D.F. Naranjo Hernandez
Please Note
16 records found
1
Advanced seismic monitoring tools for monitoring Dutch geothermal systems
Addressing event detection in noisy environments, hypocenter inversion, velocity-model validation, experimental network design, and correction of clock errors
In Chapter 2, we introduce a seismic monitoring workflow to detect and characterise low-magnitude seismic events in noisy environments. We incorporate uncertainties from the open-access regional seismic velocity model into the hypocentre estimations. We apply the workflow to the recorded data from a temporary passive network deployed around the Kwintsheul geothermal operation in South Holland, where one low-magnitude seismic event had previously been reported. The network is located in a high-noise environment, characteristic of most geothermal operations in the Netherlands. Despite the high noise levels, we identify five additional low-magnitude seismic events that occurred close to a local fault and the injection well. These are the first events ever recorded in the region. However, large hypocentre uncertainties—due to limitations in the seismic velocity model and sparse azimuthal coverage—prevent a clear interpretation of the underlying processes. From these two limiting factors, only the velocity model can be refined after an event has been recorded. However, refining the available seismic velocity model implies significant costs, as active seismic sources are usually used.
In Chapter 3, we introduce a workflow for validating the seismic velocity model based on body-wave seismic interferometry as a cost-effective alternative. Our workflow is motivated by the possibility of retrieving virtual-offset reflection responses when seismic energy arrives with near-vertical incidence to the receivers. We apply our workflow using the low-magnitude seismic events that we detected. We find that the P-wave velocity model effectively explains the observed retrieved reflections at shallow depths. In contrast, the available S-wave models do not match the data. We conclude that the P-wave model is reliable for hypocentre studies, but that the S-wave model requires refinement.
In Chapter 4, we address how the network geometry influences the detectability and hypocentre resolution of seismic events and implement a workflow for designing seismic networks. In our workflow, we integrate open-access subsurface information to generate a synthetic earthquake catalogue using knowledge of faults and areas of expected higher seismicity risk. We then apply a non-linear design strategy and a global search algorithm to ensure approximately optimal configurations. Finally, we validate the network designs through synthetic hypocentre inversions. We identify the Dutch North Sea as the area in most need of seismic receivers, due to (i) upcoming carbon capture and storage (CCS) initiatives, (ii) the lowest existing network coverage, and (iii) the potential future use of existing oil-and-gas infrastructure for offshore geothermal-energy developments. We apply our workflow to the K-14 offshore field, where carbon capture and storage is planned. The results show that the optimised networks provide sufficient azimuthal coverage and location accuracy, even under simplified assumptions. This workflow can guide the design of cost effective networks in both onshore and offshore environments.
In Chapter 5, we focus on accurate time synchronization of seismic networks. We introduce a data-driven method to detect and correct clock errors using the time-symmetry of ambient-noise correlations. We apply our method to the IMAGE network in Reykjanes, Iceland, deployed to monitor offshore geothermal activity. Offshore geothermal-energy operations introduce additional challenges due to the need for ocean-bottom seismometers (OBS), which lack direct access to GNSS signals, leading to clock-drift errors that affect event timing and localisation. We show that most OBS in the network experienced clock drift, and some had large initial time offsets. We provide an open-source Python package (OCloC) that implements this method, enabling better timing accuracy and improved hypocentre estimation in future offshore monitoring, which can be applied in future offshore geothermal energy and the upcoming carbon capture and storage operations in the Dutch North Sea.
Together, in this thesis we introduce new or adapted workflows to tackle specific limitations in current low-magnitude seismic monitoring practices. By addressing these challenges, this thesis advances the capabilities of seismic monitoring in both onshore and offshore settings. By improving detection, location, velocity model validation, network design, and timing correction, this thesis contributes to the development of robust and cost effective seismic monitoring systems. These tools support operators and regulators in making informed decisions for the safe and sustainable scaling of geothermal energy and carbon storage in the Netherlands and beyond.
...
In Chapter 2, we introduce a seismic monitoring workflow to detect and characterise low-magnitude seismic events in noisy environments. We incorporate uncertainties from the open-access regional seismic velocity model into the hypocentre estimations. We apply the workflow to the recorded data from a temporary passive network deployed around the Kwintsheul geothermal operation in South Holland, where one low-magnitude seismic event had previously been reported. The network is located in a high-noise environment, characteristic of most geothermal operations in the Netherlands. Despite the high noise levels, we identify five additional low-magnitude seismic events that occurred close to a local fault and the injection well. These are the first events ever recorded in the region. However, large hypocentre uncertainties—due to limitations in the seismic velocity model and sparse azimuthal coverage—prevent a clear interpretation of the underlying processes. From these two limiting factors, only the velocity model can be refined after an event has been recorded. However, refining the available seismic velocity model implies significant costs, as active seismic sources are usually used.
In Chapter 3, we introduce a workflow for validating the seismic velocity model based on body-wave seismic interferometry as a cost-effective alternative. Our workflow is motivated by the possibility of retrieving virtual-offset reflection responses when seismic energy arrives with near-vertical incidence to the receivers. We apply our workflow using the low-magnitude seismic events that we detected. We find that the P-wave velocity model effectively explains the observed retrieved reflections at shallow depths. In contrast, the available S-wave models do not match the data. We conclude that the P-wave model is reliable for hypocentre studies, but that the S-wave model requires refinement.
In Chapter 4, we address how the network geometry influences the detectability and hypocentre resolution of seismic events and implement a workflow for designing seismic networks. In our workflow, we integrate open-access subsurface information to generate a synthetic earthquake catalogue using knowledge of faults and areas of expected higher seismicity risk. We then apply a non-linear design strategy and a global search algorithm to ensure approximately optimal configurations. Finally, we validate the network designs through synthetic hypocentre inversions. We identify the Dutch North Sea as the area in most need of seismic receivers, due to (i) upcoming carbon capture and storage (CCS) initiatives, (ii) the lowest existing network coverage, and (iii) the potential future use of existing oil-and-gas infrastructure for offshore geothermal-energy developments. We apply our workflow to the K-14 offshore field, where carbon capture and storage is planned. The results show that the optimised networks provide sufficient azimuthal coverage and location accuracy, even under simplified assumptions. This workflow can guide the design of cost effective networks in both onshore and offshore environments.
In Chapter 5, we focus on accurate time synchronization of seismic networks. We introduce a data-driven method to detect and correct clock errors using the time-symmetry of ambient-noise correlations. We apply our method to the IMAGE network in Reykjanes, Iceland, deployed to monitor offshore geothermal activity. Offshore geothermal-energy operations introduce additional challenges due to the need for ocean-bottom seismometers (OBS), which lack direct access to GNSS signals, leading to clock-drift errors that affect event timing and localisation. We show that most OBS in the network experienced clock drift, and some had large initial time offsets. We provide an open-source Python package (OCloC) that implements this method, enabling better timing accuracy and improved hypocentre estimation in future offshore monitoring, which can be applied in future offshore geothermal energy and the upcoming carbon capture and storage operations in the Dutch North Sea.
Together, in this thesis we introduce new or adapted workflows to tackle specific limitations in current low-magnitude seismic monitoring practices. By addressing these challenges, this thesis advances the capabilities of seismic monitoring in both onshore and offshore settings. By improving detection, location, velocity model validation, network design, and timing correction, this thesis contributes to the development of robust and cost effective seismic monitoring systems. These tools support operators and regulators in making informed decisions for the safe and sustainable scaling of geothermal energy and carbon storage in the Netherlands and beyond.
Ensuring safe North Sea CO2 storage
The design of robust seismic networks to enable focal mechanism analyses for stress field orientation
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea. ...
Within the ACT SHARP Storage project framework, a newly compiled detailed earthquake bulletin (Kettlety et al., 2024) and waveforms collected in the North Sea region were utilised to invert for moment tensors. Proposed CO2 storage sites in the North Sea are often located far from existing onshore seismological networks, resulting in sparse records and large azimuthal gaps, leading to significant uncertainties in earthquake parameters estimation, such as epicentre coordinates and hypocentral depth, making it very challenging to discriminate natural and induced events.
To address these limitations, we conducted a synthetic study to optimise the placement of offshore stations to improve the monitoring of CO₂ storage sites. Using the open-source Fomosto package, we modelled seismic responses from various double-couple sources and incorporated noise data from existing OBS deployments in Germany and Denmark. The results highlight optimal station configurations and strategies to enhance seismic monitoring, enabling better recovery of focal mechanisms and detecting micro-seismicity that may constitute induced seismicity or early precursors of CO₂ storage containment failure.
This study provides practical advice on designing robust seismic networks, paving the way for improved stress field knowledge and safer CCS operations in the North Sea.
Urban challenges in seismology
Seismic monitoring of Kwintsheul’s geothermal operation (the Netherlands)
Overcoming Urban Noise and Model Uncertainty
Induced Seismicity Monitoring in Dutch Geothermal Fields
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies. ...
Within the ACT project SHARP Storage framework, we have addressed this gap by generating a comprehensive earthquake bulletin for the North Sea, revealing spatial clusters of seismic events with the majority of earthquakes with ML < 4. Focal mechanisms of earthquakes are excellent indicators of crustal dynamics, which are essential for assessing the present-day stress field. Therefore, to improve the understanding of the in-situ stress conditions, we created a comprehensive workflow to evaluate focal mechanisms based on data from the North Sea (Kettlety et al., 2023). First, we developed a routine for the seismological bulletin to aggregate the recorded earthquakes from international seismological centres. The following step included retrieval of the waveforms from data centres and quality control routines, which included dead channels check, exclusion of files with significant recording gaps and low signal-to-noise ratio, and corrections of errors in the station XML files. Then, a subset of data traces with sufficient quality was selected for moment tensor computations using a Bayesian bootstrap-based probabilistic inversion scheme (see Heimann et al., 2018). Using existing focal mechanism solutions for the North Sea region, we calibrated our processing routine and then applied it to selected earthquakes (after 1990, M > 3.5) to expand the existing focal mechanisms database.
The newly computed focal mechanism solutions provide valuable insight into the present-day stress field in areas outside the main hydrocarbon provinces and improve the risk assessment of ongoing and future CCS projects. Furthermore, we will release our processing workflow as an open-source package and a new focal mechanisms database of the North Sea to establish a standard processing routine that can be readily utilised for similar seismological studies.
Determining clock errors of ocean-bottom seismometers
An ambient-noise based method designed for large-scale ocean bottom deployments
The algorithm presented in this study exploits seismic interferometry (SI). Specifically, time-lapse (averaged) cross-correlations of ambient seismic noise are computed. As such, virtual-source responses, which are generally dominated by the recorded surface waves, are retrieved. These interferometric responses generate two virtual sources: a causal wave (arriving at a positive time) and an acausal wave (arriving at a negative time). Under favorable conditions, both interferometric responses approach the surface-wave part of the medium's Green's function. Therefore, it is possible to calculate the clock drift for each station by exploiting the time-symmetry between the causal and acausal waves. For this purpose, the clock drift is calculated by measuring the differential arrival times of the causal and acausal waves for a large number of receiver-receiver pairs and computing the drift by carrying-out a least-squares inversion. The methodology described is applied to time-lapse cross-correlations of ambient seismic noise recorded on and around the Reykjanes peninsula, SW Iceland. The stations used for the analysis were deployed in the context of IMAGE (Integrated Methods for Advanced Geothermal Exploration) and consisted of 30 on-land stations and 24 ocean bottom seismometers (OBSs). The seismic activity was recorded from spring 2014 until August 2015 on an area of around 100 km in diameter (from the tip of the Reykjanes peninsula). ...
The algorithm presented in this study exploits seismic interferometry (SI). Specifically, time-lapse (averaged) cross-correlations of ambient seismic noise are computed. As such, virtual-source responses, which are generally dominated by the recorded surface waves, are retrieved. These interferometric responses generate two virtual sources: a causal wave (arriving at a positive time) and an acausal wave (arriving at a negative time). Under favorable conditions, both interferometric responses approach the surface-wave part of the medium's Green's function. Therefore, it is possible to calculate the clock drift for each station by exploiting the time-symmetry between the causal and acausal waves. For this purpose, the clock drift is calculated by measuring the differential arrival times of the causal and acausal waves for a large number of receiver-receiver pairs and computing the drift by carrying-out a least-squares inversion. The methodology described is applied to time-lapse cross-correlations of ambient seismic noise recorded on and around the Reykjanes peninsula, SW Iceland. The stations used for the analysis were deployed in the context of IMAGE (Integrated Methods for Advanced Geothermal Exploration) and consisted of 30 on-land stations and 24 ocean bottom seismometers (OBSs). The seismic activity was recorded from spring 2014 until August 2015 on an area of around 100 km in diameter (from the tip of the Reykjanes peninsula).
To calculate the slip distribution, we merged different functions from ObsPy, MudPy and Syngine in order to retrieve, process and invert the broadband seismic data provided by the USGS and the RSNC (Red Sismológica Nacional de Colombia) including near- and far-field stations. First, we defined the fault plane for inversion using the moment tensor and regional geologic information. We then divided the fault plane into 300 rectangular subfaults in order to calculate the slip amplitude for each patch in the source region. The green functions and synthetics are calculated using different codes for the far-field (Syngine) and the near field (MudPy), both applying a triangle source time function with different durations to identify the correct rise time and fall time for this event. The synthetics and observed seismic signals are finally processed using ObsPy and the inversion is done using MudPy. After calculating the slip distribution, we find two main asperities at depths of approximately 20km with a maximum slip of about 20 cm. The two asperities are located on the left and right sides of the mainshock hypocenter. The aftershocks are first relocated and then compared with the slip distribution in order to investigate coseismic triggering by the mainshock. This kind of study is one of the first carried out for a Colombian earthquake and will help to better define fault systems and seismic hazard in this area. ...
To calculate the slip distribution, we merged different functions from ObsPy, MudPy and Syngine in order to retrieve, process and invert the broadband seismic data provided by the USGS and the RSNC (Red Sismológica Nacional de Colombia) including near- and far-field stations. First, we defined the fault plane for inversion using the moment tensor and regional geologic information. We then divided the fault plane into 300 rectangular subfaults in order to calculate the slip amplitude for each patch in the source region. The green functions and synthetics are calculated using different codes for the far-field (Syngine) and the near field (MudPy), both applying a triangle source time function with different durations to identify the correct rise time and fall time for this event. The synthetics and observed seismic signals are finally processed using ObsPy and the inversion is done using MudPy. After calculating the slip distribution, we find two main asperities at depths of approximately 20km with a maximum slip of about 20 cm. The two asperities are located on the left and right sides of the mainshock hypocenter. The aftershocks are first relocated and then compared with the slip distribution in order to investigate coseismic triggering by the mainshock. This kind of study is one of the first carried out for a Colombian earthquake and will help to better define fault systems and seismic hazard in this area.