A.J. van der Hout
Please Note
8 records found
1
Locking Strategies IJmuiden
Developing and validating a method to quantify the effects of restrictive locking measures on both salt intrusion and vessel waiting times
A first step is to identify how vessels pass shipping locks. We identify the important events that make up the entire lock passage procedure of a ship. Specifically we distinguish: approach, doors open, sailing in, doors closing, levelling, doors opening, sailing out and doors closing again. Next, we identify how the hydrodynamic processes that occur during the locking process influence salt intrusion. The most impactful hydrodynamic processes that occur are taking place between doors opening and closing, and during levelling.
Next we investigate what models are available to simulate both the shipping events and the salt exchange events. While there are several modelling concepts out there, we conclude that for the challenge at hand it is most suitable to use the mesoscopic agent-based traffic simulation model OpenTNSim to simulate vessel passages through locks. We couple this with the semi-empirical salt exchange model called the Zeesluisformulering. The main reason to choose this combination is that a discrete event agent based nautical traffic model captures exactly those events that drive the salt exchange estimates of the Zeesluisformulering. By combining both methods we get a new method that allows us to quantify how salt intrusion mitigation measures affect shipping performance and salt levels intrusion through the lock.
To determine how well the proposed combination of models works in practice we apply it to a real world case. For this thesis we select as our case location the Sea Lock IJmuiden, which at this point is the largest sea lock in the world. The lock complex in IJmuiden is suitable as a case, in February and March of 2023 salt intrusion measurements have been taken by Deltares and Rijkswaterstaat. During this period we also know what ships passed the locks, based on records taken by maritime students of the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences. Based on these data sources we can test if the combination of models is capable of reproducing the observed behaviour...
...
A first step is to identify how vessels pass shipping locks. We identify the important events that make up the entire lock passage procedure of a ship. Specifically we distinguish: approach, doors open, sailing in, doors closing, levelling, doors opening, sailing out and doors closing again. Next, we identify how the hydrodynamic processes that occur during the locking process influence salt intrusion. The most impactful hydrodynamic processes that occur are taking place between doors opening and closing, and during levelling.
Next we investigate what models are available to simulate both the shipping events and the salt exchange events. While there are several modelling concepts out there, we conclude that for the challenge at hand it is most suitable to use the mesoscopic agent-based traffic simulation model OpenTNSim to simulate vessel passages through locks. We couple this with the semi-empirical salt exchange model called the Zeesluisformulering. The main reason to choose this combination is that a discrete event agent based nautical traffic model captures exactly those events that drive the salt exchange estimates of the Zeesluisformulering. By combining both methods we get a new method that allows us to quantify how salt intrusion mitigation measures affect shipping performance and salt levels intrusion through the lock.
To determine how well the proposed combination of models works in practice we apply it to a real world case. For this thesis we select as our case location the Sea Lock IJmuiden, which at this point is the largest sea lock in the world. The lock complex in IJmuiden is suitable as a case, in February and March of 2023 salt intrusion measurements have been taken by Deltares and Rijkswaterstaat. During this period we also know what ships passed the locks, based on records taken by maritime students of the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences. Based on these data sources we can test if the combination of models is capable of reproducing the observed behaviour...
Investigating the incident records reveals that the key contributors are the primary water motions generated by the passing vessels in the Western Scheldt. The phenomenon, experienced as a sudden lowering of the water level and suction forces, can lead to the breakage of mooring lines and uncontrolled movements of inland ships, resulting in a range of safety hazards and operational disruptions. Several documented incidents, field studies and interviews highlight the urgency for effective measures to mitigate the potentially harmful effects of passing vessels on the ships in the Hansweert outer harbour and locks.
A seven-week measurement campaign, involving 1281 passages of so-called oversized vessels, reveals distinct patterns of water level fluctuations during a vessel’s passage. A vessel is considered oversized if its length exceeds 210 metres or if its draught is larger than 10 metres. These patterns are described as a translatory drawdown wave travelling into the harbour, reflecting against the lock complex and oscillating back and forth in the outer harbour until dampened. The key parameter characterizing this wave is the lowering of the water level, referred to as the drawdown height. The average measured drawdown height approximates 6 centimetres, with maximum observations up to 40 centimetres. The main factors influencing the drawdown height are the vessel’s passing distance to the outer harbour, its speed relative to the currents and its dimensions, shown by a correlation analysis between the parameters describing the passing vessel and the generated drawdown height. Extreme drawdown events were exclusively observed during a combination of a relatively high speed through the water of the seagoing vessel and small passing distances relative to the harbour’s entrance.
The impact of the drawdown effects on the inland ships is determined by the forces generated by the pressure difference along the ships, caused by the inclination of the water level. A critical drawdown height of 12 centimetres is set, based on existing force criteria and the linear relation between the drawdown height and water level slope. To improve on the existing drawdown height prediction methods, a site-specific drawdown height prediction equation has been derived. Validation of this equation using the observations made during the measurement campaign yields a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.81 and an Mean Absolute Error score of 2.2 centimetres.
Preventative measures are identified, aiming to minimize incidents and mitigate the risks related to the water motions induced by passing vessels. The predicted drawdown, generated by the passing vessel, is kept below the critical level by recommending a maximum speed related to the passing distance and dimensions of the vessel. Practically, this measure could be applied as a calculation tool or as an overlay on the pilot’s electronic sea chart. Coupling this information with awareness campaigns for pilots will contribute to minimizing the adverse effects on the ships in the outer harbour. The resilience against drawdown-induced risks could be strengthened by restricting the maximum combined width of ships moored alongside. Furthermore, by limiting the excessive slack in the lines of the moored ships, through signage and floating bollards, the movements of the ships will be restricted, reducing the risk of line breakage. Notifications of anticipated critical drawdowns would allow traffic controllers or lock operators to caution the inland ships and delay the lock chamber door openings, whilst alerting the passing vessel. Incorporating the mitigation measures recommended in this research could positively impact the safety of navigation in the Hansweert outer harbour and locks. ...
Investigating the incident records reveals that the key contributors are the primary water motions generated by the passing vessels in the Western Scheldt. The phenomenon, experienced as a sudden lowering of the water level and suction forces, can lead to the breakage of mooring lines and uncontrolled movements of inland ships, resulting in a range of safety hazards and operational disruptions. Several documented incidents, field studies and interviews highlight the urgency for effective measures to mitigate the potentially harmful effects of passing vessels on the ships in the Hansweert outer harbour and locks.
A seven-week measurement campaign, involving 1281 passages of so-called oversized vessels, reveals distinct patterns of water level fluctuations during a vessel’s passage. A vessel is considered oversized if its length exceeds 210 metres or if its draught is larger than 10 metres. These patterns are described as a translatory drawdown wave travelling into the harbour, reflecting against the lock complex and oscillating back and forth in the outer harbour until dampened. The key parameter characterizing this wave is the lowering of the water level, referred to as the drawdown height. The average measured drawdown height approximates 6 centimetres, with maximum observations up to 40 centimetres. The main factors influencing the drawdown height are the vessel’s passing distance to the outer harbour, its speed relative to the currents and its dimensions, shown by a correlation analysis between the parameters describing the passing vessel and the generated drawdown height. Extreme drawdown events were exclusively observed during a combination of a relatively high speed through the water of the seagoing vessel and small passing distances relative to the harbour’s entrance.
The impact of the drawdown effects on the inland ships is determined by the forces generated by the pressure difference along the ships, caused by the inclination of the water level. A critical drawdown height of 12 centimetres is set, based on existing force criteria and the linear relation between the drawdown height and water level slope. To improve on the existing drawdown height prediction methods, a site-specific drawdown height prediction equation has been derived. Validation of this equation using the observations made during the measurement campaign yields a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.81 and an Mean Absolute Error score of 2.2 centimetres.
Preventative measures are identified, aiming to minimize incidents and mitigate the risks related to the water motions induced by passing vessels. The predicted drawdown, generated by the passing vessel, is kept below the critical level by recommending a maximum speed related to the passing distance and dimensions of the vessel. Practically, this measure could be applied as a calculation tool or as an overlay on the pilot’s electronic sea chart. Coupling this information with awareness campaigns for pilots will contribute to minimizing the adverse effects on the ships in the outer harbour. The resilience against drawdown-induced risks could be strengthened by restricting the maximum combined width of ships moored alongside. Furthermore, by limiting the excessive slack in the lines of the moored ships, through signage and floating bollards, the movements of the ships will be restricted, reducing the risk of line breakage. Notifications of anticipated critical drawdowns would allow traffic controllers or lock operators to caution the inland ships and delay the lock chamber door openings, whilst alerting the passing vessel. Incorporating the mitigation measures recommended in this research could positively impact the safety of navigation in the Hansweert outer harbour and locks.
Improving workability estimates for the offshore wind industry
Estimating the workability of marine operations more accurately using the dynamic response motions of vessels and turbine structures
From the scale model tests, wave transmission showed to be highly dependent on the wave frequency, and thus the wavelength, of the incident waves. The floating solar system acts as a low pass filter: it lets the low-frequency waves pass through, whereas the waves with higher frequency are attenuated by the structure. This dependence is governed by the ratio between the incident wavelength and the length of the rigid platforms that the solar structure consists of, measured in parallel to the wave propagation direction. When the wavelengths were smaller than twice the length of a platform, waves were almost fully attenuated. Apart from the dependence on frequency, the basin test results also showed that the amount of wave attenuation increases linearly with the total length of the system, but only with a small slope. Furthermore, analysis of the reflected wave signal indicated that higher-order dissipative effects are likely needed to describe the decrease in transmission accurately, because the amount of wave energy that was reflected by the structure was limited.
A proof-of-concept for applying a linear numerical boundary element diffraction model to a fixed shallow solar structure was carried out. The wave surface elevation could be obtained, and these solutions were in accordance with the physical expectations. The results showed similar trends to the basin test results, but did not match quantitatively. This difference could lie in the model approach, where a two-dimensional transmission coefficient is determined from three-dimensional simulations. It could also be that the scattering effects alone cannot approximate the transmission behaviour of the system, because linear radiation effects or higher-order dissipation effects might be of similar importance and are therefore required for an accurate simulation. Radiation could be included in a linear diffraction model, but dissipation requires higher-order wave theory.
Regarding the multi-use context, a down-wave shadow zone can form if the incident waves are short enough. For the North Sea location considered, waves are typically longer than twice the length of the rigid platforms, thus the floating solar structure might not have the breakwater performance that is desired to protect other offshore activities. ...
From the scale model tests, wave transmission showed to be highly dependent on the wave frequency, and thus the wavelength, of the incident waves. The floating solar system acts as a low pass filter: it lets the low-frequency waves pass through, whereas the waves with higher frequency are attenuated by the structure. This dependence is governed by the ratio between the incident wavelength and the length of the rigid platforms that the solar structure consists of, measured in parallel to the wave propagation direction. When the wavelengths were smaller than twice the length of a platform, waves were almost fully attenuated. Apart from the dependence on frequency, the basin test results also showed that the amount of wave attenuation increases linearly with the total length of the system, but only with a small slope. Furthermore, analysis of the reflected wave signal indicated that higher-order dissipative effects are likely needed to describe the decrease in transmission accurately, because the amount of wave energy that was reflected by the structure was limited.
A proof-of-concept for applying a linear numerical boundary element diffraction model to a fixed shallow solar structure was carried out. The wave surface elevation could be obtained, and these solutions were in accordance with the physical expectations. The results showed similar trends to the basin test results, but did not match quantitatively. This difference could lie in the model approach, where a two-dimensional transmission coefficient is determined from three-dimensional simulations. It could also be that the scattering effects alone cannot approximate the transmission behaviour of the system, because linear radiation effects or higher-order dissipation effects might be of similar importance and are therefore required for an accurate simulation. Radiation could be included in a linear diffraction model, but dissipation requires higher-order wave theory.
Regarding the multi-use context, a down-wave shadow zone can form if the incident waves are short enough. For the North Sea location considered, waves are typically longer than twice the length of the rigid platforms, thus the floating solar structure might not have the breakwater performance that is desired to protect other offshore activities.
Decay of bow thruster induced near-bed flow velocities at a vertical quay wall
A field measurement
Mild-Slope Wave Modelling for Dynamic Mooring Analyses
An exploratory study into an efficient alternative to the wave penetration model
A DMA is a chain of numerical models that computes motions of moored vessels due to wind, currents or waves. It is used to model the behaviour of moored ships to evaluate operational conditions and assess the effect of structural or operational measures. The most computational costly model in the DMA chain is the wave penetration model, which computes local wave field, speeding up this part of model chain can reduce time and costs of such DMA's.
In this research, the complex wave model is replaced by a computationally efficient alternative and the main research question reads:
How can a mild-slope wave model be used for the ship motion calculation on ships moored in ports and what are the benefits and limitations?
The research is split up into two parts: 1) Development of the coupling method and evaluating its application based on academic test cases and 2) Applying the coupling to the case study of La Coruña and assessing its suitability.
A practical and efficient method to extract wave components from the wave penetration model is the r-DPRA tool developed by Deltares. The developed method is applied to the case study of the port of La Coruña. Two separate moments in time of the same bulk carrier are modelled: one with moderate offshore wave conditions and one with more severe conditions.
In the measured time series of the surge and sway motions, a clear low frequency can be found. Similarly, in the simulated time series of the surge and sway motions; both in moderate and heavy cases no low frequency wave patterns can be found. A schematic approach is used to include the long waves in the wave model and ship motion model and this approach caused a low frequency wave pattern to arise and leads to more accurate significant motions.
The comparison between the measured motions and modelled motions demonstrated the complexity of modelling real life events. As the surge and sway motions are caused by second order effects that are not included in the applied linear wave model, it is recommended to apply the developed workaround to schematically include this low wave forcing. The result of this research demonstrates the potential for the development method.
Before directly applying the method, it is recommended to test the suitability of the method on a more fundamental case, this reduces uncertainties related to real life measurements and stronger conclusions about the performance of the coupling can be drawn. Moreover, the coupling should be tested for a case where the 2nd order low frequency wave forcing is negligible. As it is confirmed in this research that the developed method is not suitable for modelling non-linear 2nd order low frequency waves.
...
A DMA is a chain of numerical models that computes motions of moored vessels due to wind, currents or waves. It is used to model the behaviour of moored ships to evaluate operational conditions and assess the effect of structural or operational measures. The most computational costly model in the DMA chain is the wave penetration model, which computes local wave field, speeding up this part of model chain can reduce time and costs of such DMA's.
In this research, the complex wave model is replaced by a computationally efficient alternative and the main research question reads:
How can a mild-slope wave model be used for the ship motion calculation on ships moored in ports and what are the benefits and limitations?
The research is split up into two parts: 1) Development of the coupling method and evaluating its application based on academic test cases and 2) Applying the coupling to the case study of La Coruña and assessing its suitability.
A practical and efficient method to extract wave components from the wave penetration model is the r-DPRA tool developed by Deltares. The developed method is applied to the case study of the port of La Coruña. Two separate moments in time of the same bulk carrier are modelled: one with moderate offshore wave conditions and one with more severe conditions.
In the measured time series of the surge and sway motions, a clear low frequency can be found. Similarly, in the simulated time series of the surge and sway motions; both in moderate and heavy cases no low frequency wave patterns can be found. A schematic approach is used to include the long waves in the wave model and ship motion model and this approach caused a low frequency wave pattern to arise and leads to more accurate significant motions.
The comparison between the measured motions and modelled motions demonstrated the complexity of modelling real life events. As the surge and sway motions are caused by second order effects that are not included in the applied linear wave model, it is recommended to apply the developed workaround to schematically include this low wave forcing. The result of this research demonstrates the potential for the development method.
Before directly applying the method, it is recommended to test the suitability of the method on a more fundamental case, this reduces uncertainties related to real life measurements and stronger conclusions about the performance of the coupling can be drawn. Moreover, the coupling should be tested for a case where the 2nd order low frequency wave forcing is negligible. As it is confirmed in this research that the developed method is not suitable for modelling non-linear 2nd order low frequency waves.
Bowthruster-induced flow on the bottom of a vertical quay wall
A field measurement
The results of this field measurement showed mean flow velocities near the quay wall generally in the order of magnitude of 1 m/s, with the exception of one test, where mean flow velocities in the order of magnitude of 2 m/s were recorded. This relatively low mean flow velocities were often correlated with large turbulent fluctuations, leading to values of relative turbulence intensities higher than the ones found in literature, and sometimes even equal to 1. Comparison with the theoretical calculations of velocities according to Dutch and German methods suggested by PIANC, showed both methods to be conservative if compared with data from most tests. Furthermore, it appeared that both formulae’s sensitivity to wall and keel clearance was not reflected by the data. Similarly, results from this measurement showed that the flow generated by simultaneous use of two bowthrusters was characterized by velocities on the bed lower than expected according to the guidelines. Recommendation would be to use either linear superposition or to multiply by square root of n (where n is the number of used propellers) when considering the use of multiple propellers, but this was not reflected by most of the data. However, two of the tests taken into exam represented an exception to these general observations: ADV1, the instrument nearer to the quay wall, recorded velocities higher than the theoretical values for tests 12 (use of bowthruster 2 at high water) and 22 (use of both bowthrusters simultaneously at low water). Results from this study showed how the use of a 4-channel bowthruster system induced a flow on the bottom of a vertical quay wall which is mainly divided in two zones. Near the quay wall is where the highest velocities have been measured, and where the flow is strictly influenced by use of the bowthrusters. There is a return flow beneath the ship, which is dissipated in the space of few meters. Underneath the suction points of the bowthrusters, it is the inflow to determine the flow characteristics on the bed. In this research, the extent of the bowthruster-induced flow was found to be less than 14 m from the quay wall. The instrument hereby located, in fact, didn't record velocities which were affected by the use of bowthrusters. This research represents a step towards filling the knowledge gaps about use of bowthrusters at a vertical quay wall. The unique dataset collected can be used in the future for validating numerical or on-scale models, working for a better understanding of the phenomenon and a more accurate and optimized design of bed protections. ...
The results of this field measurement showed mean flow velocities near the quay wall generally in the order of magnitude of 1 m/s, with the exception of one test, where mean flow velocities in the order of magnitude of 2 m/s were recorded. This relatively low mean flow velocities were often correlated with large turbulent fluctuations, leading to values of relative turbulence intensities higher than the ones found in literature, and sometimes even equal to 1. Comparison with the theoretical calculations of velocities according to Dutch and German methods suggested by PIANC, showed both methods to be conservative if compared with data from most tests. Furthermore, it appeared that both formulae’s sensitivity to wall and keel clearance was not reflected by the data. Similarly, results from this measurement showed that the flow generated by simultaneous use of two bowthrusters was characterized by velocities on the bed lower than expected according to the guidelines. Recommendation would be to use either linear superposition or to multiply by square root of n (where n is the number of used propellers) when considering the use of multiple propellers, but this was not reflected by most of the data. However, two of the tests taken into exam represented an exception to these general observations: ADV1, the instrument nearer to the quay wall, recorded velocities higher than the theoretical values for tests 12 (use of bowthruster 2 at high water) and 22 (use of both bowthrusters simultaneously at low water). Results from this study showed how the use of a 4-channel bowthruster system induced a flow on the bottom of a vertical quay wall which is mainly divided in two zones. Near the quay wall is where the highest velocities have been measured, and where the flow is strictly influenced by use of the bowthrusters. There is a return flow beneath the ship, which is dissipated in the space of few meters. Underneath the suction points of the bowthrusters, it is the inflow to determine the flow characteristics on the bed. In this research, the extent of the bowthruster-induced flow was found to be less than 14 m from the quay wall. The instrument hereby located, in fact, didn't record velocities which were affected by the use of bowthrusters. This research represents a step towards filling the knowledge gaps about use of bowthrusters at a vertical quay wall. The unique dataset collected can be used in the future for validating numerical or on-scale models, working for a better understanding of the phenomenon and a more accurate and optimized design of bed protections.
Puerto de Talcahuano
Port expansion design proposal for the port of Talcahuano, situated in the bay of Concepción