Mv

M. van der Elst

info

Please Note

28 records found

Background
Many technologies have been developed to aid in surgical instrument counting, but wide adoption is rare. A technology that has been widely adopted around 20 years ago is the weighing scale. Lessons can be extracted from its sustainment and fidelity, and applied to the development and implementation of new laboursaving technologies in healthcare.

Methods
We conducted semi-structured interviews with experienced staff in four hospitals that use weighing systems in their surgical instrument cycle, which we analysed according to the Matrixed Multiple Case Study (MMCS) methodology. Hospitals were designated a low, medium, or high sustainment and fidelity score, after which influencing factors were identified. These factors were categorised according to the i-PARIHS domains of Innovation, Recipient, Context, and Facilitation. Within-site analysis and cross-site analysis was performed to identify influencing factors associated with a high or low level of sustainment or fidelity.

Results
All hospitals showed a high sustainment. Two hospitals showed low fidelity, and two showed high fidelity. Twenty-one total influencing factors were identified, divided among all i-PARIHS domains. All hospitals experienced similar limitations of the technology, and all hospitals showed signs of facilitation efforts during the implementation phase. In low-fidelity hospitals, interdepartmental coordination and trust in technology were limited, in contrast to high-fidelity hospitals. A large and/or complex surgical instrument inventory hindered fidelity of the weighing system.

Conclusions
20 years after implementation, there is varying success concerning the fidelity of weighing systems for surgical instrument counting. All participating hospitals have adapted their workflow to the limitations of the technology in different ways. Given the relative straight-forwardness of weighing scales as a technology, our findings underline the complexity of implementation processes, regardless of the complexity of the innovation. ...

An Explainable Approach

Conference paper (2025) - Christos Spiliadis, Yiheng Chang, Justin Dauwels, Chavdar Bachvarov, John J. Van Den Dobbelsteen, Benno H.W. Hendriks, Maarten Van Der Elst, Markku Eskola
Surgical workflow analysis optimizes efficiency, resource use, and patient safety in catheterization labs. Traditional manual methods are labour-intensive and inconsistent, driving the need for automated solutions that utilize machine learning and computer vision. This thesis introduces an explainable two-stage model for workflow analysis using ceiling-mounted cameras. The approach combines a YOLOv8 object detection model with a Gaussian Mixture Model - Hidden Markov Model (GMM-HMM). The first stage detects key objects for input into the second stage, where the GMM-HMM infers workflow phases by modelling spatial and temporal dynamics for real-time classification. Validation on two hospital datasets achieves 95.2% accuracy for the RdGG dataset and 95.4% for HH Tampere, demonstrating generalizability across environments. Experimental results show high accuracy in detecting workflow phases, highlighting explainability and robustness. The combined efficiencies of YOLOv8 and GMM-HMM allow for precise phase transition identification. The model's real-time application and adaptability across hospitals suggest its clinical implementation potential. This research furthers automated workflow analysis by enhancing interpretability and adaptability. Future work aims to improve robustness against occlusions, integrate audio data, and explore applications in other surgical settings. ...
Journal article (2025) - Rick M. Butler, Emanuele Frassini, Teddy S. Vijfvinkel, Sjors van Riel, Chavdar Bachvarov, Jan Constandse, Maarten van der Elst, John J. van den Dobbelsteen, Benno H.W. Hendriks
Workflow insights can improve efficiency and safety in the Cardiac Catheterization Laboratory (Cath Lab). As manual analysis is labor-intensive, we aim for automation through camera monitoring. Literature shows that human poses are indicative of activities and therefore workflow. As a first exploration, we evaluate how marker-less multi-human pose estimators perform in the Cath Lab. We annotated poses in 2040 frames from ten multi-view coronary angiogram (CAG) recordings. Pose estimators AlphaPose, OpenPifPaf and OpenPose were run on the footage. Detection and tracking were evaluated separately for the Head, Arms, and Legs with Average Precision (AP), head-guided Percentage of Correct Keypoints (PCKh), Association Accuracy (AA), and Higher-Order Tracking Accuracy (HOTA). We give qualitative examples of results for situations common in the Cath Lab, with reflections in the monitor or occlusion of personnel. AlphaPose performed best on most mean Full-pose metrics with an AP from 0.56 to 0.82, AA from 0.55 to 0.71, and HOTA from 0.58 to 0.73. On PCKh OpenPifPaf scored highest, from 0.53 to 0.64. Arms, Legs, and the Head were detected best in that order, from the views which see the least occlusion. During tracking in the Cath Lab, AlphaPose tended to swap identities and OpenPifPaf merged different individuals. Results suggest that AlphaPose yields the most accurate confidence scores and limbs, and OpenPifPaf more accurate keypoint locations in the Cath Lab. Occlusions and reflection complicate pose tracking. The AP of up to 0.82 suggests that AlphaPose is a suitable pose detector for workflow analysis in the Cath Lab, whereas its HOTA of up to 0.73 here calls for another tracking solution. ...
Purpose
Perioperative staff shortages are a problem in hospitals worldwide. Keeping the staff content and motivated is a challenge in the busy hospital setting of today. New operating room technologies aim to increase safety and efficiency. This causes a shift from interaction with patients to interaction with technology. Objectively measuring this shift could aid the design of supportive technological products, or optimal planning for high-tech procedures.

Methods
35 Gynaecological procedures of three different technology levels are recorded: open- (OS), minimally invasive- (MIS) and robot-assisted (RAS) surgery. We annotate interaction between staff and the patient. An algorithm is proposed that detects interaction with the operating table from staff posture and movement. Interaction is expressed as a percentage of total working time.

Results
The proposed algorithm measures operating table interactions of 70.4%, 70.3% and 30.1% during OS, MIS and RAS. Annotations yield patient interaction percentages of 37.6%, 38.3% and 24.6%. Algorithm measurements over time show operating table and patient interaction peaks at anomalous events or workflow phase transitions.

Conclusions
The annotations show less operating table and patient interactions during RAS than OS and MIS. Annotated patient interaction and measured operating table interaction show similar differences between procedures and workflow phases. The visual complexity of operating rooms complicates pose tracking, deteriorating the algorithm input quality. The proposed algorithm shows promise as a component in context-aware event- or workflow phase detection. ...
This study evaluates the performance of deep learning models in the prediction of the end time of procedures performed in the cardiac catheterization laboratory (cath lab). We employed only the clinical phases derived from video analysis as input to the algorithms. Our results show that InceptionTime and LSTM-FCN yielded the most accurate predictions. InceptionTime achieves Mean Absolute Error (MAE) values below 5 min and Symmetric Mean Absolute Percentage Error (SMAPE) under 6% at 60-s sampling intervals. In contrast, LSTM with attention mechanism and standard LSTM models have higher error rates, indicating challenges in handling both long-term and short-term dependencies. CNN-based models, especially InceptionTime, excel at feature extraction across different scales, making them effective for time-series predictions. We also analyzed training and testing times. CNN models, despite higher computational costs, significantly reduce prediction errors. The Transformer model has the fastest inference time, making it ideal for real-time applications. An ensemble model derived by averaging the two best performing algorithms reported low MAE and SMAPE, although needing longer training. Future research should validate these findings across different procedural contexts and explore ways to optimize training times without losing accuracy. Integrating these models into clinical scheduling systems could improve efficiency in cath labs. Our research demonstrates that the models we implemented can form the basis of an automated tool, which predicts the optimal time to call the next patient with an average error of approximately 30 s. These findings show the effectiveness of deep learning models, especially CNN-based architectures, in accurately predicting procedure end times. ...
Journal article (2025) - Rick M. Butler, Teddy S. Vijfvinkel, Emanuele Frassini, Sjors van Riel, Chavdar Bachvarov, Jan Constandse, Maarten van der Elst, John J. van den Dobbelsteen, Benno H.W. Hendriks
Workflow insights can enable safety- and efficiency improvements in the Cardiac Catheterisation Laboratory (Cath Lab). Human pose tracklets from video footage can provide a source of workflow information. However, occlusions and visual similarity between personnel make the Cath Lab a challenging environment for the re-identification of individuals. We propose a human pose tracker that addresses these problems specifically, and test it on recordings of real coronary angiograms. This tracker uses no visual information for re-identification, and instead employs object keypoint similarity between detections and predictions from a third-order motion model. Algorithm performance is measured on Cath Lab footage using Higher-Order Tracking Accuracy (HOTA). To evaluate its stability during procedures, this is done separately for five different surgical steps of the procedure. We achieve up to 0.71 HOTA where tested state-of-the-art pose trackers score up to 0.65 on the used dataset. We observe that the pose tracker HOTA performance varies with up to 10 percentage point (Image 1) between workflow phases, where tested state-of-the-art trackers show differences of up to Image 2. In addition, the tracker achieves up to 22.5 frames per second, which is 9 frames per second faster than the current state-of-the-art on our setup in the Cath Lab. The fast and consistent short-term performance of the provided algorithm makes it suitable for use in workflow analysis in the Cath Lab and opens the door to real-time use-cases. ...
Journal article (2024) - J. L.A. Lans, N. M.C. Mathijssen, P. R. Goswami, J. J. van den Dobbelsteen, P. G. Luscuere, M. van der Elst
Background: The objective of an operating room (OR) ultra-clean ventilation system is to eliminate or reduce the quantity of dust particles and colony-forming units per cubic meter of air (CFU/m3). To achieve this, ultra-clean goal high air change rates per hour are required to reduce the particle load and number of CFU/m3. Aim: To determine the air quality in an ultra-clean OR during surgery, in terms of the number and type of microorganism and quantity of dust particles in order to establish a benchmark. Methods: Number of CFUs and the quantity of dust particles were measured. For measuring the CFUs, sterile extraction hoses were positioned at the incision, the furthest away positioned instrument table, and the periphery. At these locations, air was extracted to determine the quantity of dust particles. Findings: The number of CFU/m3 and particles was on average at wound level ≤1 CFU/m3 resp. 852.679 particles, at instrument table ≤1 CFU/m3 resp. 3.797 particles and in the periphery ≤8 CFU/m3, resp. 4.355 particles. Conclusion: The number of CFUs in the ultra-clean area is below the defined ultra-clean level of ≤10 CFU/m3 for ultra-clean surgery. The quantity of dust particles measured during surgery was higher than the defined ISO 5. ...
Journal article (2024) - J.L.A. Lans, N.M.C. Mathijssen, A. Bode, J.J. van den Dobbelsteen, M. van der Elst, P.G. Luscuere
Background
The operating room (OR) department is one of the most energy-intensive departments of a hospital. The majority of ORs in the Netherlands have an air-handling installation with an ultra-clean ventilation system. However, not all surgeries require an ultra-clean OR.

Aim
To determine the effect of reducing the air change rate on the ventilation effectiveness in ultra-clean ORs.

Methods
Lower air volume ventilation effectiveness (VELv) of conventional ventilation (CV), controlled dilution ventilation (cDV), temperature-controlled airflow (TcAF) and unidirectional airflow (UDAF) systems were evaluated within a 4 × 4 m measuring grid of 1 × 1 m. The VELv was defined as the recovery degree (RD), cleanliness recovery rate (CRR) and air change effectiveness (ACE).

Findings
The CV, cDVLv and TcAFLv ventilation systems showed a comparable mixing character in all areas (A, B and AB) when reducing the air change rate to 20/h. Ventilation effectiveness decreased when the air change rate was reduced, with the exception of the ACE.
At all points for the UDAF-2Lv and at the centre point (C3) of the TcAFLv, higher RD10Lv and CRRLv were measured when compared with the other examined ventilation systems.

Conclusions
The ventilation effectiveness decreased when an ultra-clean OR with an ultra-clean ventilation air-supply system was switched to an air change rate of 20/h. Reducing the air change rate in the OR from an ultra-clean OR to a generic OR will reduce the recovery degree (RD10) by a factor of 10–100 and the local air change rate (CRR) by between 42% and 81%. ...
Journal article (2024) - Roelf Postema, Hidde Hardon, Sem F. Hardon, Tim Horeman, A. Masie Rahimi, Roel Horeman, Felix Nickel, Jenny Dankelman, Alexander L.A. Bloemendaal, Maarten van der Elst, Donald L. van der Peet, Freek Daams
Collision feedback about instrument and environment interaction is often lacking in robotic surgery training devices. The PoLaRS virtual reality simulator is a newly developed desk trainer that overcomes drawbacks of existing robot trainers for advanced laparoscopy. This study aimed to assess the effect of haptic and visual feedback during training on the performance of a robotic surgical task. Robotic surgery-naïve participants were randomized and equally divided into two training groups: Haptic and Visual Feedback (HVF) and No Haptic and Visual Feedback. Participants performed two basic virtual reality training tasks on the PoLaRS system as a pre- and post-test. The measurement parameters Time, Tip-to-tip distance, Path length Left/Right and Collisions Left/Right were used to analyze the learning curves and statistically compare the pre- and post-tests performances. In total, 198 trials performed by 22 participants were included. The visual and haptic feedback did not negatively influence the time to complete the tasks. Although no improvement in skill was observed between pre- and post-tests, the mean rank of the number of collisions of the right grasper (dominant hand) was significantly lower in the HVF feedback group during the second post-test (Mean Rank = 8.73 versus Mean Rank = 14.27, U = 30.00, p = 0.045). Haptic and visual feedback during the training on the PoLaRS system resulted in fewer instrument collisions. These results warrant the introduction of haptic feedback in subjects with no experience in robotic surgery. The PoLaRS system can be utilized to remotely optimize instrument handling before commencing robotic surgery in the operating room. ...
Deep learning-based object detectors, while offering exceptional performance, are data-dependent and can suffer from generalization issues. In this work, we investigated deep neural networks for detecting people and medical instruments for the vision-based workflow analysis system inside Catheterization Laboratories (Cath Labs). The central problem explored in this paper is the fact that the performance of the detector can degrade drastically if it is trained and tested on data from different Cath Labs. Our research aimed to investigate the underlying causes of this specific performance degradation and find solutions to mitigate this issue. We employed the YOLOv8 object detector and created datasets from clinical procedures recorded at Reinier de Graaf Hospital (RdGG) and Philips Best Campus, supplemented with publicly accessible images. Through a series of experiments complemented by data visualization, we discovered that the performance degradation primarily stems from data distribution shifts in the feature space. Notably, the object detector trained on non-sensitive online images can generalize to unseen Cath Labs, outperforming the model trained on a procedure recording from a different Cath Lab. The detector trained on the online images achieved an mAP@0.5 of 0.517 on the RdGG dataset. Furthermore, by switching to the most suitable camera for each object in the Cath Lab, the multi-camera system can further improve the detection performance significantly. An aggregated L-camera mAP@0.5 of 0.679 is achieved for single-object classes on the RdGG dataset. ...

Current practice and staff perspectives on technological support

Background: Surgical instrument counting is a manual, attention-intensive task of the operating room (OR) nurse. Many labour-saving technologies have been proposed, but implementation remains challenging. Knowledge of current counting methods and staff preferences could guide future developments towards effective application. Approach: We observed OR nurses counting materials and instruments in 50 surgical procedures performed by various surgical specialties in a regional teaching hospital in Delft, The Netherlands. Additionally, we surveyed them on their preferences concerning the methods of counting. Key findings: Variations in approaches of surgical counting were observed, with OR nurses using multiple strategies and counting techniques to manage disruptions and limit workload. Interest in using supportive technology is limited to the preoperative and postoperative phase. Relevance: This research relates observational data to staff preferences. Our findings may guide future developments of labour-saving innovations regarding surgical counting towards developing more effective applications and to ensure successful implementation. ...
Journal article (2023) - J. L.A. Lans, N. M.C. Mathijssen, A. A.L. Traversari, I. M. Jacobs, J. J. van den Dobbelsteen, M. van der Elst, P. G. Luscuere
When making a decision on the operating room air handling installation and type of air supply system, it is relevant to know the expenditures of the different air handling installations and air supply systems. The aim of this study was to determine the capital and operational expenditures of air handling installations equipped with an ultra-clean or with a conventional system. To compare the technical requirements of Dutch air handling installations with European standards and guidelines, and evaluate the costs of surgical site infections in comparison with the capital expenditures. This study fills a gap in knowledge, detailed technical information and costs of air handling installations and air supply systems from multiple completed projects of 24 hospitals were collected, analyzed and compared. Per OR capital expenditures increase by €62,491 to €139,018 when an air handling installation with an ultra-clean system is compared to a conventional system, which is 3%–7% of the total construction costs of a completely new OR department. The yearly increase in operational expenditures per OR with an ultra-clean system compared to a conventional system was €673 to €1,896. The capital and operational expenditures of air handling installations with an ultra-clean system are higher than those with a conventional system. The technical specifications of the ORs studied in the Netherlands correspond to European standards and guidelines. When the impact on patient suffering and costs associated with surgical site infections are weighed against the investment required for an air handling installation with an ultra-clean system, it is worth considering. ...
In this paper, we aim to design an automatic camera pose estimation pipeline for clinical spaces such as catheterization laboratories. Our proposed pipeline exploits Scaled-YOLOv4 to detect fixed objects. We adopt the self-supervised key-point detector SuperPoint in combination with SuperGlue, a keypoint matching technique based on graph neural networks. Thus, we match key-points on input images with annotated reference points. Reference points are chosen on fixed objects in the scene, such as corners of door posts or windows. The point-correspondences between the image coordinates and the 3D coordinates are applied to the Perspective-n-Point algorithm to estimate the pose of each camera. Compared with other camera pose estimation methods, the proposed pipeline does not require the construction of 3D point-cloud model of the scene or placing a polyhedron object in the scene before each required calibration. Using videos from real procedures, we show that the pipeline can estimate the camera pose with high accuracy. ...
Journal article (2023) - J.L.A. Lans, A.A.L. Traversari, N.M.C. Mathijssen, T. Sprangers, J.J. van den Dobbelsteen, M. van der Elst, P.G. Luscuere
Ultra-clean ventilation systems are used in the operating room (OR) to reduce the quantity of airborne bacteria in the ultra-clean area, and reduce the incidence of surgical site infections (SSIs). When the number of colony-forming units (CFUs) in the ultra-clean (protected) area is too high, this is considered a risk factor for SSIs. ...
Journal article (2022) - J. L.A. Lans, N. M.C. Mathijssen, A. Bode, J. J. van den Dobbelsteen, M. van der Elst, P. G. Luscuere
The authors regret that they have missed during the review process that the legend belonging to figure 6a, 6b, 6c and 6d is not shown. It is necessary to show the legenda otherwise the readers cannot interpret the graphs. Apologies that we missed it during the review process of the article. The legend belonging to figure 6 is:[Formula presented] The authors would like to apologize for any inconvenience caused. ...
Workflow analysis is a young research field that has been gaining traction in recent years. Work in this field aims to improve the efficiency and safety in operating rooms by analysing surgical processes and providing feedback or support, where observations are made and evaluated by algorithms rather than human experts. For our study, we mount five cameras from different angles in a Catheterization Laboratory (CathLab) to observe and analyse Cardiac Angiogram procedures. To automate the classification of workflow and personnel activities, we propose a pipeline that first automates the camera calibration of the 5-camera network then detect locations of medical equipment and track personnel activities... ...
Journal article (2021) - Sem F. Hardon, Anton Kooijmans, Roel Horeman, Maarten van der Elst, Alexander L.A. Bloemendaal, Tim Horeman
Background: As global use of surgical robotic systems is steadily increasing, surgical simulation can be an excellent way for robotic surgeons to acquire and retain their skills in a safe environment. To address the need for training in less wealthy parts of the world, an affordable surgical robot simulator (PoLaRS) was designed. Methods: The aim of this pilot study is to compare learning curve data of the PoLaRS prototype with those of Intuitive Surgical’s da Vinci Skills Simulator (dVSS) and to establish face- and construct validity. Medical students were divided into two groups; the test group (n = 18) performing tasks on PoLaRS and dVSS, and the control group (n = 20) only performing tasks on the dVSS. The performance parameters were Time, Path length, and the number of collisions. Afterwards, the test group participants filled in a questionnaire regarding both systems. Results: A total of 528 trials executed by 38 participants were measured and included for analyses. The test group significantly improved in Time, Path Length and Collisions during the PoLaRS test phase (P ≤ 0.028). No differences was found between the test group and the control group in the dVSS performances during the post-test phase. Learning curves showed similar shapes between both systems, and between both groups. Participants recognized the potential benefits of simulation training on the PoLaRS system. Conclusions: Robotic surgical skills improved during training with PoLaRS. This shows the potential of PoLaRS to become an affordable alternative to current surgical robot simulators. Validation with similar tasks and different expert levels is needed before implementing the training system into robotic training curricula. ...
Review (2021) - J.L.A. Lans, N.M.C. Mathijssen, A. Bode, J.J. van den Dobbelsteen, M. van der Elst, P Luscuere
Background: Entrainment test methods are described in most European standards and guidelines to determine the protected area for ultra-clean ventilation (UCV) systems. New UCV systems, such as temperature-controlled airflow (TcAF) and controlled dilution ventilation (cDV) systems, claim the whole operating room (OR) to be ultra-clean. However, current test standards were not developed to assess ventilation effectiveness outside the standard protected area. Aim: To assess and compare the ventilation effectiveness of four types of OR ventilation systems in the ultra-clean area using a uniform test grid.
Methods: Ventilation effectiveness of four ventilation systems was evaluated for three different ultra-clean (protected) areas: the standard protected area (A); the area outside the standard protected area (B); and a large protected area (AB). Ventilation effectiveness was assessed using recovery degree (RD), cleanliness recovery rate (CRR) and air change effectiveness (ACE). Findings: RD, CRR and ACE were significantly higher for the unidirectional air flow (UDAF) system compared with the other systems in area A. In area B, the UDAF and cDV systems were comparable for RD and CRR, and the UDAF and conventional ventilation (CV) systems were comparable for ACE. In area AB, the UDAF and cDV systems were comparable for CRR and ACE, but significant differences were found in RD.
Conclusion: In area A, the ventilation effectiveness of the UDAF system outperformed other ventilation systems. In area B, the cDV system was best, followed by the UDAF, TcAF and CV systems. In area AB, the UDAF system was best, followed by the cDV, TcAF and CV systems. ...
Introduction
Hospitals in the Netherlands generate approximately 1.3 million kg of waste from the polypropylene (PP) wrapping paper (WP) used to wrap surgical instruments each year. The aim of this study was to develop a method to recycle WP waste into new medical devices.

Methods
WP was recovered from Maasstad Hospital, Netherlands. The WP was melted into bars, granulated, and mixed with virgin material at different ratios and temperatures. Dog bones were injection-molded from volume (v.%) virgin, mixed (%R), and recycled (100%R) granulate, and a tensile testing machine was used to compare the material properties before and after ten disinfection cycles at the sterilization department. Then, 25 instrument openers were made from the 50%R material and circulated for four weeks.

Results
The data indicated no significant differences in the mechanical properties at different melting temperatures. For dog bones made from the 100%R, 50%R, and virgin granulate, the Young's moduli were 1021 (SD13), 879 (SD13), and 795 (SD14) MPa, and the strains were 8%, 12%, and 14%. Ten disinfection cycles did not significantly change the material properties. After one month, the openers did not show any deterioration or damage other than surface scratches.

Discussion
The results indicated that the initial WP melting temperature did not influence the mechanical properties. Although devices could be produced directly from the recycled WP granulate, increasing the recycled granulate in the mix ratio increased the strength and brittleness.

Conclusions
It is feasible to recycle WP waste into a high-quality raw material for the injection molding of medical devices without using additives. This would allow hospitals to become more compliant with the circular economy enabling economically viable and circular processes that positively contribute to cleaner technical processes, sustainable products, and the reduction of medical waste. ...

Intreerede prof.dr. M. van der Elst

Digital or visual products (2020) - Maarten van der Elst