G. Pagella
Please Note
20 records found
1
Assessing Salt-Induced Degradation in Historic Timber-Masonry Buildings Using Micro-Drilling
A Dutch Soda Factory Case Study
The local stiffness of a knot in wood can be up to 30 times lower than the longitudinal stiffness of clear wood, as reported in literature and codes. However, it remains difficult to determine the local effect of knots on the stiffness of round timber and to quantify the extent of the surrounding area influenced by this reduction in stiffness. The objective of this study was to experimentally investigate the local redistribution of stiffness around knots in round timber under axial compression using digital image correlation (DIC). By providing full-field strain measurements, DIC enables a detailed characterisation of strain localisation and offers a novel approach to quantify the influence zone of knots. Two spruce piles were tested in compression, and the deformations were obtained on three distinct zones: within the knot, a transition zone, and a clear wood zone. The stiffness in the knot was approximately 1/30 of the clear wood longitudinal stiffness, while the transition zone had a reduction of about 1/15. The study supports the validity of existing design assumptions and of DIC for capturing local stiffness variations in round timber.
Mechanical Characterisation of New and Existing Timber Foundation Piles
For the assessment of historical timber foundations and their contemporary applications in structural design
The design and assessment of timber foundation piles are still open research topics, hindered by several knowledge gaps in understanding their material and mechanical properties. Timber piles have not been extensively studied in the literature, and the design standards offer minimal to no guidance on their utilization. To enable engineers to adequately design timber foundation piles, verification rules, reliable material properties, and grading specifications are required..... ...
The design and assessment of timber foundation piles are still open research topics, hindered by several knowledge gaps in understanding their material and mechanical properties. Timber piles have not been extensively studied in the literature, and the design standards offer minimal to no guidance on their utilization. To enable engineers to adequately design timber foundation piles, verification rules, reliable material properties, and grading specifications are required.....
The lack of strength values for timber foundation piles in the current Eurocode 5 hinders their appropriate engineering design and assessment. Timber piles, often submerged for their entire service life, endure high moisture levels, highlighting the need to define strength parameters of round wood under fully saturated conditions. To ensure reliable material properties, a large-scale study was conducted on 70 European softwood piles, determining strength and stiffness through axial compression tests on saturated segments extracted along the pile. Mean and characteristic wet compressive strength and stiffness values were derived, applicable to the whole pile and/or its parts. The mechanical properties of the piles were analysed in relation to grading parameters that may influence the saturated compressive strength, leading to the classification of three strength classes for visual grading. Additionally, two regression models were developed-one based on the most influencing visually graded parameters, and the other on the dynamic modulus of elasticity. The saturated compressive strength values and grading boundaries presented in this study contribute to the engineering design of European softwood foundation piles in the context of a new circular construction ecosystem, and support the integration of reliable design values into future versions of Eurocode 5.
Safeguarding Amsterdam's heritage
Predicting sapwood width to preserve ancient wooden foundations
Wooden piles are the most common foundation system in the historic city of Amsterdam (NL). The piles are fully submerged below water table and subject to bacterial decay. This study investigated sapwood and heartwood proportions in spruce, pine, and fir piles from different construction periods, in relation to their degradation. X-ray computed tomography scans on 49 wet discs were performed to measure the piles’ sapwood width, which was then validated against an empirical model based on annual rings and growth rate. Degraded areas, identified with micro-drilling measurements, were found to affect sapwood only. These outcomes were further validated on 201 pile segments, with the predicted sapwood widths being greater than or equal to the decayed portions, even in 300-year-old piles. Therefore, estimating sapwood width can contribute to determine the remaining sound cross section of the piles, providing useful input for service life models for planning timely maintenance interventions.
In the historic city centre of Amsterdam (NL), the most widespread foundation system consists of wooden piles. Since these foundations are fully below the water table, they are mostly subjected to bacterial decay. This biodegradation phenomenon proceeds slowly over time, and usually involves the less durable sapwood, with heartwood remaining sound. Hence, obtaining an estimate of sapwood and heartwood proportions in wooden piles can provide information on how deep in the cross section bacterial decay is expected to proceed. This is relevant, for instance, when developing service life models, since the remaining sound cross section of a pile can be estimated. Thus, the present work involves a comprehensive investigation on sapwood and heartwood proportions in spruce, pine and fir wooden foundation piles from different construction periods, ranging from 1727 to 2019. The amount of sapwood and heartwood was determined with computed tomography (CT) scans on 49 wet discs retrieved from the piles. Such measured sapwood width was then compared with that predicted with an empirical model from literature, based on the number of annual rings and growth rate, obtaining a successful validation. Micro-drilling measurements were also conducted on the discs to identify decayed portions, which appeared to always affect (part of) the sapwood only. Finally, this outcome was further validated against a broader dataset of micro-drilling measurements taken on over 200 pile segments, for which the sapwood widths were predicted with the aforementioned empirical model, and were found to be overall greater than the corresponding decayed portions, even in wooden piles having been in service for 300 years.
Traditional wooden foundation piles in Amsterdam and Venice
Techniques for the assessment of their state of conservation
The lack of strength values for wooden foundation piles in the design standards for timber (Eurocode 5) hinders their proper engineering design and assessment. In order to fill this gap, an extensive experimental campaign was conducted to characterize the mechanical properties of large-scale, water-submerged spruce (Picea abies L.) and pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) piles. This was achieved through the execution of axial compression tests on 253 full-scale pile segments. Wet compressive strength and stiffness values were derived for both spruce and pine piles, applicable to the whole pile and/or its parts: head, middle-part, and tip. The quality variables that most influenced the wet compressive strength of the piles were density, knot ratio (KR), number of annual rings (age), and growth rate. Based on this, characteristic strength values were derived for piles with the following grading limits: KR < 0.5, age between 20 and 100 years, and a growth rate <5 mm/year. These variables were used as key parameters to develop prediction models for the wet compressive strength of spruce and pine piles. The saturated compressive strength values and grading boundaries presented in this study contribute to the engineering design of timber piles and support the integration of reliable design values into future versions of Eurocode 5.
The compressive strength properties of timber foundation piles in Amsterdam were characterised by small-scale compression tests on saturated round wooden discs. The discs were extracted from the head, middle, and tip of five spruce (Picea abies) piles dating back to 1727, 1886, 1922, and 2021. Several piles were subjected to underwater bacterial decay, causing a reduction of their load-carrying capacity over time. The amount of decay was determined with micro-drilling measurements. The results of small-scale tests were compared to large-scale axial compression tests to assess the feasibility of retrieving equivalent strength properties, considering the influence of diameters, decay, and wood knots.
In the historic city centre of Amsterdam (NL), the predominant foundation system is comprised of wooden piles. Due to their placement below the water table, these foundations are susceptible to bacterial decay. This study aims to investigate and compare various methods for characterizing decay patterns within the cross sections of piles retrieved from two bridges in Amsterdam. The examined piles span different construction years: three originate from 1727, four from 1886, and two from 1922. Following extraction, the piles were transported to TU Delft Stevin II Laboratory, where they underwent further subdivision into three segments, each representing the head, middle, and tip, resulting in a total of 27 segments. The effects of bacterial decay were characterised by performing micro-drilling measurements, small-scale material and compressive tests on prismatic samples extracted from the segments' cross sections, computed tomography scans, and light microscopy observations. Microscopic examination revealed severe degradation in all segments dating back to 1727, extending 20–50 mm from their surface. This outcome was also confirmed by the other adopted methods: the corresponding prisms had large moisture contents and poor mechanical properties, while low basic densities and drilling amplitudes were obtained from CT scans and micro-drilling measurements, respectively. On the contrary, the internal sections of the 1727 segments exhibited no evidence of decay and demonstrated properties consistent with those observed in sound segments from 1886 and 1922. Finally, the observed gradients of density, strength, and stiffness were well correlated with micro-drilling measurements, which can therefore be reliably used as on-site assessment method to reconstruct the properties of the piles.
This case study explores the utilization of distributed fiber optic sensors (DFOS) in wooden foundation piles, for assessing and monitoring the stress distribution along their length. Three spruce and three pine foundation piles instrumented with DFOS were driven into the soil in a testing field in Amsterdam and axially loaded in compression. Since DFOS provided strain information, calculating the stress distribution in the piles required knowledge of their stiffness properties, which inherently vary from the head to the tip. Consequently, the piles were extracted and their overall wet dynamic elastic modulus (Ec,0,dyn,wet) was determined through frequency response measurements. Subsequently, the piles were segmented, transported to the TU Delft Laboratory and subjected to mechanical testing. For each segment, the mechanical properties were determined and their variability along the pile was studied, in particular for the static modulus of elasticity (Ec,0,stat,wet). This enabled a comprehensive assessment of the actual in-situ stress distribution (Δσactual,stat and Δσactual,dyn) along the length of the piles, calculated with DFOS strains and the pile stiffness (Ec,0,stat,wet and Ec,0,stat,dyn). Given the novelty of the DFOS application to timber piles, a validation of the accuracy was conducted on 3 pile segments equipped with DFOS. These segments underwent laboratory compression testing, allowing for a direct comparison between DFOS strain readings and strains measured with linear potentiometers attached to the pile segments. The results revealed good accuracy of DFOS in controlled lab conditions, with a maximum stress deviation of 0.65 MPa. Since the testing field featured a 6-meter-deep predrilled layer, where negligible shaft friction was mobilized, the no-friction stress (Δσno-friction) approximately aligned with Δσactual,stat on the piles. At pile tips, the maximum applied 300–350 kN compressive load (i.e. Δσno-friction = 20–26 MPa), resulted in Δσactual,stat = 4–7 MPa, highlighting shaft friction effect. The calculated Δσactual,dyn with a single Ec,0,stat,dyn for the whole pile, led to 3 MPa stress overestimation at pile tip. Although this calculation is conservative, the detailed knowledge of the variation of stiffness properties along the pile would result in a more efficient structural use.
The majority of bridges and quay walls in the centre of Amsterdam are supported by 100–300 years-old wooden foundation piles subjected to bacterial decay. Bacterial degradation proceeds at a slow rate, allowing the piles to perform their function for many years, although causing a reduction of their load-carrying capacity over time. In this study, micro-drilling measurements were employed to capture the amount of decay and remaining short-term compressive strength of the historic wooden piles. The applicability of micro-drilling was studied on 60 wooden piles with various decay levels, retrieved after 100–295 years of service life. An algorithm was developed for analysing the micro-drilling signals, aimed at determining the decayed outer layer of the piles’ cross section, and validated with the results of mechanical testing on the piles. The micro-drilling technique is now used on a large scale in Amsterdam, supporting the assessment of the wooden foundation piles in the city.
This work investigated the influence of knots on the compression strength of wooden foundation piles. The study involved 110 pile segments sawn from 18 spruce and 9 pine piles with a mean diameter of approximately 200 mm, and moisture contents above fiber saturation. The mechanical properties were determined performing both full-scale compression tests on pile segments, and small-scale experiments on discs sawn from selected segments, considering samples with and without knots. A knot ratio (KR) was defined analysing the knots layout of each wooden pile, and evaluating how the compressive strength was influenced by size, number and layout of knots. As final step, a prediction model was implemented based on the dry density and KR of wooden piles, to estimate the influence of knots on their compressive strength.
In the historic city centre of Amsterdam (NL), the most widespread foundation system consists of wooden piles. With the aim of modelling and predicting remaining service life of these foundations and the piles in particular, one of the possible methods for collecting data and monitoring their condition consists of micro-drilling (MD) measurements. This work evaluates the reliability of MD measurements in identifying decayed portions and specific features of wooden foundation piles, considering different moisture content (MC) values. To this end, 24 segments were selected, sawn from wooden piles extracted from site, and having time in service (TS) of 2 to 294 years (with reference to 2021, the year of extraction). 240 MD measurements were conducted at varying MC values of 7% to 212%. The obtained MD profiles showed for all TS a slight decrease in drilling resistance when increasing MC. However, from the MD signals it is possible to reliably detect the areas affected by biodegradation phenomena (e.g. bacterial decay) along the drilling depth, regardless the MC of the segment or its gradient along the drilling depth. The present study contributes to research aiming at utilizing (in-situ) MD techniques for reliably assessing and quantifying decay and to be used in remaining service life planning of wooden foundation piles.
Timber pile foundations are widespread in many areas around Europe and North-America. Especially in areas with weak soils, timber pile foundations have been a very good and economic solution. However, aging of the foundations can become a problem, as physical, biological and/or chemical degradation may occur over time. Now, that foundations can be up to 500 years in cities like Venice, Amsterdam, Hamburg, Boston and many others, questions arise about the reliability and which assessment methods can be used in order to estimate the current load carrying capacity and their residual service life. Residual service life is depending both on the time-to-failure behaviour of wood, as well as, the dead and live loads on the piles below buildings, quay walls and bridges. The approach taken integrates degradation models with a reaction kinetics based damage model. For wood that remains consistently below the waterline, the combination of bacterial degradation and long term loading is considered the most important, but degradation by fungi also may occur depending on soil and groundwater conditions. The integral assessment model will function as a tool for repair and maintenance strategies for asset managers and structural engineers.