Circular Image

J.W.C. van Lint

info

Please Note

128 records found

Max-pressure control in heterogeneously distributed and partially connected vehicle environments

Journal article (2026) - Chaopeng Tan, Dingshan Sun, Hao Liu, Marco Rinaldi, Hans van Lint
Max-pressure (MP) control has emerged as a prominent real-time network traffic signal control strategy due to its simplicity, decentralized structure, and theoretical guarantees of network queue stability. Meanwhile, advances in connected vehicle (CV) technology have sparked extensive research into CV-based traffic signal control. Despite these developments, few studies have investigated MP control in heterogeneously distributed and partially CV environments while ensuring network queue stability. To address these research gaps, we propose a CV-based MP control (CV-MP) method that leverages real-time CV travel time information to compute the pressure, thereby incorporating both the spatial distribution and temporal delays of vehicles, unlike existing approaches that utilized only spatial distribution or temporal delays. In particular, we establish sufficient conditions for road network queue stability that are compatible with most existing MP control methods. Moreover, we pioneered the proof of network queue stability even if the vehicles are only partially connected and heterogeneously distributed, and gave a necessary condition of CV observation for maintaining the stability. Evaluation results on an Amsterdam corridor show that CV-MP significantly reduces vehicle delays compared to both actuated control and conventional MP control across various CV penetration rates. Moreover, in scenarios with dynamic traffic demand, CV-MP achieves lower spillover peaks even with low and heterogeneous CV penetration rates, further highlighting its effectiveness and robustness. ...
Journal article (2026) - Chaopeng Tan, Georgios Laskaris, Dingshan Sun, Robin Abohariri, Marco Rinaldi, Hans van Lint
Max-Pressure (MP) control is a decentralized real-time traffic signal control method that is popular for its simplicity and theoretical stability. However, most existing MP controllers prioritize throughput for private vehicles without accounting for the specific needs of transit services that are essential for sustainable urban mobility. This oversight can exacerbate transit delays and undermine the effectiveness of public transportation systems. To address these challenges, this study introduces a Priority-MP framework that integrates transit signal priority and driver advisory systems into MP control for multi-modal traffic networks. By weighting pressures based on real-time vehicle occupancy and considering more realistic scenarios that account for the presence of transit stations, Priority-MP prioritizes high-occupancy transit vehicles while ensuring network queue stability. In addition, the framework integrates driver advisory systems to provide speed and dwell time recommendations for transit vehicles. Experiments on a real-world multi-modal traffic corridor in Amsterdam show that compared to existing MP control methods: 1) Priority-MP highlights an important trade-off: it significantly reduces average passenger delay by prioritizing high-occupancy transit vehicles, even though this may lead to increased average vehicle delay when the impact of transit stations are ignored; 2) Priority-MP considering transit stations reduces both vehicle delay and passenger delay while maintaining the network stability; and 3) Priority-MP integrating driver advisory systems further improves the travel smoothness of transit vehicles by reducing transit queuing counts. ...
Accurately and proactively alerting drivers or automated systems to emerging collisions is crucial for road safety, particularly in highly interactive and complex urban environments. Existing methods require labour-intensive annotation of sparse risk, struggle to consider varying contextual factors or are tailored to limited scenarios. Here we present the generalized surrogate safety measure (GSSM), a data-driven approach that learns collision risk from naturalistic driving without the need for crash or risk labels. Trained on diverse datasets and evaluated on 2,591 real-world crashes and near-crashes, a basic GSSM using only instantaneous motion kinematics achieves an area under the precision–recall curve of 0.9 and secures a median time advance of 2.6 s to prevent potential collisions. Incorporating more interaction patterns and contextual factors provides further performance gains. Across interaction scenarios, such as rear end, merging and turning, GSSM consistently outperforms existing baselines in terms of accuracy and timeliness. These results establish GSSM as a scalable, context-aware and generalizable foundation for identifying risky interactions before they become unavoidable and support proactive safety in autonomous driving systems and traffic incident management. ...
Journal article (2025) - Zahra Eftekhar, Saman Behrouzi, Panchamy Krishnakumari, Adam Pel, Hans van Lint
Large-scale prediction of trip production is essential for origin–destination (OD) demand estimation and prediction. One of the main challenges in predicting trip production patterns lies in addressing spatial-temporal correlations and variations. Whereas many studies focus on temporal correlations, very few consider spatial adjacency between traffic analysis zones (TAZ) as explanatory variables. This research proposes a method that integrates a graph convolutional neural network (GCN) into a long short-term memory network (LSTM) to do exactly that. By introducing a nationwide graph that encodes the adjacency of TAZs, spatial heterogeneity is considered in the prediction process, and a single prediction model is trained for the entire network, thereby avoiding the need to train multiple separate models and potentially reducing overall training overhead, while increasing the prediction accuracy. Moreover, with this model, we investigate the effect of spatial scale on spatial uncertainty and prediction accuracy and analyze prediction errors, residual patterns, and their associations with socio-spatial features at different spatial scales. The findings of this research have important implications for improving OD demand prediction models and provide valuable insights into the role of spatial scale and socio-spatial features in travel demand prediction. ...
Journal article (2025) - Arjan de Ruijter, Oded Cats, Hans van Lint
To understand why ridesourcing markets may be prone to evolve towards potentially socially undesirable equilibrium states, we conceptualize the network effects present in ridesourcing provision. In addition, we propose an agent-based model that allows simulating the effect of market conditions and platform strategies on system performance, accounting for such network effects. This day-to-day model captures sequential decentralized processes characterizing both sides of the two-sided ridesourcing market, i.e. information diffusion, platform registration, platform participation, and learning based on experience. We apply the model on a case representing Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Our simulation results suggest that a profit-maximizing ridesourcing platform may trade-off market transaction volume for higher earnings on successful transactions, a strategy that is harmful to the interests of travellers and drivers, and possibly of (very) limited benefit to the platform. Moreover, we find that ridesourcing operations may be viable even when potential supply and demand in an area are limited. ...
Journal article (2025) - Kexin Liang, Simeon C. Calvert, Sina Nordhoff, Ming Li, J. W.C. van Lint
Conditionally automated driving requires drivers to resume vehicle control within constrained time budgets upon receiving takeover requests. Accurately predicting drivers’ takeover time (ToT) is essential for dynamically adjusting time budgets to individual needs across scenarios. This study addresses enduring challenges in reliability and interpretability of ToT prediction models by optimizing predictor selection. Using a driving simulator experiment, we examine the relationship between ToT, driver characteristics, and perceived Spare Capacity (pSC, a cognitive construct from Task-Capability Interface theory) using Category Boosting models. Results show that (i) incorporating 13 additional driver characteristics does not significantly improve prediction accuracy when pSC is already considered; and (ii) individual characteristics influence how drivers cognitively process takeover scenarios, and their predictive contribution likely overlaps with pSC. These findings suggest that monitoring cognitive states may be more effective for ToT prediction than extensive profiling of driver characteristics. This study provides a critical first step toward predictive frameworks for adaptive takeover strategies and offers guidance for designing personalized human–vehicle interactions. ...
Smart traffic systems, like those using wellestablished methods such as SCOOT, SCATS and TUC, aim to improve traffic flow by dynamically adjusting signal timings based on real-time traffic conditions. Traffic engineers need to understand the objective functions behind traffic signal control to analyze, improve, and optimize network performances. However, different jurisdictions, different operators and competing interests imply that the underlying objective functions governing traffic signal control might not be publicly known with sufficient detail (e.g. to preserve Intellectual Property Rights). A method for discovering these functions is therefore needed, particularly to enable better cooperation among stakeholders. In this work, we train computer models to mimic the decisions made by smart traffic light systems. Using data from a simulated traffic network (with virtual sensors tracking vehicles), we test a variety of supervised models, ranging from simple decision trees to more complex neural networks. Our results show these models can accurately mimic the underlying system's actions, achieving up to 99% accuracy. This work demonstrates that supervised learning can serve as a powerful tool for uncovering hidden traffic control functions by training models to replicate the system's decisions. By analyzing these models, we can then infer the key factors influencing signal control, thereby gaining insights into the underlying objective function. ...
Accurate and timely alerts for drivers or automated systems to unfolding collisions remains a challenge in road safety, particularly in highly interactive urban traffic. Existing approaches require labour-intensive annotation of sparse risk, struggle to consider varying contextual factors, or are useful only in the scenarios they are designed for. To address these limits, this study introduces the generalised surrogate safety measure (GSSM), a new approach that learns exclusively from naturalistic driving without crash or risk labels. GSSM captures the patterns of normal driving and estimates the extent to which a traffic interaction deviates from the norm towards unsafe extreme. Utilising neural networks, normal interactions are characterised by context-conditioned distributions of multi-directional spacing between road users. In the same interaction context, a spacing closer than normal entails higher risk of potential collision. Then a context-adaptive risk score and its associated probability can be calculated based on the theory of extreme values. Any measurable factors, such as motion kinematics, weather, lighting, can serve as part of the context, allowing for diverse coverage of safety-critical interactions. Multiple public driving datasets are used to train GSSMs, which are tested with 2,591 real-world crashes and near-crashes reconstructed from the SHRP2 NDS. A vanilla GSSM using only instantaneous states achieves AUPRC of 0.9 and secures a median time advance of 2.6 seconds to prevent potential collisions. Additional data and contextual factors provide further performance gains. Across various interaction types such as rear-end, merging, and crossing, the accuracy and timeliness of GSSM consistently outperforms existing baselines. GSSM therefore establishes a scalable, context-aware, and generalisable foundation to proactively quantify collision risk in traffic interactions. ...

Privacy-Preserving Max-Pressure Control Based on Mobile Edge Computing

Conference paper (2025) - Chaopeng Tan, Marco Rinaldi, Yikai Zeng, Meng Wang, Hans Van Lint
Max-pressure (MP) control has proven effective at stabilizing network queues and improving traffic throughput in large-scale urban road networks. However, conventional MP controllers based on connected vehicle (CV) data face two critical limitations: network stability diminishes when connected vehicle (CV) penetration rates are low, and significant privacy concerns arise when utilizing individual vehicle data. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel Private-MP controller that fuses data from both fixed-location detectors and CVs in an architecture of mobile edge computing. To fully safeguard CV privacy, including macro-route information and micro-trajectory information, Private-MP employs a privacy-preserving mechanism that combines homomorphic encryption with an adaptive randomized response strategy. Simulation studies on a network with five intersections showed that despite some increases in average vehicle delay due to privacy protection, Private-MP still ensures a more robust performance on average vehicle delay than CV-based MP in low penetration rate scenarios and outperforms traditional detector-based MP control while improving fairness among connected and non-connected vehicles. ...
Journal article (2025) - Yi Lu, Hao Li, Huizhao Tu, Jian Liu, Yufei Yuan, Hans Van Lint
The operation of intelligent connected vehicles (ICVs) is fundamentally data-driven, continuously generating massive amounts of data. Given the significant value of ICV data to enterprises, industries, and nations, promoting data openness and sharing has become essential. However, such data often contain sensitive information, and its misuse can threaten individual privacy, corporate security, and even national interests. To address this dilemma, this paper develops the misuse risk score (MR-score), a novel quantification model and associated evaluation method for assessing the risk of ICV data misuse. The MR-score is constructed based on three core properties of ICV data: sensitivity; scale; and identifiability. The sensitivity score, information quantity, and identifiability factor are designated as the corresponding evaluation indicators, and systematic approaches for their quantification are proposed. The analytic hierarchy process is employed to measure the sensitivity score. Information entropy is adopted to evaluate the information quantity. A combination of k-anonymity-based and damage source determination-based methods is utilized to estimate the identifiability factor, considering data incompleteness, imprecision, and invalidity. Two empirical ICV data sets are utilized, and comparative analyses are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of the MR-score in capturing misuse risks. Higher MR-scores correspond to greater risk. The model captures the joint influence of all three data properties and reveals the marginal diminishing effect of data scale on misuse risk. This work offers valuable tools for data owners and regulatory agencies to prioritize critical data sets, implement targeted data protection measures, and enable secure data circulation while maximizing the value of ICV data. ...
Conference paper (2025) - Chaopeng Tan, Marco Rinaldi, Hans van Lint
Among real-time traffic control methods, max-pressure (MP) control stands out due to its simplicity, decentralized nature, and robust theoretical foundation. Besides, advancements in connected vehicle (CV) technology have motivated a significant amount of research into traffic signal control based on CVs. Nevertheless, few studies have been dedicated to MP control in partially CV environments and meanwhile consider multi-modal traffic flows. To fill this research gap, this study proposes CV-based multi-modal MP control (CV-MMP), which calculates the pressure based on travel time information of CVs weighted by vehicle occupancy. Therefore, a hierarchical multi-modal traffic signal priority controller is achieved in a soft manner. Besides, adapting to the requirements of practical applications, CV-MMP is extended to fuse detector data and consider phase switching lost time and cyclic phase sequence. The evaluation results based on a toy network simulation demonstrate that CV-MMP can significantly reduce transit delay with a small increase in private vehicle delay, resulting in a significant reduction in average person delay. In addition, approximately 75% of CBs pass through the network without experiencing delays due to stopping. Therefore, our method can achieve effective transit signal priority and even transit signal coordination under single transit requests. ...
The effectiveness of neural network models largely relies on learning meaningful latent patterns from data, where self-supervised learning of informative representations can enhance model performance and generalisability. However, self-supervised representation learning for spatially characterised time series, which are ubiquitous in transportation domain, poses unique challenges due to the necessity of maintaining fine-grained spatio-temporal similarities in the latent space. In this study, we introduce two structure-preserving regularisers for the contrastive learning of spatial time series: one regulariser preserves the topology of similarities between instances, and the other preserves the graph geometry of similarities across spatial and temporal dimensions. To balance the contrastive learning objective and the need for structure preservation, we propose a dynamic weighting mechanism that adaptively manages this trade-off and stabilises training. We validate the proposed method through extensive experiments, including multivariate time series classification to demonstrate its general applicability, as well as macroscopic and microscopic traffic prediction to highlight its particular usefulness in encoding traffic interactions. Across all tasks, our method preserves the similarity structures more effectively and improves state-of-the-art task performances. This method can be integrated with an arbitrary neural network model and is particularly beneficial for time series data with spatial or geographical features. Furthermore, our findings suggest that well-preserved similarity structures in the latent space indicate more informative and useful representations. This provides insights to design more effective neural networks for data-driven transportation research. Our code is made openly accessible with all resulting data at this https URL: https://github.com/yiru-jiao/spclt ...
Conference paper (2025) - Simon Leu, Gonçalo Homem de Almeida Correia, Hans van Lint, Axel Leonhardt
Integrating renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, challenges grid stability due to their intermittent nature. Vehicle-to-grid (V2G) technology provides a promising solution by utilizing electric vehicles (EVs) as decentralized energy storage systems, enabling the storage of surplus energy during low demand and its release during peak demand. The effectiveness of V2G depends critically on car usage patterns. Data from the Netherlands Mobility Panel (MPN) of 2022, comprising travel diaries from 2,505 households, was analyzed to explore this. A methodology was developed to create car usage profiles based on parking durations and locations, distinguishing weekday and weekend patterns. The analysis shows that vehicles are predominantly parked at home, with weekday profiles reflecting work-related parking and weekend profiles highlighting increased leisure activity. Households with shared cars showed higher driving activity and shorter parking durations than households with a 1:1 car-to-license ratio or surplus vehicles. Six distinct car usage clusters were identified for weekdays and four for weekends. ...

A case study of intersection-approaching behavior of professional and non-professional drivers

Journal article (2024) - Hailun Zhang, Rui Fu, Jianqiang Wang, Simeon C. Calvert, Hans van Lint
The in-vehicle communication provides promising opportunities to improve the road safety and traffic efficiency. Previous studies demonstrated that the professional drivers have better driving skills than the non-professional drivers who allocate more attention to secondary tasks. However, they may not be sensitive to the new in-vehicle technology. In addition, these qualitative studies failed to elaborate on the visual and response behavior differences among different driver groups (professional drivers such as taxi, bus, motorcoach, and non-professional drivers), and lacked the quantitative analysis of driving patterns in a new environment. This paper explores the differences in visual interaction, response characteristics, driving performance, and behavior patterns between the professional and non-professional drivers in the connected environment through a case study of intersection-approaching behavior using a driving simulator. More precisely, two driving scenarios (baseline and human–machine interface (HMI)) were designed in the driving simulator, and 65 participants, including 34 professional drivers and 31 non-professional drivers, completed the experiment. In the HMI scenario, the driver was provided with the signal light phase and phase transition remaining time of the current intersection. This paper also proposes a driving pattern extraction model based on the Bayesian non-parametric method combined with a text clustering algorithm to perform a quantitative description of the driving patterns. The results show that the professional drivers tend to interact less with the HMI compared with the non-professional drivers. Moreover, the professional drivers’ first gaze at the HMI occurs and responds earlier. The proposed driving model can effectively describe 7 patterns of intersection-approaching behavior. The connected information can significantly improve the efficiency of the intersection traffic and the driving behavior. However, the professional drivers are more responsive and behave more consistently. This study can provide insights into the development of personalized assisted driving systems, as the two driving populations differ in their interactions, responses, and behavioral patterns. ...
Traffic conflict detection is essential for proactive road safety by identifying potential collisions before they occur. Existing methods rely on surrogate safety measures tailored to specific interactions (e.g., car-following, side-swiping, or path-crossing) and require varying thresholds in different traffic conditions. This variation leads to inconsistencies and limited adaptability of conflict detection in evolving traffic environments, particularly as the integration of autonomous driving systems adds complexity. Consequently, there is an increasing need for consistent detection of traffic conflicts across interaction contexts. To address this need, we propose a unified probabilistic approach in this study. The proposed approach establishes a unified framework of traffic conflict detection, where traffic conflicts are formulated as context-dependent extreme events of road user interactions. The detection of conflicts is then decomposed into a series of statistical learning tasks: representing interaction contexts, inferring proximity distributions, and assessing extreme collision risk. The unified formulation accommodates diverse hypotheses of traffic conflicts and the learning tasks enable data-driven analysis of factors such as motion states of road users, environment conditions, and participant characteristics. Jointly, this approach supports consistent and comprehensive evaluation of the collision risk emerging in road user interactions. We demonstrate the proposed approach by experiments using real-world trajectory data. A unified metric for indicating conflicts is first trained with lane-change interactions on German highways, and then compared with existing metrics using near-crash events from the U.S. 100-Car Naturalistic Driving Study. Our results show that the unified metric provides effective collision warnings, generalises across distinct datasets and traffic environments, covers a broad range of conflict types, and captures a long-tailed distribution of conflict intensity. In summary, this study provides an explainable and generalisable approach that enables traffic conflict detection across varying interaction contexts. The findings highlight its potential to enhance the safety assessment of traffic infrastructures and policies, improve collision warning systems for autonomous driving, and deepen the understanding of road user behaviour in safety–critical interactions. ...

Application of Task-Capability Interface Theory

Conference paper (2024) - Kexin Liang, Simeon Calvert, Sina Nordhoff, Hans Van Lint
Conditionally automated driving enables drivers to engage in non-driving-related activities, with the responsibility to take over vehicle control upon request. This takeover process increases the risk of collisions, especially when drivers fail to safely complete takeovers within limited time budgets (i.e., the time offered by automation for takeovers). This phenomenon underlines the significance of providing time budgets that sufficiently accommodate drivers' takeover time (i.e., the time required by drivers to resume conscious control of vehicles). Considering that drivers' takeover time varies significantly across scenarios, this study centres on understanding the role of driver perception in takeover time using the Task-Capability Interface (TCI) theory. The TCI theory suggests that drivers adjust their behaviours based on their perceived task demands and driver capabilities. Accordingly, in a driving simulator experiment featuring diverse traffic densities and distractions, we investigated drivers' takeover time while capturing their perceived task demands and capabilities through a takeover-oriented questionnaire based on established instruments. The results show that drivers generally have longer takeover time as their perceived task demand rises, perceived driver capability diminishes, and perceived spare capacity (perceived driver capability minus perceived task demand) decreases. These patterns fluctuate under conditions of low perceived task demand or high perceived driver capability. When both conditions coincide, drivers necessitate a considerably longer time to regain vehicle control. Our findings on takeover time contribute to the development of strategies aimed at predicting drivers' takeover time, optimizing time budgets, fostering human-centred vehicle design, and enhancing the safety of conditionally automated driving. ...
Journal article (2024) - Zili Wang, Panchamy Krishnakumari, Kumar Anupam, Hans van Lint, Sandra Erkens
The relationship between real-world traffic and pavement raveling is unclear and subject to ongoing debates. This research proposes a novel approach that extends beyond traditional correlation analyses to explore causal mechanisms between mixed traffic and raveling. This approach incorporates the causal discovery method, and is applied to five Dutch porous asphalt (PA) highway sites that have substantial data sets. Findings indicate a nonlinear relationship between traffic volume and raveling, with road age emerging as a shared contributor. The results also suggest that the degree to which different vehicle types contribute as a causal factor for raveling varies with carriageway configurations and lane characteristics. This underlines the need for targeted maintenance strategies. Challenges remain due to confounding correlations among traffic variables, necessitating further development of causal discovery models. This study may not conclusively resolve the debate on to what extent traffic contributes to raveling, but we argue we provide sufficient evidence against rejecting this hypothesis. ...

A perspective of uncertainty quantification

Journal article (2024) - Guopeng Li, Victor L. Knoop, Hans van Lint
Traffic condition forecasting is fundamental for Intelligent Transportation Systems. Besides accuracy, many services require an estimate of uncertainty for each prediction. Uncertainty quantification must consider the inherent randomness in traffic dynamics, the so-called aleatoric uncertainty, and the additional distrust caused by data shortage, the so-called epistemic uncertainty. They together depict how predictable macroscopic traffic is. This study uses deep ensembles of graph neural networks to estimate both types of uncertainty in network-level speed forecasting. Experimental results given by the used model reveal that, although rare congestion patterns arise randomly, the short-term predictability of traffic states is mainly restricted by the irreducible stochasticity in traffic dynamics. The predicted future state bifurcates into congested or free-flowing cases. This study suggests that the potential for improving prediction models through expanding speed and flow data is limited while diversifying data types is crucial. ...

A Vehicle Spacing based Approach to Conflict Detection

Conference paper (2024) - Yiru Jiao, Simeon C. Calvert, Hans Van Lint
Safety is the cornerstone of L2+ autonomous driving and one of the fundamental tasks is forward collision warning that detects potential rear-end collisions. Potential collisions are also known as conflicts, which have long been indicated using Time-to-Collision with a critical threshold to distinguish safe and unsafe situations. Such indication, however, focuses on a single scenario and cannot cope with dynamic traffic environments. For example, TTC-based crash warning frequently misses potential collisions in congested traffic, and issues false alarms during lane-changing or parking. Aiming to minimise missed and false alarms in conflict detection, this study proposes a more reliable approach based on vehicle spacing patterns. To test this approach, we use both synthetic and real-world conflict data. Our experiments show that the proposed approach outperforms single-threshold TTC unless conflicts happened in the exact way that TTC is defined, which is rarely true. When conflicts are heterogeneous and when the information of conflict situation is incompletely known, as is the case with real-world conflicts, our approach can achieve less missed and false detection. This study offers a new perspective for conflict detection, and also a general framework allowing for further elaboration to minimise missed and false alarms. Less missed alarms will contribute to fewer accidents, meanwhile, fewer false alarms will promote people's trust in collision avoidance systems. We thus expect this study to contribute to safer and more trustworthy autonomous driving. ...
Journal article (2024) - Guopeng Li, Zirui Li, Victor L. Knoop, Hans van Lint
Predicting the trajectories of road agents is fundamental for self-driving cars. Trajectory prediction contains many sources of uncertainty in data and modelling. A thorough understanding of this uncertainty is crucial in a safety-critical task like auto-piloting a vehicle. In practice, it is necessary to distinguish between the uncertainty caused by partial observability of all factors that may affect a driver's near-future decisions, the so-called aleatoric uncertainty, and the uncertainty of deploying a model in new scenarios that are possibly not present in the training set, the so-called epistemic uncertainty. They reflect the trade-off between data collection and model improvement In this paper, we propose a new framework to systematically quantify both sources of uncertainty. Specifically, to approximate the spatial distribution of an agent's future position, we propose a 2D histogram-based deep learning model combined with deep ensemble techniques for measuring aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty by entropy-based quantities. The proposed Uncertainty Quantification Network (UQnet) employs a causal part to enhance its generalizability so rare driving behaviours can be effectively identified. Experiments on the INTERACTION dataset show that UQnet is able to give more robust predictions in generalizability tests compared to the correlation-based models. Further analysis presents that high aleatoric uncertainty cases are mainly caused by heterogeneous driving behaviours and unknown intended directions. Based on this aleatoric uncertainty component, we estimate the lower bounds of mean-square-error and final-displacement-error as indicators for the predictability of trajectories. Furthermore, the analysis of epistemic uncertainty illustrates that domain knowledge of speed-dependent driving behaviour is essential for adapting a model from low-speed to high-speed situations. Our paper contributes to motion forecasting with a new framework, that recasts the problem of accuracy improvement in a way that focuses on differentiating between unpredictable components and rare cases for which more and different data should be collected. ...