensing on fibre-optic cables. The SHARP Storage project was launched in late 2021 with the overall aim to increase accuracy of subsurface CO2 storage containment risk management through the improvement and integration of subsurface stress models, rock mechanical failure and seismicity observations. SHARP is collaboration between 16 research institutions and companies and is supported under the ACT3 call. ACT is an ERA NET Cofund, which is a tool established by the European Commission under the Horizon 2020 programme for research and innovation. More information on the SHARP Storage project is found at https://sharp-storage-act.eu/.
Abstract
(2024)
-
Daniela Kühn, Anna Maria Dichiarante, Tom Kettlety, Evgeniia Martuganova, Joseph Asplet, Bettina Goertz-Allmann, Mark Fellgett, John Hopper, Annie Jerkins, More Authors...
Carbon capture and storage technologies are an essential part of EU’s decarbonisation efforts. Combined with sustainable energy resources, they are necessary to move Europe towards a net zero carbon emissions economy. Currently, several Mt-scale CO₂ storage projects are being developed in the North Sea. Containment risk evaluation includes analysing tectonic earthquake patterns to potentially map faults, reveal their orientation and failure style, invert for stress directions and at later stages, enable the discrimination of natural and induced seismicity. In addition, seismological information may contribute to the geomechanical understanding of the reservoir and caprock response to large-scale CO₂ injection over time.
A wealth of data exists from various European seismological agencies, but much of it has not been analysed collectively. Within the framework of the ACT3 project SHARP Storage, an extensive unique earthquake bulletin was compiled using seismicity data from all relevant data centres serving as a basis for further analysis, including event relocation and magnitude homogenisation. Inverted moment tensors, shear-wave splitting measurements, and stress drop analysis will be compared to and complement a review of borehole stress measurements to better gauge the present-day stress field and provide constraints on geomechanical models. In addition, the seismological data is integrated with geomechanical data, further improving the understanding of the state of stress and how this relates to fault failure and slip tendency. ...
A wealth of data exists from various European seismological agencies, but much of it has not been analysed collectively. Within the framework of the ACT3 project SHARP Storage, an extensive unique earthquake bulletin was compiled using seismicity data from all relevant data centres serving as a basis for further analysis, including event relocation and magnitude homogenisation. Inverted moment tensors, shear-wave splitting measurements, and stress drop analysis will be compared to and complement a review of borehole stress measurements to better gauge the present-day stress field and provide constraints on geomechanical models. In addition, the seismological data is integrated with geomechanical data, further improving the understanding of the state of stress and how this relates to fault failure and slip tendency. ...
Carbon capture and storage technologies are an essential part of EU’s decarbonisation efforts. Combined with sustainable energy resources, they are necessary to move Europe towards a net zero carbon emissions economy. Currently, several Mt-scale CO₂ storage projects are being developed in the North Sea. Containment risk evaluation includes analysing tectonic earthquake patterns to potentially map faults, reveal their orientation and failure style, invert for stress directions and at later stages, enable the discrimination of natural and induced seismicity. In addition, seismological information may contribute to the geomechanical understanding of the reservoir and caprock response to large-scale CO₂ injection over time.
A wealth of data exists from various European seismological agencies, but much of it has not been analysed collectively. Within the framework of the ACT3 project SHARP Storage, an extensive unique earthquake bulletin was compiled using seismicity data from all relevant data centres serving as a basis for further analysis, including event relocation and magnitude homogenisation. Inverted moment tensors, shear-wave splitting measurements, and stress drop analysis will be compared to and complement a review of borehole stress measurements to better gauge the present-day stress field and provide constraints on geomechanical models. In addition, the seismological data is integrated with geomechanical data, further improving the understanding of the state of stress and how this relates to fault failure and slip tendency.
A wealth of data exists from various European seismological agencies, but much of it has not been analysed collectively. Within the framework of the ACT3 project SHARP Storage, an extensive unique earthquake bulletin was compiled using seismicity data from all relevant data centres serving as a basis for further analysis, including event relocation and magnitude homogenisation. Inverted moment tensors, shear-wave splitting measurements, and stress drop analysis will be compared to and complement a review of borehole stress measurements to better gauge the present-day stress field and provide constraints on geomechanical models. In addition, the seismological data is integrated with geomechanical data, further improving the understanding of the state of stress and how this relates to fault failure and slip tendency.
We conducted laboratory experiments using large-scale samples (height: 0.47, diameter: 0.39 m) of basalt and marble coiled with telecommunication fibre. The fibre optical cable was converted to an array of densely spaced receivers (0.01 m) using distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) technology, and the source was placed on top of the samples. We demonstrate with an active acoustic setup how we can capture both the natural and artificial fracture responses. Therefore, this work investigates the applicability of the DAS method for seismic imaging on the lab scale for further technological advancement of vertical seismic profiling using DAS.
...
We conducted laboratory experiments using large-scale samples (height: 0.47, diameter: 0.39 m) of basalt and marble coiled with telecommunication fibre. The fibre optical cable was converted to an array of densely spaced receivers (0.01 m) using distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) technology, and the source was placed on top of the samples. We demonstrate with an active acoustic setup how we can capture both the natural and artificial fracture responses. Therefore, this work investigates the applicability of the DAS method for seismic imaging on the lab scale for further technological advancement of vertical seismic profiling using DAS.
Conference paper
(2023)
-
T. Kettlety, E. Martuganova, D. Kühn, J. Schweitzer, C. Weemstra, B. Baptie, T. Dahl-Jensen, J.M. Kendall
With the development of several CO₂ storage operations in the North Sea, there is a clear need to better characterise the seismic hazard and stress state in the region. Faults and associated fracture sets can act as hydraulic pathways for unintended CO₂ migration, ill-defined stress states can lead to numerous operational difficulties, and induced seismicity will be a clear risk as CO₂ is injected into subsurface reservoirs. Seismicity can reveal the location and extent of faults and fractures, and can be used to invert for the state of stress. Both operators and regulators therefore need a clear understanding of the rate of natural seismicity, to identify and distinguish induced events from natural, and to assess the likelihood of induced fault reactivation. This requires a dedicated, site specific background monitoring programme, as well as a high-quality seismic catalogue for the region around any CO₂ storage operation. Our study has produced the first dedicated seismic catalogue of the North Sea, based on all available data from each of the relevant seismological agencies. This dataset fosters further studies into seismic hazard, leakage risk, and stress state in a region that will be vital for European CO₂ storage efforts in the coming decades.
...
With the development of several CO₂ storage operations in the North Sea, there is a clear need to better characterise the seismic hazard and stress state in the region. Faults and associated fracture sets can act as hydraulic pathways for unintended CO₂ migration, ill-defined stress states can lead to numerous operational difficulties, and induced seismicity will be a clear risk as CO₂ is injected into subsurface reservoirs. Seismicity can reveal the location and extent of faults and fractures, and can be used to invert for the state of stress. Both operators and regulators therefore need a clear understanding of the rate of natural seismicity, to identify and distinguish induced events from natural, and to assess the likelihood of induced fault reactivation. This requires a dedicated, site specific background monitoring programme, as well as a high-quality seismic catalogue for the region around any CO₂ storage operation. Our study has produced the first dedicated seismic catalogue of the North Sea, based on all available data from each of the relevant seismological agencies. This dataset fosters further studies into seismic hazard, leakage risk, and stress state in a region that will be vital for European CO₂ storage efforts in the coming decades.
This work shows the potential of using DAS for continuous water-depth monitoring by using the difference in acoustic energy in water and mud. The advantage over conventional methods is that our method can be used continuously and remotely, given that there is traffic nearby. Due to the low cost of fibres and the far-reaching dynamic range of interrogators, DAS could be a very attractive alternative for water-depth monitoring using propeller noise in shallow marine environments, ports and waterways.
...
This work shows the potential of using DAS for continuous water-depth monitoring by using the difference in acoustic energy in water and mud. The advantage over conventional methods is that our method can be used continuously and remotely, given that there is traffic nearby. Due to the low cost of fibres and the far-reaching dynamic range of interrogators, DAS could be a very attractive alternative for water-depth monitoring using propeller noise in shallow marine environments, ports and waterways.
Purpose
Current surveying techniques used by port authorities to estimate the nautical depth are limited in depth resolution and temporal resolution. Because of this, certain heavily occupied quay walls cannot be optimised in terms of utilisation. Therefore, a permanent continuous measuring system with a higher depth resolution is needed to optimise the occupation at these quay walls. We show how this could be achieved with distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) using fibre-optical cables.
Materials
We analyse recordings from a dual-frequency echo-sounder source along a standard communication optical fibre coiled vertically around a PVC pipe to represent vertical seismic profiling. This PVC pipe is placed inside a transparent plastic cylindrical tank which is partly filled with water and mud. This allows us to track the water-mud interface visually. We use a Silixa iDAS v2 and a Febus A1 DAS interrogator to convert the optical fibre into a seismic sensor. We use a wave generator to select the source frequency and an amplifier to amplify the output of the wave generator to a SIMRAD 38/200 COMBI C dual-frequency echo-sounder.
Results
We identify standing waves and use them to make accurate depth estimates of the water-mud interface inside the column we measure. Due to the high apparent velocity, the standing waves are easy to identify in the time domain. Due to the constructive interference, standing waves also show the water-mud interface in a power spectral density plot. We demonstrate that these standing waves could be used with an on-demand permanent continuous measuring system using ambient noise sources.
Conclusion
Our laboratory experiment showed that DAS could be used to estimate the water-mud interface. In addition, we showed the potential for on-demand monitoring in ports and waterways using DAS. Furthermore, due to the low cost of optical fibres, and the possibility of utilising ambient noise sources, DAS could be used for continuous depth monitoring purposes in ports and waterways. ...
Current surveying techniques used by port authorities to estimate the nautical depth are limited in depth resolution and temporal resolution. Because of this, certain heavily occupied quay walls cannot be optimised in terms of utilisation. Therefore, a permanent continuous measuring system with a higher depth resolution is needed to optimise the occupation at these quay walls. We show how this could be achieved with distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) using fibre-optical cables.
Materials
We analyse recordings from a dual-frequency echo-sounder source along a standard communication optical fibre coiled vertically around a PVC pipe to represent vertical seismic profiling. This PVC pipe is placed inside a transparent plastic cylindrical tank which is partly filled with water and mud. This allows us to track the water-mud interface visually. We use a Silixa iDAS v2 and a Febus A1 DAS interrogator to convert the optical fibre into a seismic sensor. We use a wave generator to select the source frequency and an amplifier to amplify the output of the wave generator to a SIMRAD 38/200 COMBI C dual-frequency echo-sounder.
Results
We identify standing waves and use them to make accurate depth estimates of the water-mud interface inside the column we measure. Due to the high apparent velocity, the standing waves are easy to identify in the time domain. Due to the constructive interference, standing waves also show the water-mud interface in a power spectral density plot. We demonstrate that these standing waves could be used with an on-demand permanent continuous measuring system using ambient noise sources.
Conclusion
Our laboratory experiment showed that DAS could be used to estimate the water-mud interface. In addition, we showed the potential for on-demand monitoring in ports and waterways using DAS. Furthermore, due to the low cost of optical fibres, and the possibility of utilising ambient noise sources, DAS could be used for continuous depth monitoring purposes in ports and waterways. ...
Purpose
Current surveying techniques used by port authorities to estimate the nautical depth are limited in depth resolution and temporal resolution. Because of this, certain heavily occupied quay walls cannot be optimised in terms of utilisation. Therefore, a permanent continuous measuring system with a higher depth resolution is needed to optimise the occupation at these quay walls. We show how this could be achieved with distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) using fibre-optical cables.
Materials
We analyse recordings from a dual-frequency echo-sounder source along a standard communication optical fibre coiled vertically around a PVC pipe to represent vertical seismic profiling. This PVC pipe is placed inside a transparent plastic cylindrical tank which is partly filled with water and mud. This allows us to track the water-mud interface visually. We use a Silixa iDAS v2 and a Febus A1 DAS interrogator to convert the optical fibre into a seismic sensor. We use a wave generator to select the source frequency and an amplifier to amplify the output of the wave generator to a SIMRAD 38/200 COMBI C dual-frequency echo-sounder.
Results
We identify standing waves and use them to make accurate depth estimates of the water-mud interface inside the column we measure. Due to the high apparent velocity, the standing waves are easy to identify in the time domain. Due to the constructive interference, standing waves also show the water-mud interface in a power spectral density plot. We demonstrate that these standing waves could be used with an on-demand permanent continuous measuring system using ambient noise sources.
Conclusion
Our laboratory experiment showed that DAS could be used to estimate the water-mud interface. In addition, we showed the potential for on-demand monitoring in ports and waterways using DAS. Furthermore, due to the low cost of optical fibres, and the possibility of utilising ambient noise sources, DAS could be used for continuous depth monitoring purposes in ports and waterways.
Current surveying techniques used by port authorities to estimate the nautical depth are limited in depth resolution and temporal resolution. Because of this, certain heavily occupied quay walls cannot be optimised in terms of utilisation. Therefore, a permanent continuous measuring system with a higher depth resolution is needed to optimise the occupation at these quay walls. We show how this could be achieved with distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) using fibre-optical cables.
Materials
We analyse recordings from a dual-frequency echo-sounder source along a standard communication optical fibre coiled vertically around a PVC pipe to represent vertical seismic profiling. This PVC pipe is placed inside a transparent plastic cylindrical tank which is partly filled with water and mud. This allows us to track the water-mud interface visually. We use a Silixa iDAS v2 and a Febus A1 DAS interrogator to convert the optical fibre into a seismic sensor. We use a wave generator to select the source frequency and an amplifier to amplify the output of the wave generator to a SIMRAD 38/200 COMBI C dual-frequency echo-sounder.
Results
We identify standing waves and use them to make accurate depth estimates of the water-mud interface inside the column we measure. Due to the high apparent velocity, the standing waves are easy to identify in the time domain. Due to the constructive interference, standing waves also show the water-mud interface in a power spectral density plot. We demonstrate that these standing waves could be used with an on-demand permanent continuous measuring system using ambient noise sources.
Conclusion
Our laboratory experiment showed that DAS could be used to estimate the water-mud interface. In addition, we showed the potential for on-demand monitoring in ports and waterways using DAS. Furthermore, due to the low cost of optical fibres, and the possibility of utilising ambient noise sources, DAS could be used for continuous depth monitoring purposes in ports and waterways.
Monitoring the nautical depth is vital for the safe passage of water transport. Port authorities worldwide have different navigable depth criteria and use various methods to ensure the safe navigability and manoeuvrability of ships in ports and waterways. These measurements often require a surveying vessel and are limited in repeatability and accuracy. Often, it is challenging to survey at heavily occupied quay walls; this may hinder economical activities. Additionally, because the current monitoring techniques depend on a surveying vessel's availability, monitoring significant changes in the nautical depth after, for instance, storms, is challenging, especially over large areas. Reliable continuous depth measurements could therefore help to optimise ships’ docking operations in heavily occupied areas. We show how the nautical depth can be measured and demonstrate the potential for estimating shear stresses using distributed acoustic sensing. Our laboratory study and our field test show that the acoustic energy differs for non- Newtonian fluids with different shear strength. For our laboratory experiment, we use natural and synthetic sediment suspensions for measuring the difference in acoustic attenuation with an optical fibre wrapped around a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pipe. Our first acoustic measurement conducted one hour after mixing has a shear strength of 17 Pa and shows very high attenuation. The second laboratory test recorded 24 hours after mixing, with the shear strength of 48 Pa, reveals a tremendous signal-attenuation decrease and thus amplitude increase. In our field experiment, we observe a similar increase in amplitude with increased shear strength when recording propeller noise from passing vessels for frequencies < 60 Hz. We also observe a reverse trend for frequencies > 100 Hz. This difference in amplitude with depth might be related to a difference in fibre coupling and a difference in attenuation of acoustic waves. Additionally, our field experiment shows the potential to use Distributed Acoustic Sensing for continuous depth measurements.
...
Monitoring the nautical depth is vital for the safe passage of water transport. Port authorities worldwide have different navigable depth criteria and use various methods to ensure the safe navigability and manoeuvrability of ships in ports and waterways. These measurements often require a surveying vessel and are limited in repeatability and accuracy. Often, it is challenging to survey at heavily occupied quay walls; this may hinder economical activities. Additionally, because the current monitoring techniques depend on a surveying vessel's availability, monitoring significant changes in the nautical depth after, for instance, storms, is challenging, especially over large areas. Reliable continuous depth measurements could therefore help to optimise ships’ docking operations in heavily occupied areas. We show how the nautical depth can be measured and demonstrate the potential for estimating shear stresses using distributed acoustic sensing. Our laboratory study and our field test show that the acoustic energy differs for non- Newtonian fluids with different shear strength. For our laboratory experiment, we use natural and synthetic sediment suspensions for measuring the difference in acoustic attenuation with an optical fibre wrapped around a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pipe. Our first acoustic measurement conducted one hour after mixing has a shear strength of 17 Pa and shows very high attenuation. The second laboratory test recorded 24 hours after mixing, with the shear strength of 48 Pa, reveals a tremendous signal-attenuation decrease and thus amplitude increase. In our field experiment, we observe a similar increase in amplitude with increased shear strength when recording propeller noise from passing vessels for frequencies < 60 Hz. We also observe a reverse trend for frequencies > 100 Hz. This difference in amplitude with depth might be related to a difference in fibre coupling and a difference in attenuation of acoustic waves. Additionally, our field experiment shows the potential to use Distributed Acoustic Sensing for continuous depth measurements.