M. Mirra
Please Note
46 records found
1
The existing building stock in several countries worldwide features masonry structures with timber floors, whose vulnerability to seismic events has been widely documented by academic research as well as by the catastrophic consequences of recent earthquakes. Several seismic retrofits and protection technologies have been explored throughout the years, prioritizing (among others) lightweight interventions, such as timber-based strengthening, or advanced systems involving seismic isolation and vibration control strategies (e.g. inter-story seismic isolation). The use of timber-based retrofits, particularly based on engineered wood panels fastened to existing floors and roofs, has shown to increase the hysteretic energy dissipation of these diaphragms, beneficially reducing seismic shear forces transferred to the walls when the strengthening measure is appropriately designed. Similarly, the seismic isolation of the masses localized at the roof level, can provide a strong reduction in shear loads on the walls, acting as a Tuned Mass Damper for the existing building. On the basis of the described framework, this work examines a case-study archetype masonry building with timber diaphragms: by performing numerical analyses in DIANA FEA software, this study compares (i) the application of timber-based retrofitting solution on the floors and roof, (ii) the use of an additional, superimposed roof structure acting as tuned mass damper with properly calibrated isolators, and (iii) the combination of the two systems, discussing the benefits and applicability of each seismic protection method and their integration with other retrofits, for instance from the energetic and environmental point of view.
The lack of strength values for timber foundation piles in the current Eurocode 5 hinders their appropriate engineering design and assessment. Timber piles, often submerged for their entire service life, endure high moisture levels, highlighting the need to define strength parameters of round wood under fully saturated conditions. To ensure reliable material properties, a large-scale study was conducted on 70 European softwood piles, determining strength and stiffness through axial compression tests on saturated segments extracted along the pile. Mean and characteristic wet compressive strength and stiffness values were derived, applicable to the whole pile and/or its parts. The mechanical properties of the piles were analysed in relation to grading parameters that may influence the saturated compressive strength, leading to the classification of three strength classes for visual grading. Additionally, two regression models were developed-one based on the most influencing visually graded parameters, and the other on the dynamic modulus of elasticity. The saturated compressive strength values and grading boundaries presented in this study contribute to the engineering design of European softwood foundation piles in the context of a new circular construction ecosystem, and support the integration of reliable design values into future versions of Eurocode 5.
Timber modular buildings are an emerging construction method, due to the environmental and construction speed benefits. However, the inherent discontinuity and limited deformation capacity, hinders their ability to effectively redistribute loads under accidental load cases and thus, their robustness. A method to quantify the robustness of a building is to assess its behavior under notional column removal scenarios. This study numerically investigates the behavior of a hypothetical five-storey timber post-and-beam modular building under accidental damage events represented by four different column removal scenarios. The findings indicate that the structure could develop sufficient alternative load paths to sustain the amplified accidental limit state design load in most cases, primarily through flexural mechanisms. However, due to the limited ductility of these mechanisms, modular connections were optimally redesigned to enhance axial elongation and capacity, enabling the development of catenary action. The most effective strategy for achieving a robust catenary response was the introduction of a fuse element, significantly improving the ductility of the connection and enhancing the overall structural robustness.
Traditional wooden foundation piles in Amsterdam and Venice
Techniques for the assessment of their state of conservation
In the historic city centre of Amsterdam (NL), the most widespread foundation system consists of wooden piles. Since these foundations are fully below the water table, they are mostly subjected to bacterial decay. This biodegradation phenomenon proceeds slowly over time, and usually involves the less durable sapwood, with heartwood remaining sound. Hence, obtaining an estimate of sapwood and heartwood proportions in wooden piles can provide information on how deep in the cross section bacterial decay is expected to proceed. This is relevant, for instance, when developing service life models, since the remaining sound cross section of a pile can be estimated. Thus, the present work involves a comprehensive investigation on sapwood and heartwood proportions in spruce, pine and fir wooden foundation piles from different construction periods, ranging from 1727 to 2019. The amount of sapwood and heartwood was determined with computed tomography (CT) scans on 49 wet discs retrieved from the piles. Such measured sapwood width was then compared with that predicted with an empirical model from literature, based on the number of annual rings and growth rate, obtaining a successful validation. Micro-drilling measurements were also conducted on the discs to identify decayed portions, which appeared to always affect (part of) the sapwood only. Finally, this outcome was further validated against a broader dataset of micro-drilling measurements taken on over 200 pile segments, for which the sapwood widths were predicted with the aforementioned empirical model, and were found to be overall greater than the corresponding decayed portions, even in wooden piles having been in service for 300 years.
Safeguarding Amsterdam's heritage
Predicting sapwood width to preserve ancient wooden foundations
Wooden piles are the most common foundation system in the historic city of Amsterdam (NL). The piles are fully submerged below water table and subject to bacterial decay. This study investigated sapwood and heartwood proportions in spruce, pine, and fir piles from different construction periods, in relation to their degradation. X-ray computed tomography scans on 49 wet discs were performed to measure the piles’ sapwood width, which was then validated against an empirical model based on annual rings and growth rate. Degraded areas, identified with micro-drilling measurements, were found to affect sapwood only. These outcomes were further validated on 201 pile segments, with the predicted sapwood widths being greater than or equal to the decayed portions, even in 300-year-old piles. Therefore, estimating sapwood width can contribute to determine the remaining sound cross section of the piles, providing useful input for service life models for planning timely maintenance interventions.
Low-rise masonry buildings worldwide frequently feature unreinforced masonry (URM) walls coupled with various pitched roof configurations supported by masonry gables. Past earthquakes have highlighted the vulnerability of these components to out-of-plane seismic loads due to their high slenderness, insufficient roof connections, and exposure to amplified accelerations while being subjected to minimal overburden due to their location at the upper part of buildings. This study presents key insights from the experimental campaign of the ERIES-SUPREME project, aimed at enhancing the understanding of the out-of-plane seismic behavior of masonry gables. Incremental dynamic tests were performed on three full-scale URM gables, simulating both induced and tectonic earthquake scenarios until collapse, using two shake tables. Differential motions at the top and bottom tables reproduced the interaction of the gables with three different roof diaphragm configurations, each introducing a unique filtering effect on the seismic input. The outcomes of the experiments can be used for refining existing numerical modelling strategies as well as contribute to developing improved tools for the seismic assessment of URM gables.
This article presents a dataset from an experimental campaign investigating the out-of-plane (OOP) seismic response of unreinforced masonry (URM) gables in existing buildings. Addressing a critical gap in published research, the dataset provides novel experimental data on the incremental dynamic OOP behavior of three URM gables tested under seismic loading until full collapse. All three gables were nominally identical but differed in their interaction with the supporting roof structure. This interaction was experimentally reproduced by imposing differential motions at the top of the gables, which were either linearly amplified or both amplified and phase-shifted relative to the motion at the base. This approach ensured idealized and numerically replicable boundary conditions, making the dataset an ideal benchmark for refining existing and developing new modeling approaches for URM structures. The dataset includes measured and calculated acceleration, displacement, and force time histories. Beyond supporting the validation and development of numerical models, it can also contribute to improving guidelines for the out-of-plane seismic assessment of URM gables and is openly available for further research and engineering applications.
Timber as Bridge Between Past and Future
Structural Upgrading and Conservation of the Ancient Timber and Masonry Venetian Sawmill of Vallaro (Brescia, Italy)
This work presents an extensive static and seismic retrofitting intervention performed on a relevant historic case-study building, the Venetian sawmill of Vallaro (Brescia, Italy). This heritage construction from the end of the 19th century features three building portions, two realized in timber and one consisting of a masonry structure with timber floors and roofs. The building had been neglected for decades and was in a poor state of conservation, despite representing a valuable example of the typical historic architectures of the mountainy area in the Province of Brescia. With the support of the local municipality, a complete restoration of the sawmill has started, with the objective of transforming it into a territorial museum. To this end, a series of reversible and compatible timber-based interventions were planned in consultation with the local superintendence for architectural heritage. The structural design aimed at preserving the historic value of the sawmill, especially in its original timber components, such as trusses, braced columns, and diaphragms. The present case study enables to showcase the advantages of the applied strengthening methods in such a complex architectural restoration and the importance of tailored structural detailing, combining the improvement in static and seismic performance with the protection and preservation of ancient timber members.
Design and modelling tools for timber-based seismic retrofitting
From research to practice
The majority of bridges and quay walls in the centre of Amsterdam are supported by 100–300 years-old wooden foundation piles subjected to bacterial decay. Bacterial degradation proceeds at a slow rate, allowing the piles to perform their function for many years, although causing a reduction of their load-carrying capacity over time. In this study, micro-drilling measurements were employed to capture the amount of decay and remaining short-term compressive strength of the historic wooden piles. The applicability of micro-drilling was studied on 60 wooden piles with various decay levels, retrieved after 100–295 years of service life. An algorithm was developed for analysing the micro-drilling signals, aimed at determining the decayed outer layer of the piles’ cross section, and validated with the results of mechanical testing on the piles. The micro-drilling technique is now used on a large scale in Amsterdam, supporting the assessment of the wooden foundation piles in the city.
The application of timber-based strengthening solutions to existing wooden and masonry structures, combines several benefits, such as reversibility, compatibility, lightness, sustainability, affordability, and effectiveness. With reference to existing timber floors, an efficient method to enhance their seismic response is the fastening of an overlay of plywood panels to the existing sheathing, an intervention that greatly improves in-plane strength, stiffness, and energy dissipation. In order to promote the use of this retrofitting solution in practice, this work presents a set of calculation tools supporting the design and advanced numerical modelling of timber diaphragms strengthened with plywood panels. The suite of tools allows to first estimate the full nonlinear, cyclic in-plane response of the strengthened diaphragms starting from the geometrical and material properties of the existing sheathing and the plywood overlay, as well as the mechanical characteristics of the fasteners. As second step, such estimated in-plane response can be transformed into a constitutive law for performing nonlinear numerical simulations, by means of a user-supplied subroutine developed for finite element software DIANA FEA. The presented calculation examples and the performed validation against reference studies from literature, show that the developed tools can provide an accurate estimate of the in-plane response of the diaphragms, and enable an efficient numerical simulation of their seismic behaviour. The implemented tools can be used to both obtain preliminary indication for plywood-based seismic retrofitting design, and to calibrate the interventions on existing diaphragms based on the specific characteristics and needs of a building, relying on the adaptability and versatility of this strengthening method.